News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by Cyph0n on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:12AM (#10358913)
No it wouldn't. Talented people would have little incentive to create something new.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:16AM (#10358936)
People's incentive to create is the same as it always was: creative people just want to.

What patents were set up to prevent, IIRC, was trade secrets - they were a way to bribe creators to publish their ideas rather than sit on them.

IMO, they were a sledgehammer to swat a fly. Trade secrets would be reinvented. Locking an idea out of the commons for a whole patent term (and longer if they can attach new patents off the side) is a worse outcome.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by thaumasiotes on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:06AM (#10359254)
> What patents were set up to prevent, IIRC, was trade secrets - they were a way to bribe creators to publish their ideas rather than sit on them.

This is what I learned too. I can't for the life of me understand why the US has trade secret laws in addition to the patent laws. From some light reading on wikipedia, the answer seems to be "why do we need a reason?"

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by danarmak on Friday October 09, 2015 @08:56AM (#10359672)
For that matter, software or algorithms can be under copyright (may not publish), patent (must publish as part of the patent), and trade secret (may publish only if already public knowledge) at the same time.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by venomsnake on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:33AM (#10358998)
But on the other hand reproducing the result without reading the patent, should be able to invalidate said patent. If I don't care how you achieved the one click purchase button, I should be able to have my implementation on my page.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:45AM (#10359035)
Invalidating patents may not be so hard in the abstract, but the trouble is you have to fight a long and legally technical court case to do it. With no certainty of winning even if you are right.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rrmm on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:46AM (#10359040)
That's too low of a standard imo: just knowing something is possible and what that specific thing is, confers a lot of useful information.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by JulianMorrison on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:52AM (#10359055)
However, that argument also suggests that trade secrets are not much of a barrier to innovation.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rrmm on Friday October 09, 2015 @06:15AM (#10359126)
It definitely depends on the invention in question.

Consider the case of nuclear weapons. The first big leap is that the energy of fission can be made to be explosively released. Once you know that this is the case, most people in the field might be able to come up with something along the lines of a gun-type warhead.

On the other hand, implosion devices, even if you know they are possible, still require a huge amount of work and design studies to make work reliably. Knowing that they are possible isn't the hard part--making it work is.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by noir_lord on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:14AM (#10358927)
Talented people created things for thousands of years before patents.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by Cyph0n on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:21AM (#10358960)
People have lived thousands of years without refrigeration.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by ubernostrum on Friday October 09, 2015 @06:02AM (#10359086)
Actually, people have lived thousands of years with refrigeration. Insulated structures using evaporative cooling systems (capable of acting as air conditioners, or of maintaining near-freezing temperatures suitable for refrigeration) are known to date back to the 14th century BC.
Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by CamperBob2 on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:29AM (#10358980)
Refrigeration is an excellent example of something that could have easily been developed and refined without patent protection.

Consumers win when innovators compete with each other. Patents replace market competition with a foot race.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by oldmanjay on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:47AM (#10360822)
and yet somehow we have more technical innovation now than we ever did outside of a patent system.

there is a lot of emotional and assertive speculation around this issue but all of the hard facts that are available very strongly suggest patents work despite occasional (if highly publicized) conflict. how does your theory accommodate that fact?

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by CamperBob2 on Friday October 09, 2015 @03:52PM (#10362842)
Counterexample: how did the Internet and WWW ever evolve without a significant reliance on patents? How did the software industry in general ever flourish? The best we can say from empirical observation is that patents don't lead to guaranteed failure. We certainly can't say they're necessary.

If everything that could have been patented was patented, we'd all be poorer for it. Except the lawyers, of course.

Re:Gene patents probably dead worldwide following Australian... by rrmm on Friday October 09, 2015 @05:17AM (#10358941)
If there is any issue, I don't think that is it.

The issue that might arise is that techniques that are invented might never be openly published (since there wouldn't be protection for it).

For stuff that is obvious, it wouldn't matter because it is obvious. The non-obvious stuff--the stuff that actually does deserve a patent--might be lost on occasion.

I'm not a big fan of patents in general though given my experience with them (and certainly not patents on genes, etc).