News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by refurb on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:29AM (#11505084)
True, but what is more risky? Having most of your money in a single, non-liquid asset with a very local market or having most of your money in a diversified, liquid asset?

I'm not saying owning a home is a bad idea, just having 80%+ of your money in it.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by scrumper on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:08PM (#11505906)
Owning $300k of stocks is better than owning a single $300k property for the reason you give. The question becomes a lot fuzzier when you overlay your own need for housing on top of it.

What I mean is, if I had $300k cash in the bank and I was renting an apartment I enjoyed, I'd be smarter to invest the $300k in a diversified portfolio than spend all of it on a single rental house and playing landlord.

Equally if I had $300k cash and nowhere to live, I might very well be better off buying a house than renting a home and buying the portfolio. A vast amount depends on individual circumstances and stage of life.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by refurb on Friday April 15, 2016 @06:10PM (#11507991)
I don't disagree. I'm certainly not anti-owning a home, but it's much more risky than people think it is. This is despite all the people who witnessed the 2008 crash.

I see people stretch themselves with a mortgage, dumping every dollar they have in order to make up the down payment. A single-asset investment philosophy. Why do they do it? The only answer I can imagine is that risk of their home going down in value is low. I disagree the risk is that low.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by Domenic_S on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:08PM (#11505388)
Diversification can include real estate.

Besides, it's the leverage. You can buy $625,500 of house with 2.5% down + a monthly payment with a ~4% vig. Nowhere else can you get that kind of money at that kind of rate with ~$16k down.

Then if you're smart you invest other money other places to diversify. You can live in house, unlike Vanguard funds. But you should have both.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by scurvy on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:39PM (#11505643)
Where can you buy with 2.5% down? Those days are long gone. Skin in the game and all that.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by heywire on Friday April 15, 2016 @02:42PM (#11506625)
Not 2.5%, but close, FHA still allows 3.5% down.. but then you're talking MIP and such
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by Domenic_S on Friday April 15, 2016 @03:04PM (#11506797)
Yep, I was talking about FHA but misremembered the %. Still crazy low. MI sucks but hey, 3.5%.
Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by refurb on Friday April 15, 2016 @06:09PM (#11507985)
You are correct, but with leverage comes risk.

Here is my nightmare scenario: I live in the Bay area and if I wanted to buy a single-family house, I'd be looking at $900K at a minimum (if you avoid the really run-down/dangerous areas of the city).

Let's say I have the down payment of 20%. That's $180K. I buy the house and I can swing the $6000 per month in PMI, utilities, maintenance, etc.

Then the market takes a dip of 20%. If you own a $200K home, the hit would be $40K. That would suck, but with a good paying job, you could handle it.

In SF, a 20% drop (still within the realm of possibility) means you just lost $200K (if you include the other costs of closing on the home). $200K would be 5+ years of savings down the tubes.

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by kspaans on Friday April 15, 2016 @06:55PM (#11508229)
You did _not_ lose anything! That's a paper loss! Are you a speculator expecting to sell the house in 2-4 years? If you went to all of that effort to buy a _family_ home, presumably you are planning on staying there for a while (possibly long enough for the price to recover).

On the other hand, I agree that now you're underwater and if you're forced to sell you'd be in trouble. But if there was a risk you'd have to sell the house so soon, why would you buy it in the first place?

Re:San Francisco Home Prices Fell for the First Time in Four... by Domenic_S on Friday April 15, 2016 @07:43PM (#11508439)
PMI is mortgage insurance, which you do not have to pay with 20% down. You may have meant PITI (principle, interest, taxes & insurance) which for that example situation would be about $4500/mo.

Even so, assuming your mortgage is fixed rate, your payments don't change regardless of the value of your home. Whether it's worth $1 today or $10MM today, it only matters what you paid. Like the other commenter said, it's a paper loss.