News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by blowski on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:11AM (#11666879)
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by pervycreeper on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:30AM (#11666972)
Key quote from the Quora link:

> (1) Long, thick penises were considered--at least in the highbrow view-- grotesque, comic, or both and were usually found on fertility gods, half-animal critters such as satyrs, ugly old men, and barbarians. A circumcised penis was particularly gross. (2) The ideal penis was small, thin, and covered with a long, tapered foreskin.

This is in conflict with your idea that they are just 'average', rather than idealized.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by empressplay on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:33AM (#11666988)
No, the average penis size is pretty small... it's the idea of the larger penis that's idealized in modern society
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by pervycreeper on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:36AM (#11667003)
Maybe so, but the two explanations are at odds in any case.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by creshal on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:53AM (#11667113)
Not really? Considering deviations from the average grotesque/unaesthetic and idealizing averages (see also, Norma sculpture) fits together rather well.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by pervycreeper on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @10:30AM (#11667413)
They are distinct explanations, though. I suppose you can idealize what's average, technically.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by creshal on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @10:31AM (#11667430)
Is it that incomprehensible that something as subjective as aesthetics is too complicated to be reduced to a single explanation?

> I suppose you can idealize what's average, technically.

Not just technically, it happened in a few well-documented cases, like the Norma craze I mentioned: https://www.thestar.com/news/insight/2016/01/16/when-us-air-...

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by rpgmaker on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @05:06PM (#11670655)
> The ideal penis was small, thin, and covered with a long, tapered foreskin.

Well, that's convenient. I wonder what women had to say about that ;)

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by halviti on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:34AM (#11666993)
Actually they are meant to be depicted as small for a reason, or at least this is what I was taught by multiple university professors.

The reason a depiction of a smaller penis was preferred is that it was a sign of fertility. Men with smaller penises were seen as genetically more likely to be able to impregnate a woman, and thus was a desired trait at the time.

From the second response on your quora link:

>The ancient Greeks believed that short penises allowed the man's seed to travel a lesser distance before entering the woman's body and impregnating her. A small penis was seen as being more virile. A long penis meant the seed had further to travel, and had less chance of impregnating a woman.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by zkhalique on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:58AM (#11667160)
I heard from my professors that a smaller penis represented sophrosyne (latin temperantia) rather than great unconstrained passions, a desirable trait.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by exelius on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @10:38AM (#11667491)
This is more in line with what I had read as well. A large penis was seen as "barbaric" or "brutish", while the average cosmopolitan man (who would be able to view such statues) desired to be in control of himself. This is all in line with the teachings of Aristotle; which pretty much defined the ideal man in the western world from about 600 BC until more modern philosophers started writing in the 15th and 16th century.
[dead]
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by exelius on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @12:48PM (#11668572)
I don't know I would go as far as to say it was masculine versus feminine -- there was certainly a place in Aristotle's ideal man for athleticism and prowess in battle -- but rather defining the boundaries for genetic competition as being equal parts smart, attractive and strong.

Also, as much as it sounds out of place today, classical (i.e. Greek / Roman) thinkers didn't consider women to be people - they were above slaves and animals, but it was in every way a male-dominated society.

Edit: Also, to continue along the lines of your hypothesis, too much testosterone in individuals may actually be a detriment to the society as a whole. While it may serve you well on the battlefield as nomadic raiders or hunters, that same competition can lead to an increase in internal violence that destabilizes the collective. Also, you wouldn't need as many children in a city as you would on a farm (free child labor!), so increased fertility just means more mouths to feed.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by Grishnakh on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @04:44PM (#11670519)
>too much testosterone in individuals may actually be a detriment to the society as a whole.

Are you sure about that? What about the Bonobos? I don't know specifically about their testosterone levels, but they have a lot of sex and basically have constant orgies, and seem to have very good social cohesion (for small apes) without any internal violence at all. A high sex drive doesn't necessarily mean a lot of jealousy and competition between the males.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by cLeEOGPw on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @03:57PM (#11670130)
> too much testosterone in individuals may actually be a detriment to the society as a whole.

That's what my point was. Civilizations rise when less aggressive males are "dominating" the sexual market, but that civilization is also vulnerable to more aggressive males and once exposed to them, it crumbles. We can also see this effect to some extent in western civilization.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by dmix on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @04:43PM (#11670511)
The Roman Empire largely fell because they were overexposed militarily. So one could equally argue that their hyper-masculinism was their downfall - not their lack of competitiveness.

If they showed more prudence and were less aggressive at everyone around them they would have been better prepared for the attacks from the Goths and barbarians.

Additionally, they were overextended financially as well which left them in a weak state. Over-extension is the result of highly risky behavior, which is comparable to the cowboy Wall St jockeys of the present era which are definitely a modern masculine image.

Avoiding the extremes seems to be where progress is made. Being neither overly aggressive nor so weak you get walked over by the tougher kids on the block. The boring times in history were great times for economies (see 1990s, post-WW2 America), there were still some military adventurism but mostly short-lived minor disputes (Korea, Desert Storm).

Modern statecraft is largely about economics today, not militarism. For example, I would doubt the US could fall from a lack of military prowess, while still totally dominating the world financial markets. Money goes a much longer way than guns and heart these days.

Just look at how Russia's economy is doing these days - despite being the toughest kid on the block. Even if they succeed at war mongering it could only take them so far before the west could obliterate their citizens quality of life without firing a shot.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by bernawil on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @09:33AM (#11675075)
They were not overexposed militarily. After conquering and integrating the whole mediterranean basin they only had two rivaling neighbors: Germanic peoples at the north and the parthians-sassanid-persians in the east. In times of integrity they managed just fine. The only reason the germans survived history to hurt the empire was because the Antonine emperors didn't want to genocide them.

Then the empire had a stint of epidemics and bad luck that degradated socitey and the political system, leading to constant civil war.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by Chris2048 on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:05PM (#11668723)
I thought testosterone decreased penis size?
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by erikb on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @10:26AM (#11667381)
The intelligence argument I can believe, the fertility argument I can't. What would the reason be that a small penis is more fertile?
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by AnkhMorporkian on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @10:31AM (#11667425)
The explanation is in the comment you're replying to. Of course it isn't an advantage, but apparently the greeks did believe that.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by bmelton on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @12:38PM (#11668493)
Without trying to be crass, a smaller penis fits into a wider array of vaginas, compared to too large a penis.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by Chris2048 on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:07PM (#11668736)
Not necessarily. You don't need to put it all in, while a big one reaches further...
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by llamaz on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:43PM (#11669051)
That's fair enough, for those far away women that men with small penis' would not be able to reach
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by bmelton on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @03:29PM (#11669893)
I was actually referring to girth. The vaginal canal is fairly elastic, but I've known women who complained that they were physically unable to have sex with a guy I knew because of girth.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by Grishnakh on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @04:56PM (#11670583)
Those women were either lying or exaggerating. Woman have babies through that canal, and a baby's skull is much larger than any man's girth. There is no way these women were "physically unable" to have sex with some man. It might have been uncomfortable for them if they were especially tight, but they could have done it.

This reminds me of men who claim that normal size condoms are "too small". Again, total BS. It's quite easy to blow one up like a balloon without it bursting. A larger one will be more comfortable for someone large, but the regular one will stretch to fit.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by tukelully on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @07:15PM (#11671437)
It may stretch to fit, but has a higher likelihood of shrinking back down during sex. Furthermore, a less comfortable condom due to it's size will increase pressure on the penis and reduce sensation even further. If you have a big cock, get an appropriate size condom.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by Grishnakh on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:42AM (#11676297)
>Furthermore, a less comfortable condom due to it's size will increase pressure on the penis and reduce sensation even further.

Yeah, I never said it was ideal, just that it would fit. I did say that it wouldn't be as comfortable. Same as a woman with a guy who's "too large" for her. It'll fit. It may not be comfortable, it might hurt some even, but it will fit.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by notahacker on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:57AM (#11667146)
What's above average in Greek statues is virtually every other aspect of the physique: if they're not intended to be teenagers their body dimensions usually have more in common with WWF wrestlers than the average person.

Especially when you consider that the average ancient Greek man was about six inches shorter than the average Western male today.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by maaku on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @11:54AM (#11668117)
They are in fact teenagers by the modern definitions. You were a full responsible adult shortly after puberty. Many of the greats did their best work before 20.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by Aqwis on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @12:10PM (#11668238)
Who did their best work before 20? I looked up a bunch of Greek philosophers, and it doesn't seem to apply to any of them. Socrates was in the military during his early life, and Aristotle did his most famous work late in life.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by jcranmer on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:18PM (#11668830)
One possibility is that GP is thinking that "life expectancy was 25, so 20 means you're an old geezer on the deathbed." Alternatively, it may also be a reference to the extreme youth of Alexander the Great, who became king of Macedon at age 20 and proceeded to put down a Greek rebellion and then conquer Thrace, Persia, Egypt, Bactria, cross the Hindu Kush, conquer bits of India (then unknown to the Greeks) and was only stopped from going further when his army said "it's been long enough, can we go home?" He died 3 years later, at age 32. Obviously, he is very much an outlier.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by dredmorbius on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @02:45PM (#11669548)
Measures of life expectency are misleading in this regard.

Much of low life expectency comes from very high infant mortality -- deaths to age 5 or 10. Once you've passed that threshold, your odds of survival increase markedly. Perhaps slightly lower than today's first-world standards, but hale-and-hearty at 15 doesn't mean you're going to fall over dead at 25.

You also want to look at life expectency at any given age. And I distantly recall that the number of (I can't remember specifically which) Greeks or Romans surviving to age 80+ compared favourably to modern times.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by YeGoblynQueenne on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @03:39PM (#11669983)
Yeah, Alexander was a super hero.

I remember reading stories where he charged ahead of the rest of the army, scaled enemy walls, chased down royal bodyguards and so on. He was bloody crazy. A guy with his (lack of) brains should not have made it past 16, let alone get to 32.

Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by digi_owl on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @04:12PM (#11670268)
A real life example of refuge in audacity?
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by ajcarpy2005 on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @07:47PM (#11671603)
I miss common sense.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by Havoc on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @06:10PM (#11671087)
The chances of the average (ancient) Greek sitting in front of a playstation / driving to work was also much lower though so I can imagine them being tangibly more muscular/fitter etc.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by grimmdude on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @12:49PM (#11668578)
So glad I opened HN today
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by drb311 on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @11:40AM (#11668005)
That's a relief.
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by deanstag on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:42AM (#11667033)
for a second i thought i was reading a reddit thread
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by homogeneous on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @11:37AM (#11667976)
I despise this hackneyed and arrogant reddit chide. HN has excellent moderation, but it's not such a bastion of quality discourse that breaking forum etiquette merits shitting on another community via rhetorical comparison. This site is regularly host to some terribly low-quality discussions that really only differentiate themselves from reddit insomuch as they are lacking in humor. I'm glad that HN tends to moderate out the noise, but this HN trend to invoke reddit as an insult just seems pretentious.
Re:Why do old statues have such small penises? by deanstag on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:07PM (#11668737)
oh. i did not mean it as an insult. i really thought i was reading a reddit thread :(