That's completely untrue. We reply to such comments asking people not to post those things. We sometimes detach such comments from their parents and mark them off-topic (which lowers them on the page). But removing them is precisely what we don't do.
Where these notions come from is beyond me. You might think that if you scrupulously followed a policy of not doing X, people wouldn't blithely claim that X is your policy. Nope, not so.
You know what, let's just look at the front page right now... Kind of a slow news day. Let's take a look.
Even the Rich Are Being Priced Out of Central London - Housing and Social Safety Net
Ant colony discovered in an abandoned Polish nuclear weapons bunker - Nuclear Proliferation and Arms treaties
FDA Orders Antibacterials Removed from Consumer Soaps - Federal Regulation
Mojave Desert solar plant kills 6,000 birds a year - Renewable Energy Initiatives and Climate Change
Republic – Now everyone can invest in startups - SEC and federal banking regulation
The National Economic Implications of a Taco Truck on Every Corner - Food safety and small business
Canadian surgeons urge people to throw out bristle BBQ brushes - health and safety regulations
I and others who've frequented HN for many years find that the quality of content and discussions has only improved through dang's moderation policies.
It may not be for you - that's OK, it can't be for everyone.
But HN continues to do a better job of being what it sets out to be, and the continuing growth in quality of the content and discussions - and in its traffic[1] - is a testament to that.
The people who are verifiable as having long and distinguished histories contributing to this this community [1] all seem to be appreciative and supportive of dang's work and happy with the site's evolution.
Of course they don't always agree with everything he does, but when they have an objection, they are civil, constructive, and truthful in discussing it.
My notion comes from a direct quote from you, dang. Our discussion on the subject several days ago. I don't mean to impugn you or the moderation of HN in general. I'll just re-iterate what I said then: I understand what you want but I find it sterile and incompatible with my personal values as should others and I encourage you to re-examine the goals you have for discussion on the site.