News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by snewman on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:01PM (#11788532)
A serious question: does anyone -- management, shareholders, analysts, anyone in the picture at all -- seriously think that these companies will actually find a way to invest a nontrivial portion of the cash piles they're sitting on? (Bearing in mind that to date, year after year after year, they're unable to invest quickly enough to prevent the pile from continuing to accumulate, let alone spend it down.)
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by bearcobra on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:08PM (#11788583)
I think the whole Apple car rumor is analysts trying to come up with a conceivable way they could spend a large portion of their reserves.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by asimuvPR on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:29PM (#11788750)
There is still something very apple-ish about that rumor. It might seem weird, but cars are becoming more like mobile phones with wheels. The mobile phone is the latest in the personal computing vision apple had (well, jobs). The car being an extension of that might be a natural choice for them to follow. A self driving car that picks you up whenever and wherever is to the car what the smartphone is to mobile phones. Who knows? They have the money and talent for a good effort.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by sah2ed on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:12AM (#11791037)
I think the rumor has some merit though.

Apple now have their own mapping effort similar to Google and I remember watching a video at a Google sponsored event where it was mentioned that for self-driving cars to be viable, you first need a mapping solution which Google had been building for several years as Google Maps.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by fnovd on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:05PM (#11788560)
Have there been any incredibly disruptive & profitable markets in the past 10 years? Would hanging onto cash help solidify your place in the next disruptive & profitable market? At the end of the day, the question for these companies is: can you afford not to have cash available for The Next Big Thing?
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by snewman on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:17PM (#11788650)
There's cash available for The Next Big Thing, and then there's $215B (Apple's current cash). They could buy, say, GM outright (market cap: $48B) and barely make a dent.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by cheez on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:11PM (#11788602)
Smartphones have exploded in the last 10 years....
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by WildUtah on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:26PM (#11788721)
Smartphones have exploded in the last 10 years...

The lithium ion battery problems are mostly under control now.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by rgbrenner on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:16PM (#11788643)
and yet Microsoft has been unable to use their cash to secure a foothold in the smartphone market.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by cheez on Saturday May 28, 2016 @08:14AM (#11791376)
My understanding is they get ~$1 billion/year from licensing patents to Android manufacturers.

Anyway, I wouldn't count them out just yet. It took them 5-6 years to catch up to Google Docs and these days, I often consider using Office 365 because it's local AND syncs to the cloud automatically.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by foobar2020 on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:19PM (#11788669)
They do, if though nothing else then through multi-billion acquisitions. Another thing is that we all know crises come every now and then. Being tight on cash when it hits the market means you'll have to let talent go to your competitors, slow down infrastructure growth, reduce research freedom.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by snewman on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:28PM (#11788734)
Sure, these are reasonable arguments, which are commonly used. Clearly this justifies holding on to some cash. But I question whether it justifies holding on to this much cash. At some point it has to reach diminishing returns.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by gozur88 on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:31PM (#11788771)
The problem with spending it on acquisitions is once you reach a certain size buying other companies becomes difficult due to regulatory concerns.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by petra on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:23PM (#11788699)
Alphabet seems to be starting to find a way. Say they have a working, regulatory approved self driving car, it'll take tons of money for scaling. Same for internet balloons, and probably other stuff.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by xenadu02 on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:52PM (#11788919)
They have enough experience with Google Fiber now. If they really wanted to put some of that cash to work they could start building fiber networks in 10 cities per year and blanket the top 50 metro areas (just to side-step arguments about how big the US is and the expense of deploying to rural areas).

The reality is Google Fiber exists to scare the existing players away from squeezing too hard, but not as an actual plan to create a large profitable business to deliver actual competition. Google has orders of magnitude more capital than they would need to do that if they wanted.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by petra on Friday May 27, 2016 @05:22PM (#11789134)
I'm only guessing,but since Google has no big advantage in the field of fiber, it means that their business there won't have decent margins(or returns-on-capital) like they are used to - which would make them less interested.

Also another reason they may worry, is that maybe phased-array antennas may become competitive soon, so investing on fiber for the long term might be risky.

On the other hand, stuff like self-driving cars should have a different competitive/economic story, so scaling may look different.