But also, one of the symptons of ADHD, with the "H" there, is that people must move, in my particular case one of the things I tend to do is tap my nails on the desk, use tupperware as drums, or if a actual musical instrument is nearby, even if I dunno how to play it, I play it.
So, ADHD person in open office not only has terrible productivity due to other people disrupting, but also disrupts everyone else.
To me this is terrible, since now that I know all this (and I've been fired multiple times), I've been trying, and failing, to find remote work.
As far as your firings go, if you haven't watched this video and/or read this doctor's books they really help with understanding exactly what you're dealing with: https://youtu.be/SCAGc-rkIfo
It's long but worth watching at faster playback speed and in manageable chunks. Key takeaways: "Attention deficit" is less of a symptom and more of a measurable consequence of other symptoms: Impaired inhibition/impulse control, excessive irrelevant activity and impaired persistence (think discipline). Once you understand why you fail you can start addressing or working around your gaps, particularly the ones that any medication you may be on fail to address.
I just got up to the part where he basically says that people with ADHD basically don't have an inner monologue. Is that right? If so why have I never heard this before?
In his papers and books he argues that the inner voice is essentially broken because it's either incapable of helping regulate behavior and/or doesn't manifest itself during the decision making process. Executive function and its various components are impaired, delayed or not working together the way they should.
I might also add that (this obviously depends on local laws but) you can see if there's any disability protections you can take advantage of. Where your company can work with you to help you work better, or at worst, at least, not fire you just over a disability.
Things used to be a lot better 15+ years ago, when we had cubicles. It wasn't a panacea (since you could still hear your neighbors), but the cube farms I've worked in were much quieter than these idiotic open-plan offices, and it was so much easier to concentrate.
Oddly enough, I can be very helpful to others in an open space, but I've never managed to get my own work done.
Easier said than done I suspect - people aren't necessarily aware of their own subconscious fidgeting when it's happening. How do you even build awareness of what you're doing subconsciously?
When my cubical desk is shaking like I'm in an earthquake because a coworker in a connected desk is bouncing their leg, they're more than happy to knock it off when I ask them to. That they were doing it in the first place takes them by surprise.
This happens often enough to be distracting, but rarely enough that it's hard to build a habit of catching themselves in the act.
I suppose one could build some kind of seismometer and attach it to an audio cue, but starting on a new hardware projects isn't exactly less of a distraction... and I'm not exactly immune to the siren call of bouncing my leg, either.
> In the end you're responsible for your actions.
Sure. But my take on open offices, is that they're distraction-inducing by design. Most of the rationale around them - aside from cost cutting - seems to be around such things as "It's easier to talk to people" / "see what they're working on" / ...
Who's responsible for the action of creating that environment?
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/antsylabs/fidget-cube-a...
My favourite home/office made finger toys are when you take 2 of the little plastic protectors off of the ports of screencards (and/or cables). They're a great size to stick your fingers a bit into and they usually fit inside each other nicely (it's ok if they're loose, but really great if they stick nicely). They're pretty durable too, unless if you play too hard they can last a very long time.
I phrase it along the lines of "I have trouble concentrating, so if I have to work in an open office environment I would perform the best if I face a wall".
Take Alphabet's Q2 Earnings[1] and note that in the 3 months ending June 30, 2016, Alphabet generated 6.9B$ of free cash flow. That is after all the expenses they could think up to take out of it like building new data centers, offices, snacks, google I/O attendee gifts, whatever. Now divide that by the number of employees, 66,500. That means that there was just over $105,000 per employee in free cash flow. If they spent 5% of that, on a per employee basis, that would give them $1,750 per month for additional office space for that employee. Really posh office space is like $20/sq ft per month so divide that by $20 and you get 87 square feet of really nice office, add that to the 1/4 of a cube that employees currently get and you have 100 sq feet or a 10' x 10' room for each and every employee.
So no, with a 5% hit to their free cash flow they could give every single employee an office, or at least their own 10' x 10' cube, but they they would rather that money sit in cash or cash equivalents earning basically a couple of cents on the dollar.
Since the investment rate of return is about 2% for cash equivalents, and the productivity rate of return would be on the order of at least 5%, you could say they were being dollar wise and productivity foolish.
[1]https://abc.xyz/investor/news/earnings/2016/Q2_alphabet_earn...
Would that increase be in individual productivity or team productivity? I wouldn't be surprised if the aggregate productivity goes down after moving into offices. I would love to read any papers that touch on this, if any research has been done.
I am a fan[1] of open offices, they bring certain efficiencies to team dynamics. If I want to see if someone is busy, I look up/around. If they look like they are in the zone, I send and IM and walk over. Listening in on ambient conversations in my vicinity when taking breaks/waiting for compiles is very useful as well - it's the extended version of the "watercooler effect" where I keep up to date on things I don't directly work on and I occasionally provide solutions before the issue is raised via email or group chat.
1. I am not easily distracted, I can shut out external stimuli. Usually, when I'm focusing on something (work, TV, book), you will have to tear my attention from the activity, and it will take several attempts. To my dismay, I read this makes me more susceptible to hypnosis.
One of the startups IBM acquired had some pretty solid data analysis they had done on the issue which was pretty clear for their teams.
My point though was that for high margin "info" businesses (where the product required no raw materials to manufacture) the cost of the office isn't an issue. Reading the recent Instapainting post is a good example, this guy is clearing $400K/year he can give himself a nice office to work out of.
Granted, I generally assume laptops, and many folks probably have larger desktop setups, but it's the choice factor here that is always ignored during optimizations for "efficiency".
Until you can test, say, 3-6 months of privates offices for those who want/need them vs open-plan for everyone, you won't be able to get usable comparisons.
Just the costs of the decor and other accommodations would probably outweigh the costs of having internal walls and maybe a tab bit more floor space (even tho I have a strong suspicion that traditional offices are actually more space friendly).
Cubicles and small team offices do not take much more space, in fact they can often be more space friendly since there isn't that much open space needed in order for the office not to feel like a sweatshop and you also save a lot of space on quiet rooms and meeting rooms.
Meanwhile, the quiet people are not keeping the noisy one from their work or working effectively if and when they choose to concentrate.
Result? The noisy people "succeed".
I consider it a cousin of bullying.
And, it explains a lot about contemporary Western corporate culture -- to its detriment, in my opinion.
That IS bullying.
Your perceived antisociality could be almost as bothersome to him as his sociability is to you.
I don't mean to dismiss your concern, and I can relate even, but workplaces are social environments and (apart from political rants which might border on offensive) I see no reason why you're a victim here.
And, for the record, I include in this work communication, not necessarily -- nor even primarily -- personal, "social" communication.
The loud guy I remember who would stand up, raise his voice, and shout conversations across aisles of cubes.
The "best practice" that shrunk our cubes to "corners", sitting almost shoulder to shoulder with 3 - 4 feet between us. People nonetheless holding hour long cube meetings and in-person screenshares and whatnot.
Getting a project completed and passed by a coworker, to find multiple, obvious bugs within the first five minutes. Because that person had no depth of attention whatsoever.
The best developers leaping at nascent work-from-home, because it was the one time they could really, consistently get stuff done.
But challenge HR on any of this, and "best practice" and a mark on your own record.
Asking a coworker, very politely and directly, if they could be a bit quieter -- in this case, in fact, when they were engaged in extensive, repeated personal communication of a non-urgent nature (talking with friends, on the phone and in cube visits, sometimes for 2 - 3 hours, day after day) -- and having this come back to you as a formal complaint to and "correction" -- to you -- from HR for your having asked.
Consistently, I observed the loud people "winning" by dint of being loud.
Those top developers were more senior and from a time when the company was smaller and provide private offices. That was how the company attracted and held them, in the first place. They were "vested" in their careers and families and technical debt and, in this technologically conservative area, somewhat "trapped" in their current positions.
Like a frog in the pot, new senior management and HR kept making things more miserable. If remote work hadn't come on the table when it did, I suspect they would have lost more of them in the near future.
As it was, being senior, they were provide this opportunity and had the leverage to use to to escape what was becoming an untenable office environment.
For those stuck at the office, it became a matter of working around "shouting guy", neighbors' cube meetings, and the like. A culture increasingly of interruption, distraction, and superficial attention.
I used to use ear buds to block it out, but I don't recommend it. It actually does damage your hearing. I didn't figure that out for a while. Luckily my hearing has seemed to improve a bit.
I highly recommend over the ear noise cancelling head phones. They get rid of the office A/C sounds, turn the volume down on voices and are less damaging.
(I personally use noise-canceling earphones a lot, and the only bad thing I've heard is that they may cause vertigo in some people...)
I didn't make the connection until I happened across one article about it, which I think was posted here.
The only thing I don't like about noise-canceling headphones is that I can't just wear them without sound. It creates a kind of pressure on my ear drums that just feels weird to me.
One question that the audiologist answered that you might want to know -- the noise-cancelling hiss has no impact on your hearing in a short-term or long-term way, so it is totally safe to use them without music or with low music all the time.
Maintenance: there's a little wire loop with a plastic handle included in the pelican case it ships with, lets you clean wax out of the canal. Tip: if you think one of your headphones is dead, just clean the wax out of the canal, it was blocking the sound. That's it – super simple, no idea what other maintenance you might be talking about.
Insertion/removal: nope, still quite easy. You have to give them a slight twist but definitely not hard.
Can't speak to the Music Two vs. Music One because I only have the latter, but I'll tell you that I've owned a decent number of headphones (in ear, over ear) and that the Music One are the best I've ever had.
EDIT: I swear I'm not shilling for this company. There are plenty of other great IEMs on the market. I just like these.
I switched to them mainly to protect my hearing (I tend to listen to music on the bus or on airplanes where there's a lot of ambient noise, and with open-air buds I had to crank the volume) but they're also a godsend in the workplace when I really need to focus (and I have a private office).
Of course, if it's a painful pressure, please don't risk it :)
From what I recall (and don't have any references on me) this is because they tend to filter out the lower frequency sounds, which your brain associates with a pressure change.
After some time wearing them on silent, I've found that the sensation goes away. Still, I usually use rainymood.com to block out the other subtle sounds that get through.
The sound is similar enough to the usual office noises and thus is very effective in cancelling them out. Also it has enough chaos to avoid becoming a distraction by itself. And then it doesn't hurt your hearing that much because you don't have to turn the volume too high to be effective.
I like to combine it with a little music. The only problem is, I can't find headphones that don't hurt after an hour...
That's not a solution though, that just removes the entire benefit of the open office while also removing all the benefits of having individual offices. It's important to have places where people can socialize and collaborate, the major downside of open offices is that this has to happen in the same space where everyone else is trying to work, with obvious deleterious effects on productivity. The appropriate alternative is not to simply instill a library type atmosphere of deathly quiet, the alternative is to make it easier for people to choose whether they want to collaborate, socialize, or work, which is easiest when everyone has their own office.
Empty rooms are your friends. And Metallica when no rooms available, or some good construction hearing protectors, they don't kill all sounds, but deaden a fair amount.
Loud people disrupt the quiet people, and quiet people can't work with loud people around. Either kind of behaviour makes the system not work.
Where I work, I have a budding tupperware percussionist, three imminent victims of whooping cough, some parents managing high-maintenance offspring over cell phones, and one guy who conducts teleconferences with his desk phone. So I often sneak off to empty conference rooms with a laptop if I'm trying to concentrate.