News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by electic on Thursday September 15, 2016 @09:41AM (#12506012)
Most of Tesla's issues are with the name. Drivers assume this is a fully autonomous driving system. This leads to big problems. I have seen videos of drivers sleeping while the car drives itself down the highway.

A more appropriate name would be co-pilot.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by luca_ing on Friday September 16, 2016 @07:19AM (#12513211)
> Most of Tesla's issues are with the name. Drivers assume this is a fully autonomous driving system.

You are jumping too short.

In my first year studying engineering, a professor told us "Expect misuse. If you're designing a radiator shaped such that people can sit on it, expect them to sit on it. I agree that it's a radiator and not a bench, but if you don't design for this kind of situation you are a terrible engineer."

Translated to Tesla's situation: It's absolutely not enough to tell people that they should behave a certain way, and expect them to follow. Design the system such that they either have no choice but to obey, or have safe mechanisms for disobedience.

Or don't deploy the system.

If you want an automotive example, think of how your automatic gear lever is locked in P unless you have your foot on the brake. Braking when changing gears isn't just an admonition in the manual, it's enforced.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by supercoder on Friday September 16, 2016 @07:57AM (#12513377)
But how do you design a bench to avoid it being used as a radiator.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by sixseven on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:00AM (#12506156)
Sure Tesla could've named it better, but anyone who put their life on the hand of an immature technology is beyond my comprehension. News of crashes from people using Auto Pilot comes up here and there, why are people still willing to risk their life on trusting it?
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by fucking_tragedy on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:16AM (#12506304)
Most people aren't and shouldn't be concerned with the technical details of a consumer product's implementation, especially when it is marketed as Autopilot and, in practice, it creates a false sense of security.

Tesla marketed their immature technology with the name Autopilot, they failed to include safety features their competitors' vehicles had and they knew how people behaved (trusted and crashed) because of it.

I find it hard to fault consumers for naively putting trust in their vehicles.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mtgx on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:17AM (#12506324)
This is like arguing that people are stupid for thinking that their email is private.

Most people don't know even 1% of the intricacies of the technology products or services that they are using. The responsibility rests almost entirely on the provider to offer a "safe" product (and that means also offering protection against the "stupidity" of users).

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by UnoriginalGuy on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:22AM (#12506367)
> but anyone who put their life on the hand of an immature technology is beyond my comprehension.

Because humans are flawed.

The real question is why is our regulatory framework so weak that they can ship "immature technology" that's safety critical in a consumer vehicle.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by greglindahl on Thursday September 15, 2016 @01:33PM (#12508085)
Is there any proof of your claim? I see it repeatedly repeated here on HN, but that doesn't make it true. For example, a video of a driver sleeping while driving doesn't mean that the name is an issue.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by gallerdude on Thursday September 15, 2016 @09:49PM (#12511384)
Ironically, I recall it was called autopilot to be the conservative synonym for self-driving. I guess it wasn't conservative enough.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by m_mueller on Thursday September 15, 2016 @11:09PM (#12511585)
How would autopilot be "conservative"? It's right there in the word: Pilots itself.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by gallerdude on Thursday September 15, 2016 @11:55PM (#12511716)
Well, not really. Autopilot, in airplanes at least, can maintain the course, but not much besides that.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by manicdee on Friday September 16, 2016 @12:43AM (#12511884)
The catch being that muggles do not understand that autopilot isn't taking decision-making and situational awareness responsibility away from the human pilot.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by IsThisNameValid on Sunday September 18, 2016 @09:02AM (#12525121)
In an airplane of sufficient complexity, the autopilot will be controlled by a computer (ussually refered to as an FMS {Flight Management System}). You can program a set of desired waypoints, along with a desired time of arrival, and the plane will fly the desired route with high accuracy. (auto-throttle system is also required)
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by m_mueller on Friday September 16, 2016 @01:03AM (#12511958)
That's why autopilot is probably a misnomer even in aviation, that doesn't make its use in Teslas any better though.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by toddmorey on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:24AM (#12506384)
That has been my thought exactly! And they'd still have the opportunity to then use the autopilot brand once the appropriate level of autonomy was reached. Co-pilot --> Autopilot feels much stronger than Autopilot --> Autopilot Plus™ or similar.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by lj3 on Thursday September 15, 2016 @01:13PM (#12507908)
Don't pilots typically sleep on long trips while their co-pilot flies the plane? Maybe a better term to use would be "assist". "assisted driving system" or "assisted highway driving"?
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @09:54AM (#12506108)
I never understood how the public decided that "autopilot" means a fully autonomous system. I grudgingly admit that some people think this way, but how did it happen?
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by blackguardx on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:07AM (#12506221)
Look at how the word was formed. It came from Automatic - "(of a device or process) working by itself with little or no direct human control" and Pilot - "a person who operates the flying controls of an aircraft"

In the 50s or 60s or whenever they were first introduced, it was incredibly novel to have some portion of aircraft control handled by a machine. To go from partial machine control to fully machine control seems like a natural evolution and I think the name speaks for that evolution.

I think it is fair that most consumers think that "autopilot" implies fully autonomous driving. No one calls cruise control an autopilot when in fact it is a crude form of one.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:10AM (#12506254)
"Little or no direct human control" is pretty far from "zero human supervision" so the etymological argument doesn't really do it for me.

Lots of cars have "automatic transmissions" but nobody gets upset when it fails to shift into reverse on its own based on contextual clues.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by electic on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:13AM (#12506277)
A big part of this is movies. When they show auto-pilot in the movies, people get up and just leave. There are countless times I have seen this play out in the movies and people think cars with the same name should behave the same way.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:14AM (#12506295)
Do you have an example? The only one that comes to mind is Airplane! where the whole thing is played for laughs. I'm not questioning it, I'm just unfamiliar.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by etendue on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:16AM (#12506313)
Demolition Man, I Robot, or Minority Report
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:43AM (#12506539)
It disturbs me that all the examples so far are science fiction. If people are inferring real-world capabilities from SF movies then we're totally screwed!
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by ceejayoz on Friday September 16, 2016 @09:36AM (#12513841)
> If people are inferring real-world capabilities from SF movies then we're totally screwed!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CSI_effect

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by pjc50 on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:58AM (#12506686)
Other way round: real-world capabilities are built out to meet the SF expectations. Star Trek communicators -> mobile phones. Star Trek computer -> Alexa/Siri et al.

(Besides, the alternative is for the layman to infer capabilities from marketing material, which is even more outlandishly fictional)

Oh, and if you want an exhaustive list of when something appears in media, TVtropes will always deliver: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/discussion.php?id=6zj22p5kr47sfh2...

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by etendue on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:54AM (#12506647)
I don't see why my examples should in any way "disturb you". Science fiction frequently is an inspiration for products and ideas that are made real, examples are legion.

I judiciously selected I Robot and Minority Report because Audi and Lexus, respectively, had product placement for future design concepts.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @11:03AM (#12506735)
If these movies are in fact the reason why people overestimate the capabilities of Tesla's system, then that means people's inability to distinguish science fiction from reality is getting people actually killed. That's pretty disturbing! Note, I'm not saying it's wrong, just awful.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by etendue on Thursday September 15, 2016 @11:23AM (#12506920)
I am not trying to imply that people are having difficulty distinguishing fiction from reality.

I am noting that real auto companies have deliberately placed product concepts in media to prime people's expectations of what future products will look like and what they will be able to do. Independently, there are also proper level 4 systems under active development getting plenty of popular press coverage.

I also note that the very public face of Tesla frequently makes very public and (in my opinion, overly optimistic) declarations of their product's capabilities both present and future, for example (Jan 2016), "The Model S is 'probably better than humans at this point in highway driving' according to Musk." [0]

It doesn't strike me to be all that far of a leap for an average person to conclude that the future has arrived.

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/jan/11/elon-musk...

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by RodericDay on Thursday September 15, 2016 @11:03AM (#12506738)
automatic washing machine

automatic login / logout / lock

automatic debit of monthly bills

automatic reply to calls / emails

automatic plant watering

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @11:07AM (#12506762)
> automatic washing machine

Will happily flood the house if something goes wrong.

> automatic login

Frequently requires manually reentering credentials.

> automatic debit of monthly bills

Will happily send your life savings to the power company if they typo a couple of extra zeroes on your bill.

> automatic reply to emails

Notorious for massive screwups when people enable them without adequate controls, especially when multiple people on the same mailing list do it at the same time.

All of these examples seem to reinforce the idea that "automatic" does not mean "requires no human supervision."

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by RodericDay on Thursday September 15, 2016 @11:14AM (#12506837)
The day Tesla's helper requires as much supervision as my washing machine or bank or email client, maybe they can claim naivete. Today, it's a cavalier and underhanded marketing tactic.

You're exactly the kind of fanboy I accused you of being, btw. Proper rules of engagement on HN be damned: you're wasting everyone's time with goalpost-moving and dis-ingenuousness.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by throwanem on Thursday September 15, 2016 @11:53AM (#12507162)
That's a little harsh, both in general and specifically here. I've observed 'mikeash to be relatively level-headed in his comments here, even against the general baseline of HN's usually quite high level of quality; while he does make occasional excursions into unreasonability, so do we all, and I think it's worth making allowances for such things in the cause of a process which, in my experience, generally results in a stronger understanding of an issue all around.

If you feel your time is being wasted, perhaps you may wish to consider making the choice to spend it otherwise. Were it I who felt that way, I might still hesitate to generalize from myself to everyone, no matter how justified I might imagine myself to be in so doing.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by RodericDay on Thursday September 15, 2016 @12:03PM (#12507257)
No, I quite like discussion forums. Learned a lot from them. I just like when the discussions are charitable and productive, and when people argue in good spirit.

It's easier to pick up on the hostility of a sharp barbed comment than the one in a smarmy, disingenuous one, that only insults by implication, but it's still there.

Asking where people get such impressions, then mocking the first few responses citing sci-fi with a "that's a bigger problem!", then getting some current day ones, and proceeding to very weakly deflect them with excuses that don't stand up to scrutiny, doesn't seem like someone interested in understanding a situation.

It seems like someone trying to preach their opinion, while disguising it as a learning process, taking advantage of this forum's predilection for politeness.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @12:07PM (#12507296)
What exactly is wrong with saying "that's a bigger problem" when sci-fi examples are posted? I didn't say they were wrong, I just recoiled in horror at the idea.

Am I not allowed to express my reactions to new ideas now? Or is "that's disturbing" somehow considered to be an indication of dismissal or disagreement?

I don't find these current day examples to be at all compelling. You think my response consists of excuses that don't stand up to scrutiny, I think they point out how automation has traditionally never been fully autonomous. The "they're getting it from sci-fi movies" is a lot more convincing, just horrifying.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by etendue on Thursday September 15, 2016 @01:01PM (#12507790)
> Or is "that's disturbing" somehow considered to be an indication of dismissal or disagreement?

Actually, you said "It disturbs me that all the examples so far are science fiction." which (a bit out of context and ignoring the principle of charity) could be interpreted as a cursory dismissal along the lines of, "these examples are too ridiculous to consider further".

Even with the principle of charity, I find "they're getting it from sci-fi movies" to be an unfair summary of my point, but perhaps I'm doing a poor job making my case clearly.

Thinking on it, would it be fair to expect any example of an autopilot function on a car to be from a type other than science fiction or fantasy?

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @01:22PM (#12508002)
I see what you mean, sorry to have been unclear. I think you see what I intended now.

You probably can't find it on a car without getting into SF, but an excessively sophisticated autopilot on an airplane could probably fit into an otherwise non-SF movie. Like the example of Airplane! but played seriously. I just assumed that's the sort of thing people were talking about with the idea coming from entertainment, since "obviously" technology in an SF movie is going to be unrealistic.

There certainly are some similar misconceptions generated by movies not usually considered to fall into the category of SF. For example, I'd wager a lot of people think spy satellites really can read a license plate from orbit, or that silenced guns just make a soft "pew" sound.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by electic on Thursday September 15, 2016 @11:11AM (#12506802)
> Will happily flood the house if something goes wrong.

It isn't supposed to flood the house. It is designed to be automatic. Meaning no supervision. Tesla's Autopilot isn't designed this way yet carries the name.

Let's keep going.

> Will happily send your life savings to the power company if they typo a couple of extra zeroes on your bill.

This has nothing to do with automatic payment being poorly designed. It is designed to pay the balance without your intervention...hence automatic.

> Notorious for massive screwups when people enable them without adequate controls, especially when multiple people on the same mailing list do it at the same time.

Depends on how it is implemented. There are usually more knobs to this feature and it is designed to have you program it. Based on programming, settings, etc, it will do whatever you set it to without you having to be there...hence automatic reply.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @12:04PM (#12507273)
I'm not saying automatic bill pay is poorly designed, I'm saying it requires supervision to make sure it doesn't do anything stupid. We don't expect "autopay" to be foolproof, we expect it to handle the mundane stuff.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by electic on Thursday September 15, 2016 @12:14PM (#12507369)
It is designed to be foolproof. It alerts you when banking details fail. It alerts when it makes a payment. The system also sends you a bill email before it even makes a payment a few weeks before in case you want to dispute charges. The system however is to pay bills, and when configured correctly, it does it without you having to intervene at all. Not sure why automatic bill pay requires humans to get involved.

Your bill and the automatic bill pay system are two different concerns here.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @12:36PM (#12507575)
If it was designed to be foolproof, they wouldn't bother sending you emails before they make payments.

It works fine when the situation is good, and it can fail when it encounters troublesome situations in the real world. Since it operates in the real world, it needs some monitoring.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by electic on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:26AM (#12506399)
Captain America - Civil War
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by blackguardx on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:30AM (#12506433)
Don't you think the people who coined the term autopilot envisioned an eventual future when it was fully autonomous or "fully automatic?"

It seems your major sticking point is about the state of the art of autopilots in other fields.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:42AM (#12506530)
I'm pretty doubtful that when Lawrence Sperry connected a gyroscope to a hydraulic control system in 1912 that he envisioned a future where the plane handled all aspects of flight.

Ironically, Mr. Sperry apparently trusted his own device too much, as he crashed a plane after accidentally disengaging the autopilot in the midst of becoming possibly the first person to have sex while airborne.

My sticking point is the state of the art of all autopilots in all fields. Fully autonomous systems are very new and still highly experimental (most drones still have human pilots, just remote, for example) and so I don't get how this popular conception that "autopilot = fully autonomous" happened. It's as if everyone thought that "boat" meant something with wheels that can drive on land.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by JonnieCache on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:01AM (#12506172)
Because every use they've ever seen of that phrase up until now has been in sci-fi shows, where the autopilot is an AI that flies the ship while you go back to the lounge to play 3d chess and drink dry ice cocktails?

In a world where you're constantly bombarded with press releases about self driving cars and how theyre just around the corner, its not exactly unexpected to think that an autopilot system will pilot your car automatically, especially when tesla is so heavily associated with silicon valley.

It may have a real use in planes or boats but approximately noone is familiar with that.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by masklinn on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:18AM (#12506329)
There's also the part where the sky doesn't have many obstacles, so once you engage the autopilot you can probably go and take a piss, an alarm will go off if something's weird and the copilot will have more than enough time to get their bearings, if only because you're 30kft up not 5ft away from the obstacle.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by RodericDay on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:04AM (#12506196)
Every time I hear this "defense" it reeks of disingenuous fanboyism.

People invoke factoids about how autopilot for airplane pilots works (they have training!) as if it was common knowledge.

Let's be clear here: Very few people know anything about airplane cockpits. When people read "autopilot" they think "automatic pilot" ie: the thing drives itself, similar to "auto login" login you in without a click. Marketing knows this, we all know this, let's not pretend it was an innocent mistake.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:07AM (#12506227)
It's great that you think I'm being disingenuous. I'm not even defending it here. I'm just asking a legitimate question: how did people end up with this impression? I seriously do not understand it. "Automatic" does not imply "requires zero supervision."
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by pjc50 on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:17AM (#12506326)
People got the impression from films where the autopilot is a plot device: a character turns it on and then leaves the controls to go further the plot of the film.

Also, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/autopilot

"a device that steers a ship, aircraft, or spacecraft in place of a person"

In place of. Not under the constant supervision of.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:31AM (#12506440)
I don't see how that definition conflicts with real autopilots. The autopilot does the steering instead of the human. The human supervises.

On a ship, for example, the helmsman is steering, but the officer of the deck is in charge.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by pjc50 on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:43AM (#12506534)
It doesn't necessarily conflict, but for someone who has no experience of real autopilots (ie most people), the assumption would be that it can do the job of driving the car so they don't have to.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by davidivadavid on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:41AM (#12506524)
It seems quite logical that people will in fact infer that it requires no supervision from the term "automatic."

Because automatic is opposed to manual, which requires human intervention, people assume that automatic requires no intervention (of any kind whatsoever).

From there they expect an autopilot to pilot automatically with no human intervention.

You're absolutely correct in distinguishing supervision from other forms of intervention, but it's easy to see how people can merge both concepts.

Edit: To further clarify, people assume "automatic" implies "you don't need to do anything." Supervising is doing something. So it conflicts with people's idea of "automatic."

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by maxxxxx on Thursday September 15, 2016 @09:57AM (#12506127)
To me it clearly means that the system is autonomous while the autopilot is on. What else should it mean?
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:01AM (#12506170)
Real-world autopilots cover a wide range of pilot aids, down to something as simple as a gyroscope mechanically connected to the rudder in order to automatically hold heading. Most are more capable than that, but typical autopilot features would involve holding heading, altitude (or rate of climb/descent), and speed, or navigating towards a particular point. Fully autonomous autopilots are extremely rare, and I'm not aware of any commercial system where the pilot is allowed to ignore the airplane while the system is engaged.

So, again, how did you get this idea?

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by throwaway729 on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:06AM (#12506209)
> So, again, how did you get this idea?

Because, as JonnieCache pointed out, the colloquial definition of Auto Pilot is more informed by entertainment than by the aerospace industry.

What's more baffling is why anyone would assume that the average person knows what "auto pilot" means in an aerospace setting. I mean, why in the world would that be common knowledge? In fact, I've seen enough bone-headed assertions about collision avoidance capabilities of modern aircraft that I'm pretty certain even people who think they know what auto pilot means, actually don't.

FWIW you can test this by finding people outside of the tech echo chamber who don't know what a Tesla is and asking them to describe the capabilities of a car with an Auto Pilot.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:08AM (#12506237)
You're not answering the question, you're just repeating the basis of it.

I accept that people think it means it's autonomous. Stop repeating that as if it were new to me. What I want to know is why people think that. "Because everybody thinks that, if you'd bother to ask them" is not an answer to that question.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by throwanem on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:50AM (#12506616)
"Because entertainment commonly portrays it as such, and few people are familiar with the workings of pilot aids installed aboard commercial aircraft" is an answer to that question. Perhaps it is not one you like.

Perhaps also it is not one which is accurate. I'm not really familiar with a lot of entertainment that includes this trope, which is not necessarily a surprise; what is a surprise is that TV Tropes, which is generally very detailed on such matters, doesn't seem to have anything covering it, either. That certainly suffices to inspire some doubt in my mind as to whether "oh, it's just entertainment" is an accurate answer, or a just-so story.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:55AM (#12506655)
When I asked for examples in another comment, the replies (so far) have been sci-fi movies. I'd hope that people aren't inferring real-world capabilities from sci-fi movies, but they very well could be.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by seren on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:17AM (#12506323)
I believe it comes from the fact that, colloquially, being "on autopilot" means doing something mindlessly, without being aware, or without thinking.

So when people engage their car autopilot, they allow themselves to be on autopilot, literally and figuratively.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by throwaway729 on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:14AM (#12506294)
> What I want to know is why people think that

Re-read the first sentence of my post.

Perhaps you could answer my question: why would you assume someone with no knowledge of the aerospace industry would understand what the term auto pilot means in that context?

Why would anyone assume the TCAS specification has a greater effect on public perception than the latest comic book movie?

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:17AM (#12506321)
Do you have examples of this misconception being propagated by entertainment? I'm having trouble thinking of any, but that might just be my low level of knowledge.

I'm not going to answer your question because you're trying to make me defend a position I'm not taking here.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by maxxxxx on Thursday September 15, 2016 @01:51PM (#12508239)
Tesla wants to get the credit for using the word "Autopilot" but it doesn't want to take responsibility. If they sold cars only to airline pilots you would have a point but to regular car buyers "autopilot" means it's autonomous.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @03:49PM (#12509233)
My point is just that this is the only source of meaning for the word I'm aware of, and so I'm wondering where the other meaning comes from. Apparently the answer is "movies."
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by the8472 on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:00AM (#12506160)
Pilots aren't allowed to leave the cockpit just because the plane is on autopilot.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by alistairSH on Thursday September 15, 2016 @12:58PM (#12507763)
Yet, there are documented cases where the pilots have had enough faith in the system to take a nap or play around on their laptops.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by maxxxxx on Thursday September 15, 2016 @01:49PM (#12508219)
They certainly don't have to be ready to intervene within a fraction of a second as you have to do with Tesla.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by DavidWanjiru on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:15AM (#12506298)
Is "auto" in autopilot short for automatic or automobile? It's just occurred to me it could be either if you want to be strict or pedantic. I automatically assume it's short for automatic pilot, which most people would assume means "it drives - pilots - itself," and that may be reason people assume the technology is more like a chauffeur. But if by autopilot Tesla mean automobile pilot (I admittedly don't think that's the case), then the meaning would probably change.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:15AM (#12506302)
It does drive itself, with human supervision. Just like the automatic transmission shifts gears by itself but still needs human input.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by UnoriginalGuy on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:25AM (#12506392)
That's a strange example. An automatic transmission needs no human input at all. You put it in D, and leave it in D, until you stop driving most of the time.

Did you mean manual transmissions?

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:29AM (#12506424)
It's pretty common that you need to shift it to R. Nobody leaves it in D while backing out of a parking spot and then complains that the automatic transmission didn't do its job when they collide with the wall in front of them.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by icebraining on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:48AM (#12506594)
Sure, when you want to indicate a different intention, you need to interact with it, but you don't need to keep watching over it in case it suddenly switches to R.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by Buttons840 on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:02AM (#12506180)
"autopilot" "autonomous"

Why is it so surprising that people think the prefix "auto-" means automatic or autonomous.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:05AM (#12506204)
It does mean automatic. Automatic does not mean "no human intervention or supervision" though.

And it's surprising because "autopilot" has been a real-world technology for about a century and that real-world technology almost never allows pilots to leave the plane unsupervised.

Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by Buttons840 on Thursday September 15, 2016 @05:29PM (#12509973)
I typed "define automatic" into Google and got "working by itself with little or no direct human control".
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by alistairSH on Thursday September 15, 2016 @12:59PM (#12507775)
A non-pilot probably has very little clue how an actual airline autopilot works. Nor would I expect them to.
Re:Tesla dropped by Mobileye for “pushing the envelope in te... by mikeash on Thursday September 15, 2016 @03:49PM (#12509244)
I wouldn't either, but I would expect either knowing that or not knowing how it works at all, not "knowing" that they're fully autonomous. But I'm probably expecting too much.