News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @08:27AM (#11166500)
> This sort of analysis is helpful and needed.

It's just more noise. It's one reporter's take on current events. There's no attention given to history, or even a reasoned take on the economics involved. It's pure narrative, a bunch of facts strung together with nothing tying them together but opinion.

What we're seeing is another evolution in the media-driven political cycle. Political candidacy has changed immensely in the last few years. Social media turned out to be way more politically useful than anybody ever thought it would. So candidates that use it effectively are going to be able to manipulate the news cycle more.

It doesn't give them an overwhelming advantage over the traditional power base, but they have been caught flat-footed.

That Americans are currently receptive to populist platforms shouldn't be surprising. We're still in the primary phase, and primaries are conducted in rural areas where the most provincial Americans live. The messaging needs to be kept simple.

Once the primaries are over, the nominees are going to move to the center for the real race. Happens in every single presidential election. We're just paying more and more attention to it these day. Nobody used to care about primaries.

Re:The end of the establishment? by minsight on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:06AM (#11166771)
>It's one reporter's take on current events.

Where "one reporter" was once Secretary of Labor.

Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:10AM (#11167263)
Fine, whatever. It's still bad analysis. He makes sweeping conclusions built on little but a smattering of incoherent facts. He's pandering to an audience.
Re:The end of the establishment? by narag on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:20AM (#11167866)
There's something different this time, though. I have paid some attention to the last three or four of your primaries and there has always been a guy in the role that Sanders is playing now.

Sanders still seems to have a chance after a handful of states. That's a change for sure. And the explanation seems plausible. Unless you think Sanders is charismatic leader, worshipped by the masses, it must be a change in the voters part.

Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:41AM (#11168047)
Sure, something's different. It's the nature of politics. The game is changing. This guy makes the argument that America has changed. It hasn't. Still the same ole' 'Murica. What's changed is social media.

Everybody gets excited over their pet independent candidate every single election. But now these indies can get their issues taken seriously by end-running establishment control over the news cycle.

The media creates the perception of who is winning and who is losing. Politicians trick the media into giving them coverage. They can build momentum by building awareness. Voters can only choose who they're aware of, for the reasons the media gives them. American voters are only a fraction of the population, only a quarter of Americans vote.

Three quarters of Americans don't care enough about politics to cast a vote. I'm one of them. This 4 year endeavor to place someone in the most powerful office in the world better resembles a bush-league pro wrestling circuit than anything like Serious Business.

But that's not even the strangest part. The strange part is that this is how it's been running for decades.

Sanders is not worshipped by the masses. He's merely running a flashier campaign than Hillary, so we see him more in the media. Ditto for Trump.

America is the same, it's politics that's changing. I'd prefer Hillary over Trump or Sanders, but any of them would do a decent job. Trump's basically a liberal anyway, if you look at his positions over time, he actually looks fairly reasonable. I'd prefer Hillary because she'd be able to actually get things done with Congress.

Re:The end of the establishment? by dennisgorelik on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @02:51PM (#11169669)
> be able to actually get things done with Congress

What kind of things do you expect Congress to do? Generally it's better when Congress does only absolutely necessary things and does not do anything else.

Re:The end of the establishment? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:39PM (#11168555)
> I'd prefer Hillary because she'd be able to actually get things done with Congress.

No chance. Not with Congress the way it is now, and run by Republicans. Neither will Sanders.

Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:46PM (#11168600)
They said that about Obama, but he still got shit done. The Repubs can't obstruct forever, and the Dems have learned how to deal with those tactics.

The weird thing out our democracy is, it's getting more democratic, even with pathetic turnout, the public exerts more of an influence on the news cycle, and that drives the political agenda.

Re:The end of the establishment? by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @01:18PM (#11168880)
> They said that about Obama, but he still got shit done.

Mostly in the first half-term, with a Democratic Congressional majority -- his signature legislative accomplishments (Affordable Care Act, ARRA) were achieved then.

> The weird thing out our democracy is, it's getting more democratic

No, its not.

> even with pathetic turnout, the public exerts more of an influence on the news cycle, and that drives the political agenda.

There's a number of forces steering things in between there, assuring that the impact that the news cycle has (because of the spin on the events, even if the public exerts more influence on which events get attention -- which is a dubious proposition, I think) reflects a fairly narrow set of biases held by the powerful.

There doesn't seem to be any evidence that the substantive policy output of the political system is becoming better aligned with the strength of views in the public, such that the net effect of any of this would be "more democratic."

Re:The end of the establishment? by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:59PM (#11168733)
> No chance. Not with Congress the way it is now, and run by Republicans. Neither will Sanders.

100% of the House and 1/3 of the Senate is up for election at the same time as the President. There's no particularly strong reason to believe that the next Congress must look like the current Congress.

Re:The end of the establishment? by maxerickson on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @08:38AM (#11166568)
Clay Shirky recently tweeted (yeah, that's right) an interesting analysis of this:

https://storify.com/cshirky/republican-and-democratic-partie...

Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:17AM (#11167839)
Thanks, this is much better. The "quasi-parliamentarianism" bit was fascinating.
Re:The end of the establishment? by cdent on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @08:48AM (#11166649)
I'll think you'll find that Robert B. Reich's expertise extends a bit further than "reporting".
Re:The end of the establishment? by bsbechtel on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @08:58AM (#11166720)
I'd argue he's part of the 'establishment' he's purporting to analyze from the outside, however.
Re:The end of the establishment? by cylinder on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:19AM (#11167329)
What is your point? Who better to tell us how the establishment thinks and perceives than someone inside of it?
Re:The end of the establishment? by mc32 on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @11:40AM (#11168042)
Right but he can only tell us what he thinks from that framework but that framework is failing to understand what is actually happening, so the conclusions are only useful knowing they are incorrect.
Re:The end of the establishment? by bsbechtel on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:38AM (#11167494)
Well if someone from the perceived establishment presents an analysis saying the establishment's thinking is flawed, wouldn't their own analysis be questionable, given they are a part of the group they are claiming has flawed thinking?
Re:The end of the establishment? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:13PM (#11168333)
The form of your argument is: Tesla says 19th century scientists have flawed thinking about alternating current, Tesla is a 19th century scientist, therefore Tesla has flawed thinking about alternating current.
Re:The end of the establishment? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:42PM (#11168575)
More generally, no member of any group can ever say that the group is wrong, because they're a member of the group.

But stated differently, the flaw becomes apparent: "No member of any group can ever say that the group consensus is wrong, because they are a member of the group." But the one criticizing isn't a member of the group who shares the consensus, and the contradiction evaporates.

Re:The end of the establishment? by notahacker on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:19AM (#11166859)
To which you could add that Trump and Cruz are benefiting from a large number of relatively low-profile candidates vying for the role of the "establishment candidate" which will soon be pared down, and the rules of the Democratic contest mean that Sanders either has to persuade a lot of party grandees to nominate him or win the caucus votes by a large margin.

The chances of both of them being on the ballot are pretty slim, and the likelihood of one of them being able to win an election in a head-to-head race with a non-alarming establishment candidate is slimmer still. Radical candidates can shift the political agenda, but the closer they get to actual power, the more likely they are to shift it in the opposite direction to the one they intend.

Re:The end of the establishment? by venomsnake on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:53AM (#11167130)
That is the conventional wisdom. This cycle conventional wisdom has lower than usual predicting power. The way I see Nevada - 52-47 is bad news for Hilary. She not only has to win by delegate count - she should win legitimacy with the Bernie supporters
Re:The end of the establishment? by maxerickson on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:30AM (#11167425)
Yeah, its hard to believe that the super delegates will override a popular victory. It would destroy the party.
Re:The end of the establishment? by burkaman on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:22AM (#11166879)
>We're still in the primary phase, and primaries are conducted in rural areas where the most provincial Americans live. The messaging needs to be kept simple.

Primaries are conducted everywhere, so I don't understand this part. And wouldn't "provincial" people be less likely to vote in the primary than they would be to vote in the general?

Re:The end of the establishment? by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:33AM (#11167448)
Fascinating article about stumping for primaries:

http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jan/10/white-man-pat...

Re:The end of the establishment? by pc2g4d on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @07:53PM (#11171598)
So rural voters are more susceptible to populism than urban voters?