News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by bruceb on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:50PM (#12091520)
He is renting 5 homes in Santa Monica? Does he own them or is he subletting?

Instead of having a law against short term renting it should just be one against renting for more than a total number of days in a year, say 90. That allows people who are out of town to rent but it not be a permanent hotel.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by an_account on Thursday July 14, 2016 @12:28AM (#12091635)
Since Airbnb doesn't share data with the city, it'd be very difficult to enforce a number of days limit. Currently the city is just booking short term rentals through the app as proof of wrongdoing.

For what they are trying to accomplish (whether you agree with it or not), the law they enacted will probably work decently well.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by orange_county on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:07AM (#12091748)
If you own the place, why does your city or your neighbor have to have a say in how you manage your property? This is what I don't get. It's your place, you paid for it, it's yours. If they don't like what you are doing, then they should move. This anti-house sharing nonsense is just a ploy by the hotel cartels.

If you don't own the place, and the owner is okay with you subletting, again what's the problem?

This is one of the few things I don't ever get. Regulation on things that are not an issue in the first place.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by sanderjd on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:24AM (#12091829)
Because we're living in a society, which means we trade some of our individual determination for things that society as a whole deems worthwhile. People are free to agree or disagree with individual policies, and make use of various avenues for making their opinions known, but it's pretty silly to feign ignorance of why things like property ownership are not completely unregulated. The concept of property "ownership" only exists at all because of the strong law-abiding society we are fortunate enough to live in.
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 14, 2016 @03:06AM (#12092116)
> The concept of property "ownership" only exists at all because of the strong law-abiding society we are fortunate enough to live in.

That's the core point. There's no meaning to property ownership without a society that agrees on such idea and enforces it. It's not, and it never was, "I can do whatever because it's mine".

I don't know where this idea of absolute ownership right comes from. You don't have and never had that right, unless you can enforce it with deadly force on everyone who disagrees. There's no heavenly light that proclaims a person can have absolute ownership over stuff and others need to respect that.

Rights only exist in so much as they are recognized and enforced. Society is in a big part a mutual agreement to recognize a set of rights and laws, and a guarantee that others will enforce them if any member of society decides to forget about the rules. It outsources a lot of things you'd otherwise have to kill (or rather, get killed) over.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by Mikeb85 on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:11AM (#12091769)
Why don't I just buy the house next to yours and start a 100 seat restaurant? Maybe have a poolside bar in the backyard?

Anyhow, zoning exists for a reason. Hotels are a business. You can't run any business out of your home. If you do allow any home to become a hotel, you're opening a huge can of worms...

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by davidw on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:16AM (#12091797)
> Anyhow, zoning exists for a reason

Yeah, to keep out black people, poor people and other undesirables who cannot afford single family detached homes:

http://reason.com/archives/2014/04/02/zonings-racist-roots-s...

Also, to ensure that you must have a car to do anything at all. God forbid anyone build something like a corner store within walking distance.

Other reasons here: http://www.nimbyngo.com/

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by sdoering on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:38AM (#12091869)
At least in Germany zoning laws are there to prevent businesses to intrude into residential neighborhoods. That means, I get to live in an area that is not "polluted" by noisy trucks driving up and down the street to deliver or collect goods - and so on.

It also means, I am restricted in what I do with my own property in such, that I cannot build a factory inside my home/on my ground for the same reasons.

Imho this is quite a reasonable policy.

Some other zoning laws in German communities might restrict me from planting some trees while forcing me to plant a hedge from a small list of pre defined plant varieties - just to make sure the neighborhood looks homogenous.

These laws do not make the slightest sense imho. Esp. as the allowed plant varieties oftentimes are not local but some stuff that is easy in handling and not that great for nature (no possibilities for birds to nest and such stuff).

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by davidw on Thursday July 14, 2016 @12:27PM (#12095193)
I can understand the sentiment, but I think we've gone a bit too far with it in the US.

In Italy, where I lived, there were certainly residential areas, but they were very close to businesses - from our house we could walk 5/10 minutes and be at a coffee shop, supermarket, our kids schools, a tram stop, a bakery, and a few other things.

In the US, you have massive residential-only neighborhoods like this:

https://www.google.com/maps/@44.1036878,-121.3081349,1586a,2...

It's a car or nothing.

Philosophically, you can say they just designed it wrong, but I think you can also make an argument that sometimes it's best to evolve complex things, via markets, rather than attempt a big up front design and then rigidly enforce that.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by gambiting on Thursday July 14, 2016 @05:09AM (#12092510)
Please come over to Poland which has almost no zoning laws, and every other house has some sort of business in it - car garages, hair dressers, dentists - everyone runs their business out of their house. Your neighbour wants to open a sawmill in his garage? He sure can! And yes, people do have corner shops in their houses - amazing! Except that they get deliveries at 5am every day, so a 14 tonne truck is destroying your street and waking you up every morning - isn't it great?

Maybe in US it was done to keep black people out. But I seriously doubt it, not everything has to have a racial undertone to it.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by davidw on Thursday July 14, 2016 @11:37AM (#12094738)
There's a limit somewhere, but in the US we've gone well beyond it. The town I live in specifies the minimum number of spots driveways must have (2), and that kind of thing is not abnormal.

What would happen to all those people if they were forced to close their home businesses and rent an office somewhere else? What would happen to traffic?

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday July 14, 2016 @03:54AM (#12092280)
Isn't the illegal racial zoning of the past quite different from commercial/residential/tourist zoning of today? Or are they the same because they both contain the word "zoning" in them?
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by Mikeb85 on Thursday July 14, 2016 @02:18AM (#12091984)
Please, plenty of high density cities mix commercial and residential - still doesn't mean you can run a hotel or a restaurant in your flat.

Hell, even in suburbia where I (begrudgingly) live right now, there's a grocery store, convenience store, 5 restaurants and 2 bars within a 10 minute walk (and at least 3 liquor stores).

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by moptar on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:10AM (#12092320)
A lot of disagreement on this but it's basically true. Homeowners want to protect their investment and their comfortable lifestyle so they make sure local government restricts others from diluting what they have. If more houses could be built on the same sized sections, then poorer people would move in because they'd be cheaper. Poor people tend to be more of a disturbance to their neighbors so that would make the incumbents lose what they paid for when they bought their high priced properties in peaceful suburbia. Same goes for hotels which attract transient people that the existing property owners want to keep away.

This happens on many scales. We don't want poor strangers living in our bedroom, on our lawn, in our suburb or in our country. So we have trespass laws, zoning and immigration restrictions to protect us from them.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by CalRobert on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:44AM (#12092439)
That sounds fantastic. I'd take it over several square miles of asphalt hellscape, which is your typical American residential neighborhood.
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by rtpg on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:17AM (#12091800)
Because there's usually agreements between neighbors about expected behaviour in the area. Things like "don't start yelling at 3 AM in the backyard", "Don't throw too many parties late at night", etc.

Of course what you do inside your house is your own thing, but when it comes to extra traffic/noise/trash, having the house be a bunch of short term people makes it much harder for social pressure to work.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by vidarh on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:41AM (#12091875)
How would it affect your quality of life if I started processing hazardous waste out in the open on the property next to you?

That is why your neighbour has a say: Because what you do on your property affects those around you.

Yes, I chose an extreme example, on purpose to illustrate the point: there is some level above which almost all of us will agree that what you do on your property is a public concern.

It is then down to a matter of degrees: At which point does what your neighbour do cause sufficient nuisance to give you a say in whether or not they should be allowed to continue doing it.

The notion that those who don't like what you do on your property should move is just incredibly selfish - it implies that you put your rights above theirs, because without regulation what you do on your property can very well make it economically infeasible for your neighbours to choose to move even if they wanted to.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by davidw on Thursday July 14, 2016 @11:51AM (#12094838)
> Yes, I chose an extreme example, on purpose to illustrate the point: there is some level above which almost all of us will agree that what you do on your property is a public concern.

This is the crux of the question. I think it's very arguable that we've swung too far away from letting people do what they want with their property in the US, though.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by Stasis5001 on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:13AM (#12091783)
It's a matter of zoning. If an area is designated as residential, then the city can stop you from building a hotel there. From there, it's at least a little reasonable to consider that a house used as a rental unit with new, paying guests every night being a hotel by all but name.
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by nowarninglabel on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:12AM (#12091776)
So, note I don't take an opinion on either side, but one example of why it is a problem comes from some of my neighbors. They rented out their place on AirBnB. The people who rented it held a large party. Another neighbor went over to knock on their door and ask them to turn down the music. The renter took out a shovel and knocked the neighbor into a coma. Then the renter fled.

This problem would be unlikely to occur from the owner of the house taking these actions, given the liability and inability to flee as easily.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by kristopolous on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:27AM (#12091839)
This same wording could be used against that argument:

If you (partially) own the (community), why does your neighbor have to have (more of) a say in how the community is managed?

It's your (community), you paid to live there, it's yours. If they don't like what you are doing, then they should move.

See, we expand this beyond the individual to a neighborhood wherein rules and boundaries can be set because this collective group that exists beyond the individual can be affected.

People should be held responsible for their actions, right? And you don't trust the individual doing the action's opinion on who they think is actually being affected, right?

This follows the same logic as having boisterous parties with loud music all night or shooting a pornographic movie on my front porch. Although, to be fair, in support of your argument, this was also the same logic which used to forbid black people from moving next door.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by mountaineer22 on Thursday July 14, 2016 @08:32AM (#12093165)
Because what you do affects your neighbors.

Why should I have to move if you decide to no longer use your bathroom, and instead build a make-shift outhouse on your property line by my home's entrance?

Or you decide to rent to 4 families in a 1 bedroom/1 bathroom apartment?

Also, watch what happens to "your" property when you stop paying property taxes for a number of years.

There is also the concept of the "commons", which we share.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commons

If you were advocating for separate planets, then yes, I would agree.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday July 14, 2016 @08:48AM (#12093253)
But we all know it goes far beyond that. Associations etc limit what color you can paint your front door! This principle gets its ugly tentacles deep. And every little rule tramples on the fundamental rule, Private Ownership. Freedom to do as we please with our persons and our effects. The death of 1000 cuts.
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by toolz on Thursday July 14, 2016 @08:50AM (#12093271)
What are airbnb hosts doing that affects their neighbors negatively? I'm genuinely curious.
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by thex10 on Thursday July 14, 2016 @08:48AM (#12093252)
Because neighbors are scared shitless of their property values decreasing, and our society legitimizes this fear.
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by supster on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:15AM (#12091794)
> why does your city or your neighbor have to have a say in how you manage your property

zoning laws

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by ModernMech on Thursday July 14, 2016 @12:19AM (#12091599)
Yes, that sounds sensible, but I was surprised to read that the Santa Monica law restricts renting for less than 30 days for a stay for a whole unit. This would mean I couldn't rent my place for a week while I'm on vacation, which seems wrong to me.
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by danso on Thursday July 14, 2016 @12:28AM (#12091633)
I believe this is exactly the kind of thing the Santa Monica law wants to curtail. The argument is that neighbors dislike fly-by visitors who aren't moderated by the homeowner's presence.
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by an_account on Thursday July 14, 2016 @12:24AM (#12091622)
Do people do that often with Airbnb? In my experience (I live in LA), almost all whole residence Airbnbs are long-term rental units that have been converted to short-term rental units
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by douche on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:07AM (#12091747)
I think all of the AirBnBs I have been to (across a few cities in Europe on vacation), it appears that what happened was one half of a couple moved in with the other half, and, with a lease that they couldn't get out of, rented out on AirBnB rather than eating the months of rent for an apartment they wouldn't be living in.
Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by YokoZar on Thursday July 14, 2016 @03:23AM (#12092183)
There's some fraction of people who put up a listing and then temporarily stay elsewhere when it gets booked. This tends to happen in cities with plenty of rental inventory, as otherwise they just get booked all the time.

The "frequent business traveler" type is probably more likely to let out their space when gone than the "going on vacation for one week" type too.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by wdr1 on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:41PM (#12095827)
As a Santa Monica resident, I would love that.

When I got married my (large, greek) family visited for 2 weeks. I lived in an apartment at the time, and it was wonderful that could all rent a large house to stay in. Even today that would be useful for when groups visit over the holidays & what not, but it's imply not an option.

One concern residents have is they don't want to suddenly find there's a "party house" in the neighborhood. In their defense, this was happening. (Google [House of Rock LLC] if you're curious.) However banning AirBnB isn't the right way to address that, nor does it really solve that problem.

Unfortunately, I don't ever see the law changing. There's two unlikely segments coming together to support the law:

1) The hotels. An "normal" hotel here charges ~$400/night. High end easily goes for over $600/night. And don't even ask about rates in peak season.

2) The anti-development crowd. There's a very vocal segment that wants no new development & low, affordable rents. (If you're thinking "uh, supply & demand", that gets dismissed in discussions as a Republican trick.) They also tend to not like people new to the city. They saw AirBnB taking the limited rental stock off the market (which was happening). OP's proposal would address that, but at this point, you're not going to change this group's mindset.

Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h... by abannin on Thursday July 14, 2016 @12:18AM (#12091597)
SF has a day limit (within certain conditions) but has no way to enforce it. Hence the recent actions to hold the platform accountable & AirBnB suing the city.