News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by wpietri on Friday December 25, 2015 @06:48PM (#10792733)
Could you say more about how you think that would have happened? I was a NeXT developer at the time, and I'm having trouble imagining it.

At the time, NextStep was a struggling niche OS. Jobs didn't get any real power until he returned to the helm of Apple in '97, and NextStep technology didn't hit the mainstream until 2001 with the release of the consumer version of OS X.

In contrast, Netscape's first product was released in late '94, and it was popular enough that they IPO'd in 1995.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by twoodfin on Friday December 25, 2015 @06:59PM (#10792762)
I can imagine an alternate universe where Jobs has a "Xerox" moment and immediately pivots NeXT's software efforts to developing a cross-platform graphical browser.

The "cross-platform" part is the most optimistic, to be sure. But if Jobs believed that NeXT's real value was the software (as OS X, and especially iOS, bear out), then you can imagine a strategy that used a web browser as a Trojan Horse for a platform that could overthrow the currently dominant Windows monopoly. That was basically Netscape's strategy a few years later, after all.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by dboreham on Friday December 25, 2015 @08:45PM (#10792947)
Regular people couldn't afford Next computers. They used PC clones (running mostly 16-bit Windows at the time, which is why Netscape was successful -- their browser ran on 16-bit Windows).
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by coldtea on Saturday December 26, 2015 @08:47AM (#10794107)
Which is why the parent mentions "cross platform" repeatedly.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by wpietri on Friday December 25, 2015 @09:11PM (#10793006)
Interesting.

The problem with the NextStep stuff at the time was that it required high-end hardware. Even years later when they started to make cross-platform development tools, they were limited to niche markets where you new your users would pay up for plenty of RAM. That was fine for, e.g., financial trading.

So I think they would have had to start basically from scratch, sullying their hands by writing for the sad world of 16-bit Windows 3.1. If they had done it, though, it could have been incredible.

On the other hand, they could well have been killed by the same issue that killed Netscape: the web, being definitionally open, doesn't provide a lot of defensible advantage to early movers.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by twoodfin on Friday December 25, 2015 @09:35PM (#10793067)
All true. I think this is good evidence we live in the best of all possible worlds: A Jobs/NeXT WWW browser a couple of years ahead of Netscape probably would have fared even worse against Microsoft's inevitable counterattack. For all we know, we could have ended up in a "Blackbird" (aka MSN) dominated universe, and without a revitalized Apple to give us Unix on the desktop.

Still, I do find it totally plausible that Jobs could have been inspired to redirect NeXT's struggling business to the nascent web. Some of those old WebObjects interviews that get posted to HN periodically demonstrate the he "got" the web and its potential as an application delivery platform much earlier than most.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by ams6110 on Friday December 25, 2015 @07:43PM (#10792835)
NEXTSTEP was cross platform, so not really such a far fetched idea.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by stickfigure on Friday December 25, 2015 @08:51PM (#10792957)
NeXTSTEP only became "cross platform" (meaning: ran on x86 hardware) as a desperate alternative to their failing proprietary hardware business. Seeng as how at that point the OS itself was NeXT's business, it's hard to imagine Jobs supporting software that ran on competing OSes.

Even today the only real cross-platform product Apple makes is iTunes, and that only exists so they can sell iPods (and now iPhones) to windows users. Facetime, ApplePay, iBooks... all would be better as cross platform apps, but Apple isn't interested because it doesn't help them sell more macs/iphones.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by joezydeco on Friday December 25, 2015 @11:14PM (#10793228)
And that decision almost never happened:

While it seems a given that the iPod was to be made compatible with Windows, Jobs was very resistant to the idea. At one point he said that Windows users would get to use the iPod "over my dead body". After continued convincing, Jobs gave up:

"Screw it," he said at one meeting where they showed him the analysis. "I'm sick of listening to you assholes. Go do whatever the hell you want."

http://www.macrumors.com/2011/10/25/steve-jobs-biography-wha...

Think about what iPod sales would have been if iTunes never made it to the PC platform. Would there have been enough profit to fund the development of the iPhone? Would we be where we are today?

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by digi_owl on Saturday December 26, 2015 @12:51PM (#10794656)
Well Android may still have happened (but perhaps looked more like Blackberry in its initial form). And Nokia may be around selling Maemo based phoned, though i wonder if what sunk them was Samsung (and later Chinese companies) undermining their feature phone sales in Africa etc.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by wpietri on Friday December 25, 2015 @09:17PM (#10793022)
> it's hard to imagine Jobs supporting software that ran on competing OSes.

Perhaps hard to imagine, but they actually did it. OPENSTEP Enterprise allowed you to use the NeXT development tools to build apps for 32-bit Windows platforms. That came toward the end of the NeXT saga, so you could argue it was a move of last resort. But it clearly wasn't out of the question.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by ksherlock on Saturday December 26, 2015 @12:05PM (#10794534)
until 10.5 or 10.6, OS X still included the classic NextStep and Windows GUI images. http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/09/02/mac_images/
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by pupeno on Saturday December 26, 2015 @05:21AM (#10793810)
But maybe, NextSTEP would have been more relevant if it was an OS that allowed you to use the web. But then, the web back then wasn't that great and I think the tipping point was ISPs offering commercial internet access in 94 or 95.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by joshu on Saturday December 26, 2015 @09:59PM (#10796208)
er, the web was invented there...
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by mentos on Saturday December 26, 2015 @03:59AM (#10793702)
I wonder if we'll ever see the day Apple makes a windows machine
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by coldtea on Saturday December 26, 2015 @08:48AM (#10794109)
If we do, it wouldn't be Apple but in name, just like with SGI's NT machines.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by rbanffy on Saturday December 26, 2015 @02:51PM (#10795033)
Those were the most depressing SGI machines I ever saw. The ugliest too.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by joshu on Friday December 25, 2015 @10:39PM (#10793167)
this is not correct. please be more careful not to assert opinions as facts.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by Esau on Friday December 25, 2015 @09:00PM (#10792982)
But Nextstep was a very expensive OS. I looked into it and they wanted somewhere in the neighborhood of $900.00 for a copy. I eventually bought a used NextStation from Sam Goldberger's Spherical Solutions.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by wpietri on Friday December 25, 2015 @09:18PM (#10793025)
Sure, but that's only because they were selling it into niche markets willing to pay a lot for its advantages. If they had been targeting deployment to consumer platforms, they would have priced it appropriately.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by tbrock on Friday December 25, 2015 @09:34PM (#10793065)
I know it almost happened because Tim Berners Lee said it did: https://www.w3.org/blog/2011/10/steve-jobs/

"We almost met once.

There was a get-together of NeXT developers in France, and we set up demos at tables around the room.

Robert Cailliau and I set up the WorldWideWeb.app on one table.

Steve arrived, and started making his way around the tables chatting with each project

He didn’t get to us before he had to leave."

Isn't that incredible?! Even if you aren't a fan of Steve Jobs you have to admit he would have instantly understood the power of what Berners Lee was showing him.

I think about that story a lot. Gives me goosebumps.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by wpietri on Saturday December 26, 2015 @01:11AM (#10793461)
Sorry, I'm not questioning that they almost met. I'm just not seeing what difference it would have made to the Web.

NeXT, for all its technical merit, was a repeated commercial failure. It failed as hardware, it failed as an OS for other people's hardware, and then it failed as developer tools of other people's OSes. The Jobs of 2007, at the helm of a successful company, perhaps could take an obscure technolog7 and get it widely adopted. The Jobs of 1992 had no leverage. The NeXT was full of amazing tech but he couldn't get anybody but a few koolaid-drinkers, myself included, to use it.

So if he'd adopted the WWW into the NeXT OS a year or two earlier than everybody else, I think it would have been another cool technology on the NeXT platform that everybody ignored. Mosaic and Navigator made a difference not really for what they were, but because they were available to a large audience of Windows users.

If anything, I think the later history of Apple suggests that Jobs's talent wasn't in cutting-edge technology, but in taking established technology, making it user friendly, and marketing the hell out of it. The iPod wasn't the first music player and the iPhone wasn't the first smartphone. They were just the first ones built for and marketed to the broad consumer market. There was never really a consumer market for browsers, which is part of what killed Netscape.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by coldtea on Saturday December 26, 2015 @08:57AM (#10794122)
>NeXT, for all its technical merit, was a repeated commercial failure. It failed as hardware, it failed as an OS for other people's hardware, and then it failed as developer tools of other people's OSes.

Well, we seem to forget that OS X 10.0 is basically NeXT with a new skin. So it might have failed as an "OS for other people's hardware" meaning PCs, but it did phenomenally well with Apple's hardware.

And even the "failed" NeXT company got sold for a cool half billion, an order of magnitude better than e.g. BeOS ($11 million).

And NeXT's itself market performance was OK enough to allow it to live and reach several versions all these years up to 1997 until it was bought.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by wpietri on Saturday December 26, 2015 @03:48PM (#10795239)
They failed to live up to any of their hype or any of their market goals. It didn't revolutionize education. It didn't sell much hardware, despite multiple hardware versions. It didn't gain significant market share as an OS. It didn't gain significant market share in Windows developer tools. When Apple bought them, the NeXT market was negligible enough that they basically stopped making anything for it.

They definitely had some success in niche markets, I think they turned a modest profit one year, and I don't think their investors lost any money. But it's not like they made a ton for the level of risk they took.

Yes, Jobs managed to make lemonade out of his multiple failures. But NeXT was never a commercial success.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by hoodoof on Saturday December 26, 2015 @02:17AM (#10793549)
Watch Cringley's interview of Jobs in which Jobs specifies precisely how much of the Xerox Parc technology that he saw but didn't grasp the importance of including networking and object oriented programming.

Steve Jobs was for a long time seen as someone with brilliance who tripped up on his own misguided and dogmatic world view, not the current picture of him as the ultimate visionary who sees and knows all.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by dfc on Friday December 25, 2015 @11:57PM (#10793325)

  > Even if  you aren't a fan  of Steve Jobs you  have to
  > admit he would have instantly understood the power of
  > what Berners Lee was showing him.
I see no reason to think Steve Jobs was omniscient. Do you really think he could instantly an accurately assess the future importance of a technology?
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by tbrock on Saturday December 26, 2015 @12:11AM (#10793351)
Seems to have worked out for him all the countless other times. For examples see Apple Computer, Pixar, NeXt...

Berners Lee himself writes about the possibility decades later. Decades later! The inventor of the web browser! Remembering and writing about something that almost happened... but didn't. He's clearly given some thought to the matter.

It's not like you remembering the time a co-worker ate vanilla ice cream at lunch time last week. This is Tim Berners Lee reminiscing about an opportunity to show Steve Jobs his wares.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by maaku on Saturday December 26, 2015 @12:50AM (#10793423)
That's a bit of selective remembering.

Jobs wanted Pixar to be a hardware company. Not a terrible idea as NVidia has shown us, but definitely the wrong time, and he did not foresee the brand that Pixar Animation Studios would become.

NeXT was a 2nd attempt at the overpriced workstation that was Lisa. Both were market failures.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by coldtea on Saturday December 26, 2015 @08:51AM (#10794112)
The kind of market failure that got sold for half a billion.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by wpietri on Saturday December 26, 2015 @03:32PM (#10795182)
It wasn't really NeXT that they purchased; it was Jobs.

Sure, they got an OS, and they got some good people. But it was basically an acquihire. NeXT had approximately no commercial success. If Apple had only wanted a next-generation OS to compensate for their failure to develop one internally, they could have bought Be, and for a much lower price. There were no other suitors to acquire NeXT; without Apple's acquisition, they surely would have died out within a couple of years, just like Be did.

And I'll note that the OS wasn't that great a deal for Apple; it took them more than 4 years to get a consumer-grade release of it together, far longer than they were predicting at the time. I'd again put that down to the power of Jobs's reality distortion field, not any kind of market success.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by coldtea on Saturday December 26, 2015 @05:45PM (#10795552)
>It wasn't really NeXT that they purchased; it was Jobs.

Easy to say in retrospect. But at the time Jobs was the guy who was once ousted from Apple and hadn't done that great of a commercial job with NeXT (besides the technology they created). So there wasn't much ground at the time for Jobs to be considered as some kind of "miracle man" that will save Apple.

So, while we now can say "they purchased Jobs", I think it was mostly the allure of a turn-key next-generation OS that the needed sorely at that point that made them go into it and for half a billion.

Let's not forget that Apple had just killed Copland, and was simultaneously discussing to buy BeOS.

>And I'll note that the OS wasn't that great a deal for Apple; it took them more than 4 years to get a consumer-grade release of it together, far longer than they were predicting at the time.

Again that's in retrospect. At the moment they didn't think "we're really buying Jobs, who'll do miracles and make the company #1 in the world". They thought: "We need an OS, and this NeXT thing looks like it can be turned into the next OS version soon".

>I'd again put that down to the power of Jobs's reality distortion field, not any kind of market success.

But they weren't looking for market success. After all they didn't want to buy an existing userbase but an OS to turn into "OS 9 successor" to give their (Apple's) users and attract new ones.

So, what they wanted was a good platform for what they do. And given Apple's enterprise, dtp and graphics focus in the 90s, NeXT was pretty damn close.

Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by Zelphyr on Saturday December 26, 2015 @12:25AM (#10793375)
I don't think he was omniscient but there is an interview he did in Wired I believe, around '95, where he laid out the next fifteen years in technology and pretty much nailed it. He wasn't a god. That much is obvious. But he was really smart and the term "visionary" is reasonably earned.
Re:How I found one of the earliest browsers on a NeXTcube by azinman2 on Friday December 25, 2015 @10:28PM (#10793157)
Maybe.

If this was a read-write version, then it's easy to mentally box it into a network-backed word processor (since that's what it would have been most similar to).

The power of the web took quite a few leaps in terms of a distributed effort making it into something new each time. When cast in the original scientific philosophy, it's not clear that this would seem any more important than the prodigies, compuserves, and aols that already existed.