Re:Fuck You Startup World
by km3k on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:27PM
(#12687139)
This article explains well why I avoid startups. I've considered joining some, but always get turned off by the interview phase. The ones that bug me the most...
> Fuck your crazy work hours
In my opinion, if you're working crazy hours, you've already failed, likely due to poor management of the project. The only exception I see is if you don't really have a life outside work and are working on a project that you're really passionate about, but even then it should be a temporary thing.
> Fuck your open space floor plans, You really think Zucks builds a Facebook’s 2017 roadmap while a nerf war is ranging outside
I want to get work done and move on with life, not play silly office games. Open space floor plans kill my focus.
> Fuck you startups with your extravagant parties and crazy off-site events that cost way too much money
I've never understood this. I want to work for your company. If I want to go on vacation, I'll do it with my family, not my coworkers. I have no desire to be best friends with all my coworkers.
>I want to get work done and move on with life, not play silly office games. Open space floor plans kill my focus.
I always found the people against cubicles but for open floor plans strange. In reality, it's pretty much impossible to build offices for every employee. Cubicles were supposed to be the fix for that. You have a open office with space and partitions to separate you from other people. Then someone said that open offices offer substantial collaboration for employees. The people who were drones in a cubicle farm bought into it, because I supposed it was a change from the Office Space type scenery.
But now all we get are interruptions with no recourse. We have desks that are fixed to other desks or desks that are clustered together where the only thing that separates you from your neighbor is your monitor. Everything is open, so now the collaboration areas (they're meeting areas, but calling it collaboration areas make it agile or some crap like that) aren't fully enclosed. Everyone in a 30 foot radius gets to sit in on the meeting as well!
From the other side, I get management types telling me to keep my voice down, because I'm disturbing the collaborators. Never mind that I'm trying to get work done by hammering out details with other devs and testers - their meeting that encroaches on my space in always more important. So much more important that their jokes, their laughs, their applause, their voices, and any other other form of noise have no upper noise limit. No sweat though, it's not like I'm working or anything.
Heaven forbid I do anything like open personal email, bank account info, etc.
The person to my left, to my right, behind me, and that small cluster of 5 people in that collaboration area can see my screen as plain as day.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by Florin_Andrei on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @03:09PM
(#12687580)
> Then someone said that open offices offer substantial collaboration for employees.
> From the other side, I get management types telling me to keep my voice down, because I'm disturbing the collaborators.
> But cubicles are somehow terrible.
As someone who grew up in the Eastern Bloc, I find this kind of Doublethink almost... nostalgic? Ahhh, the good old days, when we were all following Dear Leader's flawless directives!
Sorry...totally unrelated but I remembered your name fellow telescope maker ;) I think I read about your atm journey on cloudynights. Are you the one who did simple turntable grinding machine?
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by Bartweiss on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @10:04AM
(#12684427)
This feels like a bizarre mixture of sensible criticism and sour grapes.
Standing desks? Actually pretty great for those who want them! If your back hurts after a day of sitting, go find some option you like better - why should the rest of us be upset by it? Yeah, they're not an option at a lot of jobs, but demanding that everyone standardize on a bad experience because "you're not special" is a great way to make every job awful.
A book a week? Not so bad, especially if it's something light! There are plenty of books you can read in <10 hours, even content-rich ones.
Understanding complexity? Interviewing is a mess, that's a standard belief, but constant time versus exponential time isn't meaningless yet. Start by getting rid of tree reversal questions, not declaring Big-O a useless concept.
And yet there's something pretty good buried under all the impractical complaints. Putting together a "user story" shouldn't be necessary when the task is "our login page is broke, let's fix it". Adding layers of media references and cultural touchstones to every possible concept just creates useless barriers to entry. A/B testing a hundred different features in isolation isn't a viable way to build a product.
So yes: there are a lot of things to criticize, and I know this is hyperbole. It's still a weird mix of justified and left-field attacks.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by andrepd on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:40AM
(#12684250)
>I never had to shift a bit in a C array in my life! And I never got a compilation error on a white board, when I need an hash set in Java I just use HashSet- I don’t fucking care about the complexity of this code block because I can afford another EC2 instance! So fuck you.
No, fuck you for making everything run so slow on our pocket and desktop supercomputers.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by Ezhik on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @04:18PM
(#12688162)
...I said, as I shared this article in a JavaScript-powered desktop team collaboration application, and went back to writing a JavaScript-powered server-side application in a JavaScript-powered text editor.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by KaiserPro on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:22AM
(#12691653)
Haha, most excellent.
One thing that I'm only now (and stupidly late) realising is that tech journalism almost never critiques new trends.
Sure there are some gut "this fucking sucks" but there is never a real effort to provide some critical thinking about the PR emanating from whichever source.
For example, soylent is the brain child of someone who has possibly crippling [OCD](http://robrhinehart.com/?p=1331) (Having been blighted by it for most of my teenage and childhood.) It looks like one of his coping mechanisms.
I'm sure its a great product, but I wouldn't want to emulate someone's OCD lifestyle. Yet we are asked to "emulate the habits of these successful XXX" without stopping to ask, are they happy?
Yet no one seems to ask the question: "is this good?" or "whats the logical outcome?" They just seem to be keen to breathlessly relay the PR line, possible with a pithy snap reaction.
I'm not suggesting a flame war for every press release, just a health helping of critical thinking, and some research.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by kafkaesq on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:43PM
(#12687341)
Fuck reading a book a week. No one can read that fast. Let me repeat that -NO ONE CAN FUCKING READ THAT FAST.
Finally someone has the courage to tell the truth. I mean, I get the part about the necessary skimming one has to to do not just get through school, but be a practical, working academic (as described in the HBR article). Or the way that techies need to skim lots of tech books to stay ahead in one's career.
But that's not reading (in the sense of works meant to be read and not just "understood" -- that is, fiction, or high-quality non-fiction). Which means getting in the author's head; making their language your own (to the point of it sometimes actually does become the language you use, in ordinary speech and writing); getting to know their characters to the point where they have at least a partial feeling of tangible reality to them (like people you actually do know from the physical word); and their stomping grounds, to a point where they feel like places you've actually live in.
That's why it often takes me weeks, sometimes months (and multiple readings) to "read" a book. Very part-time, mind you -- I suppose I could make it go faster, if I made a "system" about it. Yeah, I suppose if I put my mind to it, I could get through a good-sized book in a week or so.
But then I would probably just end up "understanding" the book. Not reading it.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by nekopa on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @11:19AM
(#12693642)
I read incredibly fast. Reading a book a night is no problem for me. I think it is genetic, as my mother could read at a pace that astounded even me, and she could recall everything from the book too. A 500 page novel would take her about 2-3 hours to get through, then she could recite the book back to you - scenery, dialogs the works.
Now this is talking about novels. If I'm reading to learn then you have to I must interact with the book, stop and think, go back and make connections, try something out etc.
This is where I like the statement in the book "How to read a book" about reading as fast as is necessary to complete the task you want to accomplish - fast for a quick read through maybe, then slower on another read through for making notes.
So I can read a novel a night, or a pop Sci book in a day, but I've been going through a math book for the last 2 months, and of course, I've been reading the first chapter of TAOCP for about 15 years (hence the math books now :)
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by cardigan on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @05:35PM
(#12688710)
Sorry that's not the truth, I read about a book a week. This week I've read 3 and started another 2. The secret is to read for enjoyment, a lot, and eventually you get fast. If it feels like a chore, you're not reading the right books: read something else. If you're enjoying it, it's easy to get carried away and read for many hours at a time.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by kafkaesq on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @06:59PM
(#12689210)
Yeah, I get the "enjoyment" part. What it comes down to is that some people just like to read (certain kinds of things) more slowly, even though they could be reading them more quickly. Guiding principle being: it's not the number of words (or the number of books read in a year), but the intensity of the experience that they're after.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by staticelf on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @02:14AM
(#12690754)
I only do audiobooks and then I can easily complete one book in a week. Although, I think most books are uninteresting so I don't listen to one each week.
I hate reading books. It's the worst advice anyone can give me.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by staticelf on Thursday October 13, 2016 @05:11AM
(#12699438)
I've listened to REWORK and REMOTE recently, which I liked. I think I will listen to "How to win friends and influence people" but I much rather listen to podcasts.
Well I read a lot of articles, listens to a lot of podcasts and watch a lot of documentaries so I disagree. Books in general only has one point of view and doesn't reflect the real world.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by CobrastanJorji on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:25PM
(#12687116)
> Fuck your crazy work hours.
Yeah!
> Fuck you drinking culture too.
Yeah!
> Fuck your open space floor plans
Yeah!
> Fuck the transparency trend, the post mortem and the 5 whys.
Yea---wait, what? Those other things are reasonable complaints, but wondering why things go wrong and trying to stop them from going wrong for the same reason tomorrow is, you know, good.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by CobrastanJorji on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @03:51PM
(#12687965)
I concur. Incidents have many causes and different levels of failures, and "5 Why" documents make it too easy to target an easy or politically convenient solution without needing to mention the other failings.
Postmortems in general are fantastic, though. "Here is what (not who, what) went wrong, here is the list of things that made it go wrong, and here are the steps we're taking to make sure that this can't happen again or will not be as bad when it happens again."
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by meira on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @03:03PM
(#12687519)
I guess the complain about it is because to founders this is easy to do and gain some juice after failure while employees still get nothing. If it is só I agree with him. Glamourization of failure (privillege of few).
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by quinndupont on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:18AM
(#12684077)
The irony of the fact that I read this during my morning 30 minute read through of tech news—at Hacker News, the über site, no less—is not lost on me.
Although a funny essay, there's a great deal of truth here, and should make us ask some hard questions about how, why, and when the technology world and its culture should infiltrate the everyday.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:22AM
(#12684110)
Now that the 30-minute routine of tech news is done, we shall reflect on this essay during the 30-minute meditation session and add appropriate actionable items to our quarterly and yearly goals.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by ensiferum on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @05:33AM
(#12691489)
I don't work or live in the valley but that was hilarious and based on the blogosphere probably on point too. Except for the part of the hash map complexity. In fact as the volumes of data grow the complexities become more important, not less. You simply cannot brute force your way out of a bad complexity.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by dasil003 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:23PM
(#12687095)
Toxic SV culture is ripe for parody, but words won't stop it. What will stop it is when the money stops flowing so easily and the wider economy improves so that it's no longer the place to be for the greedy. Not sure I see both those things happening any time soon, in the meantime Tech is sadly the new Finance.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by ixtli on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:27PM
(#12687144)
Or, we (engineers) could all take a cue from workers of the past and organize to demand an end to abusive labor practices.
Seriously guys, just because we're making 10x the salary of a miner doesn't mean we're not also generating 100x the money for our employers without being allowed to take part in decisions that effect our lives.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by ch4s3 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:45PM
(#12687358)
You probably aren't making 10x what a miner makes. Mine foremen make around 95K[1]. A regular miner makes somewhere in the range of 40k-55k. Do you make 400k as a software developer? I'm making a broader point here, in that you aren't as seperated from blue collar workers in terms of your economic interests as you may think.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by jeffbax on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @04:30PM
(#12688253)
Yeah, but you get to make it without hugely-out-of-your-control health complications. Developers can get fat eating a lot of pizza, but they can run it off. Harder for a miner to avoid all the hazards with the job. As much as I hate the open workspace, I also would prefer being at a computer than doing manual labor in a claustrophobic mine.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by ch4s3 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @05:16PM
(#12688585)
Yeah, of course. I meant you income -> social position relative to the people who own the capital. There are interesting parallels. Mining companies operate on leased land with leased equipment backed by institutional investors... they keep it lean. The contemporary mine operator isn't totally dissimilar to the CEO/founder of a largish startup in how they approach their business. Yeah, of course writing code won't give you black lung, but you're still working for the man. The coal mine machine operator is a lot more like me than I am like Jack Dorsey.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by pawadu on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:12AM
(#12684028)
Seriously, there are so many great points in there hidden between the expletives. Here is one that really touched me:
> And what the fuck all those parties after raising money. Don’t you get it? You just dug your grave a little bit deeper. You should celebrate any day that you don’t have to sell off another part of your company.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by minimaxir on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @01:58PM
(#12686817)
Although I genuinely miss Valleywag and all the absurdity that it covered (e.g. Clinkle), I'm not sure if this is a fair critique of startup culture outside of having the excuse to say the F word a lot. As someone living in San Francisco, I can say that there are more to startups and startup culture than the stereotypes seen in Medium thought pieces and the Hacker News front page, although given the end of this particular Medium thought piece, that may be the point.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by _vya7 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:24PM
(#12687102)
He either completely misses the point, or completely gets it.
Every single one of these "benefits" are very well thought out and calculated shams meant to deceive and manipulate impressionable kids into working insane hours for less than a realistic living wage. That's the whole point.
It's just like that circus in the Pinocchio movie.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by 6stringmerc on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:29PM
(#12687175)
Not quite as exploitative as the music industry prefers to behave in pursuit of profits, but I concur the general top-down structuring of environments like that is not particularly an accident. Like hard seats in a fast food restaurant - they're not supposed to make you want to stay for an extended period of time, in theory.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by bmelton on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:29PM
(#12687169)
The only takeaway for me is the wondering whether or not the author really thinks you can't read a book a week. I mean, yeah, you have to make time to read the books, but an average length book takes something like 6-8 hours to read, so if you allocate an hour a day (which I maintain is worth doing), you're generally going to be able to comfortably knock out a book a week.
Sure, you're not churning through War & Peace every week, but for regular books, it's really not that hard.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by fdgdasfadsf on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:41PM
(#12687314)
His point is that reading is about the journey not the destination. Better to read less books but savour and enjoy them (or if non-fiction is your thing take the time to learn the materials properly) then finish them to say you finished them.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by bmelton on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @05:43PM
(#12688766)
I've known a number of folks who have done "read more" challenges, whether 50 books a year was the target or some other number, and while this is surely anecdotal, the real goal wasn't hitting some arbitrary number, but simply to encourage reading more, and prioritizing reading as a hobby.
As someone whose greatest pleasure is a day off with a good book, it's hard to balance reading with all the grownup responsibilities we have, and as a leisure item, it's usually the first thing cut from a busy day's schedule. Reading a book a week isn't as much about the number, but by gamifying the outcome, you prioritize it above things you might otherwise not.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by wombatpm on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @05:35PM
(#12688707)
People say that, but the destination is important.
"Journeys require endpoints, otherwise you're not Frodao, your just a homeless guy wandering around with stolen jewelry" - The Oatmeal http://theoatmeal.com/comics/unhappy
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:28AM
(#12684152)
> Fuck your eating disorders, why the fuck does everything has to be so extreme with you? On one end of the scale you’ve got the pizza-guzzling, office-snack hoarding monster, and on the other end you have the ‘I-must-optimize-every-living-second’ douche that only drinks fucking Soylent. Seriously, what the fuck?
And from me: also fuck your third extreme, of eating fucking hipster fruit salads all day every day, because everything has to be healthy and natural and organic and stuff. And fuck the way you force it on the industry events, so that I can't get a goddamn pizza on a programming conference because everything now has a catering company providing various kinds of weird-ass vegetarian food. I can eat healthy at home; I come to industry events for the fucking pizza.
There, I said it. I feel a little bit better.
--
As for the rest of the essay, it's a little heavy on the expletive side, but pretty much spot-on if you look at the media side of things. I'd say things aren't so bad in individual startups, but the overall culture - the blogosphere, the professional publications, etc. all feel like encouraging and glorifying this kind of nonsense.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by justin66 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:56AM
(#12684358)
> I can eat healthy at home; I come to industry events for the fucking pizza.
Really? In most realms outside IT, that's the food you buy when you consider the people eating it not worthy of actual catering. I can understand wanting pizza if the alternative is salad and water, but still.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by Animats on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:38PM
(#12687279)
I keep thinking it's time for the next dot-com collapse. The level of excess is too high. But we haven't had the first really big failure yet. Yahoo and Twitter are almost ready to collapse. Uber is still iffy, because they subsidize rides with investment capital to buy market share and lose money.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by AstroJetson on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @05:17PM
(#12688593)
You should look into getting an embedded systems job, those programs are full of shift / AND / OR / bit twiddle galore. You'll feel awesome for awhile, but trust me, all that low level bit stuff is sometimes a huge pain.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by cafard on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @04:40PM
(#12688341)
I think that I last had to shift bits in a C program back when WordPerfect (4.2 and 5.1) used an XOR cipher for encryption, and used bit-shifting and (I think) XOR-ing to give you a 16-bit key for quick rejection of bad passwords. (At least, I think that's what the key was for.)
On the other hand, I last read a book in a week last week. It was a novel, not very long or very complex; but it was a book and it took less than a week.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by tdb7893 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:38PM
(#12687289)
This article is trying to point out the absurdity of the current culture of the area, which I don't think makes him a curmudgeon. Also, reading HN (which I doubt is a terribly accurate characterization) makes Silicon Valley seem like an absurdly pretentious and expensive bubble.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by cwyers on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:34PM
(#12687234)
> Fuck reading a book a week. No one can read that fast. Let me repeat that -NO ONE CAN FUCKING READ THAT FAST. How about actually reading that god damn book?!
What the hell are you even talking about? Can't read one book a week?
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by antfarm on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @05:03AM
(#12691364)
> Fuck you and your stupid interview questions. Who the fuck thinks of these stupid fucking questions? I never had to shift a bit in a C array in my life! And I never got a compilation error on a white board, when I need an hash set in Java I just use HashSet- I don’t fucking care about the complexity of this code block because I can afford another EC2 instance! So fuck you.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by antfarm on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @05:31AM
(#12691483)
> Fuck you startups with your extravagant parties and crazy off-site events that cost way too much money, you’re supposed to buy some fucking servers instead!
So he can continue wasting CPU cycles out of pure ignorance ;)
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by julian25 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:28PM
(#12687159)
Look, I get the issues with startup culture but this guy doesn't offer any reasonable suggestions on how to fix them and just uses his Medium soapbox to throw a tantrum. If you want things to change, writing an article with 35 "fucks" is not the way to do it.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by enkiv2 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:38PM
(#12687290)
There's a system that more or less works, and generates a much greater innovation to hype ratio. And, that's the system of normal small businesses. The alternative shouldn't need to be mentioned, because everywhere other than SV, it's omnipresent.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by bl4ckcontact on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:38PM
(#12687284)
I agree with you, but it is clear here that he is using Medium as his outlet to vent, and I think that is fine. Whether or not his tantrum is valid or even rational is not so much the point, in my opinion. He recognizes that he himself is a participant in the cult-like behavior that plagues the tech scene, and recognizing there is problem in the first place is a good start.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by _vya7 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:29PM
(#12687166)
Sometimes anger is justified. And sometimes it calls for a good venting. Sometimes it even calls for a little activism. And sometimes all of these are just futile, because richer people are in control of what you see and hear, who have interest in keeping their pockets full using the hard work of young impressionable kids who don't know the real value of their own time. It's sickening, and the anger is justified. The rant is probably going to be forgotten tomorrow though, and unfortunately won't save a single soul from the startup world.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by abritinthebay on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @04:55PM
(#12688448)
> Fuck reading a book a week. No one can read that fast.
Now the rest of the complaints are... well at least reasonable to rant about (well, the technical ones are kinda crap, but culture ones are apt).
But this? This is just silly.
Reading a single book shouldn't take someone a week. A good sized book can be read in weekend afternoon if you're really into it. But 3 days of occasional reading should get most writing that isn't incredibly dry polished off.
All that complaint is is the author saying "I don't want to, and I won't make the time to."
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by meesles on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:27PM
(#12687134)
Meh. I could write this same post about the corporate world stereotypes, but that would be dumb. This person has a problem with healthy people, fat people, people who have an interest in their field, people who work hard and overachieve, just an absurd breadth of random adjectives and interests that make people unique.
It just seems like they wish everyone was the same so they wouldn't be compared to the tons of people who've found success in the 'startup world'.
Re:Fuck You Startup World
by kbenson on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:34PM
(#12687237)
Maybe we need a HN edition.
Fuck you HN, and your overly critical and serious comments complaining about how the article isn't new, isn't cool, isn't specific enough.
Fuck you HN for feeling the need to comment just to get your voice out there, just to put something down, just so you can add your snide remark at the end to prove your own intelligence to your peers.
And fuck me, for doing all of the above in pointing that out.
> Fuck your crazy work hours
In my opinion, if you're working crazy hours, you've already failed, likely due to poor management of the project. The only exception I see is if you don't really have a life outside work and are working on a project that you're really passionate about, but even then it should be a temporary thing.
> Fuck your open space floor plans, You really think Zucks builds a Facebook’s 2017 roadmap while a nerf war is ranging outside
I want to get work done and move on with life, not play silly office games. Open space floor plans kill my focus.
> Fuck you startups with your extravagant parties and crazy off-site events that cost way too much money
I've never understood this. I want to work for your company. If I want to go on vacation, I'll do it with my family, not my coworkers. I have no desire to be best friends with all my coworkers.
I always found the people against cubicles but for open floor plans strange. In reality, it's pretty much impossible to build offices for every employee. Cubicles were supposed to be the fix for that. You have a open office with space and partitions to separate you from other people. Then someone said that open offices offer substantial collaboration for employees. The people who were drones in a cubicle farm bought into it, because I supposed it was a change from the Office Space type scenery.
But now all we get are interruptions with no recourse. We have desks that are fixed to other desks or desks that are clustered together where the only thing that separates you from your neighbor is your monitor. Everything is open, so now the collaboration areas (they're meeting areas, but calling it collaboration areas make it agile or some crap like that) aren't fully enclosed. Everyone in a 30 foot radius gets to sit in on the meeting as well!
From the other side, I get management types telling me to keep my voice down, because I'm disturbing the collaborators. Never mind that I'm trying to get work done by hammering out details with other devs and testers - their meeting that encroaches on my space in always more important. So much more important that their jokes, their laughs, their applause, their voices, and any other other form of noise have no upper noise limit. No sweat though, it's not like I'm working or anything.
Heaven forbid I do anything like open personal email, bank account info, etc. The person to my left, to my right, behind me, and that small cluster of 5 people in that collaboration area can see my screen as plain as day.
But cubicles are somehow terrible.
> From the other side, I get management types telling me to keep my voice down, because I'm disturbing the collaborators.
> But cubicles are somehow terrible.
As someone who grew up in the Eastern Bloc, I find this kind of Doublethink almost... nostalgic? Ahhh, the good old days, when we were all following Dear Leader's flawless directives!
Standing desks? Actually pretty great for those who want them! If your back hurts after a day of sitting, go find some option you like better - why should the rest of us be upset by it? Yeah, they're not an option at a lot of jobs, but demanding that everyone standardize on a bad experience because "you're not special" is a great way to make every job awful.
A book a week? Not so bad, especially if it's something light! There are plenty of books you can read in <10 hours, even content-rich ones.
Understanding complexity? Interviewing is a mess, that's a standard belief, but constant time versus exponential time isn't meaningless yet. Start by getting rid of tree reversal questions, not declaring Big-O a useless concept.
And yet there's something pretty good buried under all the impractical complaints. Putting together a "user story" shouldn't be necessary when the task is "our login page is broke, let's fix it". Adding layers of media references and cultural touchstones to every possible concept just creates useless barriers to entry. A/B testing a hundred different features in isolation isn't a viable way to build a product.
So yes: there are a lot of things to criticize, and I know this is hyperbole. It's still a weird mix of justified and left-field attacks.
No, fuck you for making everything run so slow on our pocket and desktop supercomputers.
One thing that I'm only now (and stupidly late) realising is that tech journalism almost never critiques new trends.
Sure there are some gut "this fucking sucks" but there is never a real effort to provide some critical thinking about the PR emanating from whichever source.
For example, soylent is the brain child of someone who has possibly crippling [OCD](http://robrhinehart.com/?p=1331) (Having been blighted by it for most of my teenage and childhood.) It looks like one of his coping mechanisms.
I'm sure its a great product, but I wouldn't want to emulate someone's OCD lifestyle. Yet we are asked to "emulate the habits of these successful XXX" without stopping to ask, are they happy?
Yet no one seems to ask the question: "is this good?" or "whats the logical outcome?" They just seem to be keen to breathlessly relay the PR line, possible with a pithy snap reaction.
I'm not suggesting a flame war for every press release, just a health helping of critical thinking, and some research.
Finally someone has the courage to tell the truth. I mean, I get the part about the necessary skimming one has to to do not just get through school, but be a practical, working academic (as described in the HBR article). Or the way that techies need to skim lots of tech books to stay ahead in one's career.
But that's not reading (in the sense of works meant to be read and not just "understood" -- that is, fiction, or high-quality non-fiction). Which means getting in the author's head; making their language your own (to the point of it sometimes actually does become the language you use, in ordinary speech and writing); getting to know their characters to the point where they have at least a partial feeling of tangible reality to them (like people you actually do know from the physical word); and their stomping grounds, to a point where they feel like places you've actually live in.
That's why it often takes me weeks, sometimes months (and multiple readings) to "read" a book. Very part-time, mind you -- I suppose I could make it go faster, if I made a "system" about it. Yeah, I suppose if I put my mind to it, I could get through a good-sized book in a week or so.
But then I would probably just end up "understanding" the book. Not reading it.
Now this is talking about novels. If I'm reading to learn then you have to I must interact with the book, stop and think, go back and make connections, try something out etc.
This is where I like the statement in the book "How to read a book" about reading as fast as is necessary to complete the task you want to accomplish - fast for a quick read through maybe, then slower on another read through for making notes.
So I can read a novel a night, or a pop Sci book in a day, but I've been going through a math book for the last 2 months, and of course, I've been reading the first chapter of TAOCP for about 15 years (hence the math books now :)
I hate reading books. It's the worst advice anyone can give me.
What kinds of books are you reading? I assure you, there's something out there for everyone.
I think your statement is a cop out. There's no better way to get a greater understanding of the world out thereb
Well I read a lot of articles, listens to a lot of podcasts and watch a lot of documentaries so I disagree. Books in general only has one point of view and doesn't reflect the real world.
I mean, I listen to 3 books on audible (pretty easy to do). Light entertaining books like Predictable Irrational, Toyota Kata, etc.
At the same time the whole month I'm working / doing exercises of a difficult math or programming book.
Therefore 4 books in a month an average of 1 a week.
Yeah!
> Fuck you drinking culture too.
Yeah!
> Fuck your open space floor plans
Yeah!
> Fuck the transparency trend, the post mortem and the 5 whys.
Yea---wait, what? Those other things are reasonable complaints, but wondering why things go wrong and trying to stop them from going wrong for the same reason tomorrow is, you know, good.
[1]:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5_Whys#Criticism
Postmortems in general are fantastic, though. "Here is what (not who, what) went wrong, here is the list of things that made it go wrong, and here are the steps we're taking to make sure that this can't happen again or will not be as bad when it happens again."
Although a funny essay, there's a great deal of truth here, and should make us ask some hard questions about how, why, and when the technology world and its culture should infiltrate the everyday.
;).
Seriously guys, just because we're making 10x the salary of a miner doesn't mean we're not also generating 100x the money for our employers without being allowed to take part in decisions that effect our lives.
[1]https://www.google.com/search?q=mine+sallaries&oq=mine+salla...
> And what the fuck all those parties after raising money. Don’t you get it? You just dug your grave a little bit deeper. You should celebrate any day that you don’t have to sell off another part of your company.
Yes, but not much.
Every single one of these "benefits" are very well thought out and calculated shams meant to deceive and manipulate impressionable kids into working insane hours for less than a realistic living wage. That's the whole point.
It's just like that circus in the Pinocchio movie.
Sure, you're not churning through War & Peace every week, but for regular books, it's really not that hard.
As someone whose greatest pleasure is a day off with a good book, it's hard to balance reading with all the grownup responsibilities we have, and as a leisure item, it's usually the first thing cut from a busy day's schedule. Reading a book a week isn't as much about the number, but by gamifying the outcome, you prioritize it above things you might otherwise not.
And from me: also fuck your third extreme, of eating fucking hipster fruit salads all day every day, because everything has to be healthy and natural and organic and stuff. And fuck the way you force it on the industry events, so that I can't get a goddamn pizza on a programming conference because everything now has a catering company providing various kinds of weird-ass vegetarian food. I can eat healthy at home; I come to industry events for the fucking pizza.
There, I said it. I feel a little bit better.
--
As for the rest of the essay, it's a little heavy on the expletive side, but pretty much spot-on if you look at the media side of things. I'd say things aren't so bad in individual startups, but the overall culture - the blogosphere, the professional publications, etc. all feel like encouraging and glorifying this kind of nonsense.
That's an odd reason to attend an event/conference.
Really? In most realms outside IT, that's the food you buy when you consider the people eating it not worthy of actual catering. I can understand wanting pizza if the alternative is salad and water, but still.
Now UI stuff, that's where the real fun is!! ;-)
On the other hand, I last read a book in a week last week. It was a novel, not very long or very complex; but it was a book and it took less than a week.
> But more than all, start-up world, fuck you for making me one of you.
I'm on your lawn, aren't I?
I should get off, shouldn't I...
Doesn't say anything for people against things that legitimately suck though.
:(
I JUST WANTED TO GO INTO SPAACE!
Cookie for anybody who gets that semi-obscure reference.
What the hell are you even talking about? Can't read one book a week?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TgL_5QcZCMo
I was hearing Ed Norton say "fuck you!" as I read this.
Living in the bay area and working for a startup it's easy to relate and it's funny, i'll five the author that.
After the second paragraph it starts getting pretty old though...
Startup or not, I wouldn't hire that guy.
So he can continue wasting CPU cycles out of pure ignorance ;)
it's one of the automatic deals and has presets and --
i don't even eat doritos
Now the rest of the complaints are... well at least reasonable to rant about (well, the technical ones are kinda crap, but culture ones are apt).
But this? This is just silly.
Reading a single book shouldn't take someone a week. A good sized book can be read in weekend afternoon if you're really into it. But 3 days of occasional reading should get most writing that isn't incredibly dry polished off.
All that complaint is is the author saying "I don't want to, and I won't make the time to."
It just seems like they wish everyone was the same so they wouldn't be compared to the tons of people who've found success in the 'startup world'.
2/10, barely entertaining.
Fuck you HN, and your overly critical and serious comments complaining about how the article isn't new, isn't cool, isn't specific enough.
Fuck you HN for feeling the need to comment just to get your voice out there, just to put something down, just so you can add your snide remark at the end to prove your own intelligence to your peers.
And fuck me, for doing all of the above in pointing that out.