News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by Thaxll on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @10:56AM (#12735004)
Who uses SD card anyway? I mean seriously pretty much everything is cloud hosted now days, so 64-128GB is not enough?
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by jimktrains2 on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:05AM (#12735136)
> I mean seriously pretty much everything is cloud hosted now days

You're really OK with cloud hosting? Why? Do you have a quota? I do. 2GB a month.

> 64-128GB is not enough

No? Not really? Not when some apps think it's OK to be 10s to 100s of MB in size? Not when I care around detailed off-line maps of a majority of the US. Not when I care around a a good portion of wikipedia offline. Not when I use my phone as an impromptu camera. Not when I want to carry around a large variety of music so that I can listen to what when I'm in the mood.

I mean 128GB is getting there, but it would be nice to be able to expand that, or start with a budget phone and expand it. Or, be able to swap cards if I'm on a long trip with various documents on one or the other.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by fragmede on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:14AM (#12735250)
Google and Apple both charge $100 for an upgrade from 32 to 128 GB of storage, but a 128 GB microSD card is only $40, and prices will only go down on that with time. Five years from now, a $20 microSD card is likely to far exceed 256 GB, but smartphones with no microSD card slot are doomed to be stuck at their original size. If you've fully bought into the consumer mindset and always have to have the latest and greatest, great, but some people are still on iPhone 4s'.

The cloud (around harddrive island) is great and all, but for those times when you're out of internet range, the local mp3 collection you can actually listen to is far superior, and some people have amassed sizable collections over the years.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by kitsunesoba on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @12:43PM (#12736245)
I don't know if it's true for the Pixel phone as well, but the iPhone has been using flash storage that's more like an SSD than traditional flash since the iPhone 6S and the iPad Pro 9.7" - they even use a miniaturized MacBook NVMe controller - and it's a great deal faster than an SD card. Most 128GB consumer SSDs sit at the ~$90 price range, which makes the upgrade price make a little more sense.

Of course the speed boost vs. an SD card might not matter to you but that's another subject.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by tinus_hn on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @03:26PM (#12737840)
The whole point of the different sizes is to have differentiation. It allows Apple to have a cheaper and a more expensive model. That way they have a reasonably affordable model for customers that are more price sensitive and an expensive model for people who don't really care.

These prices are not really related to flash memory prices. You pay more to have a phone that you can enjoy more.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by ianburrell on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @02:51PM (#12737490)
Pixel uses UFS storage which is significantly faster than the flash storage in most phones. The Samsung S7 also has UFS. But not as fast the NVMe interface in recent iPhones.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by ricw on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @02:52PM (#12737500)
SD Cards are nothing like internal storage that typically use high performance ssds. They are much cheaper and also much much slower than ssds.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by falcolas on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @04:23PM (#12738306)
And yet much, MUCH faster than an upload to or download from a cloud service.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by Guillaume86 on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @06:34PM (#12739330)
And a lot more energy efficient
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by lostsock on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @08:12PM (#12739866)
And for a lot of what is stored on them, like music, photos and movies that speed is totally unnecessary.

It's the same reason I still have both an SSD and HDD in my computer. I use the fast expensive storage for things that effect performance and the slower but much cheaper storage for my "bulk media" needs.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by falcolas on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @09:22PM (#12740225)
Photos, imo, are a great example of where cloud storage falls apart. High quality photos take a lot of disk space and take forever to up- and download in their native formats.

Once you overrun your local disk cache, you're SOL until those gigs of photos are moved.

Not to mention the browsing problem; thumbing through thousands of thumbnails and hundreds of full sized photos in a session is impossible with cloud storage.

There's a reason photographers buy multi-terabyte SANs and spend days backing those up online after a single shoot.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by shostack on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @06:22AM (#12742545)
With the current gen of phones I'd say high res videos are the more painful use case. 4k video files are gigantic.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by jasonkostempski on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:11AM (#12735212)
Can't tell if you being sarcastic. If not:

A) Charging an extra $100 for a little extra local storage is the biggest scam in technology right now, some are worse than others, but anything less than a TB for $100 is infuriating.

B) 64-128GB is not nearly enough for the ridiculous resolution the cameras work at, especially video.

C) Not everyone wants their stuff in the cloud.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by mcphage on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @02:03PM (#12737070)
> but anything less than a TB for $100 is infuriating.

1 TB SSD cards cost ~$300, and at that price I don't think they'd even fit in a smartphone. So if you get infuriated that you don't get 1 TB for your $100, you really need to work on your expectations & anger level.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by victorhooi on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @07:06PM (#12739540)
Nearly all manufacturers are moving away from removable storage in phones.

For the majority of users, it complicates things, and can lead to nasty edge cases if they don't understand it.

Note that iPhones have never offered removable storage.

Also, SD cards can often be of dubious quality. Even good quality ones would never be as good as the NVMe (or similar) SSDs now used in high-end phones.

Put it this way - for your laptop, would you rather a NVMe SSD, or a MicroSD card you bought from Amazon? One is going to have much more predictable write performance under varying conditions, and you know will last. The other, well...I know what I'm trusting my data to.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by shostack on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @06:26AM (#12742564)
There's definitely a contingent (perhaps even larger so outside the US) where SD storage is important.

The question is whether that group is large enough to create sufficient demand for a removable storage phone beyond the desire of these companies to drive adoption and lock in with their respective cloud services.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by robocat on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @09:59PM (#12740405)
I used to agree.

Less keen after losing all photos due to an SD card failure (SD card was a reputable brand from a reputable supplier).

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by thirdsun on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @02:10AM (#12741482)
I'm sure I don't have to tell you after that loss, but of course offline data doesn't render backups obsolete.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by pjmlp on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:00AM (#12735070)
Almost everyone that I know that isn't comfortable putting private data available for the world to see when there are security exploits.

Also, not all of us live in areas where the Internet is available 100% of the time at cheap connection rates.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by huehehue on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:06AM (#12735138)
And considering that many of these Pixels are going straight to the Fi network...I'd rather keep media on the device than pay $10/gb to retrieve it.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by skybrian on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:14AM (#12735248)
Seems like that's what WiFi is for?
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by detaro on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:14AM (#12735249)
Until I get unlimited LTE traffic for free/very cheap, available all over the world, having my data cloud hosted is a lot more expensive and annoying than having it locally. Even if I shell out for a plan with a lot of included data, I still can't rely on actually having useable reception.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by justin66 on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:11AM (#12735205)
I can compress my music collection down to mp3 and get almost all of it onto a 128GB SD card. It's nice to have.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by e12e on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @12:15PM (#12735914)
I have some 50 cds in lossy ogg atm, but just because I haven't gotten around to break out my backup hds and get the rest on there. There are few things more annoying than audio stuttering and stopping due to intermitted wifi/4g coverage - having the option of a 128gb sd card (presumably one that I can double in a few months if needed) is great.

Sure, when you have access to good wifi, with a good back-end connection, "the cloud" is nice. But try living a week without wifi, with spotty 4g, and all that old resentment to having the only copy of your data somewhere you can't easily get at it comes flooding back. Not to mention if you go somewhere without 4g, but still want some music in the evenings.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by 1024core on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:19AM (#12735303)
MP3 works out to about 1MB/minute. That's 128,000 minutes of music, or about 2133 hours, or 133 days if you listen to music 16 hours/day, every day.

Are you sure you want that much music to lug around?

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by justin66 on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:24AM (#12735361)
It doesn't weigh any more.

The point is that it's nice having the full selection available, and to not have to worry about streaming and compression quality, which I don't always have control over. Deciding which music should or shouldn't be on the phone is a task I'd like to minimize, as well.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by newscracker on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:24AM (#12735367)
Depending on the country, SD cards may be used to share media, like photos, music, videos, etc., and to also copy media from others and play them on one's phone. Yes, it's very slow, but many people who use them don't know and don't care as much about the speed.

SD cards are also not very reliable, but again, many people who use them don't consider that to be critically important.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by Zikes on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @10:58AM (#12735046)
The Pixel is 32 & 128, and +$100 for the 128GB option. A MicroSD card does not cost $100, and offers far more space.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by post_break on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:02AM (#12735099)
MicroSD card is also extremely slow compared to phone memory. I would have paid $100 to get my Samsung phone with 128gb if they offered it vs the 128gb sd card I have.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by blisterpeanuts on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:09AM (#12735188)
Aren't modern type 10 MicroSD cards plenty fast enough to serve up video? How much faster do they need to be, and what applications would require it?

I thought RAM (typically 2 or 4 gigs these days on most phones) is where the fast computation takes place, whereas the non volatile memory merely emulates disk storage.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by post_break on Friday October 21, 2016 @11:27AM (#12761200)
They are worlds slower than phone memory. It's like usb stick vs Sata 3 SSD.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by Thaxll on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @10:59AM (#12735058)
What do you need the space for?
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by AdmiralAsshat on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:09AM (#12735182)
I have over 1 TB of music, and on my current HTC One M9, I keep a 128GB SD card in it, onto which I've thrown about 90 gigs of my most listened to music. It's still not quite enough for everything I'd like to have in there, but I just bought a 200 GB card that was on sale yesterday, so that should help.

Photos would be another reason. Particularly since Google has been ranting about how high quality their camera is.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by Zikes on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @12:55PM (#12736394)
Yeah, even with "unlimited cloud storage" they only store the original quality of photos for the amount of space you pay for, past the initial few GBs.
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by dflock on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @01:41AM (#12741360)
I thought that limitation was gone for pixel users?
Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by blisterpeanuts on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:13AM (#12735232)
I'd love to have my 60-70 gigs of music on board my phone and available at all times, not just when I have good cell coverage or wifi.

Also, when I visit Canada, data is suddenly super expensive.

What's more, I'd like to have all my GPS maps available offline. It's very difficult situation when I've traveled to some out of the way place where I have no reception, and can't load any maps to navigate me home.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by dspillett on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:09AM (#12735178)
Photos, videos, maps, and other data, all accessible while not online as in some places being reliably online with a fast enough link is expensive or completely impossible.

You could carry a laptop to archive the data off to I suppose, but that makes the arrangement a lot less conveniently portable if you didn't already have to cart that with you for other reasons.

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by mgkimsal on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @11:07AM (#12735158)
pictures? music?

not everyone wants to pay hundreds of dollars to host stuff someplace else, wait for it to sync, run the risk of being lost/destroyed, and paying even more if/when data caps are broken (or paying even more for 'unlimited' data).

Re:Google Pixel: the Android iPhone you've been waiting for by x0x0 on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @06:59PM (#12739499)
Keep in mind that the OS eats, IIRC, 10g-ish of that supposed 32. And you'd better keep another couple g free for OTA updates. So you're now down to more like 20g of useable space. On a phone that shoots hd video.

Me personally: a 4g spotify cache so I don't burn through data, cached maps, lots of pics and video, and I'm constantly dealing with out of space warnings.