Re:The end of the establishment?
by bsbechtel on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:38AM
(#11167494)
Well if someone from the perceived establishment presents an analysis saying the establishment's thinking is flawed, wouldn't their own analysis be questionable, given they are a part of the group they are claiming has flawed thinking?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The end of the establishment?
by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:13PM
(#11168333)
The form of your argument is: Tesla says 19th century scientists have flawed thinking about alternating current, Tesla is a 19th century scientist, therefore Tesla has flawed thinking about alternating current.
Re:The end of the establishment?
by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @12:42PM
(#11168575)
More generally, no member of any group can ever say that the group is wrong, because they're a member of the group.
But stated differently, the flaw becomes apparent: "No member of any group can ever say that the group consensus is wrong, because they are a member of the group." But the one criticizing isn't a member of the group who shares the consensus, and the contradiction evaporates.