News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:10PM (#11874032)
Searched Linkedin for people with titles containing "Public Safety Operations" and who work, or have worked, at Blackberry.

One of them is now the "Manager of Law Enforcement Operations" at Kik. She describes her job as involving creating and fostering "positive working relationships with law enforcement and government agencies worldwide," and prides herself on "successfully manag[ing] large-scale projects from start to finish while hitting targets". Shudders.

It's amusing that the state has coerced private companies into running its apparatus. Has anybody studied the implicit "tax rate" across economies including such costs of regulation, compliance and state security?

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by dpc59 on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:20AM (#11874614)
If it's like the rest of the military industrial complex, odds are those companies are getting paid.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by Sir_Substance on Thursday June 09, 2016 @07:35PM (#11873193)
I really don't understand how RIM manages to consistently misunderstand their target market so badly.

Not that they have many (or any) fans left, but back when they were the bees knees, they were used by and often mandatory company phones for government departments and fortune 500 companies exactly because they were considered the apex of mobile security.

I know it's been a while since they were the apex of anything but jesus guys, at least pretend to try or something.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by walrus01 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:53PM (#11874186)
Oh they're still the apex of something, now they're the apex of Ontario-Quebec region Canadian technology corporation failures, having taken the place of the previous reigning champion, Nortel.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by ArkyBeagle on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:28AM (#11874302)
I thought Nortel renamed itself A Louer.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by jameskegel on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:00AM (#11876026)
literally means "for rent".
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by ArkyBeagle on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:25PM (#11880612)
Yessir. As observed driving around Montreal circa 2003.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by sidegrid on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:26AM (#11874298)
Why Quebec?
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by noarchy on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:37AM (#11874328)
There are still a good number of federal government offices based in Quebec, including one massive complex (Place du Portage) across the river from Ottawa. BlackBerries are still handed out to a fair number of government employees here.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by sspiff on Friday June 10, 2016 @03:57AM (#11874895)
Not sure if all this applies to corporate BlackBerry environments, which have their own servers, and generate their own sets of keys.

I think you need to ask the company (or government agency) for their keys to decrypt their conversations over the BlackBerry system.

The consumer-mode BlackBerry stuff has long since been open to law enforcement, but the corporate communications are locked by the corporations themselves, and only they have the keys.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by mrmondo on Friday June 10, 2016 @05:24AM (#11875195)
Luckily, it turns out no one has a blackberry. I kid, but also I'm pretty sure it's been at least 5 or so years since I've seen someone with one. Are they still prevalent in the states?
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by Zenst on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:43PM (#11877682)
Oh you would be amazed at what their management can do, I got told of by a senior manager for asking a question back in 2006 and asked why we were abandoning the business users in favour of the consumers users with the pearl and focus bias towards consumer over business. I left 2007.

Indeed same year I'm recorded in a townhall meeting asking about QA and same manager saying, yes we will be doing that down the line.

Some brilliant and amazing technical people there in my time but darn, some serious seagull management types who failed to fly away. Interestingly most bad management I find have no technical background. Though have known good managers who had no technical background, they are rare and none at RIM that fitted that niche.

For me I feel they used Dilbert as an inspirational guide for running a business at times.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by maxsilver on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:27AM (#11876175)
I think people are misunderstanding this.

BBM (a consumer-level Facebook Messenger type app) is not BES (the mobile security system for corporate/government enterprises that BlackBerry theoretically does not hold keys to).

It would be like when Microsoft turns over Live Messenger and Skype IM's to law enforcement and people said "well, I guess no company will ever buy/use a Microsoft Server again". And yet, companies still buy Microsoft Servers.

That difference doesn't make this any less bad. But I wouldn't expect any major fallout from it either.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by hackuser on Thursday June 09, 2016 @07:41PM (#11873224)
> RIM

They are now called Blackberry Limited, not RIM.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by darwingr on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:05PM (#11874013)
In the past I'd totally agree. But these days a large portion of RIM's target market in Canada is the government.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by mikestew on Thursday June 09, 2016 @07:29PM (#11873168)
Man, this pisses me off so much I'm...I'm...I'm never going to buy a Blackberry! After Chen's comments on the San Bernadino case, I'm not surprised much. I should be outraged or something, but what am I going to do? Petition my government? BB is Canadian, I'm U. S. Not buy a phone I never stood a chance of even considering? Recommend to my boss that she not buy BBs for the team, like she was never going to do? Not write software for BB, just like I've been doing for, like, ever?
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by bpchaps on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:16AM (#11874266)
Start by whipping out clever FOIA requests to find information on it. Dig, dig, then dig more. Find a pro bono lawyer who can do a FOIA suit on your behalf. You'd be surprised by how much information you can get so long as you're patient and can cleverly avoid "unduly burdensome" rejections.

For example, you can now get the Chicago's mayor's phone records by requesting it through their IT department, who asks the phone company to parse their billing logs, which includes the phone records.

Two tabs, and still a work in progress (waiting for their dns resolution logs now for the next step): https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1hgG79eIr8MbkjYrCvcTR...

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by a_imho on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:48AM (#11875468)
I like your work, hope it gets traction. FOIAs could very well raise some much needed awareness and push back on mass data collection and surveillance practices when government is on the other end of it.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by JumpCrisscross on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:40AM (#11874508)
> Find a pro bono lawyer who can do a FOIA suit on your behalf

How do you do this?

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by bpchaps on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:53AM (#11874544)
Wish I could help out here.. I found my lawyer through a friend. Though, in Illinois, FOIA pays out a decent amount if you win a FOIA suit. Finding a lawyer to help out might not be that hard if similar laws exist where you live.

If you can't find a lawyer, find someone locally who knows FOIA very well. Lots of activism and open data crowds have loads of experience with it.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by AJ007 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @07:35PM (#11873190)
Based upon how narrow of a market they have left, this is probably a game ender for Blackberry branded devices.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by LeifCarrotson on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:56PM (#11873989)
The people who are still buying Blackberries won't hear about this.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by daxorid on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:37PM (#11874133)
s/hear/care/

BB users by and large consider government surveillance irrelevant.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by noarchy on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:39AM (#11874336)
>BB users by and large consider government surveillance irrelevant.

And interestingly, every single BB user I know works for the government (I'm in Canada).

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by jugbee on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:01PM (#11877333)
I hear you
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by helb on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:10PM (#11873343)
> I'm never going to buy a Blackberry

There soon won't be any Blackberry to buy anyway…

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by a3n on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:26PM (#11873409)
And I'll still keep not buying Blackberry!
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by derefr on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:43PM (#11873743)
Hopefully QNX can make it out alive.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by uudecode on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:11AM (#11874241)
Call me cynical but I say this is doubtful. Microsoft will probably buy it and kill it. Or the QNX patents will go to a NPE ("patent troll").
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by tn13 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:53PM (#11873528)
At this rate there wont be any blackberry. Also, it was Apple that had resources to fight back. If it was my startup I would have not choice but to comply or shut shop.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by mtgx on Thursday June 09, 2016 @07:40PM (#11873218)
So Blackberry supposedly sells "secure devices" and "secure messaging" and other services, only to brag behind customers' backs about how they "kicked ass" in betraying their customers' trust and handing their data over to the police? Guilty or not, that's ultimately for a judge to decide, not the police, or Blackberry. The point is, it shouldn't be Blackberry's job to betray its customers like this, certainly not while selling them "high security".

From my point of view, good riddance Blackberry. You will not be missed.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by java-man on Thursday June 09, 2016 @07:34PM (#11873188)
This, unfortunately, is inevitable. Any communication provider that controls the keys (i.e. no client-side key management) will eventually be compelled, coerced, or bullied into sharing some details of the users' communications.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by sintaxi on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:29PM (#11877568)
> compelled, coerced, or bullied

A warrant?

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by java-man on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:34PM (#11881015)
Is there anything to prevent a court of law to issue a warrant requesting unlocking of a particular device by its user?
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by sintaxi on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:31PM (#11881290)
I actually think this very situation is happening in the states right now where someone is "required" to unlock their encrypted hard drive and the defendant is claiming to have forgot the password. Not sure what has happened with the case though.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by justcommenting on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:23PM (#11873399)
Collaborators undermining the rule of law and due process.

I doubt history will look kindly on these practices, and the story makes me even more eager to see RIM and its products in the dust bin.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by pekk on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:42PM (#11874154)
Even if you were ever so slightly indirect, you just literally described Blackberry as equivalent to assisting the Nazis. The apparently intended parallel is that the US government or Canadian government is the same as the Nazis.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by ionised on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:39AM (#11877136)
> you just literally described Blackberry as equivalent to assisting the Nazis

He literally did not do that.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by Naritai on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:22PM (#11873666)
To some extent this is a reflection on the company's Canadian culture. Canadians tend, to the extent that can ever be generalized about a nation of people, to be pro-government and assume that the government may not be perfect but has the best interests of its citizens at heart. For example, Americans refer to their government decisions as 'they decided', but Canadians say 'we decided'.

Given this, I'm not surprised BB thinks they're doing the right thing by helping governments spy on their people.

Source: I'm a Canadian who has lived in the US for 8 years. I was quite patriotic in my youth, so I've spent some time reflecting on the differences between Canada and the US.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by grizzles on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:49PM (#11873766)
I don't think you can generalize at all. Your comment is essentially self stereotyping. I'm good at math so I must be asian. Oops, that doesn't work for me.

Blackberry was a great company once, with wonderfully generous founders that donated tens of millions of dollars to fundamental physics research. No longer.

Now the Blackberry PRIV is PRIV until they say it's UNPRIV. That sounds like false advertising to me. I feel downright sorry for their customers in repressive countries.

There have been quite a few stories lately about their sales doing terribly. I wouldn't be surprised if this leak was some kind of purposeful act of desperation to drive sales by ingratiating themselves with their government and corporate accounts that see this as a feature. For shame.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by secfirstmd on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:49PM (#11873962)
Agreed. Have worked with dozens of human rights defenders and journalists in repressive countries who thought that just because they had Blackberrys they were safe. :(
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by mattm on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:16PM (#11874050)
Well, I'm a Canadian and I agree with him. Quite often in Canada you'll see commercials saying you shouldn't do something because "it's the law".
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by Naritai on Sunday June 12, 2016 @07:12PM (#11890796)
Among your errors is conflating culture and race. Those aren't the same thing.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by MichaelGG on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:03PM (#11873808)
>Major League Baseball's drug investigation that saw New York Yankees star Alex Rodriguez suspended in 2014

I looked this up. Seems to be in the US, and also, it's just some guy using personal drugs, albeit for profit. Shouldn't even be an offense, let alone something for police to "kick ass" in.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by Naritai on Sunday June 12, 2016 @07:09PM (#11890779)
Oh I agree with you there. But since BB corporate head office is in Canada, I assume that's where the decision to engage in this program was made.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by slavik81 on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:19AM (#11874451)
True to an extent, but I think you extrapolate further than the attitude really extends. The demise of the long gun registry is a counterexample.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by Naritai on Sunday June 12, 2016 @07:11PM (#11890790)
Using cultural traits to explain specific actions is always a tenuous argument, i agree. I do think that such an action will be treated more kindly by the Canadian press than it would by an American one, though. Let's see.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by vic-traill on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:49AM (#11876290)
The real issue that jumps out at me is that BB is assisting companies in side-stepping the MLAT (Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty) which gives the Canadian government the legal authority to obtain court orders on behalf of countries that are parties to mutual legal assistance agreements.

As the article notes "U.S. law prohibits the likes of Apple, Facebook, and Google from intercepting communications on behalf of foreign agencies', in Canada it is not prohibited but should include MLAT [0] in the workflow, which would slow the process down and ensure some eyes on the request that don't have a commercial interest at stake.

BB is receiving these request from foreign operators directly.

For BB to seemingly satisfy these requests with such, well, gusto is disturbing to me, both as a Canadian as as someone who does still carry a work-issued BB (a Z30, it's a great mobile device!).

[0] http://justice.gc.ca/eng/cj-jp/emla-eej/mlatocan-ejaucan.htm...

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by brian-armstrong on Thursday June 09, 2016 @07:41PM (#11873220)
This article makes me wonder about the interview[1] where Lazaridis walked out after being asked about BlackBerry security. Perhaps he was feeling defensive about these practices?

[1]: http://youtube.com/watch?v=Q6iGe7vuGeQ

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by orbitingpluto on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:49AM (#11874530)
I received a couple free BB Playbooks. Still a good cardio gym tablet, because I don't care if it gets smashed or stolen. Battery life is great, I only need to charge it every 3 days or so. Alas, QNX...

Used to be annoyed that it needed to phone home every single time I connected by Wi-Fi. There is also a security vulnerability on port 4455, can't remember what it is called though.

The guy who created Ghost Commander ( https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ghostsq.co... ) ported it over to the Playbook. It is the only thing keeping that tablet usable.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by amag on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:51AM (#11876300)
Maybe, in the face of losing customers to Apple and Samsung (et al), they are trying to cut their own little niche in the mobile market among people who has nothing to hide and likes it when they help the police 'kick ass'.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by brokenmachine on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:11PM (#11873349)
Well, that's the nail in the coffin... Bye bye Blackberry.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by dec0dedab0de on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:24AM (#11874291)
I don't understand how blackberry has access to intercept anything. Are all phones constantly phoning home checking if i_belong_to_a_bad_guy == True maybe at the time of a software update they base it on one of the unique identifiers. Ultimately though, who cares this day and age the only people I know using blackberries are people with big hands who like to type fast.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by thought_alarm on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:31AM (#11874312)
They're talking about data that is dispatched through Blackberry's network: BBM messages and their consumer internet service (BIS) that handles email and web traffic on older devices.

BlackBerry will turn over BBM messages in the same way that the phone company will turn over SMS messages, and Microsoft and Yahoo and Google will turn over email messages.

All of those companies have to operate within US law. The controversy here is related to how BlackBerry is cooperating with less-friendly foreign governments.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by dec0dedab0de on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:39AM (#11874338)
ahh, so not BES data or any arbitrary data on a consumer phone. That makes sense then. Maybe there should be an open standard for data requests, and transparency, and if you get caught breaking it you get removed from DNS and BGP.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by jugbee on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:01PM (#11877329)
Man... I literally bought my PRIV just last week due to verified boot, hardware encryption and now i get this?

Selling my almost brand new PRIV. 450$. PM

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by arm on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:04PM (#11880842)
Good luck getting someone here to pay $450 for it though…
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by Aoyagi on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:47AM (#11875955)
And I've just realised what PRIV is supposed to refer to. Oh well, the device seemed so appealing....
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by b01t on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:24AM (#11876156)
Google and Apple are part of PRISM, and Blackberry too now.. what options do we have left? Cyanogenmod?
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by duckingtest on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:17AM (#11876500)
Chinese smartphones. They may or may not have backdoors in them, but then China state surveillance doesn't care about you, unless you work on a missile research or something similar.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by mt10DAR on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:59AM (#11876352)
nope they're breached by microsoft : https://www.engadget.com/2015/04/16/microsoft-apps-cyanogen-...

If we're open about it nothing is really secure anymore. Nothing can really provide us with security atm, i would even hesitate to trust a company like blackphone.

I side towards abstiance, use an older dumb/feature-phone thats less likely to have backdoors (downside is its less likely to have the latest security updates). Dont send revealing photos, dont carry a gps tracker with you. Remove your presence for the web, stop providing companies with all your data (facebook etc) and actually meet people face to face for your conversations.

The only argument i can think of against the above is that people want to listen to their music and audiobooks on the go. Simple solution, get a feature phone which can support that or accept that your life is now open to everyone who wants to know everything about you.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by tclancy on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:13AM (#11876460)
That's one way to differentiate yourself from the competition.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by batz on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:22PM (#11873874)
Their best hope is to get their assets acquired by a big defense contractor like MOT, BAE, etc, to supply the niche of north american public sector mobile devices.

Like a Canadian hockey team Blackberry insists they invented the game, but every time they get to the playoffs they choke because they're just so overwhelmed at being invited.

Any interesting engineering they might have done in the past is dwarfed by their farcical inability to turn it into something people actually wanted.

It's just all so....canadian.

Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by patrickbolle on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:37PM (#11873918)
Great analogy. Hits home as a Leafs fan from Kitchener.
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by Aelinsaar on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:09PM (#11873833)
BlackBerry is a ship that can't sink fast enough. I only feel for the people who will lose their jobs (those not in upper management at least).
Re:BlackBerry hands over user data to help police 'kick ass,... by imchillyb on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:53AM (#11874542)
> ... those not in upper management ...

Well, you did say people not monsters.