Could you point me to the place in Picketty where he does more than speculate about how the wealthy gain more wealth?
These investments manipulates markets such as real estate to perpetually increase value of their investments without positive impact on society.
You seem to be confusing middle class NIMBYs (the main people manipulating real estate markets) with the very rich. Middle class homeowners are the ones preventing new construction, it's the wealthy developers who are trying (and failing) to be productive.
As they buy up premium estates in major cities around the world, supply gets constrained, more people gets priced out of home ownership and must agree to pay ever increasing rents to those investors.
You are deeply confused. Buying up housing does not reduce the supply of living space; similarly, a rich person investing in a copper mine does not reduce the supply of copper. If the rich person makes improvements (e.g., buying land and building flats on it, buying a copper mine and expanding it) then they increase the supply.
Again, where in Piketty's book do you believe he shows that the rich buy up and artificially limit the supply of a scarce resource? Please cite a page #.
As per Piketty's book, read this paper which has analysis on where major capital gains for rich come from: http://www.mit.edu/~mrognlie/piketty_diminishing_returns.pdf.
A poor person today is richer in many ways to the rich of 1915 thanks to technological advance, but there still is a huge gap between the opportunities of the poor today and those of the ultra rich.
More fundamentally I just don’t think it is good for the ultra rich to live a life that is so different to the rest of society. These people have an enormous amount of power and it is not good for the rest of us if they live a life detached from the worries and concerns of us common folk. You just can’t make good decisions on the basis of bad information and if this is formed from the worries and concerns of your ultra rich friends and you then you are going to end up with a warped perspective of what life for most people.
Why not? So Jay Leno has a 10,000 sqft garage and 500 cars, what do I care? Tom Cruise doesn't affect my daily life. Politicians do, and most of them are rich but not ultra rich.
People will always have a warped perspective of others, that's just how the human brain works. In fact we discuss that on HN frequently, how Silicon Valley can seem so clueless solving "white first-world problems".
The ultra rich have a very large influence over politicians. This is why they are important. If they just spent their time flying around in private jets and talking to each other then it wouldn't matter - once they start to have a very large influence over public policy it matters what they think.
In regards concrete claims the ultra rich appear to far more to the economic right than the average person. I am sure you are aware of this.
Is it therefore reasonable to say "I think the lives of people who read Scott Sumner's blog are fundamentally different to the average middle income person in the same way that royalty lives a different life to a commoner"? If not, why not?
The ultra rich live a life that is very different to the rest of us. This is an interesting article on their views [1].
1. http://articles.latimes.com/2013/mar/22/opinion/la-oe-page-w...
Are you sure that's true? It may be, but there are certainly plenty of counter-examples. Gates and Buffett immediately come to mind, as well as presumably many of the people on this page: http://givingpledge.org/
If I were asked I would be keen to lower taxes on incomes and raise taxes on inheritances. We really don’t need a self-perpetuating parasitic overclass.
As for erasing class distinctions, consider the possibility that we already have. Imagine telling a person in 1915 about the world today; the children of rich struggling hard in school with the goal of getting a job where they can work hard in order to provide consumption for the poor (who mostly don't work). These rich people will wear the same hoodies and turtlenecks as anyone else, live in moderately larger houses than the poor (or at least in moderately nicer locations), and have virtually no goods and services that are unavailable to the poor.
Would this modern world not count as wildly imaginative?