News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mirimir on Friday October 09, 2015 @04:43AM (#10358836)
Now, if we can just agree that natural products and traditional cures can't be patented. India has been fighting hard for that.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by ekianjo on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:07AM (#10358902)
If we could kill patents altogether that would be a much nicer step. Patents are an invention from another Era and make absolutely no sense nowadays, and we see them constantly abused to make our lives worse in the end.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mirimir on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:23AM (#10358968)
I tend to agree with Cyph0n that patents can promote innovation. But "prior art" ought to be defined sanely. If something has been well known in India for thousands of years, how can some multinational patent it? How can some chemical that occurs in nature be patented? And then there's the whole universe of stuff that's different by one atom over there, and so deemed patentable.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by dougabug on Friday October 09, 2015 @06:34AM (#10359165)
The question should not be whether you believe that it is possible for patents to promote innovation. Rather can you prove based on evidence that they clearly and irrefutably, in fact, do so? Do patents ever harm or retard innovation? Is it economically worth the burden of the patent system for the benefit achieved, or are there better alternatives?

Moreover, how much theoretical economic payoff justifies surrendering a basic right? Should government be given sweeping power to dictate how we use our minds?

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mirimir on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:04AM (#10359250)
Those are excellent points. There's no doubt that multinationals have gamed the global patent, copyright and trademark systems. On the other hand, it is plausible that the possibility of limited monopoly would promote innovation. But how would one measure costs vs benefits?
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:20AM (#10359513)
It's arguable that limited monopoly promotes the first innovation. But it should be obvious, it prevents all the possible third party innovations that riff off the first.

It's easy to miss the dog that didn't bark, or the improvement that couldn't be sold.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by dougabug on Friday October 09, 2015 @02:28PM (#10362309)
There's also the question of inequality. Granting monopolies exacerbates inequality, so a hypothetical short term boost to productivity growth might not translate into meaningfully better quality of life for most people. Government engineered barriers to competitive use of specific ideas could undermine the bargaining power of workers, and artificially inflate or support prices of key goods.

It seems like an innovation supporting tax would be less restrictive, while still rewarding useful innovations that the market somehow fails to reward.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mirimir on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:21PM (#10363946)
Indeed. What comes to mind are farmers who depend on highly tweaked crops to survive, but who are forbidden (or prevented by design) from even saving seeds. Let alone trying to improve the strain.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mirimir on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:16PM (#10363936)
That is an excellent point.

The key, then, would be to distinguish and reward such primary innovation. Maybe it's obvious when you see it. Or maybe do some Bates thing with panels of experts.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mirimir on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:34PM (#10363981)
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by zamalek on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:19AM (#10360156)
Possibly, patent should have some minimal effort time. After, say, 3 years you have to demonstrably prove that you will take the patent to market. For example, a software product should have some code written that uses the patent, even if incomplete. So long as you do nothing with the patent, anyone can get a royalty free license to it when they challenge you (after the grace period).

This would encourage people to take their innovations to market, instead of sitting on them and bunkrupting anyone else who tries to.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by teddyh on Friday October 09, 2015 @03:08PM (#10362576)
You can game “taking an innovation to market” any number of ways. Making the product unrealistically expensive. Only manufacturing a very limited number, or even a single, item. Making an item that technically uses the patent but is in a very different sort of field than any product which would be actually useful. Making the actual product practically unusable, or hideously ugly, or horribly uncomfortable.

These are all things which normally would be solved by competition in the marketplace, but you don’t have competition, since a patent is a monopoly. So you have to solve all these problems some other way.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mindcrime on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:34AM (#10360701)
I tend to agree with Cyph0n that patents can promote innovation.

They can also inhibit innovation. Something to consider...

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mirimir on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:26PM (#10363956)
Right. So maybe the key distinction is that breakthrough patents tend to promote innovation, but follow-on patents tend to inhibit innovation.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:12AM (#10358918)
I don't think they made any sense from the get go, not even in the steam age.

In general, the first implementation of a good idea was a bad one, of limited use, not a well refined concept. And then the patent-holder sat on the patent until it expired, and then - finally - the whatever-it-was became a vital and widely used commodity as creativity started to be applied.

So all it did was slow the pace of change.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by belorn on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:46AM (#10359039)
Patents worked great for what they were intended for, which was for the English crown to raise funds outside of parliaments control, and later in the US when they used it to encourage the immigration of skilled workers.

The English crown had the big problem that its treasury was dictated by parliament during the 16th century, so it sold royal decrees (writ patents) granting exclusive rights. Parliament passed after an outburst of patenting by the monarch the then new Statute of Monopolies, which said that only Parliament might grant monopolies in statutory form and that only for new inventions.

The British North American settlers later recognized that their society benefited by disclosure and that disclosure supplemented the very weak technical literature of the world in which they lived. They had plentiful of free natural resources but a very small skilled workforce, so they wanted to encourage the immigration of skilled people on a deal which required the disclosure of their inventions in a publicly consult-able reference form.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:57AM (#10359070)
Kings, huh. An awful idea.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by doki_pen on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:20AM (#10359512)
Not true. Patents increase the incentive for people to do hard research and development. Whether or not that increased incentive is necessary is debatable.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by Peaker on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:36AM (#10359578)
They also decrease the incentive for people to do research and development (e.g: as derivative works from existing inventions).

Which effect is stronger? It is very plausible that overall, the decrease is far stronger than the increase, as the vast majority of inventions are derivative.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by dboreham on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:36AM (#10360260)
What you say may be true in some cases but I personally think twice or three times about doing any hard research and development because the chances are either some megacorp or patent troll will eventually come eat my lunch with bogus claims of infringement and the associated high cost of litigation.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by ekianjo on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:02AM (#10360462)
Problem is that patents are not used the way they were intended to. A patent was supposed to be licensable so that other companies could still use the said technology if they so wished. But in practice what patents do is lock the market and prevent the exploitation of said technologies until they expire, which in turn slow down innovation significantly.

And don't even get me started on all the "obvious" patents out there, or the one that clearly are no invention because prior art actually exists - but then they take years to be invalidated, if ever. It is just an enormous debt on Society as a whole.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by norea-armozel on Friday October 09, 2015 @09:03AM (#10359698)
That may be true, but the current setup in the US at least cost us 500 billion over a decade in litigation alone. Something in our system has to be reworked to minimize the social cost of innovation.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by teekert on Friday October 09, 2015 @06:41AM (#10359193)
You are completely ignoring the fact that large Pharma companies would be unable to have any return on investment, would not be able to pay their employees and thus many people would be unemployed and there would thus be no incentive to even develop new drugs.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by thaumasiotes on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:03AM (#10359246)
I think drug development is one of the strongest cases for a patent system. However:

> many people would be unemployed

This isn't an argument at all. It's better for people to be unemployed than to be employed in an enterprise that makes everyone else worse off.

> and there would thus be no incentive to even develop new drugs

Of course there would. We had drug development before we had patents.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by ekianjo on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:04AM (#10360488)
> Of course there would. We had drug development before we had patents.

And moreover, there are other ways to protect your invention without using patents - such as trade secrets, manufacturing expertise, exclusive supplier agreements, and of course, ONGOING innovation (instead of inventing one thing and getting a rent out of it for 20 years).

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by teekert on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:23AM (#10359322)
> This isn't an argument at all. It's better for people to be unemployed than to be employed in an enterprise that makes everyone else worse off.

Are you hinting at a specific company? I don't think the people that got cured from metastatic cancer would agree that they would be better of without Merck and their PD-L1 antibodies.

To be clear I'm responding to ekianjo's > If we could kill patents altogether that would be a much nicer step. I'm also not in favor of patenting natural products, gene sequences and traditional cures.

I am in favor of establishing a system where a companies would have a solid return on investment while still having the drug available to everybody without damaging the incentive to invest billions to come up with only a handful of drugs. The problem is, the drug market is not a free market, an individual has no reasonable way of saying "I don't agree to your price and I will thus not use your product." ... as consumers have with normal products.

>Of course there would. We had drug development before we had patents. Perhaps I should say: There would be no efficient, lean very driven companies looking for drugs. Off course there may have been people who found drugs out of hobby of while being paid for by the state.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by crpatino on Friday October 09, 2015 @09:11AM (#10359732)
> I don't think the people that got cured from metastatic cancer would agree that they would be better of without Merck and their PD-L1 antibodies.

Of course they wouldn't; its the relatives of all those who could not afford the drug and died who would be all-in for this!

And you seem to believe that the Free Hand of Market does magically fix every problem. Not so. It is just a Hand after all, with no eyes and no brain.

Big companies have their own share of inefficiencies. Maybe is not as bad as in the public sector, but they are far from working at full capacity. And whatever advantage private sector has you have to offset against the potential for corporate malfeasance. With corrupt public officials at least you know they limit themselves to trying to get rich and providing good paying jobs for their friends. In the private sector you give executives the chance to do the same thing legally, and then they go on to weaponize the patent system and actively block any progress (in house AND from external competitors) that is perceived to threaten a revenue stream.

Ultimately the people that count, the intellectual powerhouses that carry the weight of everybody else, are the same ones that you've dismissed as hobbyist. They are the only ones that care about the drugs themselves, and they care enough to do it even if nobody pays them, as long as they are not busy trying not to starve to dead. They usually don't care where their paycheck comes from (grants, profits, venture capital, etc), and as long as all their needs and reasonable wants are provided for they continue to perform their magic.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by teekert on Friday October 09, 2015 @09:45AM (#10359938)
>Of course they wouldn't; its the relatives of all those who could not afford the drug and died who would be all-in for this!

We don't have that problem in the Netherlands so maybe that is what requires fixing. Here, if a drug is too expensive, nobody has access to it (only the ultra rich perhaps) and that creates an incentive to keep drugs affordable to certain extent.

Again I'm not saying the current system is optimal but cancelling the right to monetize your inventions at least until your investment has been earned back seems nothing but reasonable to me.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by refurb on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:54AM (#10359663)
Of course there would. We had drug development before we had patents.

Really? Can you provide an example?

From what I understand patents started in the US shortly after formation of the country. The first drugs discovered didn't happen until the late 1800's.

In fact, the names of many of these drugs were "Dr. Smith's patented flu medication".

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by thaumasiotes on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:09PM (#10363296)
Some selections from Wikipedia:

> Later in his life [before 200 BC], Qin Shi Huang feared death and desperately sought the fabled elixir of life, which would supposedly allow him to live forever. He was obsessed with acquiring immortality and fell prey to many who offered him supposed elixirs.

> The ostensible goals of alchemy are often given as the transmutation of common metals into gold (known as chrysopoeia), the creation of a panacea, and the discovery of a universal solvent.

(emphasis mine)

> Plant extracts, including willow bark and spiraea, of which salicylic acid was the active ingredient, had been known to help alleviate headaches, pains, and fevers since antiquity. The father of modern medicine, Hippocrates (circa 460 – 377 BC), left historical records describing the use of powder made from the bark and leaves of the willow tree to help these symptoms.

All of that is drug development. In the case of willow bark extract, it was successful drug development. But I'm not going to blame the people of 200 BC for being technically less adept than the people of today. If they'd had the knowledge and tools we have, they would have done their development from that base.

Snake oil was named "Dr. Smith's Patented Flu Medication" to give the impression that the government officially vouched for its effectiveness, not in gratitude to the patent system.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by danarmak on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:53AM (#10359661)
> We had drug development before we had patents.

How is that? We've had patents for centuries; we've had drug development for maybe one century.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by thaumasiotes on Saturday October 10, 2015 @01:27AM (#10364618)
We've had drug development for millennia.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by ekianjo on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:32AM (#10359355)
Not true at all. Look at Bio drugs for example. Even when they are to be generiqued, there is almost no company jumping in to make them because it's damn hard to make in the first place and there is very little incentive to do so, so the major players stay in place. A good example: all injectable diabetes drugs, but there are others out there as well.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by doki_pen on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:24AM (#10359525)
Absurd, the price of albuterol has gone up 10 fold since patents have been reinforced on it. When companies have patents on life saving drugs they can charge whatever they want. If they have no patent, they are forced to keep the price low enough so no one wants to compete.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by jcadam on Friday October 09, 2015 @09:22AM (#10359782)
The new albuterol inhalers are inferior to the old. The "innovation" was the removal of CFCs (asthma inhalers were an exception to the CFC ban, until recently). This required new, patentable, formulations (though the 'active' ingredient remained the same), which gave us the sucktastic, easy-clogging, overpriced sulfate-based inhalers we have today. The pharma companies were all too willing to go along with the EPA on this one. The FDA and EPA would have you believe this transition went smoothly for asthmatics. They are lying.

Some people are allergic to the new inhalers (sulfates can irritate the airways), which led to the creation of a black market for the old ones, but that supply is bound to run out eventually.

With insurance, I pay about $40 for one of the new inhalers (If you're poor and don't have insurance, you get to die, I guess). Generally they make my breathing more constricted for a minute or two until the albuterol kicks in, so I try to avoid taking a hit from my inhaler unless I'm really having trouble. Nice. Fortunately, since I moved to a beach town on the coast of Florida last year, I haven't needed my inhaler very often. Unfortunately, I'm no longer willing to relocate for work (dirty, city air is the worst), now that I've found a place where the air isn't trying to kill me. :)

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by teekert on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:51AM (#10359653)
You do understand that the profits go partly back into making new drugs? And also partly into paying people with families?

Again: I understand the need for keeping medicines cheap but the removal of patents seems like an overkill with adverse effects.

> If they have no patent, they are forced to keep the price low enough so no one wants to compete. ... And no one feels like inventing a new drug that will immediately be copied and sold at a price near that of the raw materials (the only overhead is the factory) making it impossible to pay all the scientists who are working on the next drug.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by doki_pen on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @09:47AM (#10380402)
I was simply counter-pointing the contention that patents don't affect prices. You are making a completely separate argument.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by melling on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:24AM (#10359527)
I can't tell if this is a reputable site but it catalogs drugs as they become generic:

http://www.drugs.com/generic-approvals.html

I know people who have fought not to have generic or bio-similar drugs.

Anyway, can you provide references to validate your claim? Just because someone says something on the Internet doesn't make it true.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by ekianjo on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:39AM (#10360276)
Look at all Insulins - there are no generics. http://www.businessinsider.com/why-is-there-no-generic-insul...
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mattlutze on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:09AM (#10359266)
No patents anywhere means companies with more money and a thumb on the pulse will unabashedly ape smaller do-ers work.

We should encourage independent inventors and small / mid-size businesses to risk capital on R&D, and reward them with a bit of protection so they can do some marketing while bringing a new thing to market, without having to worry about a big company duplicating their work and selling over them.

The internet doesn't fix the economies of scale afforded by a big cash pile, for either marketing or distribution.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by pjc50 on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:24AM (#10359327)
Big cash piles are easy to turn into a big patent pile which can be used to fence out independent inventors and small / mid-size businesses. What proportion of patents are filed by SMEs anyway?
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mattlutze on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:04AM (#10359457)
In one study by the US Small Business Administration, they looked at 2007-2009 (to understand economic activity during the height of the Great Recession) and noted 42% of companies that file 15 or more patents over the two-year period had 500 employees or less (which is, to them, a small to medium business).

https://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/rs411tot.pdf

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rmc on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:30AM (#10358987)
It makes sense if you invent a better lightbulb.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by Cyph0n on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:12AM (#10358913)
No it wouldn't. Talented people would have little incentive to create something new.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:16AM (#10358936)
People's incentive to create is the same as it always was: creative people just want to.

What patents were set up to prevent, IIRC, was trade secrets - they were a way to bribe creators to publish their ideas rather than sit on them.

IMO, they were a sledgehammer to swat a fly. Trade secrets would be reinvented. Locking an idea out of the commons for a whole patent term (and longer if they can attach new patents off the side) is a worse outcome.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by thaumasiotes on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:06AM (#10359254)
> What patents were set up to prevent, IIRC, was trade secrets - they were a way to bribe creators to publish their ideas rather than sit on them.

This is what I learned too. I can't for the life of me understand why the US has trade secret laws in addition to the patent laws. From some light reading on wikipedia, the answer seems to be "why do we need a reason?"

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by danarmak on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:56AM (#10359672)
For that matter, software or algorithms can be under copyright (may not publish), patent (must publish as part of the patent), and trade secret (may publish only if already public knowledge) at the same time.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by venomsnake on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:33AM (#10358998)
But on the other hand reproducing the result without reading the patent, should be able to invalidate said patent. If I don't care how you achieved the one click purchase button, I should be able to have my implementation on my page.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:45AM (#10359035)
Invalidating patents may not be so hard in the abstract, but the trouble is you have to fight a long and legally technical court case to do it. With no certainty of winning even if you are right.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rrmm on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:46AM (#10359040)
That's too low of a standard imo: just knowing something is possible and what that specific thing is, confers a lot of useful information.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:52AM (#10359055)
However, that argument also suggests that trade secrets are not much of a barrier to innovation.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rrmm on Friday October 09, 2015 @06:15AM (#10359126)
It definitely depends on the invention in question.

Consider the case of nuclear weapons. The first big leap is that the energy of fission can be made to be explosively released. Once you know that this is the case, most people in the field might be able to come up with something along the lines of a gun-type warhead.

On the other hand, implosion devices, even if you know they are possible, still require a huge amount of work and design studies to make work reliably. Knowing that they are possible isn't the hard part--making it work is.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by noir_lord on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:14AM (#10358927)
Talented people created things for thousands of years before patents.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by Cyph0n on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:21AM (#10358960)
People have lived thousands of years without refrigeration.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by ubernostrum on Friday October 09, 2015 @06:02AM (#10359086)
Actually, people have lived thousands of years with refrigeration. Insulated structures using evaporative cooling systems (capable of acting as air conditioners, or of maintaining near-freezing temperatures suitable for refrigeration) are known to date back to the 14th century BC.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by CamperBob2 on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:29AM (#10358980)
Refrigeration is an excellent example of something that could have easily been developed and refined without patent protection.

Consumers win when innovators compete with each other. Patents replace market competition with a foot race.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by oldmanjay on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:47AM (#10360822)
and yet somehow we have more technical innovation now than we ever did outside of a patent system.

there is a lot of emotional and assertive speculation around this issue but all of the hard facts that are available very strongly suggest patents work despite occasional (if highly publicized) conflict. how does your theory accommodate that fact?

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by CamperBob2 on Friday October 09, 2015 @03:52PM (#10362842)
Counterexample: how did the Internet and WWW ever evolve without a significant reliance on patents? How did the software industry in general ever flourish? The best we can say from empirical observation is that patents don't lead to guaranteed failure. We certainly can't say they're necessary.

If everything that could have been patented was patented, we'd all be poorer for it. Except the lawyers, of course.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rrmm on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:17AM (#10358941)
If there is any issue, I don't think that is it.

The issue that might arise is that techniques that are invented might never be openly published (since there wouldn't be protection for it).

For stuff that is obvious, it wouldn't matter because it is obvious. The non-obvious stuff--the stuff that actually does deserve a patent--might be lost on occasion.

I'm not a big fan of patents in general though given my experience with them (and certainly not patents on genes, etc).

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by lifeisstillgood on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:44AM (#10359031)
I think you are conflating several issues here.

Firstly there is a difference between natural product and traditional cures / medicine. See the below link for the recent Nobel prize, or just imagine the difference between chemical isolation of aspirin and understanding it's pathways and "chew some bark of that tree"

I think it is fair and valid for scientific inquiry to be considered seperate and more than traditional correlation.

However i also think that patents on scientific outcomes are a bad thing and in general should be avoided.

So, yes patent is bad. No don't give "traditional cures" any special protection, and don't give "natural products" any distinction from other areas of scientific inquiry.

Do have ethical committees however :-)

http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2015/10/07/the-2015-nobel-...

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by mirimir on Friday October 09, 2015 @06:13AM (#10359119)
Yes, there are distinctions to be made. But the status quo is clearly absurd.

Also, contrasting "scientific inquiry" vs "traditional correlation" in the context of patents is misleading. There's no requirement to demonstrate mechanistic understanding to get a patent. So it's arguably all just correlation.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by josaka on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:46PM (#10361373)
In the US, "laws of nature, natural phenomena, and abstract ideas are not patentable." See Mayo v. Prometheus (https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=505607866460473...)