Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by mdaniel on Thursday September 01, 2016 @03:22PM
(#12408138)
If anyone wants a succinct example of how misguided this is, https://www.youtube.com/user/Kurzgesagt is an amazing channel filled with thoughtful and well researched videos, but their Twitter account reported last night that their second video discussing nuclear power ran afoul of the "content guidelines" and was de-monetized.
I can't imagine an educational channel deserving this treatment - it makes me so sad for everyone involved.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by ramblenode on Thursday September 01, 2016 @04:09PM
(#12408475)
"Nuclear power, Syrian refugees, clear cutting the Amazon--those are a lot to think about and we don't want to offend someone. We'll just double up on cat videos instead. Everybody likes cat videos, right?"
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by blackflame7000 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @05:32PM
(#12409065)
Nothing controversial about cats... Unless they are the feral kind in which case you can find many arguments online that are in favor of their eradication.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by baldfat on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:40PM
(#12409657)
These are house cats :P ERADICATION IS NEEDED :)
“The results were certainly surprising, if not startling,” said Kerrie Anne Loyd of the University of Georgia, who was the lead author of the study. “In Athens-Clarke County, we found that about 30 percent of the sampled cats were successful in capturing and killing prey, and that those cats averaged about one kill for every 17 hours outdoors or 2.1 kills per week. It was also surprising to learn that cats only brought 23 percent of their kills back to a residence. We found that house cats will kill a wide variety of animals, including: lizards, voles, chipmunks, birds, frogs, and small snakes.”
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by deadmik3 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @03:30PM
(#12408186)
YouTube renamed to Google SafeSpaces
As a real comment though, maybe this is Google's way of trying to put the pillow over YouTube's face? It's been costing them money for a long time, maybe this is their way to kill it without just going "yeah iz ded"
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by icebraining on Thursday September 01, 2016 @05:30PM
(#12409050)
Profitable or not, YouTube is the uncontested king of web video right at the moment when cord cutting is starting to get significant. They'd be insane to let that go.
Besides, they're only removing monetization, not banning the videos. It's just a way to avoid offending their advertisers by getting them mixed up with uncomfortable content.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by _0ffh on Friday September 02, 2016 @06:11AM
(#12412006)
They're not even trying to be flexible.
Advertisers could be given a choice, if they are fine with controversial content. Maybe use a handful of tags, like politics and swearing are fine, but no sex, violence or cat videos, please! All the pussy companies can then choose to only advertise on reaction videos, for all I care.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by btym on Thursday September 01, 2016 @02:59PM
(#12407949)
Prohibiting the open discussion of "controversial or sensitive subjects" is unbelievable. Partners are no longer allowed to have political opinions or discuss major world events. What the fuck, YouTube?
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by krapp on Thursday September 01, 2016 @04:36PM
(#12408682)
Youtube isn't prohibiting the discussion of these subjects, they're just not allowing those videos to be monetized.
Partners exist to make money for Google, on Google's terms, and in Google's best interests. Monetizing videos is a service Google provides for their advertisers and licensed content owners first, content creators last.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by angry-hacker on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:01PM
(#12409486)
There is no story. Welcome to life.
While I don't support it, most of the youtubers are spoiled with ad money for no good reason. Same policies apply to adsense and every other ad network too.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by npiazza83 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @04:14PM
(#12408512)
To be fair its hard to know what merits censorship on Hacker News as well. Mods frequently remove posts that are inflamatory, political, "unsubstantive", and your very comment may well fall under their guidelines for removal.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by dang on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:45PM
(#12410236)
> Mods frequently remove posts that are inflamatory, political, "unsubstantive",
That's completely untrue. We reply to such comments asking people not to post those things. We sometimes detach such comments from their parents and mark them off-topic (which lowers them on the page). But removing them is precisely what we don't do.
Where these notions come from is beyond me. You might think that if you scrupulously followed a policy of not doing X, people wouldn't blithely claim that X is your policy. Nope, not so.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by npiazza83 on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:49PM
(#12415278)
Sure, that's why there are daily front page articles here on Edward Snowden, the 2016 election, TTIP, Google and other's involvement in the Obama administration and the pentagon, the Coup in Turkey...
You know what, let's just look at the front page right now... Kind of a slow news day. Let's take a look.
Even the Rich Are Being Priced Out of Central London - Housing and Social Safety Net
Ant colony discovered in an abandoned Polish nuclear weapons bunker - Nuclear Proliferation and Arms treaties
FDA Orders Antibacterials Removed from Consumer Soaps - Federal Regulation
Mojave Desert solar plant kills 6,000 birds a year - Renewable Energy Initiatives and Climate Change
Republic – Now everyone can invest in startups - SEC and federal banking regulation
The National Economic Implications of a Taco Truck on Every Corner - Food safety and small business
Canadian surgeons urge people to throw out bristle BBQ brushes - health and safety regulations
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by tomhoward on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:43PM
(#12417163)
Those are blatant mischaracterizations of the articles, and your assertion in the first paragraph is highly inaccurate.
I and others who've frequented HN for many years find that the quality of content and discussions has only improved through dang's moderation policies.
It may not be for you - that's OK, it can't be for everyone.
But HN continues to do a better job of being what it sets out to be, and the continuing growth in quality of the content and discussions - and in its traffic[1] - is a testament to that.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by npiazza83 on Saturday September 03, 2016 @01:29AM
(#12417898)
I and others who've frequented HN for many years find that the quality of the content has gone down, and the moderation of discussions has become more haphazard and arbitrary as a response to the influx of BS.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by tomhoward on Saturday September 03, 2016 @03:52AM
(#12418223)
Your appeals might have more impact if you were commenting from an account that had existed for more than 11 days - so we could actually see your comments and submissions history - and if your accusations at dang didn't rely so heavily on exaggerations or falsehoods.
The people who are verifiable as having long and distinguished histories contributing to this this community [1] all seem to be appreciative and supportive of dang's work and happy with the site's evolution.
Of course they don't always agree with everything he does, but when they have an objection, they are civil, constructive, and truthful in discussing it.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by npiazza83 on Saturday September 03, 2016 @01:18PM
(#12420008)
Your appeal to authority hasn't addressed a single one of my quite valid arguments. I created an account several days ago using my real name and real email to discuss real issues I was having with the moderation here.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by npiazza83 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @10:37PM
(#12410437)
Detaching a post from its parent and marking it as off-topic seems to me a pretty pusillanimous semantic difference to outright deletion. Context is key to comprehension.
My notion comes from a direct quote from you, dang. Our discussion on the subject several days ago. I don't mean to impugn you or the moderation of HN in general. I'll just re-iterate what I said then: I understand what you want but I find it sterile and incompatible with my personal values as should others and I encourage you to re-examine the goals you have for discussion on the site.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by DanBC on Thursday September 01, 2016 @03:49PM
(#12408310)
> Controversial or sensitive subjects and events, including subjects related to war, political conflicts, natural disasters and tragedies, even if graphic imagery is not shown
Evolution is (for some bizarre reason) both controversial and political.
Will videos explaining evolution be de-monetised?
EDIT: YT seem to be doing a boneheaded "search for problem words in titles, and demonetise that video". Hence this channel (which is full of stuff that is possibly against the new terms is mostly monetised apart from one video about preventing veteran suicide. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zRo1KI1JC3A )
(Not sure if it counts as political conflict, or if that means more along the lines of Basque Seperatism?)
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by wodenokoto on Thursday September 01, 2016 @10:32PM
(#12410417)
What I do find odd is that Youtube is not auctioning advertisement space based on content of the video + user profile.
Why not allow small advertisers a discount on "controversial" videos?
I'm also surprised how much advertisers considers themselves linked to the content they advertise next to. I consider FB and Youtube ads completely user profile based, but maybe I live in my own little tech bubble.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by CommanderData on Thursday September 01, 2016 @05:31PM
(#12409059)
The tables are in favor of those with money i.e. Advertisers. The new rules seem to stem from normal TV advertising rules.
Leaving or boycotting while in some situations is good, I don't think is not a solution in this case - the dynamics of the web / content content creation means there will be someone to replace a creator quickly if they no longer provide (users will just look elsewhere for their needs).
No doubt these policies were pushed anticipating a backlash. This move is a thought-out strategy - it will be interesting to see how this will turn out, or if it follows YouTube's expectations.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by ramblenode on Thursday September 01, 2016 @03:47PM
(#12408295)
> Promotion of drugs and regulated substances, including selling, use and abuse of such items
Regulated by whom? Alcohol is banned in some countries, so does that mean a video on wine tasting is eligible for monetization if uploaded in the UK but not eligible if uploaded in Saudi Arabia?
It seems like a reactive and overbearing policy change, but I'll admit to being ignorant of their motivations. This kind of soft censorship is a loss to the end user, regardless.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by dragonwriter on Thursday September 01, 2016 @04:32PM
(#12408649)
> Regulated by whom? Alcohol is banned in some countries, so does that mean a video on wine tasting is eligible for monetization if uploaded in the UK but not eligible if uploaded in Saudi Arabia?
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by imh on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:26PM
(#12409594)
I don't get the accusations of censorship here. They aren't stopping people from publishing of these videos, they're just telling the creators they won't pay for them anymore (beyond hosting costs, distribution, etc).
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by ry_ry on Thursday September 01, 2016 @03:41PM
(#12408249)
Too crowded for what, though?
The comments threads have always been an internet Mos Eisley cess-pit, so I'm unconvinced the social aspect have ever been particularly prevalent, and the competition amongst content creators is obviously intense, but to say nobody goes there is just plain wrong.
Heck, the content glut means the likely hood of hitting relevant content quickly is higher than ever, quality notwithstanding.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by dragonwriter on Thursday September 01, 2016 @03:08PM
(#12408019)
> Somebody should do a video startup that values free expression and adult topics of discussion, and eat their lunch.
If you can find a way to get the people either providing or consuming the media to pay, that might work (though not so much at eating YouTube's lunch as serving a different market).
If you want to monetize that with advertising, good luck: YouTube's content restrictions follow the general trend of big advertising-supported media, because its what the paying customers for that want.
Re:YouTube Bans Sexual Humor, Profanity, Political Conflict,...
by tomlock on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:55PM
(#12410269)
I don't think this is particularly surprising. Advertisers often won't run their ad on a particular show on TV because of its content. Youtube is most likely bowing to advertiser pressure on this.
I can't imagine an educational channel deserving this treatment - it makes me so sad for everyone involved.
“The results were certainly surprising, if not startling,” said Kerrie Anne Loyd of the University of Georgia, who was the lead author of the study. “In Athens-Clarke County, we found that about 30 percent of the sampled cats were successful in capturing and killing prey, and that those cats averaged about one kill for every 17 hours outdoors or 2.1 kills per week. It was also surprising to learn that cats only brought 23 percent of their kills back to a residence. We found that house cats will kill a wide variety of animals, including: lizards, voles, chipmunks, birds, frogs, and small snakes.”
http://www.wildlifemanagementinstitute.org/index.php?option=...
As a real comment though, maybe this is Google's way of trying to put the pillow over YouTube's face? It's been costing them money for a long time, maybe this is their way to kill it without just going "yeah iz ded"
Besides, they're only removing monetization, not banning the videos. It's just a way to avoid offending their advertisers by getting them mixed up with uncomfortable content.
Advertisers could be given a choice, if they are fine with controversial content. Maybe use a handful of tags, like politics and swearing are fine, but no sex, violence or cat videos, please! All the pussy companies can then choose to only advertise on reaction videos, for all I care.
citation needed
http://www.wsj.com/articles/viewers-dont-add-up-to-profit-fo...
Partners exist to make money for Google, on Google's terms, and in Google's best interests. Monetizing videos is a service Google provides for their advertisers and licensed content owners first, content creators last.
That's the real story here.
While I don't support it, most of the youtubers are spoiled with ad money for no good reason. Same policies apply to adsense and every other ad network too.
That's completely untrue. We reply to such comments asking people not to post those things. We sometimes detach such comments from their parents and mark them off-topic (which lowers them on the page). But removing them is precisely what we don't do.
Where these notions come from is beyond me. You might think that if you scrupulously followed a policy of not doing X, people wouldn't blithely claim that X is your policy. Nope, not so.
You know what, let's just look at the front page right now... Kind of a slow news day. Let's take a look.
Even the Rich Are Being Priced Out of Central London - Housing and Social Safety Net
Ant colony discovered in an abandoned Polish nuclear weapons bunker - Nuclear Proliferation and Arms treaties
FDA Orders Antibacterials Removed from Consumer Soaps - Federal Regulation
Mojave Desert solar plant kills 6,000 birds a year - Renewable Energy Initiatives and Climate Change
Republic – Now everyone can invest in startups - SEC and federal banking regulation
The National Economic Implications of a Taco Truck on Every Corner - Food safety and small business
Canadian surgeons urge people to throw out bristle BBQ brushes - health and safety regulations
I and others who've frequented HN for many years find that the quality of content and discussions has only improved through dang's moderation policies.
It may not be for you - that's OK, it can't be for everyone.
But HN continues to do a better job of being what it sets out to be, and the continuing growth in quality of the content and discussions - and in its traffic[1] - is a testament to that.
[1] http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/ycombinator.com
The people who are verifiable as having long and distinguished histories contributing to this this community [1] all seem to be appreciative and supportive of dang's work and happy with the site's evolution.
Of course they don't always agree with everything he does, but when they have an objection, they are civil, constructive, and truthful in discussing it.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/leaders
My notion comes from a direct quote from you, dang. Our discussion on the subject several days ago. I don't mean to impugn you or the moderation of HN in general. I'll just re-iterate what I said then: I understand what you want but I find it sterile and incompatible with my personal values as should others and I encourage you to re-examine the goals you have for discussion on the site.
Evolution is (for some bizarre reason) both controversial and political.
Will videos explaining evolution be de-monetised?
EDIT: YT seem to be doing a boneheaded "search for problem words in titles, and demonetise that video". Hence this channel (which is full of stuff that is possibly against the new terms is mostly monetised apart from one video about preventing veteran suicide. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zRo1KI1JC3A )
(Not sure if it counts as political conflict, or if that means more along the lines of Basque Seperatism?)
Why not allow small advertisers a discount on "controversial" videos?
I'm also surprised how much advertisers considers themselves linked to the content they advertise next to. I consider FB and Youtube ads completely user profile based, but maybe I live in my own little tech bubble.
Leaving or boycotting while in some situations is good, I don't think is not a solution in this case - the dynamics of the web / content content creation means there will be someone to replace a creator quickly if they no longer provide (users will just look elsewhere for their needs).
No doubt these policies were pushed anticipating a backlash. This move is a thought-out strategy - it will be interesting to see how this will turn out, or if it follows YouTube's expectations.
Regulated by whom? Alcohol is banned in some countries, so does that mean a video on wine tasting is eligible for monetization if uploaded in the UK but not eligible if uploaded in Saudi Arabia?
It seems like a reactive and overbearing policy change, but I'll admit to being ignorant of their motivations. This kind of soft censorship is a loss to the end user, regardless.
Alcohol isn't regulated in the UK?
If by "dying" you mean "growing up into mass-market, big-money commercial media" then, sure, its been dying.
The comments threads have always been an internet Mos Eisley cess-pit, so I'm unconvinced the social aspect have ever been particularly prevalent, and the competition amongst content creators is obviously intense, but to say nobody goes there is just plain wrong.
Heck, the content glut means the likely hood of hitting relevant content quickly is higher than ever, quality notwithstanding.
Too late to edit and spare my blushes sadly. Still, it got a sheepish chuckle out of me when I finally twigged, so it's not all bad news!
If you can find a way to get the people either providing or consuming the media to pay, that might work (though not so much at eating YouTube's lunch as serving a different market).
If you want to monetize that with advertising, good luck: YouTube's content restrictions follow the general trend of big advertising-supported media, because its what the paying customers for that want.
It's why the walking dead can show gratuitous over the top violence, but they have save "They're fucking with the wrong people" for the blu-ray.
Can't have that swearing. Oh no.