This is effectively the yellow pages model, where cleaners pay for leads via advertising placements, and own the long-term relationship with the customer.
I dunno. My success rate was 25% at best. Found a few contractors I really liked and kept contact info for. And had a half dozen that only used the "deals" to try to land big remodeling jobs.
Office By Q is a good example of really trying to understand customer needs and putting a compelling proposition into the marketplace.
For in-home cleaning, there might be a middle-ground. I could see trying out a few cleaners to be useful and selecting a favorite. Or maybe 2 different cleaners with different specialties rotating. But for just scheduling the same person at the same time, you can't really count on taking an ongoing cut.
Its the standard in every industry. Once you've built your ground, you never like to go through a third party.
Uber's advantage comes from catering really well to ad-hoc, short-hop travel, but this is a different market.
(taxi expenses are covered by his work but personal car travel is not, so he doesn't drive, go figure)
It becomes a natural fit.
Uber kind of services work because they are currently burning millions of investor money to subsidize your travel. Once they run out of money, you are back to the same thing again.
Which is why some times you must do extra work for free, because it keeps people around you happy and in return they are indebted to do something in return for you(Recommend you, tip you, hire you etc)
Traveling adhoc without planning is only for single 20 year olds start up techies. People with families, elderly etc generally have to plan in advance if they decide to do something.
I can't count the times cabs just no showed when I was living in DC. Nearly missed a few flights.
This is the key failure.
Anyone's whose regularly procured cleaning services knows the dance. You find a reputable cleaning service, they send out a cleaner. If you don't like them, you keep asking for a different one. When you find one you like, you ask them what they'd charge if you deal with them directly.
Why should they pay an app developer (or cleaning service) a cut of their profit when they can just show up and earn it themselves?
Most of the house keepers I've known did this until they'd built up enough of a consistent clientele that they could break out on their own....eventually building their own "crew".
Cleaning services are only good for businesses who require a paper trail for tax deduction purposes and who aren't as price sensitive as individuals.