News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by rdegges on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:32PM (#11597757)
OnHub is one of the best routers I've ever owned. I've been buying custom router hardware for years -- I even went as far as building my own OpenBSD / PFsense router way back when, but nothing I've ever built (or bought!) has given me the same reliability / stability / speed as the OnHub.

I'm seriously impressed with it.

Also: the OnHub management app for mobile is AMAZING. It is so cool.

Awesome product. Really great to see them put more effort into it and support integrations with IFTTT :D

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by dan_quixote on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:06PM (#11597997)
Single data point on custom router build reliability:

I've been using IPFire/pfSense on a little passively cooled Celeron box for a couple years. It reliably hits the theoretical gigabit limit ~800Mb/s and has never once failed even while running intrusion detection. Coupled with a ~$150 wireless router-turned-access point, I have never had a single reliability issue.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by matt_wulfeck on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:35PM (#11598201)
Have you ever measured combined power usage of your two devices?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by sethrin on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:37PM (#11598589)
In what circumstances do you foresee the power usage of networking equipment as having more than a notional impact on one's life? (Serious question)
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by sirtaj on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:27PM (#11598884)
For one: if you live in a place with unreliable power supply (as I do), it dictates how much backup time you get from your UPS.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by sethrin on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:50PM (#11599000)
To clarify, when the power goes out, you are still able to get online? Otherwise it would seem like it would be somewhat pointless to have the networking equipment plugged into the UPS. I have worked online during a power outage using a cellular internet adapter, but obviously no UPS or router was involved there.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by sirtaj on Saturday April 30, 2016 @01:24AM (#11600504)
The outages are almost always due to load-shedding, so the POTS network doesn't lose power and our ADSL link remains connected.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by sethrin on Saturday April 30, 2016 @06:36PM (#11603946)
Interesting! I appreciate the response. Sorry that you have to deal with that, though.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by what_ever on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:59PM (#11599537)
Power outages can be very local. So yes, you can use internet using UPS backup.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by sethrin on Friday April 29, 2016 @09:44PM (#11599921)
Have you actually experienced this? I can easily imagine that a given apartment/home could be out and the building/distribution point still be up, but anything less local than that would certainly take my connection offline. And I'd very much hope that my domicile wouldn't have such spotty power as to make me need to worry about having my router on a UPS. In places I've lived with spotty power (Central America) the whole town or island would typically go out. Are you describing a hypothetical situation or is this actually a thing?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by NickNameNick on Friday April 29, 2016 @11:02PM (#11600138)
Historically where I live, power outages wouldn't affect the copper telephone network. At least not for reasonable durations cuts.

I don't have an analog phone anymore, so I don't know how true that still is, post recent network upgrades.

I have coworkers who used VOIP phones, and who kept their routers and wireless base stations on UPS. I'm not sure if that setup was ever tested in anger.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by sethrin on Friday April 29, 2016 @11:21PM (#11600179)
Landline phones were powered by the phone company, over the lines. As long as the wires themselves aren't down, the phone company can keep the system working for days without power -- phones themselves don't need much power. DSLAMs do, though.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by stordoff on Friday April 29, 2016 @11:49PM (#11600252)
> Otherwise it would seem like it would be somewhat pointless to have the networking equipment plugged into the UPS

Power cuts for me are typically short lived (often due to a RCD in the house rather than an actual outage). My networking gear is on my UPS, so that local transfers (e.g. to my NAS) can continue, or so I can shutdown my NAS manually if I'm not using it to get a little more time out of the UPS (I can probably do that via the hardware switch, rather than the WebUI, so not a huge concern).

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by wildmusings on Friday April 29, 2016 @11:49PM (#11600254)
I grew up in Miami and I remember one time a hurricane knocked power out at our house for over a week. We got a generator and we were able to get online. School was cancelled of course, so I was thrilled. I don't remember if we had DSL or cable at that point. Telephone always seemed to withstand power outages too. You don't even need a generator or UPS because corded phones can power themselves with just the phone line.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by untog on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:47PM (#11597866)
Curious: what do you do with the management app?

I have an Apple Airport thing and had a similar experience - years of buying cheap routers then suddenly I had one that "just works". To the point that I haven't had to open/use the administration panel in an absolute age.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by rdegges on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:25PM (#11598523)
I use it for a bunch of stuff: to share access to my guest network with visitors: you can basically click the 'share' button and send an SMS / hangout / * message to someone with your network SSID / password for quick access.

I also use it to monitor my connection: do speed tests directly from the router (even remotely!).

And finally: monitoring network usage, stats, etc. It's a beautifully designed, fluid, fast, and just all around amazing app!

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by cmrdporcupine on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:52PM (#11597891)
The app also gives you insights into what's happening with your OnHub -- per device traffic sums, speed tests, alerts, etc.

And we're constantly improving it.

IMHO that's the real win with the OnHub; the router itself is constantly upgraded with up to date firmware with security updates and new features. And the mobile app that administrates it is constantly getting new features.

Maybe I should transfer to marketing.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by seanp2k2 on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:55PM (#11598325)
Honestly Google's rep for discontinuing support for stuff is why I'm not interested in such a connected device. Will it continue getting updates after Google drops it in 0-5 years? Who knows. Will the open-source community be able to put OpenWRT on it or something to give it life after it can no longer receive firmware updates? Not sure.

I do know that my current Ubiquiti and Apple network infrastructure devices will still work if I plug them in in 10 years. I can't say the same for this. $200 seems reasonable for what it does, but less so if it's knocked down to dumb router mode if Google pulls the plug some day.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by narrowrail on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:07PM (#11598397)
As an aside: I'm in the OpenWRT camp right now, and minimizing my exposure to large companies, but I find this constant drum beat about "Google shutting products down" to be tiring. It also derails from the topic at hand.

I think it's great what they're doing with OnHub, and hope we can have iOS/Android apps for managing OpenWRT installs too. I wouldn't personally recommend buying one unless you can at least install ddWRT, but I haven't even bothered to learn what CPU they are using.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by alphapapa on Friday April 29, 2016 @09:05PM (#11599787)
Yes, it is tiring when Google does this. I'm so tired of it that I'm not willing to invest my time, data, or processes into new Google services or products.

If you are also tired of this drumbeat, please ask Google to stop beating the marching-products-to-their-doom drum.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by untog on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:12PM (#11598426)
What reassurance does Apple give that Google do not?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by potatolicious on Friday April 29, 2016 @08:15PM (#11599606)
I have an OnHub, but even then I'm a little wary of Google's track record when it comes to "sunsetting" products.

There is no explicit foolproof assurance from either Apple or Google, but in Apple's case they haven't been known for introducing products and then dropping all support for it when it fails to live up to sales/strategic expectations.

In fact Apple's modern track record is pretty impressive - the latest iOS runs on a phone introduced in 2011.

Google's "throw everything at the wall and keep the stuff that sticks" approach is IMO one that only makes sense when you discount brand value completely and assume nobody will remember the stuff that didn't stick, and their unceremonial shutdowns. It's a theoretically appealing approach but IMO impractical because people remember.

Even when Google compensates people for the shutdowns - see the Nexus Q - it still leaves a bad taste, and makes people wonder if they're buying a real honest product in a particular space or an experiment to be cut lose at a moment's notice.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by alphapapa on Friday April 29, 2016 @09:11PM (#11599809)
Wow, what kind of bias would lead this comment to be downvoted into grayness?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by deprave on Friday April 29, 2016 @09:28PM (#11599880)
A positive bias towards anything coming from Google. Just look at the number of Google employees on this thread...

The "let's see what sticks" approach might work well for software, especially the Google kind: ad-supported "free" cloud-based software services. Complaints trigger the knee-jerk reaction of "you never paid." It doesn't work for hardware, and I don't know why Google would risk its reputation for what must barely move the needle on their income statements.

Apple's approach of providing SDKs that work with their existing devices, thereby testing the waters and seeing what products get built, what consumers like, etc. before entering it themselves seems like a much more sensible move.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by asendra on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:25PM (#11598865)
History?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by warrenm on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:33PM (#11598913)
It doesn't require phoning home to Apple, for one
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by untog on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:43PM (#11598969)
Google doesn't require phoning home - it'll just continue to use the same software it does today. Similarly, my Apple router phones home to detect when a software update is available. I don't really see the difference here.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by dannyr on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:09PM (#11598412)
You're not over Google Reader yet?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by exhilaration on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:36PM (#11598577)
Well that and the Nest Smart Home hub they decided to kill off a few weeks ago:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11423411

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11435245

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by deelowe on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:27PM (#11598882)
I keep saying this. People keep ignoring me, but it really does matter in this case. This only happened AFTER nest was no longer a Google property. To me the timing seems somewhat suspicious and I believe Nest pushed for more autonomy. They were never really integrated into Google proper. Their stuff runs on their on servers & software stack and their HQ isn't on the Google campus.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by ceejayoz on Friday April 29, 2016 @08:23PM (#11599636)
> This only happened AFTER nest was no longer a Google property.

Huh? Nest is still a Google property.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by deelowe on Friday April 29, 2016 @09:10PM (#11599802)
Nest is an Alphabet property: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nest_Labs
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by ceejayoz on Friday April 29, 2016 @10:49PM (#11600103)
That makes "This only happened AFTER nest was no longer a Google property" a totally meaningless semantic distinction, then, and leaves me confused as to the point you're trying to make with it. You don't suddenly have "a new boss" when they get married and change their name.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by eli on Friday April 29, 2016 @10:00PM (#11599987)
That seems like an odd distinction. Isn't everything Google owns also owned by Alphabet? Is the consumer supposed to perceive a difference?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by Natanael_L on Saturday April 30, 2016 @06:54AM (#11601219)
Google is now a subsidiary to Alphabet. So no.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by on_and_off on Saturday April 30, 2016 @08:34AM (#11601439)
Well, it seems that it is going to to make a difference in how Nest is managed.

Google has just created a hardware division that will handle most of its efforts in that area :

Nexus, Pixel, OnHub, ATAP, Chromecast, consumer hardware, ... they are all going to be integrated in this division instead of being scattered throughout the company.

Glass will also become a part of that division (Nest has been handling it since the end of the explorer program).

Nest will continue to operate independently.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by kyrra on Friday April 29, 2016 @11:46PM (#11600246)
Nest runs their software on AWS, they call that out here: https://nest.com/security/
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by victorhooi on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:33PM (#11598910)
That story has already been beaten to death....lol.

Nest bought out Revolv - and then immediately ceased all sales.

They then kept the servers running for another 18 months, before announcing they were going to shut them down.

Revolv was an also-ran in the home automation stakes - speculation on my part, but there was probably a reason they got bought out instead of raking in the big bucks.

Let's say they sold a few thousand units - do you really think it's worth keeping it running indefinitely? A lot of those people have probably moved on.

I don't have hard data to back this up - but I have a growing suspicion most of the people shrilly screaming the loudest on HN don't actually even own a Revolv - the chances of them being one of those few thousand of couple is pretty small.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by MaulingMonkey on Friday April 29, 2016 @11:57PM (#11600275)
> Let's say they sold a few thousand units - do you really think it's worth keeping it running indefinitely?

That's not the only option. Some alternatives would have been to make it not a SASS reliant brick. Or to open source enough that people could do that work themselves, at least in theory. Or to offer buybacks. I did read:

> Nest is working with customers on a case-by-case basis on compensation, according Burnett. The company would not disclose exactly how Revolv users would be compensated or whether their Revolv devices could be replaced by Nest devices.

( Edit: http://www.cnbc.com/2016/04/06/nest-to-disable-revolv-hub-mu... )

Any former Revolv users want to disclose how they did/didn't get screwed over, actually?

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by timothya on Saturday April 30, 2016 @04:41AM (#11600957)
It says on Revolv's website that they're giving full refunds to current customers:

"If you're a current Revolv customer, please email us at [email protected] so we can help you out during this transition and provide you with a refund of the purchase price of your Revolv hub." - http://revolv.com/

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by Karunamon on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:14PM (#11599340)
>do you really think it's worth keeping it running indefinitely?

At some point, I think it becomes less about "worth" and more about doing the right thing. Is it fair that everyone who bought that device is left holding a worthless chunk of plastic because of the inscrutable whims of various SV tech giants?

If not for reams of legalese nobody reads and yet has to agree to in order to even hook the thing up, it would probably already be illegal in some way.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by victorhooi on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:39PM (#11599447)
Your point about "doing the right thing" is a complete logical fallacy. Are you implying that group A is somehow more deserving that group B?

Don't forget - the "tech giants" you refer to are comprised of people, most of whom have jobs and families

This isn't about whims of tech giants - more about whims of the market.

If the pitchfork-waving masses on HN screaming about Revolv had all actually, well, bought a Revolv, I suspect the company wouldn't have gone bust. The fact of the matter is - the market (or we) spoke - we didn't like Revolv, and that was the reason they failed in the marketplace.

I don't think Nest made any secret of it - as soon as they bought out Revolv, they announced it quite publicly on their blog - we are stopping all sales of this product, immediately - but we will continue to support it for some time.

This was no deep conspiracy - it was, well, the product's a wash, we're buying out the company, and keeping the team.

Think about it - they probably still had stock of the product lying around at the time - they would rather just destroy those than sell them - what does that tell you about the product?

http://www.theverge.com/2014/10/24/7061557/nest-acquires-rev.... http://www.cepro.com/article/theories_on_home_automation_hub....

There were heaps of pundits at the time who speculated on why Revolv failed.

I think that's a far more worthy topic of discussion (i.e lessons learned on why it didn't gain traction), than going on about why we're not supporting a failed product from 2 years ago.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by Karunamon on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:52PM (#11599510)
I don't think you know what a logical fallacy is. Which one did I commit? Calm down, please. I am not "waving a pitchfork". I didn't own a Reolv, I don't have a horse in this race.

However, I do think that there's a valid discussion to be had over the fate of a device that's integrated to the point a "home automation hub" is. The normal expectation is that these devices continue to work for the life of the device, not when some company throws a switch somewhere.

The problem here is that there's no alternative. No graceful degradation. If Ecobee dies tomorrow, I still have a working thermostat.

This? None. Your device is now literally and figuratively worthless, the money you spent on it literally wasted. Were I a purchaser of one of these things, I'd be feeling damn scandalized, ripped off, and rightly so.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by victorhooi on Saturday April 30, 2016 @12:54AM (#11600433)
Revolv was sold as a cloud-managed device - the thousand or so people who bought one knew this.

This isn't a unique problem just to Revolv, or home automation.

What happens when any company that provides a SaaS or cloud service goes bust?

Say you host your app on AWS, or DigitalOcean - if the company shuts down, will you claim that it's not "fair" for them to shutdown on you, and they must keep your application running?

Tech companies shut down all the time - sure, it sucks both for the people that work at that company, and for their customers (but I suspect more for the employees - you may have just lost some expensive tech toy - they've potentially lost their livelihoods.)

Let's take a step back, and look objectively at the facts - there was a small hardware startup, that created a cloud-based home automation product.

A few thousand people probably bought it - not enough to keep the company going. They were acqui-hired, all remaining stock destroyed, but the company that acquired the team decided to keep the servers up for a couple more years. After that, they announced they were pulling the plug.

Sure, it sucks - but they bought a cloud-managed product from a new hardware startup. I don't think any of these people were stupid - they knew exactly what they were buying.

If they didn't want to have this risk, then they would have bought from either 1. a larger company that was less likely to go bust or 2. a non-cloud managed product.

However, many of the advantages of the product are probably from it being cloud-managed. I see no issue with buying a cloud-managed device, as long as you know what you're getting into.

And look - let's be honest - home automation - I don't exactly want to be opening up my home network to the world, just so I can access it from my phone. Having a hosted service to do this is pretty cool.

Likewise, I don't have the compute power to do any cool ML at home - but if it was all done on the cloud, and there was a company behind it with the infrastructure and engineering effort, that's a good thing.

I have two Dropcams - they're pretty cool devices. Very easy to setup - but cloud managed. This is tradeoff I knew when I bought them. If the company disappeared, I understand my cameras would fail to work.

I would be upset - but I don't think it would be "unfair". I'd just hope that the people who worked at the company were doing alright.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by Karunamon on Saturday April 30, 2016 @12:33PM (#11602351)
they knew exactly what they were buying.

Why am I reminded of a scene from Airplane! here?

The average person probably doesn't even know what "the cloud" is beyond the name of a product or two. They know that they can push a button their phone and turn the lights off.

You imply a level of knowing and care that most people do not have, and so one that is not realistic, or reasonable to expect.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by nitrogen on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:44PM (#11599474)
Charging money for hardware and then remotely disabling it sounds awfully similar to fraud.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by timothya on Saturday April 30, 2016 @04:40AM (#11600951)
They're giving full refunds to all their customers, so it's more like those customers got to use the device for "free" while it was available.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by nitrogen on Saturday April 30, 2016 @02:48PM (#11602991)
That is a different story. If only all vendors did the same.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by Godel_unicode on Sunday May 01, 2016 @02:06AM (#11605081)
No, that's literally exactly the story in question. What if this is the Google answer for hardware going forward? Buy what you're interested in before it's ready, give us signal about what's good/bad, and if we kill it we pay you back what it cost.

Isn't that what we as consumers want?

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by SystemOut on Friday April 29, 2016 @08:05PM (#11599570)
Yeah, but normally when companies get bought for small amounts of money it's because they're running out of cash and would probably get shut down anyways. If they were making a profit they'd have been bought for more or they would have raised more cash if their business looked like it might be sustainable.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by victorhooi on Saturday April 30, 2016 @12:58AM (#11600442)
I agree with you - I have no inside knowledge of this, but all the evidence from the time points to not many Revolv units being shipped - I'd be surprised if there were more than several thousand units sold in total, over the lifespan of the company.

They'd have no chance of ever recouping their investment, or gaining any kind of critical mass.

An acquirhire was probaby a good thing, at that stage - the founders/employees get a new job, and the customer base get an extension on the shutdown, at least for a couple years.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by fucking_tragedy on Saturday April 30, 2016 @02:24AM (#11600636)
Plug in an Apple Airport Express from ~2008 and see how supported it is in El Capitan.

I had to use Wine on Linux to use an older Windows application to do the initialization.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by AdmiralAsshat on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:19PM (#11598479)
So, at the risk of sounding hostile, the article notes the following:

Eight months later, the OnHub still doesn't support IPv6, and the USB port still can't be used for network storage. Bluetooth, Thread, and Weave support are all still dormant.

IFTTT support is great, but shouldn't the priority for a $200 router be in delivering features that were promised from the get-go?

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by mikecb on Friday April 29, 2016 @08:42PM (#11599700)
The PM has been very active on various forums talking to users about best ways to implement things like storage. IPv6 is enabled in beta channel (channel switching was accelerated after many users expressed desire for it), and is waiting on upstream stability fixes, which afaik they are submitting directly to the linux kernel. It will roll out when ready, not before. This is what I want from a piece of infrastructure.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by dingaling on Saturday April 30, 2016 @01:20AM (#11600494)
> IPv6 is enabled in beta channel ... and is waiting on upstream stability fixes

I'll be interested to see the kernel patches because in my experience the kernel-side of IPv6 has been stable for over a decade, including the past seven years with a native IPv6 Internet connection through Linux routers.

Google itself enabled public IPv6 connectivity in 2009 so I am surprised that a Google-affiliated team is having issues with IPv6.

> This is what I want from a piece of infrastructure.

I want infrastructure to support current networking standards.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by mikecb on Saturday April 30, 2016 @12:52PM (#11602434)
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by knz on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:19PM (#11598834)
Google I/O is in a few weeks - is it possible this is a precursor to something more involving Weave and other IoT systems?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by i2shar on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:49PM (#11599493)
I've been waiting to buy a router for the same reason. Expecting newer versions with support for Weave/Brillo being announced. I had also read somewhere that it has a disabled Zigbee/Z-wave radio - don't know if that's true. But it would be nice to have a "smart hub" integrated into your router.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by umsm on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:10PM (#11598037)
I completely agree with untog. Apple's Airport device is so seamless that it's a pleasure to use.

What kind of firmware / security updates do you get with OnHub? Aren't firmware updates dangerous if everything is working perfectly (the possibility to introduce issues)?

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by mikecb on Friday April 29, 2016 @08:06PM (#11599576)
They issued a security update within 24 hours of the cve, and > 99% of users had it within 48. That's what we need to happen.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by Zombieball on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:00PM (#11598727)
Until you need to define static routes and realize it's not possible on the Apple routers (happened to me this week).
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by dannyr on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:10PM (#11598419)
Is there anything out there that is already perfect and should not be improved?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by westernmostcoy on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:41PM (#11598235)
I feel like asking "what kind of updates" is too vague a question to reasonably answer.

Yes, updating any software adds some risk of something breaking. This is not unique to OnHub. This is still a pretty nice feature for most people.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by vox_mollis on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:13PM (#11598435)
All due respect, as you don't represent your employer, but a LAN-facing router that is automatically updated by a PRISM partner is an immediate no for those concerned about surveillance (dragnet or targeted) inside the home.

Edit: misread the specs, point still stands.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by wmf on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:53PM (#11598684)
OnHub doesn't have a microphone.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by TheSpiceIsLife on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:58PM (#11599040)
But the other x number of devices connected to it in your home do.

Automatic Security Updates is a contradiction in terms.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by Karunamon on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:15PM (#11599349)
The average user is a lot more likely to be a victim of a targeted attack by a hacker than a targeted attack by the state.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by nitrogen on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:45PM (#11599481)
Nobody's worried about targeted state attacks, they're worried about dragnet state attacks.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by Karunamon on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:47PM (#11599487)
...which don't seem to rely on vulnerabilities introduced via update mechanisms.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by nitrogen on Friday April 29, 2016 @10:11PM (#11600013)
I don't think we can say that for sure. For one example, there was the Skype update that removed most peer-to-peer features and added interception abilities.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by Karunamon on Saturday April 30, 2016 @12:30PM (#11602342)
Or, because peer to peer Skype sucked given the dismal status of the average home user's internet connection.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by paul_milovanov on Saturday April 30, 2016 @11:41PM (#11604752)
in the hypothetical case you're right, what gives you any assurance that the manufacturers of any of your other connected devices are not cooperating with the state?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by Nullabillity on Friday April 29, 2016 @08:05PM (#11599565)
Aside from the idiotic mandatory app, that's not at all exclusive to OnHub.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by potatolicious on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:19PM (#11598476)
The management app is a pretty neat way to set up a router - it certainly beats futzing around with a shitty HTML UI.

Other than that I've found it useful for testing WiFi signal strength - in old brick buildings you can get unintuitive dead spots, and the app lets you put your phone somewhere and test signal quality.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by greggman on Saturday April 30, 2016 @12:42AM (#11600402)
Actually I have the opposite experience. I need to use my routers at events for all kinds of situations. If the router uses html I can configure it regardless of os and having to go find an app. I also often use the router without internet (only need lan) which means no internet to download an app

Apps to configure routers are an anti-feature IMO

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by matwood on Friday April 29, 2016 @09:19PM (#11599834)
Same. I have an older Airport and it just works. I also have an express to extend the network and it also just works. I don't know the last time I had to use the management tool except to apply updates.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by thrownaway2424 on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:44PM (#11597840)
I haven't seen my OnHub since I turned it on last year. This puts it well ahead of all other wifi access points I have owned.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by jhoechtl on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:49PM (#11598286)
I haven't seen my Asus ac68 ever since. Reading these comments all the way down leaves the impression as the hefty overpriced OnHub is the only reliable wifi router on earth.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by stordoff on Saturday April 30, 2016 @12:03AM (#11600286)
Same here - Asus RT-AC68U running DD-WRT has a current uptime >100 days and noticed no problems with it during that.

The only downside is lack of auto-updates, but for my setup I'm not too concerned about that (WAN-side management features are disabled, and is behind another router anyway; occasional manual updates mostly mitigate LAN-side attacks [and web UI is usually disabled which prevents most of them anyway])

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by semi-extrinsic on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:07PM (#11598400)
I haven't seen my $50 Buffalo N300 since I bought it, flashed and configured dd-wrt on it about 2 years ago.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by thrownaway2424 on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:15PM (#11598449)
Your N300 is not getting security updates, but my OnHub is.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by semi-extrinsic on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:20PM (#11598840)
Pray tell, security updates for what?

My router has all WAN-side management features etc. turned off, WPS is turned off and it has a long random WPA passphrase. Unless someone breaks into my apartment, there just isn't a significant potential for security risks that I'm aware of.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by delroth on Friday April 29, 2016 @08:25PM (#11599645)
Unless you also disable execution of Javascript on all the devices that connect to your network (including your phones, set-top boxes, etc.), these devices can be used to attack your router from the LAN. Just use Javascript to autosubmit a form with action="http://192.168.1.1/exploitable/endpoint/" (you can autodetect the IP, look for Javascript port scanners on Google) and you're in.

And before you say that DD-WRT is not $WEIRD_CHINESE_BRAND and obviously doesn't have such vulnerabilities on its HTTP interface that can be accessed without auth, see https://www.cvedetails.com/vulnerability-list/vendor_id-9341... for some real examples, including "getting root by sending an HTTP query that doesn't require any authentication".

In fact, for that remote root exploit, disabling Javascript execution wouldn't even help that much, because it can be triggered through e.g. <img src="..."/> on any HTML page you visit (with some guessing required for the IP address, but there are only so many IPs people commonly use for their gateway).

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by greggman on Saturday April 30, 2016 @12:56AM (#11600438)
How is that any more secure? Are you sure every native app on your phone isn't sending the correct network packets to your router to reconfigure it? Seems like in either case all you need is a password to protect either in a secure enough way. Or isolate the router config on its own vlan
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by shiftpgdn on Friday April 29, 2016 @11:14PM (#11600167)
DD-WRT allows you to set access control lists. A simple protection would be only allow device with X MAC address to see the admin page(s). That device could be a virtual machine that only exists to manage the router.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by slrz on Saturday April 30, 2016 @10:53AM (#11601880)
Or simply disable the freakin' web interface if people just can't get it secure?

You should still apply security fixes for (relevant) kernel and sshd issues, of course.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by dzhiurgis on Monday May 02, 2016 @06:47AM (#11610419)
At this point it would be the best if Google just contributed to OpenWRT project itself.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by victorhooi on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:37PM (#11598936)
All products probably have (undiscovered) security holes - whether it's issues with the firewall, issues with the management console, SSL vulnerabilities, manufacturer backholes that get discovered later, or vulnerability in the wireless encryption scheme - this is stuff we find out later (if we knew about it earlier, it would have been fixed).

Having security updates pushed to your phone is never a bad thing.

It's the reason why enterprise Linux distro updates promise security patches (but possibly not bug fixes) for such a long period - because people do care about these things. Security patches are a good thing.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by nopinrop on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:51PM (#11599008)
Those precautions alone won't save you from CSRF and XSS vulnerabilities common in SOHO routers.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by TheSpiceIsLife on Friday April 29, 2016 @06:03PM (#11599063)
Agreed. I'm way more concerned about my computers and phones being compromised than I am my router. In comparison to the other devices I use the router has a tiny attack surface.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by ithkuil on Saturday April 30, 2016 @12:30AM (#11600368)
good thing the world is slowly moving to TLS, because your router, with its tiny attack surface, is the prototypical man in the middle
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by mrbill on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:35PM (#11598200)
Same here.. Long string of custom built routers, pfsense with wifi, OpenWRT, etc... even at one point a very expensive Cisco industrial-class 2.4/5 AP.

Now I have an Ubiquiti Edgerouter Lite as my "core" router, and the OnHub acting as just-an-AP in bridge mode. It Just Works, and works better than any piece of wireless gear I've had before.

My only "complaint" would be that I'm forced to use a mobile app for configuration - although in the OnHub subreddit, it was said a while back that a basic web UI was in development.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by NegativeLatency on Friday April 29, 2016 @06:21PM (#11599135)
Why not get a ubiquity AP?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by mrbill on Saturday April 30, 2016 @12:52PM (#11602438)
I had a Ubiquiti Unifi-LR (flashed with normal OpenWRT so I didn't have to use their Java-based management software for ONE access point) that worked great, but the OnHub works even better. The -LR was 802.11n-only.

The Unifi-AC runs about $269, more than the OnHub.

Looks like they now have a Unifi-AC-LITE, which is sub-$100, but it wasn't available when I got the OnHub that I know of.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by seanp2k2 on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:51PM (#11598292)
Interesting. I was running pfsense since 2006 on a P4 box with PCI Intel pro NICs + WRT54G on DD-WRT, then on an AMD Geode-based HP thin client with an expansion board to give it PCI-E to use a Pro1000/MT card + Cisco Aironet 1200 from eBay that someone flashed LWAP FW onto and couldn't fix so they sold it as parts/not working ($50 IIRC, had to track down the right firmware, took a day of messing with it), and finally now an ERLite + Airport Express + Ubiquiti AP AC Pro.

Power usage on the P4 sucked (>100w idle). The eBay thin clients did much better, usually around 20-40w, and the ERLite is lowest (and it's fanless). I ran a Cisco 2651XM for a while before any of this, but it maxed out doing NAT slower than my home connection was. Honestly though, I was just super excited to get something off-the-shelf for $100 that was stable, supported, low-power, and didn't require much administration. Messing with this stuff was a fun hobby and I learned a lot, but now I don't have as much time and it just needs to work.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by untog on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:42PM (#11598963)
> Messing with this stuff was a fun hobby and I learned a lot, but now I don't have as much time and it just needs to work.

Fact of life right there. When I was younger I assembled my own PCs, researching the best CPU, case, etc. etc... these days I have a Macbook that I can't even open. Makes me a little sad, but I need something that I can rely on - and I don't really have the time to research and construct my own machine.

I miss it a little, though. While is why it's really fun to play around with Arduino stuff. Reduces it down to harmless hobby level.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by daurnimator on Saturday April 30, 2016 @05:00AM (#11601007)
FWIW, I recently bought mikrotik hardware, and my god... it's so much better than the regular stuff I've been using for years.

You need to be rather technical to use it IMO, but they're such a step above the rest you'd be mad not to buy one.

e.g. model to get at the moment for home use: hAP ac. it's a 5 gigabit port router with ac wifi.

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by hiddennetwork on Saturday April 30, 2016 @09:49AM (#11601673)
What bothers me about this device is the necessity to have a live Google account, which takes in everything I surf in real time. I have serious reservations about this.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by ajonit on Sunday May 01, 2016 @05:26AM (#11605516)
Create an account just for this router and fwd incoming mails to your main email.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by nunez on Saturday April 30, 2016 @02:17PM (#11602829)
Have you ever tried using an Apple AirPort Extreme? That's the router we're running with at home and it's been damn amazing. I haven't had to touch the thing since I bought it 1.5 years ago, and it's only been off three times during the time I've had it (all due to power outages). It's also ridiculously fast; I get almost all of my allocated throughput over Wi-Fi. It's amazing.
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by deelowe on Friday April 29, 2016 @05:24PM (#11598861)
Can you explain this further? I'm running pfsense now and it's rock solid. Always has been. So, in that case are you saying that onhub is faster somehow?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by cmrdporcupine on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:46PM (#11597851)
Thanks. I work on the iOS mobile app, it's nice to hear positive feedback. Out of curiosity, are you using Android or iOS?
Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by rdegges on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:26PM (#11598533)
Using the Android app on my Nexus 6p. Absolutely love it.

Please pass along kudos to the Android / onHub teams!

<33

Re:Google rolls out “If This Then That” support for its $200... by wmf on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:59PM (#11597944)
The app looks cool but it doesn't really do much (not that I need it to do anything).