News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by RodericDay on Saturday January 02, 2016 @08:01PM (#10828943)
Zizek phrased it kind of nicely once, in a way that stuck with me. He probably borrowed from somewhere, and I'll continue to lossily reproduce whatever the sentiment was, but it goes something like this.

How is it possible that we are completely and utterly optimistic about breaking all sorts of physical barriers, like landing on Mars, and reusing rockets, and communicating worldwide via little handheld microcomputers, and reattaching body-parts, and aiming to live forever, and do all sorts of crazy biological engineering.

And yet trying to imagine a world were you don't have billionaires having lavish parties while people starve or drone in soul-sucking jobs, or where sweatshops are deemed "bad but better than the alternative", or indeed any sort of radically different social arrangement is seen as hopelessly naive or regressive.

He had better examples, something about a dude with a bifurcated tongue. But the idea stuck with me- what's up with the bounds of our imagination? How come they're limitless when it comes to facing off against gravity, and completely defeatist when it comes to erasing class distinctions?

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by grecy on Saturday January 02, 2016 @08:19PM (#10829000)
>what's up with the bounds of our imagination? How come they're limitless when it comes to facing off against gravity, and completely defeatist when it comes to erasing class distinctions?

In my experience, that's only true in America.

People in Canada, Australia, England and Argentina and perfectly happy to discuss and debate ideas and ways to remove (or drastically reduce) class distinctions. Politicians even enact policy to do it.

I think the propaganda of "The Communists" has been drilled into the American public so solidly, it's not only un-American to suggest a change to the status quo, it's also considered utterly impossible.

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by merpnderp on Saturday January 02, 2016 @11:58PM (#10829564)
The US redistributes enough money to the poor to make them richer than the UK, and likely many other wealthy nations in the world. It's not like the US is some Mad Max universe where the poor are forgotten and left without aid.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by SolaceQuantum on Sunday January 03, 2016 @12:40AM (#10829661)
>The US redistributes enough money to the poor to make them richer than the UK

Source? Also what do you mean richer than the UK?

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by tempestn on Sunday January 03, 2016 @06:04AM (#10830231)
I'm guessing parent means that the poor in the US are richer than the poor in the UK. (Not sure whether that would be in an absolute sense or relative to cost of living, nor have I verified it in either case.)
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by natrius on Saturday January 02, 2016 @08:08PM (#10828965)
Communism happened. It killed lots of people, and made radical changes in the social order unappealing to most. Now ideas don't just have to sound plausible, but you also have to prove that they won't lead to the deaths of millions.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by jqm on Saturday January 02, 2016 @11:08PM (#10829452)
You don't have to prove that ideas won't lead to the deaths of millions at all. Right now there are a bounty of ideas floating around, many the basis of whole civilizations and governments which very possibly could lead to the death of millions if left to finish course. And nary a peep.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by MisterBastahrd on Sunday January 03, 2016 @12:15AM (#10829599)
Communism never happened. Communist propaganda happened.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by clarky07 on Sunday January 03, 2016 @01:17AM (#10829745)
haven't we mostly proven that communism isn't a thing that can work given human nature?
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by vidarh on Sunday January 03, 2016 @09:13AM (#10830650)
What do you believe communism is and how do you believe it goes counter to human nature? It's an impossible thing to discuss without nailing down exactly what it is you are talking about as most people haver wildly diverging ideas of what it implies.

But most people seem to tend to think that communism requires some kind of pure altruism to work (and to be fair, there have been socialist and communists that also believed that), but a central aspect of Marxism is the opposite:

The working class must learn to value its own work and not buy into the subjective moralism of the capitalist classes (that tend to ascribe virtue to wealth: if you're rich, it is generally assumed to be an indicator you have worked hard, while poverty equally is suspect), but be willing to grab the proceeds of their labour. Marx spent a considerable amount of time ripping to shreds early "utopian socialism" (Fourier, Owens et. al) for failing to understand this amongst other failings.

The very insistence of revolution as the mechanism for social upheaval in Marxism is explicitly that Marx did not believe that the ruling classes would be willing to give up privileges willingly even in the face of election defeats, and so once a sufficient working class majority comes into being, sooner or later there would be conflict.

An egalitarian system according to Marx is a desirable, advanced stage of society, but it will come into being, he argues, not because it is the right thing, but because it is the only possible next step: the working classes can only overcome the power of the capitalist classes through sheer numbers, and can unite only because capitalism eventually creates a situation where carving up the pie equally becomes a net improvement for a rapidly growing majority: The rational choice for most of us to maximize our own wealth is an equal distribution the moment the majority of wealth is health by a minority of people, because most of us will otherwise be in the majority that receives less (and for this reason he was insistent that a socialist revolution would fail if attempted somewhere not advanced enough to allow redistribution to eradicate poverty - if it instead merely spread poverty out, class struggles would resume).

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by collyw on Sunday January 03, 2016 @07:28AM (#10830390)
This is a dumb argument when the alternative also involves the exact same human nature.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by paulddraper on Sunday January 03, 2016 @12:23PM (#10831325)
Billions of communists disagree.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by semi-extrinsic on Saturday January 02, 2016 @08:37PM (#10829062)
Have you heard of social democracy, i.e. taking those ideas and not implementing them by being a murderous crazy dictator? It's working out just fine for the countries which are consistently ranked as the best to live in in the world. As opposed to the US, which is closer to third world status when it comes to things like low median wage, little to no maternity leave, expensive and poor healthcare system, school shootings, poor literacy rates, high drug use rates, etc etc.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by natrius on Saturday January 02, 2016 @08:53PM (#10829119)
I like social democracy. (I was just establishing the burden of proof, not taking a position.)

I'm skeptical that America has enough social cohesion for such a thing to be fully implemented here. Literacy and median wages are fine for the white majority, so we've got most of the trappings of a social democracy for white America. Why would Americans use the state to benefit all people when Americans aren't even willing to put agents of the state on trial when they kill unarmed black people?

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by iofj on Sunday January 03, 2016 @01:34AM (#10829773)
First thing that needs to happen to social cohesion in America is stopping focusing everything on race.

Yes, minimum wage affects different races differently. But so does everything else. And one thing I'm pretty sure about : the rich are pushing down minimum wage for reasons that have nothing whatsoever to do with race. Even if the people involved are racists, it still would have little to do with why this is happening. So race is absolutely not relevant to this discussion.

The way this works is that money is being used to make a subgroup of our society desperate enough to do whatever a number of rich folks want them to do, no questions asked. Nobody really cares who's in this subgroup, as long as it's not them and they're sufficiently desperate.

So can we please shut up about whether the amount of melanin in the upper epidermis of some subgroup of the poor is small, medium or large and start talking about the economics at work here ?

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by natrius on Sunday January 03, 2016 @01:52AM (#10829801)
The reason I mentioned race is because so many people around here want to ignore it. To ignore it is to ignore the reality that most Americans do not relate with minority groups. Bad news in a minority group is like bad news from the other side of the planet.

If your solution to a problem requires unity, you probably need to find another solution. America is not united.

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by ZeroGravitas on Sunday January 03, 2016 @02:42PM (#10831976)
You seem to accept that the powerful elite will work to push down wages (broadly including providing healthcare and the modern social democratic benefits) but are ignoring the possibility that the quickest and easiest way for them to achieve this is to divide and conquer the poor by race, and its working beautifully for them.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by maxerickson on Saturday January 02, 2016 @08:48PM (#10829099)
US median wages aren't low compared to Western Europe. Modestly lower than the Nordic countries yes, but modestly higher than France and Germany and so forth.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by collyw on Sunday January 03, 2016 @07:30AM (#10830392)
What is the US median wage? All I ever see are SF developer salaries on here, which are way higher than most parts of Europe.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by maxerickson on Sunday January 03, 2016 @07:42AM (#10830408)
There's a choose your statistic problem, but it is ~$28,000 or $29,000 (that's based on the estimated median individual wage among employed persons (which I think wage implies employment)).

https://www.ssa.gov/cgi-bin/netcomp.cgi?year=2014

I guess income inequality measures result in less favorable comparisons than basic measures of wages.

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by merpnderp on Sunday January 03, 2016 @12:12AM (#10829594)
After government transfers, the bottom income quintile in the US makes more than in the UK and many other wealthy nations. Looking at heart disease and cancer, the US does better, with a less healthy more diverse population than just about every other country (the top ten hospitals with the best cancer survival rates are overwhelmingly in the US), maternity leave may not be mandated, but is available to many if not most. 98% of the US has completed at least 5th grade. And how is the US so different from a social democracy? Massive transfers of wealth to the poor, strong regulations, large government influence in industry, and of course democracy, with strong protections against a "murderous crazy dictator".
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by DanBC on Sunday January 03, 2016 @07:44AM (#10830412)
The US does well on cancer, but that's because cancer is mostly a disease of old age and the US spends a lot of public money via medicaid on older people.

> 98% of the US has completed at least 5th grade.

There's a lot of illiteracy in the US.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literacy_in_the_United_States

> The study, the most comprehensive study of literacy ever commissioned by the U.S. government, was released in April 2002 and reapplied in 2003 giving trend data. It involved lengthy interviews of over 90,700 adults statistically balanced[clarification needed] for age, gender, ethnicity, education level, and location (urban, suburban, or rural) in 12 states across the U.S. and was designed to represent the U.S. population as a whole. This government study showed that 21% to 23% of adult Americans were not "able to locate information in text", could not "make low-level inferences using printed materials", and were unable to "integrate easily identifiable pieces of information." Further, this study showed that 41% to 44% of U.S. adults in the lowest level on the literacy scale (literacy rate of 35 or below) were living in poverty.[2]

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by collyw on Sunday January 03, 2016 @07:35AM (#10830399)
"Looking at heart disease and cancer, the US does better.."

No it doesn't

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_OECD_countries_by_heal...

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by applecore on Saturday January 02, 2016 @10:16PM (#10829336)
Here's the explanation for this phenomenon: the former is an example of man versus nature, whereas the latter is man versus man. We're rational animals, so we can try to use our intellect to overcome the insurmountable physical odds of living in an otherwise uncaring universe. However, when we're pitted against each other, we have no such luck.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by yummyfajitas on Saturday January 02, 2016 @11:01PM (#10829437)
The standard left wing complaint is that billionaires don't have enough lavish parties, but instead reinvest their wealth in new productive capacity. See, e.g., Picketty, Krugman, or anyone favoring stimulus directed at the bottom of the income distribution. Do you dispute this?

As for erasing class distinctions, consider the possibility that we already have. Imagine telling a person in 1915 about the world today; the children of rich struggling hard in school with the goal of getting a job where they can work hard in order to provide consumption for the poor (who mostly don't work). These rich people will wear the same hoodies and turtlenecks as anyone else, live in moderately larger houses than the poor (or at least in moderately nicer locations), and have virtually no goods and services that are unavailable to the poor.

Would this modern world not count as wildly imaginative?

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by sytelus on Sunday January 03, 2016 @04:51AM (#10830083)
You are missing a big point. Sure super rich can only utilize fraction of their wealth however rest of the wealth rarely gets utilized to increase productivity of the society. The majority of investments in their portfolios (as per Piketty's carefully collected data) are actually in non-productive activities such as real estate, hedge funds, HFT, derivatives, commodity manipulation and so on. These investments manipulates markets such as real estate to perpetually increase value of their investments without positive impact on society. In fact, from analysis of Piketty's data it was found that if wealthy people only invested in "productive" instruments then their wealth accumulation would dramatically deaccelerate. So the argument that wealthy provides most of their capital for economy to bloom is fairly misleading. They do provide this capital for some GDP growth but it's fairly small part of their investment portfolio. The major portion of the portfolio has singular goal of generating massive passive income perpetually for generations by activities such as artificially limiting supply side or ballooning demand side in markets such as real estate. There are no known social advantage of these kind of investments. Next time when you send that $3000 mortgage payment, put a note there: "wealth transfer for 1%" :). See other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/edit?id=10829915
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 03, 2016 @02:57PM (#10832045)
How are real estate, hedge funds or derivatives non-productive? A hedge fund or derivative investment ultimately directs productive assets towards real world uses. If the wealthy are getting high returns from this (and Picketty claim the wealthy get the highest returns), then the wealthy are better at directing real investments to their most productive use.

Could you point me to the place in Picketty where he does more than speculate about how the wealthy gain more wealth?

These investments manipulates markets such as real estate to perpetually increase value of their investments without positive impact on society.

You seem to be confusing middle class NIMBYs (the main people manipulating real estate markets) with the very rich. Middle class homeowners are the ones preventing new construction, it's the wealthy developers who are trying (and failing) to be productive.

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by sytelus on Sunday January 03, 2016 @05:18PM (#10832802)
Money invested in real estate doesn't get used to manufacture goods and services or start industry or research or education or anything good for humanity. It's "sleeping money" as far as economy is concerned. In fact, it's worse because as more and more real estate gets owned by super rich and their investment arms, it puts more pressure on middle class by having to cut higher and higher portion of their income on mortgages and lowering their lifestyle standards, savings and risk taking abilities. As per some reports, as much as 30 to 70% of super rich portfolio gets directly in to real estate investments. As they buy up premium estates in major cities around the world, supply gets constrained, more people gets priced out of home ownership and must agree to pay ever increasing rents to those investors. It should be bewildering to anyone that this situation exists even though population hasn't been increasing much in western countries. This is known as "economic rent" (look up the term in Wikipedia) where investor strives to create a setup that passively generates income ad infinity without contributing to society. It's essentially creating generational entitlement system whereby suddenly usual economics like "you get what you worked for" no longer applies. The real estate has been primary tool for centuries to add phenomenal gains in to most of the super rich wealth and Piketty's data shows that it is the primary reason why wealthy are acquiring more wealth at rate much higher than overall GDP increase. It's hard for most people to see this because many times they are home owners benefiting from this while in reality they are not and also because they don't realize that real estate is basic human necessity just like air and water. No one wants Chinese billionaires or entities like Blackrock to buy up all of the water supply, inflate its price and then ration it to people with bidding wars. So the assertion that as super rich gets more richer, they benefit society by starting industries is pretty misguided. So far the data shows that this kind of productive investment has much lower returns than non-productive investments because of higher risk factors. So if rich were doing only doing productive investments, they would not be able to acquire more wealth at current pace.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 03, 2016 @08:29PM (#10833532)
You seem to believe the rich have the ability to somehow buy up all the supply of some good (land, water) and then arbitrarily raise the price.

As they buy up premium estates in major cities around the world, supply gets constrained, more people gets priced out of home ownership and must agree to pay ever increasing rents to those investors.

You are deeply confused. Buying up housing does not reduce the supply of living space; similarly, a rich person investing in a copper mine does not reduce the supply of copper. If the rich person makes improvements (e.g., buying land and building flats on it, buying a copper mine and expanding it) then they increase the supply.

Again, where in Piketty's book do you believe he shows that the rich buy up and artificially limit the supply of a scarce resource? Please cite a page #.

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by sytelus on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:06AM (#10834115)
When there are 100 houses and 100 buyers in market, demand and supply is met and likelihood that transactions will yield fair prices is high. When investors from China and Wall Street descend on markets, you suddenly have 200 buyers and only 100 houses in market. If you live in a major city in western world, go meet the real estate agent nearest to you. Ask them how many bidding wars happen and how many deals are all cash. Most all-cash deals are almost always investor purchase. This is the reason (along with local laws on new construction) why we have housing inflated by massive 10% a year even though population gain is all but negligible. The result is that typical family now pays huge chunk of their income in highly inflated mortgage payment which is nothing but wealth transfer from them to super rich who hogged up critical resource in the hope to increase their investment return.

As per Piketty's book, read this paper which has analysis on where major capital gains for rich come from: http://www.mit.edu/~mrognlie/piketty_diminishing_returns.pdf.

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by yummyfajitas on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:01PM (#10841077)
You are conflating supply of housing with real estate speculation. You might as well complain that GOOG is up $750 and AMZN is $630; this is completely true, but it doesn't make searching the internet or buying stuff online cost more.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by crzwdjk on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @03:01AM (#10841958)
He may be doing that, but he is not alone: the government has spent the past 8 or so decades trying to conflate the two in everyone's mind, and at this point, the only way to keep that up is to make housing into a de-facto collectible by strictly limiting its supply. This means that all those terribly high housing costs in SF are mostly economic rent, which is not productive and also tends to increase inequality. But that's not a problem caused by billionaire business owners, for the most part. It's caused by upper middle class worries about their speculative investment and the schools their children would go to, and the resulting regulatory capture.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by danieltillett on Saturday January 02, 2016 @11:30PM (#10829502)
I think you are describing the upper middle income rich. The ultra rich are nothing like us in the main.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by merpnderp on Saturday January 02, 2016 @11:56PM (#10829561)
They use the same iPhone, have access to the same chemo, and watch the same movies. The only difference is they fly in private planes instead of commercial, drive high end Mercedes instead of Fords, live in mansions instead of apartments. But their HVAC cools just the same as my window unit, it's just quieter. Yeah, they have lots of things we don't. But the difference is smaller than between a rich person in 1915 and a poor person today.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by danieltillett on Sunday January 03, 2016 @01:34AM (#10829772)
I think the life of the ultra rich is fundamentally different to the average middle income person in the same way that royalty lives a different life to a commoner. Sure we all breath, eat, sleep and procreate, but the differences in the concerns of the ultra rich and the rest of us is quite large.

A poor person today is richer in many ways to the rich of 1915 thanks to technological advance, but there still is a huge gap between the opportunities of the poor today and those of the ultra rich.

More fundamentally I just don’t think it is good for the ultra rich to live a life that is so different to the rest of society. These people have an enormous amount of power and it is not good for the rest of us if they live a life detached from the worries and concerns of us common folk. You just can’t make good decisions on the basis of bad information and if this is formed from the worries and concerns of your ultra rich friends and you then you are going to end up with a warped perspective of what life for most people.

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by Domenic_S on Sunday January 03, 2016 @02:55AM (#10829895)
> More fundamentally I just don’t think it is good for the ultra rich to live a life that is so different to the rest of society.

Why not? So Jay Leno has a 10,000 sqft garage and 500 cars, what do I care? Tom Cruise doesn't affect my daily life. Politicians do, and most of them are rich but not ultra rich.

People will always have a warped perspective of others, that's just how the human brain works. In fact we discuss that on HN frequently, how Silicon Valley can seem so clueless solving "white first-world problems".

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by danieltillett on Sunday January 03, 2016 @03:41AM (#10829955)
The reason why I mention in the next sentence - the ultra rich have a lot of power. I want the powerful to understand how us commoners live.

The ultra rich have a very large influence over politicians. This is why they are important. If they just spent their time flying around in private jets and talking to each other then it wouldn't matter - once they start to have a very large influence over public policy it matters what they think.

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 03, 2016 @02:25AM (#10829836)
In what way is it different? You keep asserting this without making any concrete claims.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by danieltillett on Sunday January 03, 2016 @03:47AM (#10829964)
As a non-member of the ultra rich all I can do is look in on the peeks they give us via the media. I am willing to admit that it is possible that they are exactly like you and me, but they certainly don't appear to be.

In regards concrete claims the ultra rich appear to far more to the economic right than the average person. I am sure you are aware of this.

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 03, 2016 @09:28PM (#10833713)
Lots of groups are far to the economic right of the average person. For example, this is probably true of people who subscribe to Scott Sumner's blog.

Is it therefore reasonable to say "I think the lives of people who read Scott Sumner's blog are fundamentally different to the average middle income person in the same way that royalty lives a different life to a commoner"? If not, why not?

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by danieltillett on Sunday January 03, 2016 @11:49PM (#10834058)
I know you are a smart guy yummyfaijitas so I think I don’t need to point out the fallacy in this argument.

The ultra rich live a life that is very different to the rest of us. This is an interesting article on their views [1].

1. http://articles.latimes.com/2013/mar/22/opinion/la-oe-page-w...

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by tempestn on Sunday January 03, 2016 @06:10AM (#10830241)
> In regards concrete claims the ultra rich appear to far more to the economic right than the average person.

Are you sure that's true? It may be, but there are certainly plenty of counter-examples. Gates and Buffett immediately come to mind, as well as presumably many of the people on this page: http://givingpledge.org/

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by danieltillett on Sunday January 03, 2016 @06:37PM (#10833142)
I am not to sure how to the left Gates and Buffett actually are, but they are really good examples of ultra rich with the perspective of the upper middle classes. Unlike the hereditary ultra rich, they are self-made men who grew up in upper middle class families. The fact that they want to give away their wealth rather than pass it on to their children is a sign they recognise the morally corrosive nature of inherited wealth.

If I were asked I would be keen to lower taxes on incomes and raise taxes on inheritances. We really don’t need a self-perpetuating parasitic overclass.

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by Apocryphon on Saturday January 02, 2016 @11:32PM (#10829511)
It's not enough, just as going to the Moon was not enough.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by chongli on Sunday January 03, 2016 @12:33AM (#10829647)
How come they're limitless when it comes to facing off against gravity, and completely defeatist when it comes to erasing class distinctions?

The key distinction in this problem is between overcoming fixed barriers of nature and overcoming the dynamic, highly adaptable nature of human beings. Personally, I don't believe we're ever going to come up with a fixed set of laws that could constrain the infinite range of human behaviour to the realm of fairness and make cheating impossible. At least not without eliminating all freedom for everyone.

Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by brbsix on Saturday January 02, 2016 @08:58PM (#10829128)
I was under the impression that Keynesian economics is/was said limitless facing off against gravity. However as was already mentioned, when these sort of experiments go wrong (e.g. Communism), they tend to go terribly wrong. It would be nice if we could actually perform these experiments on a local, entirely voluntary scale however the Fed seems to have captured that market already.
Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom by paulddraper on Saturday January 02, 2016 @08:09PM (#10828970)
We're talking about getting a couple volunteers to Mars one time, not forcing billions of people there permanently.