This is the key failure.
Anyone's whose regularly procured cleaning services knows the dance. You find a reputable cleaning service, they send out a cleaner. If you don't like them, you keep asking for a different one. When you find one you like, you ask them what they'd charge if you deal with them directly.
Why should they pay an app developer (or cleaning service) a cut of their profit when they can just show up and earn it themselves?
Most of the house keepers I've known did this until they'd built up enough of a consistent clientele that they could break out on their own....eventually building their own "crew".
Cleaning services are only good for businesses who require a paper trail for tax deduction purposes and who aren't as price sensitive as individuals.
This is effectively the yellow pages model, where cleaners pay for leads via advertising placements, and own the long-term relationship with the customer.
I dunno. My success rate was 25% at best. Found a few contractors I really liked and kept contact info for. And had a half dozen that only used the "deals" to try to land big remodeling jobs.
Office By Q is a good example of really trying to understand customer needs and putting a compelling proposition into the marketplace.
For in-home cleaning, there might be a middle-ground. I could see trying out a few cleaners to be useful and selecting a favorite. Or maybe 2 different cleaners with different specialties rotating. But for just scheduling the same person at the same time, you can't really count on taking an ongoing cut.
Its the standard in every industry. Once you've built your ground, you never like to go through a third party.
Uber's advantage comes from catering really well to ad-hoc, short-hop travel, but this is a different market.
(taxi expenses are covered by his work but personal car travel is not, so he doesn't drive, go figure)
It becomes a natural fit.
Uber kind of services work because they are currently burning millions of investor money to subsidize your travel. Once they run out of money, you are back to the same thing again.
Which is why some times you must do extra work for free, because it keeps people around you happy and in return they are indebted to do something in return for you(Recommend you, tip you, hire you etc)
Traveling adhoc without planning is only for single 20 year olds start up techies. People with families, elderly etc generally have to plan in advance if they decide to do something.
I can't count the times cabs just no showed when I was living in DC. Nearly missed a few flights.
Yes, for sure. I've had professional home cleaners for nearly 10 years now. And over the course of those years, I've had many conversations with friends and neighbors who do as well (e.g. in giving/receiving recommendations). I can't imagine using a service that sends someone different every time, or even someone for whom I can't see reviews and receive references before the first visit. I think most of the people I've talked to are in the same boat. This is a service that requires putting a lot of trust in the service provider. I could potentially see myself using an app that helped me find a provider, but it would need to give me a lot of information about them up front, and let me choose from several. And then it would have to let me keep getting the same person every time. It ends up being more like an Angie's List than a Homejoy.
For something like a handyman, where the service is less intimate and less frequent, this might make more sense (though I have had enough horrible experiences with handymen that I also would want personal recommendations at this point)...
The morning of my appointment I looked online and they'd switched my cleaner. The new person arrived 45 minutes late, did a poor job, and tried to get me to book her outside of Handy.
Finding someone on Craigslist is easier and cheaper. Answer a random ad, asses quality after their first visit. Either book them on a recurring schedule or move on to the next ad. The only difference is paying with a cheque rather than a CC.
After 4 different attempts to cancel we gave up and called American Express. They blocked Handy from charging the card again and did a chargeback for every dollar we ever spent with them.
Against my better judgment, I attempted to book through them again the next week. Cleaner didn't show up and would not answer his/her phone.
On numerous prior visits the cleaner was very late and/or did a very poor job. Handy doesn't care.
This is a truly terrible service--one of the worst experiences I've ever had with a company.
Apps like Handy want to invert that, but in the case of Handy they basically failed to provide the consistent quality and a critical mass of cleaner to offset people reluctance to engage with cleaners like this. This lead to the kind of frustration the parent describe. The real loss for Handy is not the cancellation or even the loss of that customer for good, the real loss is that they lost the recommendation of that customer and recommendation is the main way your currently chose a cleaner.
If you pay for Bob to come over and clean your kitchen because you know Bob does great work, it's perfectly reasonable for me to call you up and say, "Bob's sick today, can I send Jed over instead?" But it's also perfectly reasonable for you to say "no, so cancel my appointment for today." It is not reasonable for me to charge you a cancellation fee under that scenario.
Here is the relevant clause from the Handy TOS:
"Handy cannot guarantee that the same Professional will be scheduled for each Recurrent Service appointment"
Next, they make it worse by charging a fee for the pleasure of being disappointed. Pretty bad customer experience.
But it's not good customer service to notify your client that their request can't be accommodated when it's too late for them to do anything about it. If the notice was prior to the cancellation-fee period, then sure, charge the fee if canceled within 24-hours. But if you give me late notice, at least allow me to late-cancel in return.
https://www.handy.com/help#/315d90/a4db36/19c48c
If they let you book a Pro and that Pro cannot make it on late notice, it is absurd to charge a late notice cancellation fee.
At least Amex is great about not giving a shit about awful TOS. If you screw your customers over and accept Amex you'll soon find out that you won't be getting paid.
"We'll do our best to match you up again on your new booking, but please understand that as an independent contractor, it is up to the discretion of the professional to accept or decline your booking. In the event we cannot match you, another professional will be assigned."
If you don't like that deal, don't take it. But don't be all pissed off when they do exactly what you agreed to.
The reason the cancellation policy exists is because if you cancel the Professional doesn't get paid and it's too late to rebook them to someone else. According to Handy, the cancelation fee goes to the Professional who you cancelled on. In this case the Professional cancelled, why should they still get paid?
A cancellation fee makes perfect sense in many cases, but sometimes companies take their own policies by the letter even when it's infuriating and bad for everyone. A better tack is to instead think about what the policy's intent is and how to handle it like adults. Usually in these cases the customer just shuts up and pays the fee and will never use the company again, but at least this time they had the follow through to take their money back (and if there's one thing a company notices it is their merchant account sending money in the other direction). A win for the little guy, great job OP!
eg:
If Handy doesn't like the deal where an Amex customer can request a chargeback for inadequate customer service then they shouldn't accept Amex as payment.
That being said I have had Handy come and clean many times now and not changed it, so I think there is a slight convenience factor. It would be better if Handy just facilitated the direct communication with the same person to come every time. And instead of charging me a fee, charged the cleaner a kind of 'management' fee. I think that would better.
The alternative is if Homejoy would have treated Cleaners as employees and properly trained them. A properly trained and paid Cleaner as an employee would have provided that trust you seek.
If I'm paying someone less than 100$ to come in to a place where they could walk out with $10K+ worth of electronics, jewelry, etc I either need to be there to supervise or have a long standing relationship with the person. Ideally I would like to know enough of their other clients that a single robbery doesn't make economic sense for them. Once the relationship exists the agency brings minimal value.
What if the highly qualified employee from Homejoy was for $200-$250?
Finding a warm body to drag a tepid rag around your countertop is easy, sure, but finding someone who's 1) consistent 2) always on-time and 3) not $100/hr is next to impossible.
Perhaps in a large metro it's easier, but I've had basically no luck in suburban silicon valley.
I live in Silicon Valley now. . . found the best cleaner I've ever had. Very happy with her and her helper's work.
Back in the day I had a cleaning service that I trusted and used regularly put a wet rag on top of a CSU/DSU [1]. Not something that I ever thought could happen. Ironically the spare CSU/DSU was sitting right next to that. (Cold and ready to be put in service if the main one failed.) There were of course vents on the top. That's where the rag went. And I was near the equipment at the time (I would never let a cleaning service in where there was sensitive equipment without being onsite).
http://www.yelp.com/biz/homejoy-san-francisco
e.g. "I have never had more problems with any service or company than I have with this business."
When you're standing on an unknown, rainy street corner far away from home, a taxi's services are urgently required, and not abundant. When you're lounging on your sofa and start contemplating how it would be nice for someone else to bin the pizza boxes, it's the opposite on both counts.
Moreover, I don't see the money men being impressed by a founder who can put out a piece so toe-curlingly embarrassing as "Dear Future HomeJoy Engineer".
Commentary: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8795197
Does Y-Combinator review those posts at all before they go out and provide any guidance? If not they might want to consider it...
But there is no reason that an app-based cleaning service can't succeed, full stop. There's plenty of room to add value, just like there is in any other business where you can get economies of scale. Homejoy just didn't focus on those parts of the business.
- Partner with P&G and Unilever to get access to trial products that you can give to your cleaners to try
- Act as an agent to negotiate group rates on stuff like health insurance
- Provide business services if you book a certain number of appointments each year. Tax help, those kinds of things.
- Maybe you can provide access to events or something where Homejoy books a group of cleaners and since it's a business you can charge them good rates
- Find other way to book cushy jobs that you can give access to for your most used cleaners
Obviously there's a 1099 line that they don't want to cross but if you provide access and opportunities and tier it based on appointments booked then you provide incentives to stay on the platform.
Similarly for customers, do things like give away cleanings or discounts randomly. Use your partnerships from above to give customers free stuff or coupons. Sell cleanings in 10 packs or offer a monthly or annual subscription that comes with a discount.
That is, once a service provider has a customer, that customer represents the overwhelming majority of value to be had by the service. Likewise, for a customer who is happy with and trusting of a cleaner, discounts would likely have to be unsustainably large to move them.
Finally, with the middleman in the transaction, discountability is actually eroded. There is really little economies of scale to be leveraged at the cleaners' level and customers would probably come out better if cleaners simply passed the Homejoy cut to them.
https://crunchbase.com/organization/handybook/
edit: I'm in Chicago
http://thebillfold.com/2014/10/my-day-interviewing-for-the-s...
That said, I'm sure "doesn't seem to be struggling from what I can tell" could have been said about Homejoy, until it couldn't. Venture capital makes it difficult to tell who is succeeding, and who just has money to spend.
My first question when I heard of them is how they prevent cleaners from ever using the platform again. This seems to be the single biggest long term stumbling block, that they never really got close to solving.
http://techcrunch.com/2015/07/31/why-homejoy-failed-and-the-...
Aside: I saw Adora at the London StartUp school hosted by YC. She really didn't come off that convincing to me. Then she said something really, really strange - "You don't fail until you give up", and I wondered why someone would say something like that.
The thing that convinces me is her determination. She worked as cleaner before starting the business, and understood some of the pain. She probably overlooked at the issue and probably overconfident like the article cited, but someone who was willing to cover cleaner to apologize for cancellation on Thanksgiving? That's very good for her (but unable to prioritize some critical negativity in the algorithm? that's just sad). Without knowing the full story (we are just hearing fragments from allegedly ex-Homejoy employees), I think the business model is not profitable. Maybe doing cheap is really hard, and doing fancy and professional is the only way out.
No, it didn't. Some of my previous comments:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8468863
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6856221
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8489834
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8709632
Homejoy won't be the last company of this type to collapse.
My next cleaning comes around, and I'm hit with a $101 charge. The receipt literally says "Price: $101, Discount: $58, Total Charged: $101". I end up having to go back and forth over Twitter DM because they refuse to respond to my emails and pick up their phone to get my charge adjusted. I ask if the remaining three cleanings that I was signed up for would honor the $43 price reflected in my account summary. They said yes.
The day before the next cleaning, I get hit with the same $101 charge. Again, I reach out to them and spend about three hours going back and forth finding out that the "last representative did not provide the right information", and that I need to "show the coupon code (I) used" (there wasn't one). I ended up getting my service cancelled for good.
Terrible. Never again. I'd rather pay a premium for a real cleaner to show up.
http://www.yelp.com/biz/handy-san-francisco
http://www.yelp.com/biz/handy-los-angeles
http://www.yelp.com/biz/handy-chicago
Handy is also facing lawsuits:
http://gbdhlegal.com/wp-content/uploads/cases/Handybook-File...
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/07/woman-sues-startu...
Handy isn't the only one, and this ought to be illegal. If I can sign up online I ought to be able to cancel online.
These companies can lie to themselves and the public all they want - the exclusive purpose of making you call to cancel (or worse, visit a physical location) is to discourage cancellations. It compromises the notion of a free and voluntary exchange of money for services.
And if you send in the paperwork, but not by certified mail? They'll toss it, unactioned.
How can the gyms get away with this?
It seems like providing the gym itself is more of a side hobby to the main business: find people to bill and keep billing them whether they like it or not, and build a core competence to avoid ever not billing someone.
One time, a new cleaner showed up, but I wasn't home. She didn't have the key, and so she couldn't clean. I asked for a refund and never got it.
However both of these sites will have the same problem as Homejoy. I used rover.com to book pet sitting just for the insurance, but after a few positive experiences, I am now booking directly with the pet sitter. Same thing happens on care.com almost all the time.
These sites are more valuable as a craigslist or angie's list competitor: Use them once or twice per year, then don't visit the site again after you've found your provider.
They should focus on making money from listing fees, insurance premiums, and being the strongest market for their respective industries at all times, so that when I go back to the site in 6 months time, I can trust that it will be just as good an experience as it was last time.
Furthermore, they're doing the typical thing that businesses resort to when they're desperate. They're asking you to review every single damn time you use their service. (I had the same sitter for 30 weeks in a row. Clearly I like her or I'd use someone different. Stop bugging me!)
They also try to steer you towards using their service more when there's no need for it. Every time I book a stay, they want me to look into other pet sitters on their site. Why would I do that? I'm completely happy with the one I found. If I ever need a change because I move or the sitter moves, or we have a falling out, I'll consider looking for a new one. Until then, get out of my face!
And on top of it, they're trying to push services I don't need. I never want someone to come to my house to walk my dog. I don't need strangers coming by my house. And I need an overnight maybe 3 times a year. (And I'll continue to use the day sitter I have as they also do overnights.) It's almost impossible to find a day sitter on rover.com, and they seem to be pushing everything but that.
Their whole model seems like it's living on borrowed time to me.
In my state, you need to be licensed to provide child care. It looks like California and a few other states are similar.
It seems to depend on how many children are being looked after and where the care takes place.
Home joys minimum worked out to be about $75 per visit... So about $37.5 per hour... And I don't think folding clothes as a service worth $600 per month.
It's more of a hassle to schlep the clothes to & fro, but may be better value to you.
So, yeah, it's hard to see a couple of hours of work costing less than $50 or so. And, if this is a weekly or more frequent expense, that starts to add up. I have a housecleaner come in every few weeks and it does help to keep my place in some semblance of order, but it's definitely a luxury expense and I would probably be too cheap to have it done weekly.
As a W2 employee, yes. If you're asking someone to work as a 1099 and eat their own self-employment taxes, transit costs, etc, that's going well below minimum wage.
Minimum wage can be as low as $7.25 for W2 employees. This calculator suggests that corresponds to only $10/hour for a contractor: http://www.rate-calculators.com/
I find ghaff's argument more compelling: people will pay more simply because they want someone they can trust in their home.
Homejoy had none of that. You rarely move home, and your cleaner rarely does either. Effectively, from transaction #1 you're in a perfectly replicable pattern - Cleaner X comes to your house every Y weeks and works for Z hours. No matter how great that initial app experience is, it's basically not needed afterwards.
There's also something interesting in here about the limits of the "gig economy". Arguably, by creating a marketplace of cleaners competing with each other for your money, they'd drive costs down for customers. In reality, inviting someone into your home is a very personal thing, and people much prefer to build a relationship with someone that they might pay a little more on a regular basis, than get a different person each time. It is a premium service, after all.