News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by KKKKkkkk1 on Friday April 15, 2016 @10:56AM (#11504802)
As a foreigner, I don't understand this attitude. Why would you want all your wealth to be invested in a single leveraged asset that's also depreciating, requires your constant attention and ties you to a single locale?
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by jseliger on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:12AM (#11504951)
1. People don't understand the time value of money, or how the alternative to owning a house is owning stocks / bonds.

2. Buying a house is a form of forced savings. This can be useful because people are irrational, per Kahneman's Thinking, Fast and Slow.

3. Cultural brainwashing (I think this is the biggest factor).

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by rconti on Friday April 15, 2016 @02:48PM (#11506676)
Favored tax treatment of housing
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by switch007 on Saturday April 16, 2016 @03:30AM (#11509691)
I often read counterarguments to buying that apply to our younger years, but rarely see them declared as such. Should a 40, 45 year old still be renting?
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by earlz on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:46AM (#11505221)
Even without all of the financial aspects everyone else has mentioned, if you own the home you can do whatever (well, with approval from the local homeowner committee if applicable). Don't like a wall separating the kitchen and living room? Tear it down. Want to rip up your yard and install new grass and a garden? Go ahead.

My current landlord allows pretty much no modifications to anything, just recently cut down the only 2 (40+ year old) trees around the house (for insurance purposes apparently), and won't allow anything to be planted in the yard except for flowers in a garden. I want an actual vegetable garden, and I would've never cut down those two trees. All of this is on top of the financial aspects of actually owning the house and paying rent to contribute to an asset (which at least in my area is about 40% cheaper, sans maintenance and taxes) and when it's paid off, I don't have any more rent...

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by dionidium on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:14PM (#11507284)
You always have rent, by some name or another. Homeowners pay property taxes and homeowners insurance. Homeowners with an extant loan pay interest.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by reverend_gonzo on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:08AM (#11504914)
A number of reasons:

1) You don't pay rent. Once you own the place free and clear, it's yours and you always have a home.

2) While the house depreciates, property may may still appreciate, especially if you live in a nice area, and even more so if you own the land beneath you.

3) There are tax benefits to owning your own house.

4) When you start out, it's usually not that much wealth, since you're taking a loan on it, though it is highly leveraged. As you pay more of it down, if you're smart, you'll have diversified your assets, so it's not all in one spot.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by kspaans on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:15AM (#11504967)
> 1) You don't pay rent. Once you own the place free and clear, it's yours and you always have a home.

Assuming you can keep up with property taxes! :P Though I understand they can vary a lot from place to place.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by antognini on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:22PM (#11505497)
Well, you'll be paying property taxes whether you own or rent. It's just not as visible if you rent.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by mtanski on Friday April 15, 2016 @06:35PM (#11508109)
Pick a place that has low property taxes and has legal limits on yearly increases. Like CA or NYC on 1 to 3 family homes.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by fiatmoney on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:14AM (#11504960)
You pay rent to the government, around here about 1.25% of the purchase price / year.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by GavinMcG on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:30AM (#11505094)
That's not rent. That's a tax, which is what you agree to in exchange for living in one of the most advanced societies on earth.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by stuxnet79 on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:28PM (#11505548)
There's something to be said about the lawlessness and utter lack of meddling by governments in some of the not so advanced societies on earth. I occasionally try to explain the notion of property tax to my relatives back in my home country and they just never get it. They always interpret it as "paying rent on land you already own" and I don't fault them as that's how I look at it too shrugs
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by logfromblammo on Friday April 15, 2016 @03:44PM (#11507081)
This isn't the proper forum to discuss the morality of taxation. I have been in those forums. I don't want HN to become like them.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by baddox on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:33PM (#11505594)
Of course it's a tax. I think the commenter was just pointing out that you do still pay a recurring fee for property even when you own it.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by pascal1usa on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:07PM (#11505375)
It's theft. People don't explicitly agree to it. It's forced on you. And most taxes don't go towards the advancement of society. Advancement comes from the people and businesses.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by mywittyname on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:37PM (#11506171)
This applies to most every law. You never agreed to 99.99% of the laws you're required to follow everyday.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by geggam on Friday April 15, 2016 @02:31PM (#11506554)
No one follows you around to ensure you follow them.

Rest assured most people dont follow the laws they do know 100% of the time and better yet... No one knows 100% of the laws they are required to follow.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by chrisabrams on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:41PM (#11505661)
Real Estate is an awesome investment, but when done correctly. The irrationalness of buying a house gets in the way at times.

To address some of your concerns:

- Time: It only depreciates if you buy at the top of the cycle and sell before it recovers it's value - assuming you're able to stay in a house long enough for the cycle to recover. Many people can't wait for cycles - when it's time to move, it's time to move. Don't buy if you're unsure about the future of your market. Definitely don't buy if you believe your market will _never_ go down. That's called irrational exuberance and the '07-08 crash was aided by that psychological non-sense.

- Money: Let's say you put 200k down into a house in SF and take out a 800k loan, so you pay 1M total for the house. If the market drops 10% over the next year, you've lost 100k in your downpayment. That sucks. Now let's say you waited 2 year from now when the market has cooled off, and you purchase the same home for 850k. You put your 200k down again, but this time, the home increases in value 10% over the next 2 years. Sounds like a better deal, right? Value is correlated to many things, but timing is one that cannot be ignored.

- All my money is locked into my house!!!!!: No, it really isn't. I don't understand why many people think this. It's called a HELOC, or Home Equity Line of Credit. You can get one for around 4% annual interest right now. You can take ~80% of your current principal in the house, and pull it out as needed through your HELOC. This is very common and a great way to use principal money as needed. So taking the same example as above, if you have ~250k in principal in your house after 1-2 years, you can use roughly 200k of that money (assuming you pay back your HELOC of course). Now if you're thinking...wait...that means I'd have 2 loans...we'll of course. But when you rent, you get to use 0% of that money for anything.

Housing, for most of us, is a long term investment - unless you just have millions lying under your mattress. Looking at things from a 1-3 year perspective is why so many people rent. Again, for some people that's their only option, but if you are fortunate to be able to plan for the 5-10-15 years down the road, you can really make housing work in your favor.

Just don't buy this year. Let things cool down :)

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by mtanski on Friday April 15, 2016 @06:41PM (#11508139)
> Value is correlated to many things, but timing is one that cannot be ignored.

The real estate market as a general rule moves slower then the stock market (when it does crash in a day or a week). Timing the stock market is hard, much more doable with the real estate market.

Example Houston, clearly the area is losing oil and gas jobs which make a decent chunk of their economy and also drive commerce downstream locally (car sales, entertainment, etc...) but the house prices currently do not reflect that reality in Houston.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by nattaylor on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:14AM (#11504963)
In addition to what reverend_gonzo said, there is the simple fact that rents (mostly) go up and mortgage payments don't.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by nattaylor on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:30AM (#11505088)
I've always thought this calculator was an insightful way to play out various home buying scenarios since you can adjust pretty much anything, including the tax benefits and the market return of an equivalent investment. http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calc...
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by kspaans on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:20AM (#11505012)
Interest rates aren't guaranteed to stay low. Here are the historic rates: http://b-i.forbesimg.com/phildemuth/files/2013/07/image001.p...

Though if you have a long-term fixed-rate mortgage, you are probably OK.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by nattaylor on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:27AM (#11505064)
True, I was assuming fixed rate.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by spriggan3 on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:30PM (#11505579)
Yes, like subprime mortgage rates didn't go up ...
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by jorts on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:00PM (#11505839)
They were variable rate loans or had balloon payments... If you get a fixed rate loan the amount you pay per month on your mortgage will not go up.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by surfmike on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:11AM (#11504938)
Most of the value is in the land. And historically the prices have gone up over the long term, so your leveraged investment allows you to get more returns.

Also, unlike stocks, if housing falls, at least you get utility from it-- you live in it.

Finally, there are many neighborhoods in the US where the rental options are pretty limited. You need to buy to live a lot of places.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by jschwartzi on Friday April 15, 2016 @10:58AM (#11504824)
Because it means you don't have to pay rent after you retire.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by refurb on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:06AM (#11504907)
But you're not paying rent because you have hundreds of thousands of dollars locked up in tye house?

The real question is, how much money would you have made if all that equity was in the stock market? Sometimes that can be more than what rent would be.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by reverend_gonzo on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:09AM (#11504927)
And sometimes the stock market crashes and takes everything with it.

See: every ten years.

At least with a house, even if the value goes down, you still have a home.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by refurb on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:29AM (#11505084)
True, but what is more risky? Having most of your money in a single, non-liquid asset with a very local market or having most of your money in a diversified, liquid asset?

I'm not saying owning a home is a bad idea, just having 80%+ of your money in it.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by scrumper on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:08PM (#11505906)
Owning $300k of stocks is better than owning a single $300k property for the reason you give. The question becomes a lot fuzzier when you overlay your own need for housing on top of it.

What I mean is, if I had $300k cash in the bank and I was renting an apartment I enjoyed, I'd be smarter to invest the $300k in a diversified portfolio than spend all of it on a single rental house and playing landlord.

Equally if I had $300k cash and nowhere to live, I might very well be better off buying a house than renting a home and buying the portfolio. A vast amount depends on individual circumstances and stage of life.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by refurb on Friday April 15, 2016 @06:10PM (#11507991)
I don't disagree. I'm certainly not anti-owning a home, but it's much more risky than people think it is. This is despite all the people who witnessed the 2008 crash.

I see people stretch themselves with a mortgage, dumping every dollar they have in order to make up the down payment. A single-asset investment philosophy. Why do they do it? The only answer I can imagine is that risk of their home going down in value is low. I disagree the risk is that low.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by Domenic_S on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:08PM (#11505388)
Diversification can include real estate.

Besides, it's the leverage. You can buy $625,500 of house with 2.5% down + a monthly payment with a ~4% vig. Nowhere else can you get that kind of money at that kind of rate with ~$16k down.

Then if you're smart you invest other money other places to diversify. You can live in house, unlike Vanguard funds. But you should have both.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by scurvy on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:39PM (#11505643)
Where can you buy with 2.5% down? Those days are long gone. Skin in the game and all that.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by heywire on Friday April 15, 2016 @02:42PM (#11506625)
Not 2.5%, but close, FHA still allows 3.5% down.. but then you're talking MIP and such
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by Domenic_S on Friday April 15, 2016 @03:04PM (#11506797)
Yep, I was talking about FHA but misremembered the %. Still crazy low. MI sucks but hey, 3.5%.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by refurb on Friday April 15, 2016 @06:09PM (#11507985)
You are correct, but with leverage comes risk.

Here is my nightmare scenario: I live in the Bay area and if I wanted to buy a single-family house, I'd be looking at $900K at a minimum (if you avoid the really run-down/dangerous areas of the city).

Let's say I have the down payment of 20%. That's $180K. I buy the house and I can swing the $6000 per month in PMI, utilities, maintenance, etc.

Then the market takes a dip of 20%. If you own a $200K home, the hit would be $40K. That would suck, but with a good paying job, you could handle it.

In SF, a 20% drop (still within the realm of possibility) means you just lost $200K (if you include the other costs of closing on the home). $200K would be 5+ years of savings down the tubes.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by kspaans on Friday April 15, 2016 @06:55PM (#11508229)
You did _not_ lose anything! That's a paper loss! Are you a speculator expecting to sell the house in 2-4 years? If you went to all of that effort to buy a _family_ home, presumably you are planning on staying there for a while (possibly long enough for the price to recover).

On the other hand, I agree that now you're underwater and if you're forced to sell you'd be in trouble. But if there was a risk you'd have to sell the house so soon, why would you buy it in the first place?

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by Domenic_S on Friday April 15, 2016 @07:43PM (#11508439)
PMI is mortgage insurance, which you do not have to pay with 20% down. You may have meant PITI (principle, interest, taxes & insurance) which for that example situation would be about $4500/mo.

Even so, assuming your mortgage is fixed rate, your payments don't change regardless of the value of your home. Whether it's worth $1 today or $10MM today, it only matters what you paid. Like the other commenter said, it's a paper loss.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by kspaans on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:18AM (#11504988)
You say "stock market crashes", I say "dividend yields go way up!". The losses are usually paper losses (hello tax-loss harvesting!), which don't bother long-term investors (whether they are home owners or stock investors). (I don't think you can tax-loss harvest a home though...)
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by deegles on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:45AM (#11505209)
Only after you own enough homes to create a publicly traded REIT :)
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by mywittyname on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:39PM (#11506192)
Everything? When was the last time the stock market went to zero?

Every market crash in the US has been follow by a even bigger boom.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by drudru11 on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:18AM (#11504996)
... If you can still swing the mortgage
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by OldSchoolJohnny on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:47AM (#11505233)
There are untold retired people who have been forced to move due to rising property taxes. Many of the benefits of owning evaporate when you take into account everything.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by Domenic_S on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:11PM (#11505412)
Evaporate? No. Those retired people would still be paying property taxes -- you think landlords just eat that cost? Rent includes taxes, maintenance, etc, it's just spread out through the year.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by scurvy on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:51PM (#11505744)
CA prop 13 fear monger much?
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by beatpanda on Friday April 15, 2016 @03:09PM (#11506844)
Because in America, the balance of rights is heavily tilted in favor of landlords, and if you're a renter, you are constantly in danger of losing your home with little to no legal or social consequences for your landlord.