Re:Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough h...
by davidw on Thursday July 14, 2016 @12:27PM
(#12095193)
I can understand the sentiment, but I think we've gone a bit too far with it in the US.
In Italy, where I lived, there were certainly residential areas, but they were very close to businesses - from our house we could walk 5/10 minutes and be at a coffee shop, supermarket, our kids schools, a tram stop, a bakery, and a few other things.
In the US, you have massive residential-only neighborhoods like this:
Philosophically, you can say they just designed it wrong, but I think you can also make an argument that sometimes it's best to evolve complex things, via markets, rather than attempt a big up front design and then rigidly enforce that.
In Italy, where I lived, there were certainly residential areas, but they were very close to businesses - from our house we could walk 5/10 minutes and be at a coffee shop, supermarket, our kids schools, a tram stop, a bakery, and a few other things.
In the US, you have massive residential-only neighborhoods like this:
https://www.google.com/maps/@44.1036878,-121.3081349,1586a,2...
It's a car or nothing.
Philosophically, you can say they just designed it wrong, but I think you can also make an argument that sometimes it's best to evolve complex things, via markets, rather than attempt a big up front design and then rigidly enforce that.