News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by DougN7 on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:00AM (#12230148)
My first thought was "why doesn't the cleaning lady move?" And that lead to a thought experiment: what if everyone moved to Nebraska for a more comfortable life. Prices would go up. The people would experience a Nebraska winter and be willing to have less 'real' money and move back to California. And that's right where we are in the real world. You can't balance just part of life (taxes) when there are other imbalances (benefits of place) that can't be balanced. If costs/life style were comparable in cost between CA and NE, there would be a massive influx into CA. Economics is awesome - it explains so much!
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by morgante on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:01AM (#12230336)
The benefits of California are vastly overstated.

Almost nothing about the climate (I like winter) or culture appeals to me, yet I'm pulled towards there to succeed in a tech career. This is simply network effects in action, except that unfortunately this network has been built in one of the locales in the US with some of the most aggressively anti-growth policies possible. Things would be much better if tech was centered around somewhere like Chicago or even New York.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by pc86 on Friday August 05, 2016 @08:15AM (#12231651)
> I'm pulled towards [California] to succeed in a tech career.

I promise it is very possible to have a successful career in technology without being anywhere close to California.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by mbillie1 on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:30AM (#12232574)
Yes it is, but the large bay area groupthink collective will try to explain that it's really not possible to shine as a developer anywhere else. It's easier to overpay by 2x in a rat-race society while you destroy the city you're all overcrowding when you can claim it isn't your fault, that you are obliged by professional etiquette to live there.

At least it keeps the area where I live free of that sort of toxic culture!

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by morgante on Friday August 05, 2016 @12:39PM (#12233700)
It's certainly possible, after all I've managed to do it so far. It's not optimal though, as you are fighting an uphill battle in certain respects.

In particular, outside of SV it's substantially harder to:

1) Break into the top ranks of tech compensation. The companies and roles paying >200k/yr are heavily concentrated in SV.

2) Found a successful startup. The concentration of capital and connections in SV remains unparalleled elsewhere.

I don't think it's really that different from finance. You can have find finance jobs throughout the country and you can even build a successful career in most places. But if you want to succeed at the highest level, you'd be well-advised to move to NYC.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by coryfklein on Friday August 05, 2016 @05:34PM (#12235887)
> 1) Break into the top ranks of tech compensation. The companies and roles paying >200k/yr are heavily concentrated in SV.

> 2) Found a successful startup. The concentration of capital and connections in SV remains unparalleled elsewhere.

From my perspective, your definition of a "successful software career" is rather narrow. Where else can you make 6-figures your whole life and be considered a failure?

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by morgante on Friday August 05, 2016 @05:50PM (#12235955)
Success is continuous, not binary. Clearly Jerry Yang is very successful, but he's not as successful as Mark Zuckerberg.

Like I said, it's perfectly possible to have a nominally successful career in software elsewhere. It's just that if you want to reach even higher levels of success in software, you're encouraged to move to SV.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by softawre on Monday August 08, 2016 @04:12PM (#12250555)
Would you rather make 200k in Los Gatos or 130k in Indiana?

I'll take the 130k.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by whack on Friday August 05, 2016 @09:21AM (#12232085)
It's "very possible" to have a "successful career" in lots of places, doing lots of sub-optimal things. But if your goal is to optimize your tech career, that narrows down your options significantly.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by John23832 on Friday August 05, 2016 @09:43AM (#12232245)
That really depends on what you define as "optimal". Having worked at the Google's, FB, and Apple's of the world is something to put on a resume. 9/10 the job isn't fulfilling.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by whack on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:23AM (#12232515)
I'm not telling anyone what their life goals should be, or what they should optimize for. Just pointing out that if someone highly prioritizes career success, they would find themselves having to move to SF (or one of the few other hubs). I don't think it's anyone's role to lecture others on the internet about what their life goals should or should not be.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by sethammons on Friday August 05, 2016 @11:36AM (#12233100)
Define "career success." I live 3+ hours out of LA. I work with scaling distributed back end systems. I make well into 6 figures (admittedly with a 1 in front). Bay area companies try to recruit me often enough but tend to not be able to afford me (and I really like where I work). I'm not trying to toot my own horn, and I may be in a minority; however I don't find myself "having" to move to a tech hub, and I feel successful thus far in my career. Tangentially, I avoid SF like prices: my mortgage in my mountain community is about $800/mo. Sorry to be pedantic, but the correction I'd make to your statement: one can likely incease their chances for career progression (or starting their career) by moving to a tech hub.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by whack on Friday August 05, 2016 @11:55AM (#12233276)
> "one can likely incease their chances for career progression (or starting their career) by moving to a tech hub."

That's neither pedantic, nor a correction. That's exactly what I've been saying all along. Career success isn't a 0/1 boolean, and no matter how successful someone currently is, there's always the potential for even greater career success. Optimizing for career success includes optimizing your chances for career progression.

Semantics aside, I think we're in agreement.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by pc86 on Monday August 08, 2016 @09:40AM (#12247624)
Out of curiosity do you work from home or do you happen to work for a company that's located where you are?
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by sethammons on Monday August 08, 2016 @06:33PM (#12251284)
I commute out 3 days a week (about 1.5h away) and I work from home two days a week.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by sgnelson on Friday August 05, 2016 @11:55AM (#12233273)
for a very narrow and personal definition of "optimal."
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by vonmoltke on Friday August 05, 2016 @09:59AM (#12232354)
If your goal is to live in an area where there is actually a shortage of talent and it is really easy to get a new job if you don't like your current one, there are only a handful of options outside of California.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by pc86 on Friday August 05, 2016 @11:31AM (#12233061)
I live in an area where most of the cities are smaller and less crowded than a SF/NYC/Chicago suburb. Tech jobs abound and there is truly a talent shortage. By every quantifiable measure your cost of living here is lower, your paycheck goes farther, and at a nominal level the paycheck is very close to anything you would get in SF for a comparable position.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by vonmoltke on Friday August 05, 2016 @11:46AM (#12233190)
I live in Dallas, and from what I can tell any shortage here is self-imposed. We just laid off four good developers. Took them three months to find new work. I keep running into walls with recruiters and HR departments who won't even interview me because I don't have their specific boxes checked off. Beggars can't be choosers, so my conclusion is they are not really beggars.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by paulddraper on Saturday August 06, 2016 @01:16AM (#12237143)
Where specifically have you lived and found this to be the case?
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by jasonkester on Friday August 05, 2016 @03:33AM (#12230623)
Thought experiment: Would developer salaries in general be as high as they are today if we hadn't happened to choose an area with such high cost of living area as our nexus, with the consequential requirement to pay so much to attract talent?

That is, would a guy like me (or you) be able to pull in multi-six-figures a year to telecommute to the Bay Area from out in the sticks if there weren't so many poor souls physically there keeping rates up for the rest of us?

What would things look like if the tech hub were in Ft. Worth TX instead (or Scott's Bluff, Nebraska), with hundreds of miles of flat empty cheap land in all directions to keep housing prices down near zero.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by eloisant on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:16AM (#12230758)
The cost of living follows salaries of the tech sector, not the other way around.

Even the tech hub was not on a peninsula, you'd still have an expensive center and poor people would have to suffer a long commute like East Bay people do in the Bay Area.

Just look at London or Paris: it's not cheap despite not having the same geographical problem. It's not as expensive as the Bay Area because there are many people with various jobs, not just highly paid tech workers.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by whack on Friday August 05, 2016 @09:26AM (#12232116)
It's a combination of demand and city-policies. San Francisco has a lower population density than queens, but the same housing price levels as Manhattan. If the city got its act together and built up a housing density that's on par with Manhattan, cost of living would fall dramatically.

Good governance matters. It makes a huge difference in cost-of-living. The way SF is run, it's almost as though people want the cost-of-living to be as high as possible.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by softawre on Monday August 08, 2016 @04:14PM (#12250564)
> The way SF is run, it's almost as though people want the cost-of-living to be as high as possible.

Surely you're joking? Of course that's what they want. SF people, home owners, are voting on SF policy. Do you want to lose half the value of your house?

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by dragonwriter on Monday August 08, 2016 @04:52PM (#12250789)
> SF people, home owners, are voting on SF policy. Do you want to lose half the value of your house?

Its more complex than that, as SF people voting on policy also include renters, and even if rent control insulates them from directly paying for price increases, market price declines save them money (and both increases and declines affect local costs of other goods, so they affect CoL even if they don't directly affect existing renters rent payments.) But, renters are largely people who have decided the trade-off of quality for cost at the current price does make sense, so they are less likely than outsiders who might want to move to SF if it was more affordable to make trade-offs that impact the qualities that they prefer in SF for lower prices, even if it would reduce their cost of living.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by galdosdi on Friday August 05, 2016 @12:47PM (#12233786)
The long commute for those who can't afford the center is not actually a law of nature. Better infrastructure gives better results.

For example, you can get to midtown manhattan in half an hour on NJTransit from East Orange, NJ, a very cheap place to live. The NYC metro area is chock full of affordable neighborhoods where the tradeoff is merely having a commute, not a LOOONG commute.

Ideally, you have your infrastructure scale as the city grows, to maintain constant commute times for workers even as they move further out.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by lj3 on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:08AM (#12232415)
Artists and designers also live in the bay area and work for bay area tech companies, but they don't get paid the same salaries developers do. The video game industry is also in the bay area, but they don't need to pay as much to attract talent. Their salaries are less than web devs, but not that much less.

Salaries are a function of supply and demand. In that way, it wouldn't matter if the companies are in SV or in Kansas: they're still shooting themselves in the foot. Every company wants to hire the best, the top 10% of developers, when in actuality they probably only need to avoid the bottom 25% (assuming tech talent follows a bell curve). By setting up the ridiculous filters to hiring, they're artificially limiting the supply of developers on the market by 65%. In doing so, they keep the salaries of developers artificially high.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by FT_intern on Friday August 05, 2016 @11:24AM (#12233002)
UX engineers are paid well though if you consider "UX engineer" as the new fancy term for designer
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by toomanybeersies on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:21AM (#12230775)
No, they wouldn't be as high.

In most other developed countries, developer salaries are about the same as physical engineering salaries and other highly skilled jobs.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by talmand on Friday August 05, 2016 @09:55AM (#12232324)
>> with hundreds of miles of flat empty cheap land in all directions to keep housing prices down near zero.

I can assure you that housing prices in that area are not near zero, even with all that land that is not necessarily available for development.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by bluedino on Friday August 05, 2016 @07:52AM (#12231512)
>> What would things look like if the tech hub were in Ft. Worth TX instead

Hasn't helped Austin

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by chaostheory on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:33AM (#12230438)
There are other large metros that support a lot of tech companies outside of California.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by jonlarson on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:05AM (#12230725)
But few of them have such a high concentration of true tech companies where the tech is the product and not a cost center.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by chaostheory on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:27AM (#12232546)
There are at least 2-3 other metros that meet this criteria and the cost of living is cheaper than the SF Bay Area (or LA)
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by muzz on Friday August 05, 2016 @12:50PM (#12233829)
Are you referring to Seattle and NYC? They are cheaper but not by much.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by chaostheory on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:04PM (#12235376)
There's also Austin. Portland is up and coming.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by seanmcdirmid on Friday August 05, 2016 @05:13AM (#12230924)
As a west coaster, I can't stand Chicago or New York. The weather sucks, the topology is boring, the people are either boring Midwesterners, or crass north easterners. I'm happy the west coast gets more play, though I would probably not want to live in SF.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by koolba on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:51AM (#12231249)
(emphasis mine)

> As a west coaster, I can't stand Chicago or New York. The weather sucks, the topology is boring, the people are either boring Midwesterners, or crass north easterners. I'm happy the west coast gets more play, though I would probably not want to live in SF.

While the stereotypes exist for a reason (and anybody who's lived in NYC or Chi-town testify to these particular ones), have to disagree with you on the being able to put up with "those" people. It's the west coast that is the outlier here as a (stereotypical) bunch of pansies who can't (again stereotypically) deal with rawness of reality.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by seanmcdirmid on Friday August 05, 2016 @07:11AM (#12231343)
I'm fortunate, or not, for having lived in western (Seattle) and eastern Washington, Bay Area, Portland, Toledo, New York City (well, Westchester County), Vicksburg MS, Boca Raton, Salt Lake City, Austin (some for a few months, many for a few or more years).

There is nothing wrong with the other areas of the US, and Americans are mostly the same, but I find the laid back style of the left west coast just to be the most suited. Well, Californians can take that a bit too far...

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by empthought on Friday August 05, 2016 @05:42AM (#12231019)
That's "topography." The topology at Chicago, Harvard, MIT, and Princeton is clearly less boring than the topology at West Coast schools, Stanford included.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by seanmcdirmid on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:01AM (#12231080)
Ah, true, oops. Yes mountains, not networking.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by Arnt on Friday August 05, 2016 @07:03AM (#12231310)
Go look up what topology means, I think I'll like it. It applies to more than just networking and some people find it fascinating.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by throwaway1979 on Friday August 05, 2016 @07:05AM (#12231313)
I've lived in both the Bay area and NYC. I can tell you the culture in NYC is very strong and hard to match. My spouse and I often look back fondly at the fun times we had in NYC. Chicago also has a very fun vibe depending on where you are. The Bay area is weak in that department IMHO.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by seanmcdirmid on Friday August 05, 2016 @09:24AM (#12232098)
I lived in Beijing for the last 9 years and had lots of fun, but am looking forward to going back to the west coast in a couple of weeks to live a comfortable productive family life. I guess it depends on what you are looking for.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by morgante on Friday August 05, 2016 @12:33PM (#12233648)
Good for you. I don't dispute that many people really like the culture and weather of California.

My problem is that a lot of people seem to be pretending that the only reason there's so much demand for housing in California is due to the favorable weather/people, when in reality a huge proportion of the people there wouldn't be there if it weren't economically beneficial.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by seanmcdirmid on Friday August 05, 2016 @05:43PM (#12235921)
I never said just California. I'm actually like further up the coast more.

It is nice that the economics and the nice weather coincide. It probably isn't a coincidence either, as tech is primarily limited by human resources.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by shawndumas on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:18PM (#12234095)
Blame Shockley for wanting to be near his aging mom.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by pmiller2 on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:05AM (#12230165)
The other side to that is the cleaning lady barely makes enough to survive in SF, much less fund a cross-country move.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by duaneb on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:28AM (#12230237)
...much less start a business on the other side.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by thesimpsons1022 on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:46AM (#12230479)
...much less abandon her family and friends
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by henrikschroder on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:36AM (#12230263)
Because she can make $70k as a cleaning lady by living in a city where a lot of households make $500k+ and can afford to pay more than the average for cleaning services. I suspect cleaning ladies in Nebraska don't make $70k...
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by koolba on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:46AM (#12231236)
> Because she can make $70k as a cleaning lady by living in a city where a lot of households make $500k+ and can afford to pay more than the average for cleaning services. I suspect cleaning ladies in Nebraska don't make $70k...

I suspect the vast majority of cleaning ladies in SF don't make $70k either.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by dkersten on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:54AM (#12230868)
But isn't that the whole point of this discussion? That the money made in Nebraska, while less in absolute terms, still buys more due to lower cost of living and/or taxes?
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by seanmcdirmid on Friday August 05, 2016 @05:11AM (#12230915)
If your only higher costs are housing and maybe a bit more expensive food, you'll still come out way ahead since everything else stays the same in price. You might have to live in a closest, but you'll have way more money for retirement, or to send back home (as cleaning ladies are often immigrants).
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by spraak on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:46AM (#12231232)
> as cleaning ladies are often immigrants

Do you have receipts for this claim?

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by seanmcdirmid on Friday August 05, 2016 @07:23AM (#12231394)
You mean citations? When I worked in the states, many of the cleaning staff were immigrants. It's not a bad job for them, the pay is good (relatively speaking, vs. training needed), it doesn't require much language skills. Of course, it really depends where you are, but we were talking about SF, I think.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by Amezarak on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:21AM (#12231149)
Just idle curiosity, but why did you choose Nebraska? The top five states in which a hundred goes farthest, are, according to the article, Mississippi, Arkansas, Alabama, South Dakota, and West Virginia. It doesn't really change your point (I don't suppose Californians would enjoy our summers any more than they would enjoy Nebraskan winters), but I wondered.

The absence of a table makes it hard to tell what the absolute order is, but Missouri, Iowa, Oklahoma, South Carolina, and Ohio also come out ahead of Nebraska, putting it at least at 11th.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by mobilefriendly on Friday August 05, 2016 @05:52AM (#12231047)
Actually the cleaning lady is comparing California with Central America-- international immigration is why CA's population continues to grow. U.S. citizens have been fleeing California by the millions for the last two decades. https://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/great-california-ex...
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by netghost on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:08AM (#12230169)
If you're curious, "Nickel and Dimed" is a great book that explores some of this.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by dalore on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:07AM (#12231104)
In America your job is tied to your medical benefits. Lots of people would like to just move but can't because their job provides medical insurance. And they might have a preexisting condition preventing them from getting medical insurance elsewhere easily.

So this economics that balances out the part of life you mention, is reduced since people are less mobile due to medical insurance.

If medical insurance was provided by the state (like in most other countries), you would see more people moving where it would be more efficient for them (and the economy) to work.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by matthewmacleod on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:16AM (#12231129)
I'm not so familiar with the US healthcare system, but I was under the impression that the ACA meant that pre-existing conditions were much less of an issue?

In any case, I'm not sure the conclusion follows. We see exactly the same pattern in the UK, where healthcare is almost entirely public. What the calculation fails to take into account, IMO, are other factors – someone who has lived in a location for a long time may be skeptical of moving, simply because they have roots (homes, friends, family, social groups etc.) and disrupting that is hard.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by dalore on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:28AM (#12231175)
Yes disrupting social inertia is hard. But it's compounded in the states with medical insurance tied to their job. It's yet one more thing preventing people from moving, even if they want to.

Not only that, if you move in the states you will want a job already lined up. If you build up a bunch of savings and then move to find a new job you won't be covered and so it's more of a risk.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by vonmoltke on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:09AM (#12232424)
I can tell you that medical insurance is about #5 on my list of reasons I am not moving without a job lined up. I think you are overstating the importance of medical coverage and understating the other factors that come with an out-of-area move.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by dalore on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:40AM (#12232651)
It's number #5 for you, but it's still on your list. If you had a preexisting expensive medical condition, it would be #1 on your list.

Most other countries, it's not even considered a factor.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by vonmoltke on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:45AM (#12232693)
I have a pre-existing condition. Don't presume to judge me based on the inflated importance you give to medical coverage.

And so what if it is on my list? Taking it off removes so little friction that it is effectively irrelevant.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by maxerickson on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:54AM (#12231267)
Yeah, it's now possible to get insurance for individuals with preexisting conditions.

It's pretty expensive though, I'm not sure a lot of people would leave a job that included healthcare as a benefit to move to another area and look for a job.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by vonmoltke on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:47AM (#12232711)
My understanding is that the only thing ACA exchange plans are allowed to charge extra for is tobacco use.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by awjr on Friday August 05, 2016 @08:22AM (#12231687)
I've seen this raised as a big issue with enabling a more flexible workforce.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by galdosdi on Friday August 05, 2016 @12:39PM (#12233695)
There's also probably a lot fewer jobs for cleaning ladies (or any job) in Nebraska. Unless you're independently wealthy you don't get to choose a place; you just get to choose a (place, job) tuple.

Yes, this is still an example of economics explaining stuff.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by murbard2 on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:17AM (#12230386)
Income can also be chosen to a large extent. You can work more, work less, do a harder job, do an easier job. Basing taxes on income suffers from the problem you describe.

A flat annual fee, as suggested by Proudhon, would be much more fair. I do not mean a "flat tax", which actually scales linearly with income, but a flat dollar amount.

The federal government could replace all of its taxes, all of them (income, corporate, capital gain, etc) with a simple $500 a month per person payment.

This would also make a lot of people reconsider their voting priorities. Let's see how likely they'd be to support trillion dollar wars.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by timwaagh on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:16AM (#12230755)
For me it is easy to afford 500 euro a month. my taxes would go up slightly (I'm not high income, i pay 450 euro a month now and have some rebates) but i'd be ok. for my roommate, who is usually a student but now just gives a few tennis lessons and works in an ice cream store, it would mean becoming homeless. because she could no longer afford the rent i charge (which is 300 euro). And it's hard to keep a job when you're homeless. She'd be reliant on her parents or else she'd need to sell her body. I don't think it's fair to do that to a girl of 19. Although she is talented enough there is no way she will make as much as I do in a reasonable timeframe.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by jfoutz on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:46AM (#12230480)
maybe i dropped a zero or something, but i think you're needing about double that to cover the $4T. $4T/350M workers /12 months =~ $1000, per person. if you just count 160M workers, it's more like $2000
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by vacri on Friday August 05, 2016 @03:19AM (#12230587)
That's only 125% of a full-time $10/hour min-wage-ish job!
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by murbard2 on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:16PM (#12235455)
You're right, I used $2T for the federal budget incorrectly, it's $4T
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by evjim on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:47AM (#12230483)
$500 per month sounds like the ultimate wage slavery. I prefer being exceptionally underemployed. Reducing almost all my expenses. Forced income tax seems immoral.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by cookiecaper on Friday August 05, 2016 @03:05AM (#12230544)
This is not a new thing. It's called a head tax and it was quite a normal way to be taxed prior to the industrial revolution (which enabled the government to take the payment directly out of the paycheck before it ever reached the recipient).

Also, things like property tax have the same effect -- can't get away from taxes even if you have no other expenses. Property tax can be jettisoned by selling your property, but then where are you going to live? You'd need to generate taxable income to rent someone else's property.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by derefr on Friday August 05, 2016 @03:13AM (#12230566)
With a head tax, having no income and just crashing on a friend's couch (i.e. being a dependent) would put you "in the red", no? As would the more common cases of being a dependent because you're too young, or too old, or too stay-at-home-parenting to work.

Or is a head tax meant to apply to "households" (in the census sense) rather than to individuals? Or, alternately, is the breadwinner of a household meant to pay the head-tax for all their dependents?

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by cmdrfred on Friday August 05, 2016 @03:52AM (#12230679)
The purpose of something like a head tax seems to be to lower the taxes of the wealthy. I can't conceive of any other reasoning.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by logfromblammo on Friday August 05, 2016 @11:38AM (#12233119)
I can think of other reasons.

It requires no more bookkeeping or accounting beyond that which is already required by the census.

It would apportion federal taxes to the states in proportion to their populations, as required in the Constitution prior to the income tax amendment. This could potentially reduce the number of taxing authorities any given individual would be exposed to. Your state might pay the federal capitation, but might raise the funds for it via other methods of taxation rather than its own head tax.

It reinforces the idea of equality before the law.

It encourages pursuit of additional income. You are more likely to do additional work for an extra $500 if you then get to spend all $500 of it, rather than just 75% of that.

The government is encouraged to promote increased birth rates and immigration as a means of increasing its revenue.

But the number one argument both for and against against head taxes, depending on who you are, is that it creates an inherent de facto limit on government spending, based on what the lower class can afford to pay. If there are people who simply cannot pay more than $500 a month, you cannot raise more than $500 x population via the capitation. So you can't spend more than that without resorting to other sources of revenue.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by cmdrfred on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:43PM (#12234819)
A considered response that I will have to take point by point.

* It requires no more bookkeeping or accounting beyond that which is already required by the census.

That bookkeeping while annoying is extremely profitable, every additional dollar added to the IRS budget results in 4 dollars of revenue[0]. Simply put from a governmental perspective it's highly cost effective. While a head tax might be cheaper directly to implement, it has other costs that aren't considered that I will get into below.

* It would apportion federal taxes to the states in proportion to their populations, as required in the Constitution prior to the income tax amendment. This could potentially reduce the number of taxing authorities any given individual would be exposed to. Your state might pay the federal capitation, but might raise the funds for it via other methods of taxation rather than its own head tax.

I concede this point, but this more of a solution looking for a problem than anything. Moving money into different accounts is pretty much a solved problem.

* It reinforces the idea of equality before the law.

A flat percentage after a single deduction related to the cost of living would be equality (a man should not be taxed before he feeds himself in my opinion), the myth that the CEO and board actually created the billions of dollars that his corporation captured (because he worked a few hundred times harder then the guy pulling 12 hour shifts on the factory floor) is old and tired. It was his employees that did so as well, and taxing them at a far greater percentage (79.58% on minimum wage to be exact) than him is not equality. It's theft.

* It encourages pursuit of additional income. You are more likely to do additional work for an extra $500 if you then get to spend all $500 of it, rather than just 75% of that.

Firstly, Where is this a problem? On the one side of the spectrum we have the poor working 3 jobs to pay rent (whom you propose to more than quadruple the tax burden on, thus all but stopping the velocity of capitol and probably destroying the economy[1]) whom need to earn as much as they possibly can just to get by. On the other side the wealthy/upper middle class is generally obsessed with status symbols. That won't change if you tax them at 4,40, or 91% (see 1953 - 1961). They will still want to buy the newest Tesla, send their kids to whatever expensive school and go on exotic vacations as long as their neighbors do. Hell, in bad times many of them finance it up until bankruptcy to keep up appearances (see 2008 - 2010). The data is clear, they will continue to work and spend as they always have.

Secondly, Not once has someone gone, "Yeah I'd take that 10 million, but I'd have to pay 2.5 in taxes, so burdensome, forget it" and even if they did, someone else will step up and fill the void if a market exists. On the other hand if you tax a minimum wage employee at 80% why the hell would you even bother going to work? You are homeless and hungry either way, what will the few dollars you earn for 8 hours of work get you? Might as well sit in the park and panhandle, it's more profitable.

* The government is encouraged to promote increased birth rates and immigration as a means of increasing its revenue.

They aren't now? I see plenty of tax benefits for having children. More people, more consumption, more incomes, more revenue. The only difference here is the government has no incentive to raise the average rate of pay of Americans. Why educate them so they can get better jobs? Why worry about the state of the economy? They pay $1000/month anyway. A percentage doesn't have this problem.

* But the number one argument both for and against against head taxes, depending on who you are, is that it creates an inherent de facto limit on government spending, based on what the lower class can afford to pay. If there are people who simply cannot pay more than $500 a month, you cannot raise more than $500 x population via the capitation. So you can't spend more than that without resorting to other sources of revenue.

Firstly, why can't the government just take out debt like it does currently. This plan does nothing to prevent that and a proposal to do so can be applied to any tax plan (IE, constitutionally prohibit the government from taking new debt).

Secondly, I'd argue that the working poor can't afford the current levels of taxation. Raising it to above 60% for the working poor and below 1% for the wealthy is not a solution to that problem. In fact, the entire reason for the 2nd amendment is to prevent something like that from happening. If anyone seriously purposed this change there would be riots in the streets. If it passed, many would die before it was repealed or the government overthrown entirely. This is the nation that started a war with the greatest military power on earth at the time over a 3% tax on a single non-essential good, you'd be wise to not forget that. The rural poor certainly haven't.

So in conclusion, the people advocating this wish to lower their taxes at the expense of others and use justifications that make little sense in order to attempt to do so.

[0]http://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/irs-funding-cuts-co... [1]https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/cat/longres.aspx?sk=42986....

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by logfromblammo on Monday August 08, 2016 @11:42AM (#12248620)
You're thinking of IRS accounting wrongly.

I would assume (and always question assumptions) that tax revenues would be nonzero if IRS funding were zero. Some people will just voluntarily pay their taxes out of a sense of civic duty. Then, for the first dollar spent on the IRS, that will return some multiple of that dollar. I assume there are diminishing returns:

  Revenue = integral( f(IRS_budget), 0, IRS_budget ) + C
  f(1) > 4
  f(current_IRS_budget + 1) = 4
  f(current_IRS_budget + 2) < 4
That means that Congress decided to just stop funding the IRS at some point. In a sane business, this might be because all other projects return more than $4 for each additional dollar spent, and the revenues cannot immediately be used for additional spending. If there were no such restriction, all projects could be brainlessly funded to the point where only $0.99 in revenue is realized from an additional $1 in budget.

The head tax simply has a different function: Revenue = integral( g(IRS_budget), 0, IRS_budget ) + D

We don't know what the shape of that function might be, only that there is a hard upper limit on revenue equal to the capitation * population.

--

You're confusing equality with fairness. A capitation would be equal. A fixed percentage after deduction would be fairer. I might argue that a different tax equation would be even fairer than that. But government is not, and never will be, fair. The minimum amount of fairness we should tolerate is equality.

--

You are missing the point about incentives for extra work. An extra $10M is so far beyond the scenario I had in mind that you might as well be talking about trade routes in the Tau Ceti system.

In the real world, at the very bottom, payroll taxes are very significant, as they are a regressive tax. Means testing on subsidy programs also play a role. So some people face a choice such that if they work harder, they actually get less disposable income. If you get $200 (gross) a week from working 20-30 hours part time at the supermarket, and you get WIC and/or SNAP benefits, due to your poverty, you are still paying $12.40 plus unemployment tax, even with no income tax withholding, for $187.60 net. If you become full time, working 40 h/wk at $7.35/h, you lose your SNAP benefit. And you are now paying $18.20 in payroll taxes per week. You now have $275.45/wk to spend. If your SNAP benefit was more than $87.85, you are doing more work for less disposable income. The average SNAP benefit is $127/person.

Accounting wise, the loss of subsidy is roughly equivalent to an additional tax on the extra earned income. If the only tax/subsidy were a capitation, no one would ever refuse promotion from part time to full time and a raise from $7.25/hr to $7.35/hr out of fear that they would end up with less to spend. (Again, not necessarily a fair way to encourage additional work.)

--

The government's ability to borrow and run the money-printing presses is orthogonal to discussion on forms of taxation.

--

I am not advocating a head tax. I am simply stating possible arguments in its favor, playing the devil's advocate. It is pretty much the exact opposite of guaranteed basic income, which I think would be more favorable. But a capitation is not an unmitigated negative. It does have its good points, which have to be compared with other systems. You said you couldn't think of any positives about it, so I gave you some to consider. I am not extremely motivated to defend any of those points, but I hope you will concede that they do exist.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by notahacker on Friday August 05, 2016 @08:44AM (#12231809)
Property taxes might be just as difficult an imposition to avoid, but generally scale with the size of the property and don't apply to those who are living of the goodwill of others; they're also seldom conceived as income tax replacement schemes starting at $6000 a year.

Even back in eras when slavery and serfdom weren't widely seen as immoral, attempts at universal head taxes tended to cause riots.

Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by conanbatt on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:42AM (#12230467)
Subscription Taxes! Interesting idea and had never heard something like that.
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by dredmorbius on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:06AM (#12231098)
???
Re:The Real Value of $100 in Each US State by kristopolous on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:46AM (#12230295)
That's an example of rational choice theory btw.