If a company does not have excess cash, and/or has several good projects (NPV>0), returning money to stockholders (dividends or stock repurchases) is BAD.
Read more here: http://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/New_Home_Page/lectures/...
Management is usually granted stock and/or stock options, which aligns their interest with the other stock owners.
A couple could be shareholders believe they have better uses for the money elsewhere and to keep management disciplined (i.e. too much cash makes management reckless).
Think about if you were a partial owner of two businesses. One business has a lot of cash but isn't growing. The other business is growing but doesn't have a lot of cash. As a partial owner, what would you do?
MS, Apple and Google are in different situation. They want to hold cash to protect and grow their network externalities. It's zero sum game in long term.
Article about their cash woes when they "only" had $120B to invest: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2012/oct/26/apple-inves...
Apple now have their own mapping effort similar to Google and I remember watching a video at a Google sponsored event where it was mentioned that for self-driving cars to be viable, you first need a mapping solution which Google had been building for several years as Google Maps.
The lithium ion battery problems are mostly under control now.
Anyway, I wouldn't count them out just yet. It took them 5-6 years to catch up to Google Docs and these days, I often consider using Office 365 because it's local AND syncs to the cloud automatically.
The reality is Google Fiber exists to scare the existing players away from squeezing too hard, but not as an actual plan to create a large profitable business to deliver actual competition. Google has orders of magnitude more capital than they would need to do that if they wanted.
Also another reason they may worry, is that maybe phased-array antennas may become competitive soon, so investing on fiber for the long term might be risky.
On the other hand, stuff like self-driving cars should have a different competitive/economic story, so scaling may look different.
Why? The low government spending on R&D, from the US. So much technology came from government R&D. I just don't think private R&D is enough for the "next big thing".
Of course with this much overseas and its increasing value how much must be stashed before you exceed the value of the company in question. On a completely different tangent, how much does it take to intimidate your competition to nothing in fear you are waiting to jump?
Hoarding cash is extremely bad from a macro-economical standpoint. The govt should be alarmed of this type of development.
There is a reason why we need 2% inflation - it is to push people with money to spend it or risk loosing its value. Its what keeps the economy churning and keep people employed.
This massive cash hoard is essentially one entity holding on to all the gold in the kingdom - resulting in deflation in the rest of the economy.
These companies are waiting for a disruption, and will just use their cash hoard to buy the company that threatens their monopoly ? How is this not a massive issue of anti-trust ?
and yet, what these big, very smart companies are doing is not investing. they're just sitting on it.
it seems a positive inflation rate, as an economic growth strategy for a nation, can only do so much. it's also helpful if companies and investors actually see some enterprises or industries worth investing in, or worth creating from thin air, in the current economic environment.
"For other industries, though, a dollar of savings is worth a lot more than itself. For pharmaceutical companies, a dollar in savings is worth $1.50. For software firms, it’s even higher: more than $2. This means that investors are behaving as if they trust the executives in these industries, like Larry Page of Alphabet, to be smarter about using that money than the investors themselves could be. ...
"Why? The answer, perhaps, is that both the executives and the investors in these industries believe that something big is coming, but — this is crucial — they’re not sure what it will be. Through the 20th century, as we shifted from a horse-and-sun-powered agrarian economy to an electricity-and-motor-powered industrial economy to a silicon-based information economy, it was clear that every company had to invest in the new thing that was coming. These were big, expensive investments in buildings and machinery and computer technology. Today, though, value is created far more through new ideas and new ways of interaction. Ideas appear and spread much more quickly, and their worth is much harder to estimate."
Source: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/24/magazine/why-are-corporati...
The implication is that big tech companies see some very disruptive trends coming down the pipeline, but they're not sure which specific idea or ideas should take most of the investment, and they're hedging their bets by hoarding cash for now. Maybe when the AI/automation revolution kicks into high gear, we'll finally see what they spend all this money on.