Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by jerf on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:14AM
(#10547017)
Looking at the simplewriter's JS [1] that lists the legal words [2], it appears to have 3634 entries in it. I assume that under the "rules" alternate forms of the top 1000 words are permitted. I'm not sure the "rules" have been explained elsewhere. (Perhaps in the book but that's not out yet.)
"goer" is a legal form of go. I mention this because I actually thought for a moment myself it might not be, but of course Googling it revealed it is extensively used in compound words like "movie-goer". Not sure I've ever seen it in the wild standing on its own, but I'll concede the point. One must grant a certain amount of flexibility here...
(And from the "surprisingly klunky translation" department, what player of Final Fantasy X could forget the Blitzball team name the Luca Goers? [3])
[1]: http://xkcd.com/simplewriter/
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by snewman on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:14AM
(#10547015)
I think he's allowing conjugations, e.g. "run", "runs", "running", "ran" count as one word. And he's stretching it to include "goer" as a conjugation of "go".
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by evanpw on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:15AM
(#10547020)
There's a whole thread of speculation about the rules on the xkcd forum [1]. It looks like the conclusion is that derived words are allowed, and the base word list comes from here: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Wiktionary:Frequency_lists/Co.... "go" is #37.
Re:A Basic Guide for Curious Minds: Review of “Thing Explainer”
by tgb on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:13AM
(#10547014)
They probably classify them by top thousand base words. Otherwise every noun and its plural count, every verb and its conjugations, etc. Though it is kinda cheating to call goer a top word.
Edit: He's taken the common word list and added different forms as he needed them. Go -> goer and goers, because he wanted to use them. Grow is allowed, but grower and growers are not, because he didn't need them.