News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The end of the establishment? by mike_hearn on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @07:33AM (#11166214)
This sort of analysis is helpful and needed. Explanations like "everyone is stupid" don't get you anywhere.

The article doesn't say it explicitly, choosing to hint at it instead, but I think a big part of the popular revolt against big, remote establishments everywhere (also see: Brexit referendum polling) is that these institutions have normally made little or no effort to self police, or demonstrate any kind of ability to self discipline or self reform. The past 15 years especially have seen a more or less constant stream of scandals where people at the top of societies power structures very clearly acted badly or even broke laws, yet nobody was ever held to account ... except those who tried to reveal the wrongdoing. The track record of the elite enforcing the same rules against themselves that they enforce against everyone else is utterly miserable.

This is not a US specific thing. It can be seen to a lesser extent in other parts of the world too. One of the biggest arguments for the UK leaving the EU is that the EU has become a vast bureaucracy that is remote, bloated, undemocratic, disconnected from the people etc. The tone-deafness was made clear when the EU demanded yet another budget rise despite the fact that the member states were all trying to cut their own deficits, often by freezing public sector wages or simply laying people off.

Now mix this in with the partitioning of American society into ever more clearly distinct political tribes and it's not surprising that people who have a message of "We are outsiders just like you who won't hesitate to really shake things up" are getting so much traction. A big part of Obama's original appeal was his entirely unrealised promise to try and reform Washington. Unfortunately he lost interest in that once elected. Not that he could really have fixed anything anyway: the mismatch between emphasis on the US President and how much power they actually have is kind of ridiculous.

Re:The end of the establishment? by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:33AM (#11166958)
>The past 15 years especially have seen a more or less constant stream of scandals where people at the top of societies power structures very clearly acted badly or even broke laws, yet nobody was ever held to account ... except those who tried to reveal the wrongdoing.

I find this argument baffling when applied to the EU.

Most of the scandals were in the banking and finance industries, not - say - the EU parliament.

The Greek debacle, which was probably the biggest failure of the EU since its creation, was created by the EU's banking and finance industries.

Perhaps it's the industry that's the problem, and not Europe itself?

Not that the EU isn't remote, but it's not so remote that it has no interest in promoting standards of human rights legislation.

By a remarkable coincidence, a key foundation of Brexit is the dismissal of the EU's requirement to treat workers in a civilised manner as "Brussels red tape".

As for Trump - the idea that you can dethrone an Establishment run by and for narcissistic billionaires by electing another narcissistic billionaire seems entirely fantastic.

If Trump is elected, the US establishment will be happy to do business with him, as usual.

Sanders may be a tougher nut to crack, which is why he can't be allowed to win - and why the idea that these candidates "challenge the Establishment" is nonsense, when no Establishment policy is under any serious threat in this election. (Or any other.)

Re:The end of the establishment? by tomp on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:02AM (#11167202)
> The Greek debacle was created by the EU's banking and finance industries.

No, it was created by the EU who bailed out the banks, paying them money and forcing the loss on the taxpayers.

> Most of the scandals were in the banking and finance industries, not - say - the EU parliament.

The EU parliament is a scandal in and of itself - "let's waste some money and have two parliament buildings in two cities!"

Re:The end of the establishment? by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:33AM (#11167451)
>No, it was created by the EU who bailed out the banks

No, it was caused by the Greeks living beyond their means.

Re:The end of the establishment? by justinhj on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:11AM (#11167781)
You can't live beyond your means without help from a complicit financial body enabling you to do it
Re:The end of the establishment? by madaxe_again on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:25AM (#11167918)
Of course you can. This is what sovereign bonds are for.
Re:The end of the establishment? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:00PM (#11168215)
In which case the financial body is whoever is buying the bonds.
Re:The end of the establishment? by tomp on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:14AM (#11167809)
Well... Greeks created a Greek problem. EU extended this problem to all EU citizens.
Re:The end of the establishment? by golergka on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:13AM (#11167797)
> forcing the loss on the taxpayers.

So, the people who originally took the loans from the banks. How horrible! People, being forced to pay their debts.

Re:The end of the establishment? by pjc50 on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:27AM (#11167926)
Not usually the same individuals!

e.g. In the case of Kaupthing, quite a lot of UK local governments were directly using them as a deposit bank and lost money when the bank collapsed. These deposits were made whole by the UK central government.

Re:The end of the establishment? by tomp on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:15AM (#11167817)
Well, the alternative interpretation is, bankers who originally gave loans to people who couldn't pay, were "compensated" for their (too) risky behavior.
Re:The end of the establishment? by golergka on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:21AM (#11167873)
It's still those people's ethnical obligation to pay what they owe.
Re:The end of the establishment? by rwallace on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:27PM (#11168450)
When irresponsible or predatory lending has taken place, there is blame to be allocated on both sides. That means we are not justified in simply throwing the entire burden of solving the problem onto the borrowers.
Re:The end of the establishment? by pjc50 on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:37AM (#11167487)
The Greek debacle was created by the Euro, establishing a common monetary area without a corresponding common fiscal area to rebalance it (not that a common fiscal area would have been feasible: the EU is really not ready to file federal EU tax returns).
Re:The end of the establishment? by madaxe_again on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:24AM (#11167908)
Alternately, it was caused by the Greek govt issuing bonds like candy based on fraudulent growth projections, who belatedly realised they couldn't inflate their way out of a corner as they (and everyone else in control of an unpegged currency do) used to - hence the drachma having about as much value as the paper it was printed on.
Re:The end of the establishment? by larsiusprime on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:51AM (#11168143)
Which was arguably a predictable occupational hazard of establishing a common currency.
Re:The end of the establishment? by mike_hearn on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @04:18PM (#11170313)
I wasn't actually thinking of the EU when I wrote that paragraph specifically. My post was perhaps an unclear mishmash of comments on both the USA and - as a side note - the EU.

I agree that the EU does not seem to have a serious problem with top officials ignoring the rules and being unpunished for it (or if it does, I don't know about it). However the USA clearly does. James Clapper being just one example. Hillary Clinton being another who is in the news right now.

W.R.T. Greece, that is very clearly a couple of systemic problems coming together:

1) Banks being too big to fail. Same problem all over the world. Not EU specific.

2) EU being willing to continue giving Greece large sums of money far after it became clear that the country was completely broken and shouldn't be in the EU at all, because they're ideologically incapable of contemplating the EU getting smaller.

> By a remarkable coincidence, a key foundation of Brexit is the dismissal of the EU's requirement to treat workers in a civilised manner as "Brussels red tape"

I guess you're thinking of the working time directive?! Not sure what you mean here. At any rate, it's a bit off topic for this thread which is really about US politics, perhaps I shouldn't have brought up the EU at all.

Trump's argument is very simple - "To get to Washington you need a lot of money, most of these guys get it from shadowy lobbyists, but I am already super rich and that makes me unbuyable - and thus a man of integrity who says what he thinks. With me you know exactly what you're gonna get".

It is a very simple, straightforward argument and unfortunately it has a core of truth to it.

Re:The end of the establishment? by pdkl95 on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @04:58PM (#11170569)
> The Greek debacle, which was probably the biggest failure of the EU since its creation, was created by the EU's banking and finance industries.

Exactly. Greece was merely the scapegoat for the bailout of the massively over-leveraged banks that bet against their sovereigns when they saw the Euro would equalize risk.

For a much better explanation of how the EU got into this mess, see the this[1] talk by Mark Blyth (Econ prof at Brown).

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B6vV8_uQmxs#t=777

Re:The end of the establishment? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:36PM (#11168534)
The problem with the EU isn't the scandals. It's the total lack of responsiveness to the people.

We're going to create this constitution, and you (the people) don't get to vote on it, but you have to live under it. Oh, one country insists on letting the people vote, and the people vote against it? They'll have to vote again, because the people can't be allowed to stop what we're doing.

That is where you find the EU "establishment" completely out of touch with the people.

Re:The end of the establishment? by gaius on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:56AM (#11167653)
Question: when did the auditors last sign off on the EU's accounts?

I know the answer, I just wonder if you do.

Re:The end of the establishment? by Angostura on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:15AM (#11167813)
Here we go again. You do know why those accounts aren't signed off in full? Nothing to do with internal EU shenanigans, it is is because when Brussels pays out money to national governments for projects, they don't always get all the receipts back. Without the receipts, no sign-off http://www.britishinfluence.org/it_s_the_british_media_that_...
Re:The end of the establishment? by gaius on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:19PM (#11168390)
It's taxpayers money being sloshed around with no oversight, no matter how you try to spin it.
Re:The end of the establishment? by tomwalker on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:19PM (#11168385)
It is still a 7.9 billion Euro 'error rate'
Re:The end of the establishment? by rayiner on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:01AM (#11167700)
> A big part of Obama's original appeal was his entirely unrealised promise to try and reform Washington. Unfortunately he lost interest in that once elected. Not that he could really have fixed anything anyway: the mismatch between emphasis on the US President and how much power they actually have is kind of ridiculous.

I don't think it's fair to say he lost interest in it. It's a combination of 1) having less power than people think; and 2) having to be everyone's President, not just the people who elected him.

If you were President and had a good faith desire to govern by national consensus, what would you do? Deregulate industries? Increase regulation? Flat tax? Eliminate social security? Increase social security? Universal healthcare? No healthcare? End the drug war? How much of that do you think would drum up more than bare majority support?

Re:The end of the establishment? by mike_hearn on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @04:13PM (#11170268)
If I had campaigned on "fix Washington" and that seemed to be the primary driving force of my supporters, I guess I'd focus the bulk of my time on process. Ending gerrymandering, devolving power, making Congress' procedures work better, actually punishing even very top ranking officials if they broke the rules, things like that.

Obama campaigned on "fix Washington" but then went on to drive a fairly ordinary centre-left policy agenda (centre-left by American standards).

Re:The end of the establishment? by Futurebot on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @04:38PM (#11170445)
Apparently, it's much harder than it seems in our system: http://www.vox.com/2015/11/17/9749754/obama-presidential-pow...

'President Harry Truman complaining:

"I sit here all day trying to persuade people to do the things they ought to have sense enough to do without my persuading them. ... That's all the powers of the President amount to."'

Re:The end of the establishment? by infinite8s on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:35PM (#11172199)
How would he end gerrymandering? Voting districts are set by each state's respective legislative body (supposedly guided by the national census results).
Re:The end of the establishment? by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @01:04PM (#11168770)
> I don't think it's fair to say he lost interest in it. It's a combination of 1) having less power than people think; and 2) having to be everyone's President, not just the people who elected him.

I think its mostly #1, combined with the fact that reform was behind a few high-priority economic issues, and by the time they were taken care of, Congress was embroiled in campaigns for the midterm elections, where the Democratic majority fell to a Republican majority unusual (even in the history of divided government in this country) unwilling to work with the President (Mitch McConnell, famously, stated that his #1 priority as Senate Majority Leader was to assure that Obama was a one-term president), which meant there was no way for any reform agenda Obama had to make progress.

> If you were President and had a good faith desire to govern by national consensus, what would you do?

I don't think any President has had a good faith desire to govern by national consensus (nor do I think that governing by national consensus in the US, at any point in its history, would be a reasonable or even sane desire.) OTOH, Presidents have very little practical choice, on certain matters, other than to operate within the constraints set by Congress' willingness to participate.

Re:The end of the establishment? by waterlesscloud on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:05AM (#11167737)
It's probably more accurate to say reform was more his marketing hook than his genuine interest in the first place.
Re:The end of the establishment? by rayiner on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:18AM (#11167844)
Why?
Re:The end of the establishment? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:55AM (#11168175)
Because the questions you're asking (reform how?) were as present on the campaign trail as they are now. If you campaign strongly on "flat tax" or "end the drug war" and are elected then you have your mandate. If you campaign on "hope and change" then it creates the problem you're pointing out -- what is that supposed to mean? Change what?
Re:The end of the establishment? by FD3SA on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @02:35PM (#11169535)
Because he hired Henry Paulson, the ex-CEO of Goldman Sachs who single handedly devised the entire CDO ponzi scheme, as his Treasury Secretary.

For those interested, more here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzrBurlJUNk

Watch the entire documentary, lays it out plain and simple. To this day, not a single prosecution.

Re:The end of the establishment? by maxerickson on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @04:40PM (#11170456)
Obama's first appointee to Treasury Secretary was Timothy Geithner. He took over from Paulson 6 days after Obama became president. That delay is maybe slightly unusual, but it hardly makes Obama responsible for the actions that Paulson took 6 months prior (I guess hiring Geithner indicates that Obama didn't have a problem with those actions, as Geithner was also one of the architects of the bailout).
Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @08:27AM (#11166500)
> This sort of analysis is helpful and needed.

It's just more noise. It's one reporter's take on current events. There's no attention given to history, or even a reasoned take on the economics involved. It's pure narrative, a bunch of facts strung together with nothing tying them together but opinion.

What we're seeing is another evolution in the media-driven political cycle. Political candidacy has changed immensely in the last few years. Social media turned out to be way more politically useful than anybody ever thought it would. So candidates that use it effectively are going to be able to manipulate the news cycle more.

It doesn't give them an overwhelming advantage over the traditional power base, but they have been caught flat-footed.

That Americans are currently receptive to populist platforms shouldn't be surprising. We're still in the primary phase, and primaries are conducted in rural areas where the most provincial Americans live. The messaging needs to be kept simple.

Once the primaries are over, the nominees are going to move to the center for the real race. Happens in every single presidential election. We're just paying more and more attention to it these day. Nobody used to care about primaries.

Re:The end of the establishment? by minsight on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:06AM (#11166771)
>It's one reporter's take on current events.

Where "one reporter" was once Secretary of Labor.

Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:10AM (#11167263)
Fine, whatever. It's still bad analysis. He makes sweeping conclusions built on little but a smattering of incoherent facts. He's pandering to an audience.
Re:The end of the establishment? by narag on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:20AM (#11167866)
There's something different this time, though. I have paid some attention to the last three or four of your primaries and there has always been a guy in the role that Sanders is playing now.

Sanders still seems to have a chance after a handful of states. That's a change for sure. And the explanation seems plausible. Unless you think Sanders is charismatic leader, worshipped by the masses, it must be a change in the voters part.

Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:41AM (#11168047)
Sure, something's different. It's the nature of politics. The game is changing. This guy makes the argument that America has changed. It hasn't. Still the same ole' 'Murica. What's changed is social media.

Everybody gets excited over their pet independent candidate every single election. But now these indies can get their issues taken seriously by end-running establishment control over the news cycle.

The media creates the perception of who is winning and who is losing. Politicians trick the media into giving them coverage. They can build momentum by building awareness. Voters can only choose who they're aware of, for the reasons the media gives them. American voters are only a fraction of the population, only a quarter of Americans vote.

Three quarters of Americans don't care enough about politics to cast a vote. I'm one of them. This 4 year endeavor to place someone in the most powerful office in the world better resembles a bush-league pro wrestling circuit than anything like Serious Business.

But that's not even the strangest part. The strange part is that this is how it's been running for decades.

Sanders is not worshipped by the masses. He's merely running a flashier campaign than Hillary, so we see him more in the media. Ditto for Trump.

America is the same, it's politics that's changing. I'd prefer Hillary over Trump or Sanders, but any of them would do a decent job. Trump's basically a liberal anyway, if you look at his positions over time, he actually looks fairly reasonable. I'd prefer Hillary because she'd be able to actually get things done with Congress.

Re:The end of the establishment? by dennisgorelik on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @02:51PM (#11169669)
> be able to actually get things done with Congress

What kind of things do you expect Congress to do? Generally it's better when Congress does only absolutely necessary things and does not do anything else.

Re:The end of the establishment? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:39PM (#11168555)
> I'd prefer Hillary because she'd be able to actually get things done with Congress.

No chance. Not with Congress the way it is now, and run by Republicans. Neither will Sanders.

Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:46PM (#11168600)
They said that about Obama, but he still got shit done. The Repubs can't obstruct forever, and the Dems have learned how to deal with those tactics.

The weird thing out our democracy is, it's getting more democratic, even with pathetic turnout, the public exerts more of an influence on the news cycle, and that drives the political agenda.

Re:The end of the establishment? by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @01:18PM (#11168880)
> They said that about Obama, but he still got shit done.

Mostly in the first half-term, with a Democratic Congressional majority -- his signature legislative accomplishments (Affordable Care Act, ARRA) were achieved then.

> The weird thing out our democracy is, it's getting more democratic

No, its not.

> even with pathetic turnout, the public exerts more of an influence on the news cycle, and that drives the political agenda.

There's a number of forces steering things in between there, assuring that the impact that the news cycle has (because of the spin on the events, even if the public exerts more influence on which events get attention -- which is a dubious proposition, I think) reflects a fairly narrow set of biases held by the powerful.

There doesn't seem to be any evidence that the substantive policy output of the political system is becoming better aligned with the strength of views in the public, such that the net effect of any of this would be "more democratic."

Re:The end of the establishment? by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:59PM (#11168733)
> No chance. Not with Congress the way it is now, and run by Republicans. Neither will Sanders.

100% of the House and 1/3 of the Senate is up for election at the same time as the President. There's no particularly strong reason to believe that the next Congress must look like the current Congress.

Re:The end of the establishment? by maxerickson on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @08:38AM (#11166568)
Clay Shirky recently tweeted (yeah, that's right) an interesting analysis of this:

https://storify.com/cshirky/republican-and-democratic-partie...

Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:17AM (#11167839)
Thanks, this is much better. The "quasi-parliamentarianism" bit was fascinating.
Re:The end of the establishment? by cdent on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @08:48AM (#11166649)
I'll think you'll find that Robert B. Reich's expertise extends a bit further than "reporting".
Re:The end of the establishment? by bsbechtel on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @08:58AM (#11166720)
I'd argue he's part of the 'establishment' he's purporting to analyze from the outside, however.
Re:The end of the establishment? by cylinder on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:19AM (#11167329)
What is your point? Who better to tell us how the establishment thinks and perceives than someone inside of it?
Re:The end of the establishment? by mc32 on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:40AM (#11168042)
Right but he can only tell us what he thinks from that framework but that framework is failing to understand what is actually happening, so the conclusions are only useful knowing they are incorrect.
Re:The end of the establishment? by bsbechtel on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:38AM (#11167494)
Well if someone from the perceived establishment presents an analysis saying the establishment's thinking is flawed, wouldn't their own analysis be questionable, given they are a part of the group they are claiming has flawed thinking?
Re:The end of the establishment? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:13PM (#11168333)
The form of your argument is: Tesla says 19th century scientists have flawed thinking about alternating current, Tesla is a 19th century scientist, therefore Tesla has flawed thinking about alternating current.
Re:The end of the establishment? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:42PM (#11168575)
More generally, no member of any group can ever say that the group is wrong, because they're a member of the group.

But stated differently, the flaw becomes apparent: "No member of any group can ever say that the group consensus is wrong, because they are a member of the group." But the one criticizing isn't a member of the group who shares the consensus, and the contradiction evaporates.

Re:The end of the establishment? by notahacker on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:19AM (#11166859)
To which you could add that Trump and Cruz are benefiting from a large number of relatively low-profile candidates vying for the role of the "establishment candidate" which will soon be pared down, and the rules of the Democratic contest mean that Sanders either has to persuade a lot of party grandees to nominate him or win the caucus votes by a large margin.

The chances of both of them being on the ballot are pretty slim, and the likelihood of one of them being able to win an election in a head-to-head race with a non-alarming establishment candidate is slimmer still. Radical candidates can shift the political agenda, but the closer they get to actual power, the more likely they are to shift it in the opposite direction to the one they intend.

Re:The end of the establishment? by venomsnake on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:53AM (#11167130)
That is the conventional wisdom. This cycle conventional wisdom has lower than usual predicting power. The way I see Nevada - 52-47 is bad news for Hilary. She not only has to win by delegate count - she should win legitimacy with the Bernie supporters
Re:The end of the establishment? by maxerickson on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:30AM (#11167425)
Yeah, its hard to believe that the super delegates will override a popular victory. It would destroy the party.
Re:The end of the establishment? by burkaman on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:22AM (#11166879)
>We're still in the primary phase, and primaries are conducted in rural areas where the most provincial Americans live. The messaging needs to be kept simple.

Primaries are conducted everywhere, so I don't understand this part. And wouldn't "provincial" people be less likely to vote in the primary than they would be to vote in the general?

Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:33AM (#11167448)
Fascinating article about stumping for primaries:

http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jan/10/white-man-pat...

Re:The end of the establishment? by pc2g4d on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @07:53PM (#11171598)
So rural voters are more susceptible to populism than urban voters?
Re:The end of the establishment? by noja on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @08:41AM (#11166593)
I'd argue that media ownership by the few should not be forgotten, it has a huge influence on our opinions of huge remote organisations. If I am being constantly told that something is bad, and never told when it is good, I will gradually shift my opinion. Attrition wins.
Re:The end of the establishment? by VLM on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @08:53AM (#11166686)
Here's a helpful poll:

http://www.gallup.com/poll/176042/trust-mass-media-returns-t...

So for 3/5 to 2/3 of the population, observation shows that a unified message from all the multinational megacorp journalists of anti-Trump hatred results in soaring poll numbers for Trump. Every time some elitist smarmy condescending newsreader indicates their oh so holier than thou hatred of Trump, his poll numbers go up a little more.

Note this applies to the "other guys" too. Decades of screaming on fox news about how Bill Clinton and now Obama are going to destroy the country, planet, universe ... chicken little buffer overflow. If I can't vote for Trump I will vote for Sanders. If the establishment neocons on fox news hate him, he might be somewhat off, but also can't be that bad of a guy, I mean look at the other people they hate who aren't the best but aren't that bad. Obama may very well go down in history as one of our worst presidents, but hes just not that bad.

Note that a 3/5 majority would be quite a landslide in a general election.

Re:The end of the establishment? by notahacker on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:35AM (#11166976)
Is that the link you intended to post? Because all it shows is that only around 40% of the public trust the media (and of those that distrust the media, a substantial proportion don't trust the media because they don't think it's liberal enough). Most people are perfectly capable of distrusting both the media and the candidate that is indisputably advocating points they disagree with. Some of them distrust the media because they think it's giving Trump an easy ride.

Sure, there is a demographic that sees negative coverage of Trump (and Sanders) as proof he must be the only totally honest guy with real, serious policies. But it isn't 3/5 of the population, or anything close.

I mean, you'd probably find the figure for British citizens that trust the media to be at least as low. Trouble is, trust in people that the media widely dislike is even lower, and so they still lose.

Re:The end of the establishment? by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:54PM (#11168679)
> A big part of Obama's original appeal was his entirely unrealised promise to try and reform Washington. Unfortunately he lost interest in that once elected.

Perhaps more relevantly, it was always he lost the narrow (and unreliable, thanks to a handful of often hostile Democratics) Congressional majority at the first midterm, and it was replaced with an unusually obstructionist opposite-party majority which meant that any Obama policy initiative was dead on arrival.

> Not that he could really have fixed anything anyway: the mismatch between emphasis on the US President and how much power they actually have is kind of ridiculous.

Candidates often have been very eager to point this out and trying to reflect some of the attention to their Presidential campaign to other avenues (including down-ballot campaigns and maintaining an active grassroot network for their priorities.) But this tends to be ineffectual; people still act like electing a President is all you need to be concerned about, and act surprised when they don't get what they want from doing that alone.

Re:The end of the establishment? by scrumper on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:52AM (#11168151)
> the mismatch between emphasis on the US President and how much power they actually have is kind of ridiculous.

Just to touch on this one point, the situation has its own twisted logic. With this election the concept of the presidency may be entering a new phase where it acts primarily as a lighting rod for disaffection. This effectively helps to strengthen existing power structures in the houses (the parties, ways of working, lobbyists etc.) by focusing popular discontent on a single office.

Re:The end of the establishment? by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:37AM (#11167484)
>One of the biggest arguments for the UK leaving the EU is that the EU has become a vast bureaucracy that is remote, bloated, undemocratic, disconnected from the people etc.

Except the EU isn't that big, about 33,000 staff [1]. I also seem to remember voting in EU elections so it's hard to call it undemocratic.

[1] http://ec.europa.eu/civil_service/docs/hr_key_figures_2016.p...

Re:The end of the establishment? by mike_hearn on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @04:31PM (#11170393)
I was trying to reflect the argument as made, rather than saying I agree with it myself.

That said, 33k is quite a bit larger than I expected, actually, given that the entire UK civil service is about 10x that size but the EU doesn't do benefits management, tax collection, defence, doesn't run a justice system, transport system, etc.

With respect to democracy in Europe, it's a bit complicated. People tend to care a lot more about their national parliaments than the EU parliament. The UK, in particular, gets outvoted in the EU parliament a whole lot, so regardless of what you think of the system in the general sense, for the UK it results in having to do things it doesn't want quite a bit.

Re:The end of the establishment? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:44PM (#11168592)
Do you also remember voting for the EU constitution? Or did that get decided for you?
Re:The end of the establishment? by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @03:09PM (#11169814)
Re:The end of the establishment? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @04:15PM (#11170286)
Ah, my error. I was using the wrong name. Yes, it was democratically rejected... and then replaced by the Treaty of Lisbon, which did most of the same things, and which was done in a way that nobody got to democratically vote on it.
Re:The end of the establishment? by bsaunder on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @08:13AM (#11166426)
I think you make some good points.

When reality diverges from perception (as you and the OP seem to suggest, and I agree), it feels to me there a sort of economic potential energy there that may provide an opportunity for someone to capitalize on. Perhaps we need some scrambling unicorns to pivot and see how they could help improve democracy and level the playing field between the disconnected establishment and the general populace.

As an individual, I frequently sigh at my ability to impact the momentum of things. The world may not be as I'd like it, but I see little I can do about that. I get that small changes by many individuals can have a big impact in the aggregate.

Perhaps what would help would be a social amplifier app that would allow users to plan/schedule and participate in small changes in mass that could send louder social signals to the establishment. Maybe folks would to listen to us more frequently than once every 4 years.

I'm sure there are other opportunities and the devil is in the details. I'm not saying this is easy, but society needs some new tools. The folks here on HN are precisely the right people that should be doing something about this.