Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by mavhc on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @09:05AM
(#10546685)
Amused that the first sentence is "Terminology is an occupational hazard of philanthropy", I think he meant "hard words are often used by people who give money away"
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by lhl on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:29AM
(#10547439)
As others have mentioned, that's actually not what it means. Here's a version that's closer to the gist of it:
"When you are trying to give away money, the people asking for it can often use special or hard words and ideas that you may not know or that may be confusing."
Sadly "rare," "uncommon," "unclear," and a whole bunch of other words don't make the simplewriter cut (too bad the XKCD tool doesn't automatically try to pull up closet matches from a thesaurus filtered against the word-list).
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by sp332 on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @09:38AM
(#10546847)
An occupational hazard is a danger that engaging in a profession opens you up to. Like injuries in football, or getting sued for malpractice as a doctor.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by mc32 on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:21AM
(#10547391)
I think it means people for varying reasons see it appropriate to use industry specific terminology when discussing things with non insiders, either out of custom (no code switching) or as a way to project "professionalism" when it's not necessary for communication to occur.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @01:08PM
(#10548100)
> Amused that the first sentence is "Terminology is an occupational hazard of philanthropy", I think he meant "hard words are often used by people who give money away"
Or you could have read literally the next three sentences and learned what he actually meant.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by mc32 on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:19AM
(#10547385)
Gates is spot on and Munro extraordinary. Too often managers feel obliged to use technical language where none is either needed nor natural.
People talking about budgets and fiscal planning making use of hi-tech specific, bio-tech, etc. Anything which passively indicates that they are up to date on cant and argot of totally unrelated fields but serve as signal of being at the edge or on the cusp of all things new and modern and professional.
Examples, using MM for millions, or K for thousands (is that metric K or computing K), or saying "spend" as a noun. Having to sound like one knows and is up to date with all the different industry terminologies must be taxing.
Best of all is when a person is actually familiar with the terminology and senses the forced nature of the out of context use. They can only smile at the stilted use.
" I am going to translate a passage of good English into modern English of the worst sort. Here is a well-known verse from Ecclesiastes:
I returned and saw under the sun, that the race is not to the swift, nor the battle to the strong, neither yet bread to the wise, nor yet riches to men of understanding, nor yet favour to men of skill; but time and chance happeneth to them all.
Here it is in modern English:
Objective considerations of contemporary phenomena compel the conclusion that success or failure in competitive activities exhibits no tendency to be commensurate with innate capacity, but that a considerable element of the unpredictable must invariably be taken into account.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by _kst_ on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @04:06PM
(#10549277)
Can you format the quotations as quotations (leading "> ", I think) rather than indenting them? As it is, you have to scroll right to read the entire quotation.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by kbenson on Thursday November 12, 2015 @12:32PM
(#10554607)
Choosing flowery, poetic prose to translate into into modern techno-babble doesn't sway me to the point of view that the former was better than modern English. Neither is a good example of clear, concise communication IMHO. The former's reason for being lengthy is at least understandable. It serves the purpose of both slowing the reader, and supplying them with examples and metaphors to ponder over. The latter's reason for being obtuse is much less understandable, since it actually hampers communication for the sake of style (that is, the style provides little to no extra informational benefit).
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by semi-extrinsic on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @02:31PM
(#10548669)
Nature Climate Change recently published [1] a comparison of the language in the IPCC climate change executive summary versus the seminal scientific papers by Einstein and Hawking. Einstein and Hawking's writings are significantly easier to read. (Easy to read doesn't imply easy to understand, but it doesn't hurt either.)
[1] http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/nc...
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by gramasaurous on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @02:29PM
(#10548656)
Reminds me of this[0] talk by Guy Steele where he explicitly defines any word outside of a given set before he can use that term in his speech. Interesting language exercise, definitely worth a watch!
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by maweki on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @09:10AM
(#10546707)
Yeah, the book is real fun. Amazon seems to have sent it early and I am not complaining.
It's a lot of text in comparison to the original poster-comic and a lot of stuff seems very repetitive (it's bound to be, right?) since many principles of planes, submarines, rockets are the same (physics). Still a fun read if you don't plow through it in one sitting.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by coldpie on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:10AM
(#10546988)
I'm curious to see how the book is received. I excitedly bought and enjoyed the What-If collection, but I'm not sure a book of diagrams with simple language is all that interesting. Thanks for posting what you thought of it.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:57AM
(#10547252)
Most of the trouble building a world after Apocalypse, is all those working hard against you - the raiders and thieves and generally chaotic elements. Otherwise, it'd be no harder than setting up a new town somewhere.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by gadders on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:13AM
(#10547350)
In the book he does distinguish between two types of apocalypse - the first is where lots of people die, such as in a global plague or nuclear war. The second type is where the number of people is the same, but infrastructure is wiped out such as a massive solar flare.
In the latter you'll have massive famine and also likely fighting against other survivors.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @02:26PM
(#10590085)
Note that "massive famine and likely fighting against other survivors" will turn an apocalypse of the second sort into an apocalypse of the first sort.
I also think apocalypses that start out as the first sort are also likely to produce famines and fighting against other survivors; survivors will be desperate, and even though the population has declined, the infrastructure to support it (particularly, the social infrastructure, even if the physical infrastructure is untouched) will likely have declined even more than the population.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:41AM
(#10547509)
In any breakdown of society, you'll have broken desperate people who turn to raiding instead of rebuilding. I don't think the two will be very much different?
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @01:14PM
(#10548138)
In the former case, you have a few people and (relatively) a lot of resources. In the latter, you have a lot of people and nowhere near enough resources. That's going to lead to more desperate violence, by many orders of magnitude.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by pjc50 on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:36AM
(#10547128)
Depending on how much you mean by "civilization" and "scratch", this isn't the kind of thing that's doable in a lifetime. If it were, international development would be a lot easier.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by dean on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @12:41PM
(#10547874)
Love the idea. But maybe he should expand his vocabulary a little bit beyond 1000 words. Saying "food holder" instead of "dish", obscures instead of clarifies, which defeats the purpose. Same for "up goer" instead of "rocket". And "funny voice air" instead of "helium". I'm intrigued enough to pick up the book, but I know stuff like that will just be annoying.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by dean on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @01:57PM
(#10548447)
Maybe you're right. But to me, the purpose of using plain words instead of technical jargon, is to clarify meaning. On the other hand, maybe he's just trying to be funny.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by gadders on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:16AM
(#10547028)
I would just like to take this opportunity to do my annual joke that Bill Gates should try and monetise his blog with affiliate links or he'll never make any money.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by visakanv on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @09:04AM
(#10546676)
Here's the thing– the "rules" of grammar only really exist to facilitate effective communication.
Every so often, a skilled communicator chooses to bend a rule in order to make a point. If the point is well made, it sticks, and people start imitating it.
Next thing you know, the newly-coined word becomes an "actual" word with real currency. (I put "actual" in quotes, because if you think about it, all words are made up. All "rules" are really just general guidelines.)
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by 33W on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:52AM
(#10547229)
So on a whim, I put some system documentation that I wrote into the simple word writer linked on that page (xkcd.com/simplewriter). So many red words... perhaps that's a challenge suited for another day.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by jschwartzi on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:00AM
(#10547273)
Depending on context, filler is a much more complicated concept. You could be referring to stuff they put in food that is not food, or stuff they put in cracks to fill them in, or a nozzle at a gas station.
By contrast, go is such a foundational word to English that it appears in English reading primers for toddlers, and a goer goes.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @02:36PM
(#10590146)
If he uses regular rules for allowable modifiers (e.g., "-er" can be added to a verb that is in the base list, to form a noun that is refers to the agent of the action described by the verb, then "filler" would be allowed if "fill" but not "filler" was on the list, but only to refer to the actor who causes something to be filled, rather than thing with which something is filled.)
I certainly think its clear (and even implicit in his own descriptions) that the exact methodology is not disclosed, but I don't think its far to say simply "he cheated".
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by smackfu on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @09:13AM
(#10546721)
Beyond what the other comments said, that was the title of the very first diagram he made like this, and he was probably just trying to pick a punchy title.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by kbutler on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:01AM
(#10546944)
Although I enjoy the Saturn 5 "Up goer five" description, I doubt that "goer" is in the top 1,000 most common words...
Edit: He's taken the common word list and added different forms as he needed them. Go -> goer and goers, because he wanted to use them. Grow is allowed, but grower and growers are not, because he didn't need them.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by jerf on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:14AM
(#10547017)
Looking at the simplewriter's JS [1] that lists the legal words [2], it appears to have 3634 entries in it. I assume that under the "rules" alternate forms of the top 1000 words are permitted. I'm not sure the "rules" have been explained elsewhere. (Perhaps in the book but that's not out yet.)
"goer" is a legal form of go. I mention this because I actually thought for a moment myself it might not be, but of course Googling it revealed it is extensively used in compound words like "movie-goer". Not sure I've ever seen it in the wild standing on its own, but I'll concede the point. One must grant a certain amount of flexibility here...
(And from the "surprisingly klunky translation" department, what player of Final Fantasy X could forget the Blitzball team name the Luca Goers? [3])
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by snewman on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:14AM
(#10547015)
I think he's allowing conjugations, e.g. "run", "runs", "running", "ran" count as one word. And he's stretching it to include "goer" as a conjugation of "go".
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by evanpw on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:15AM
(#10547020)
There's a whole thread of speculation about the rules on the xkcd forum [1]. It looks like the conclusion is that derived words are allowed, and the base word list comes from here: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Wiktionary:Frequency_lists/Co.... "go" is #37.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by tgb on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:13AM
(#10547014)
They probably classify them by top thousand base words. Otherwise every noun and its plural count, every verb and its conjugations, etc. Though it is kinda cheating to call goer a top word.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by IIAOPSW on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @09:29AM
(#10546801)
Some of your money that is left in the bank is given to other people so long as they promise to give back even more money. Even though the bank doesn't have all the money that it has taken, so long as most people do not ask for their money at the same time the bank will always have enough for people that want their money back. The bank gives you some extra money for letting them do this. When a lot of people believe the bank can't give their money back, it may cause everyone to try and take their money out. This is called a bank run and can be very bad.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by chrisbennet on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:30AM
(#10547447)
That's the description of banking we were taught in school and though it's not wrong, in practice, banks don't really work that way.
Banks deposits are a tiny source of the money banks loan. In practice, they loan out a portion of the collateral that they get when issuing a loan.
Example: They give Bob a house loan for $100K and in return they get the deed to a house worth $110K and an IOU from Bob for $100K (plus some interest). The bank can now treat the house as a $100-110K asset on their own balance sheet and loan part of that asset ($90K) out to another borrower.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by VLM on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @01:08PM
(#10548101)
Its weirder than you think. No banks have owned loans for a very long time. They're resold to various quasi government-ish organizations (think, like the IRS or the federal reserve, although not the IRS) in exchange for cash raised by selling mortgage backed security bonds. All kinds of random individual and orgs own those bonds. They pay off pretty well almost a sure thing when the first derivative of interest rates is negative, not so well at zero to positive.
Banks and mortgage brokers act as commissioned sales forces for the MBS bond market, basically.
"When you are trying to give away money, the people asking for it can often use special or hard words and ideas that you may not know or that may be confusing."
Sadly "rare," "uncommon," "unclear," and a whole bunch of other words don't make the simplewriter cut (too bad the XKCD tool doesn't automatically try to pull up closet matches from a thesaurus filtered against the word-list).
Or you could have read literally the next three sentences and learned what he actually meant.
http://reliefweb.int/report/world/words-matter
http://xkcd.com/simplewriter/
People talking about budgets and fiscal planning making use of hi-tech specific, bio-tech, etc. Anything which passively indicates that they are up to date on cant and argot of totally unrelated fields but serve as signal of being at the edge or on the cusp of all things new and modern and professional.
Examples, using MM for millions, or K for thousands (is that metric K or computing K), or saying "spend" as a noun. Having to sound like one knows and is up to date with all the different industry terminologies must be taxing.
Best of all is when a person is actually familiar with the terminology and senses the forced nature of the out of context use. They can only smile at the stilted use.
http://www.orwell.ru/library/essays/politics/english/e_polit...
" I am going to translate a passage of good English into modern English of the worst sort. Here is a well-known verse from Ecclesiastes:
Here it is in modern English: "http://people.ischool.berkeley.edu/~pam/papers/goodwriting.h... : targeted at legal writing, but the suggestion to have a point and stick to it is universally applicable.
[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ahvzDzKdB0&feature=youtu.be
It's a lot of text in comparison to the original poster-comic and a lot of stuff seems very repetitive (it's bound to be, right?) since many principles of planes, submarines, rockets are the same (physics). Still a fun read if you don't plow through it in one sitting.
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Knowledge-Rebuild-World-After-Apocal...
In the latter you'll have massive famine and also likely fighting against other survivors.
I also think apocalypses that start out as the first sort are also likely to produce famines and fighting against other survivors; survivors will be desperate, and even though the population has declined, the infrastructure to support it (particularly, the social infrastructure, even if the physical infrastructure is untouched) will likely have declined even more than the population.
(There's a ZOOM link in the description on the right)
Every so often, a skilled communicator chooses to bend a rule in order to make a point. If the point is well made, it sticks, and people start imitating it.
Next thing you know, the newly-coined word becomes an "actual" word with real currency. (I put "actual" in quotes, because if you think about it, all words are made up. All "rules" are really just general guidelines.)
http://blog.xkcd.com/2015/09/22/a-thing-explainer-word-check...
Of course now that you've raised the point, I'll probably have to waste some time today working out a simple word name for myself.
> I found myself wishing that Munroe had allowed himself a few more terms—“Mars” instead of “red world,” or “helium” instead of “funny voice air.”
https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/-er#Etymology_1
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agent_noun
By contrast, go is such a foundational word to English that it appears in English reading primers for toddlers, and a goer goes.
The point is, he's not simply stemming. He cheats.
I certainly think its clear (and even implicit in his own descriptions) that the exact methodology is not disclosed, but I don't think its far to say simply "he cheated".
Edit: He's taken the common word list and added different forms as he needed them. Go -> goer and goers, because he wanted to use them. Grow is allowed, but grower and growers are not, because he didn't need them.
"goer" is a legal form of go. I mention this because I actually thought for a moment myself it might not be, but of course Googling it revealed it is extensively used in compound words like "movie-goer". Not sure I've ever seen it in the wild standing on its own, but I'll concede the point. One must grant a certain amount of flexibility here...
(And from the "surprisingly klunky translation" department, what player of Final Fantasy X could forget the Blitzball team name the Luca Goers? [3])
[1]: http://xkcd.com/simplewriter/
[2]: http://xkcd.com/simplewriter/words.js
[3]: http://finalfantasy.wikia.com/wiki/Luca_Goers
[1] http://forums.xkcd.com/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=98621
What if some of your audience knows the word? Then it's a judgement call.
It checks out: http://xkcd.com/simplewriter/
Banks deposits are a tiny source of the money banks loan. In practice, they loan out a portion of the collateral that they get when issuing a loan.
Example: They give Bob a house loan for $100K and in return they get the deed to a house worth $110K and an IOU from Bob for $100K (plus some interest). The bank can now treat the house as a $100-110K asset on their own balance sheet and loan part of that asset ($90K) out to another borrower.
Or something like that. ;-)
Banks and mortgage brokers act as commissioned sales forces for the MBS bond market, basically.