News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by scriptman on Sunday June 07, 2015 @04:48AM (#9673875)
I think part of the problem with freemium is that it changes your perception of where the value lies. The user discounts the value of the free component to nothing and only measures the value of the additional functionality that is unlocked with buying the premium portion. A lot of the time, this looks like a ripoff.

The developer on the other hand tends to look at the value of the whole application and prices the premium portion in consideration of this.

I'm not sure that I have a solution, except to say that the developer might be more succesful to discount the value of the free portion to nothing as well and only price the premium portion at a rate that considers the actual value that it adds to the user experience. I think you have to consider the free portion as a marketing expense.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by Moru on Sunday June 07, 2015 @10:37AM (#9674766)
When I was working in retail ages ago this was said many times as advice for new companies starting out. "It's easier to lower the price when you don't sell enough than to raise the price on something that is selling well."

Today it seems to work this way: "We start with free stuff and then we try to find ways to make money later". I think this is part of why we have the customers we have today. They expect everything to be free and then give you 1 star reviews if the background color is off a shade.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by scriptman on Sunday June 07, 2015 @10:55AM (#9674859)
Today, that could be because devs tend to confuse how to measure success and keep a foot in multiple camps.

If you are trying to create a viral app, then giving your software away for free increases your chances of hitting the jackpot. But it decreases your chances of achieving steady cash flow in the short to medium term. If you charge upfront, then you probably aren't going to go viral. But you might be able to pay your costs. Freemium is an each way bet.

Everyone dreams of virality, but this dream might be sabotaging your nice, niche, steady earning app. You need to choose between your ego playing the app lottery or making small steady gains with real money. Sometimes going after virality is the right decision, but you have to look at your app and its target market and choose your charging model carefully.

As for the customers having low expectations, if the developers don't think that their software is worth anything, then it's probably not surprising that the customers agree.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by untog on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:29PM (#9675289)
Today, that could be because devs tend to confuse how to measure success

Devs/VCs. Or, rather, a VC is looking for a big sale down the road, not a company that makes steady income with low priced transactions.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by tonyedgecombe on Sunday June 07, 2015 @07:30AM (#9674214)
Not only that but 'customers' who don't pay can also be some of the more difficult people to deal with, they are the ones who leave a 1 start review instead of sending you a bug report.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by DamagedProperty on Sunday June 07, 2015 @11:01AM (#9674882)
Behavior Consistency. I recently learned about this phenomenon. People make decisions on an emotional level and then logically support them afterward. In fact, there are studies where people who have had their brain damaged and no longer process emotion have a really hard time, or simply can't, make decisions.

Someone has to emotionally decide to put X amount of hard earned money on something before hand. The rationalization of this affects the overall experience. When an item is free their commitment to the app was zero.

There was a fascinating study about this.

Festinger, L., & Carlsmith, J. M. (1959). Cognitive consequences of forced compliance. The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 58(2), 203.

Where participants were given a task to convince other people to perform a long and boring task. One group was given $1 to convince people while another group was given $20. They found the $1 dollar convincers actually believed what they were saying where as the $20 group shrugged off their actions to convince people to perform the boring task as, "I did it for the money." $1 was too low to rationalize away.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by Lawtonfogle on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @10:34AM (#9686129)
>Behavior Consistency. I recently learned about this phenomenon. People make decisions on an emotional level and then logically support them afterward.

This is something I wish more people understood. It explains so much of human behavior when you realize that all (most) rational reasoning is merely a justification of their already decided upon stance.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by frenchie14 on Sunday June 07, 2015 @03:58PM (#9676157)
On a somewhat related note, you may enjoy this TED talk if you haven't seen it. It's on the paradox of incentives and motivation: http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_pink_on_motivation?language=en
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by caseysoftware on Sunday June 07, 2015 @09:58AM (#9674623)
I think this is a key thing that is usually overlooked. When someone gets the app for free, they haven't self-qualified by paying and as a result they have zero personal investment. They don't want to "get their money's worth" or "look forward to the next version." Instead they get annoyed, leave a comment, and quickly forget about your app.

I think you should always charge something - even $0.99 - just to filter most of the casual users and get a more qualified (and invested) customer.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by orasis on Sunday June 07, 2015 @11:33AM (#9675023)
You should not charge anything if your app is semi-viral. I've done the experiments and charging kills growth for high retention apps.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by nstart on Sunday June 07, 2015 @10:11AM (#9674670)
If everyone did this (for cases where it actually mattered. Some app types are supported fine by in app ads) I would love to see how it would change the entire market perception towards paying for software. Right now it's viewed as a risk. A "should I make my app a paid for app or not?". I'd love to live in the utopia of developers simply being able to look at their creation, say that this is the value for it, and have people respect that.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by vijayr on Sunday June 07, 2015 @11:21AM (#9674970)
Charging money will definitely reduce the number of stupid comments, but that is not totally foolproof either. On Amazon, I've seen many times people leaving bad reviews (after paying for it) not because the product was bad, but because they understood the description wrong and hence the product did not meet their expectations. It is amazing how many people won't take 2 mins to actually read the description before buying.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by snowy on Sunday June 07, 2015 @10:17AM (#9674688)
I totally agree. I put an app on Google Play Store recently with a yearly subscription based payment for use. Even though it has a 10 day free trial I have people downloading it, leaving one star reviews without even trying the app and leaving reviews with the likes of 'Should be free'. Very disheartening..
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by ianlevesque on Sunday June 07, 2015 @04:24PM (#9676243)
This is representative of the Android user base in general. It's one reason you see so many iOS first apps despite the market share difference.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by soylentcola on Monday June 08, 2015 @11:13AM (#9679592)
And meanwhile, I keep using Android because I enjoy and prefer several things about the platform versus iOS and sometimes have to deal with an app being unavailable. It really is the one thing that I dislike about the platform. The freemium model (when done properly) is something I vastly prefer as well.

I look at it like the old shareware titles. I get a free demo that's either time limited or where I need to pay to unlock the full version. That way I can test the software or play the game or whatever, then if it's something that meets my needs, I can pay $1-10, secure in the knowledge that I won't be disappointed or surprised after buying something that turns out to be unwanted.

I'd say that the vast majority of apps and games I've purchased worked that way. Free download, mess with the app or play the first 5 levels of the game and then when I run into the limit where I need to pay, it's not a big deal because I know what I'm getting. The plague that is pay-to-win or other microtransactions in games is awful but that's probably not too relevant to this thread and is just as big a problem on iOS.

When I see the comments on the Play store or the App store, full of people complaining that the dev has the gall to ask for $1 or $2 for some useful or entertaining bit of code, it is very disappointing. That's the sort of money people pay for a Coke or to have someone drive a pizza 10 minutes to your house. I feel like if I get more than a day or two's use out of a mobile app, it's easily worth at least a buck or two and I'd vastly prefer to pay once than to deal with popup ads or recurring subscriptions and microtransactions.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by abhishm on Sunday June 07, 2015 @04:56AM (#9673895)
Yup. And the problem now is if its not free, your product is not going to get ANY users. I really hope, everyone starts rolling back on freemium, because its hurting everyone (except customers).
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by mhomde on Sunday June 07, 2015 @05:29AM (#9673968)
I would argue that it hurts customers too, at least for some apps. If a developer doesn't get constant revenue there'd be little incentive or resources to update and maintain the app.

The customers are then stuck with an app that might have been good but decays over time.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by glesica on Sunday June 07, 2015 @09:49AM (#9674595)
Until the next cool freemium app in that space comes out, then the customer just switches to that one.

The real problem is that we just don't need 80 gazillion apps. The "app" market is extremely competitive, that's really what people are complaining about, profits have been driven down to basically nothing. Normally you would expect some developers to drop out of the market, which would help the situation, but two things are stopping that from happening, in my opinion.

First, the platform companies (Apple and Google) have been incredibly successful at promoting app development as a gold mine. For every developer who gets sick of it and moves on to something else, two people become "app developers".

Second, there's a startup bubble and the wisdom out there says you need an app or your startup is nothing. This partly relates to the first point, the hype around "apps", even years after Apple launched the app store, is deafening.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by rokhayakebe on Sunday June 07, 2015 @11:54AM (#9675108)
App stores should try charging people $100/year after the first year an app is in the store.

Or the reverse, pay $100 to pull your app from the store after its first year.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by nostrademons on Sunday June 07, 2015 @01:23PM (#9675498)
I believe Apple does do this - it's $99/year to become an Apple Developer, and I think you need to be an Apple Developer to have an app in the app store.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by clarky07 on Sunday June 07, 2015 @04:30PM (#9676263)
It is $99/year to have apps in the App Store, but it is per developer account and not per app.

I almost think devs would be better off if it was per app. At least any devs planning to make a living off the store. It would cut down on a lot of the crappy spammy apps out there.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by detaro on Sunday June 07, 2015 @06:29PM (#9676555)
It would also kill the one-off hobby stuff with which many, especially teens, get their taste for (app) development, which would be a high price to pay. Without a secondary path to distribute apps I think it would be a bad idea.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by abhishm on Sunday June 07, 2015 @08:34AM (#9674394)
yeah
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by amelius on Sunday June 07, 2015 @08:41AM (#9674413)
In my opinion, freemium is a form of predatory pricing.

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predatory_pricing

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by DamagedProperty on Sunday June 07, 2015 @10:48AM (#9674828)
I do believe many companies are employing this practice with freemium apps. There is something bigger happening here with freemium. At first we all called it "race to the bottom" pricing. And if felt like that. If felt like the value of our apps were dwindling to stay competitive.

But let's just look at how things were for a second. If you sold an app for 4.99 you making a promise to the consumer that you would deliver value equal or greater than your price. And you if you didn't keep that promise it was up to the consumer to get a refund or suck it up. This was largely a pre-internet thing. The internet has made distribution a non-issue. Now you can get your products and ideas out there for little to no cost.

What we are seeing is an opportunity to show initial value to our users and offer higher value at a premium. This increases the reach of our work and helps us to find those 1000 true fans. Of course, we have to nurture those relationships. It's a lot of work.

I don't think there is anything wrong with premium pricing. People are use to it still. Why aren't we just focusing on the value we bring to people and whether it's premium or freemium none of it would be an issue.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by ohitsdom on Sunday June 07, 2015 @09:07AM (#9674501)
It can be done responsibly. But unfortunately, I agree it's mostly predatory.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by soylentcola on Monday June 08, 2015 @11:25AM (#9679658)
Freemium can mean several things. I've purchased several apps (and generally paid more for them) when there was a free download that offers some functionality and the option to pay for the full version. Sometimes these are games where the first chapter is free and then you pay $5 for the full game after you've played a bit. It lowers the "friction" for the customer because you get to try something out at no cost but if you enjoy the first hour of play, you're more confident that you'll enjoy the other 5 hours.

Other times these are utilities. The Philips Hue lamps have an official app that's passable but the third party "Hue Pro" adds functionality. The free version does basically what the Phiilps app does or you can pay $2 and unlock all of the "fun" addons like music sync and lava lamp mode. Once I know that the app works and isn't buggy, I'm glad to pay. Same for launchers like Nova. Free version is a nice launcher that I vastly prefer to the stock launcher but I can pay a few bucks and get several more options. I probably wouldn't have paid $3 times 4 or 5 launchers just to find the one I liked but once I tried all of the free versions, I paid for the full version of the one I liked best.

It's like shareware. With the glut of options, you don't want to pay every time you try several solutions to find the best one so you try a bunch then buy the best. If I had to pay $1-10 to try every app on my phone, I'd just install less apps (or, to be honest, I'd probably try cracked copies to find the best option, then buy the best one).

As long as the quality of mobile apps is so varied, it really is hard to convince potential customers to pay any amount of money sight unseen. I've installed so many iOS and Android apps that lasted a total of 10 minutes on my devices it's not even funny. If I paid even $1 for each of them to learn those lessons, it would've turned me off to buying mobile apps at all.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by onewaystreet on Sunday June 07, 2015 @06:57AM (#9674142)
There are a few apps that are making a lot of money from the freemium model. As long as that continues other developers will chase that dream.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by abhishm on Sunday June 07, 2015 @08:37AM (#9674399)
Hmm.. which all are? Its hardly even a choice. As a consumer myself, anything not free doesn't interest me anymore. Companies are spoiling consumers (including me) silly.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by onewaystreet on Sunday June 07, 2015 @10:37AM (#9674763)
Look at the apps on the top grossing chart. Supercell, for example, makes over a billion a year.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by e12e on Sunday June 07, 2015 @01:11PM (#9675468)
I'm not sure freemium games with in-app purchases are a very good model for apps in general (I'm not saying you're suggesting anything other than that they make a lot of money, just pointing it out in the context of this discussion).

It's hard for me to see how they're anything but a form of unregulated (yet) gambling/exploitation of people vulnerable to gambling.

Who in their right minds think that tens, hundreds of dollars is a good price to pay for virtual gemstones?

At any rate, for others that where unfamiliar with Supercell, I'm assuming parent means the makers of:

https://thinkgaming.com/app-sales-data/1/clash-of-clans/

A somewhat related article:

http://www.theguardian.com/technology/shortcuts/2013/mar/26/...

(And there's of course been a number of articles on "predatory" game design, based around compulsive/addictive behaviour)

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by nsgi on Sunday June 07, 2015 @06:28AM (#9674082)
Interesting. How does this fit with the common advice (from patio11, etc.) that developers generally underprice their software?
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by Chris_Newton on Sunday June 07, 2015 @10:26AM (#9674722)
It’s worth remembering that when people give that advice on HN, it’s usually in a business-to-business context. Business-to-consumer sales are a different thing entirely, with different motivations and often a different purchasing process. Consumer purchasing behaviour can be highly price-sensitive (and affected by numerous other factors as well as price) so for software or a service with low marginal costs, offering lower prices with greater numbers of sales can easily work out better than higher prices but fewer sales.
Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by nostrademons on Sunday June 07, 2015 @01:26PM (#9675514)
Patio11 is working in a different domain than mass-market products. He deals with niches; by raising your price in a niche, you find a different niche that is willing to pay more, which by definition will make you more profit.

This basically never works with the mass market, because the mass market, by definition, contains all those people who can't afford to pay more. To make a mass-market product work, you basically need a vision as to how everyone on earth should be doing things differently than they're currently doing them, and the sales and product skills to convince users of that vision.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by e12e on Sunday June 07, 2015 @01:24PM (#9675502)
I'm no expert either, but I don't think this only applies in b2b scenarios. There's some old anecdotes about new restaurants pricing themselves too low, failing to gain customers (due to being perceived as too cheap/must be low quality). After raising prices, serving the same food, they suddenly got more customers. Similar stories for retail (yes, anecdotes are not data -- but AFAIK this kind of thing is marketing 101).

I've not seen any studies on this wrt app stores, but my impression is that you can be completely free (and it helps with a brand name, like Autocad or Adobe) -- or you can be a little pricey with no free trial -- and still be perceived as being "high quality".

Note that big companies offering great apps for free is most likely a case of predatory pricing -- they might not have any ambition of making money from the apps ... ever. But if it funnels a certain percentage into their for-pay other apps/services that might be an acceptable price to pay for marketing.

Add a free trial, freemium, or low price point -- and your app is likely to be judged more harshly.

The price points/perceptions are likely a little different in the various app stores too, and vary a bit from country to country (eg: median salaries (and median prices for a cup of coffee) are likely to affect what people think are reasonable value for money).

I do think many developers dream of getting a big number of users, and tend to overestimate how quickly success should come. I would guess that getting a hundred paying users should be an important milestone, and depending on the app, one might need to keep those around for quite a while (a year?) before one might really start to see an effect of word-of-mouth in terms of sales. This isn't nearly as sexy as getting to one billion users in a year, but probably more realistic?

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by scriptman on Sunday June 07, 2015 @07:49AM (#9674267)
I'm not an expert like patio11 or others, but I think that it could be that developers aren't always as interested in economics as they should be and this can lead to not understanding the behaviour of markets.

Technically, developers have to underprice their software to be successful. This is true for any product or service that you want to sell. Particularly for productivity focused software, the end user has to derive signficantly more in value than they pay in direct costs to the developer. In general, in my experience involved with b2b software/services, people want to being saving 20-30% of their time or money to strongly consider changing their existing habits.

The reason for this is that there are also indirect costs that the end user incurs that developers don't always take into account in their cost models. End users incur costs in learning new software products, there are ongoing cognitive load costs in remembering how to use the product and there are opportunity costs in choosing your products over something else, not even necessarily in the same market. There is a cost that the user incurs in taking a risk that your software will solve their problem before they really understand its full capability. Even taking up an icon space on their phone/tablet/desktop has a cost to the user as it's a place they can't put a different app. Your app takes up harddrive space that the user has paid for and your app uses up some of their bandwidth. Finally, you aren't just competing against other software vendors in your market, you are competing against every other thing in any market the end user might want to spend their money on. End users have a limited amount of money and time and there are a huge amount of things they can spend their money on.

You can't accurately measure any of these indirect costs, but you know they are there and you can estimate them. When you take into account the indirect costs suddenly there aren't as many dollars left on the table that developers aren't charging for.

Another point is that the closer you price your software to its marginal utility to the end user, the more likely the end user is going to shop around looking for alternatives. You open yourself up to competition which could increase your marketing expenses. You could also suffer more churn, which is expensive to you.

The point is, you want your users feeling like they are getting amazing value from your product. You don't want them feeling like your product costs just a bit less than the value they derive (which may seem like the most efficient price to you) because if that's the case your business is actually teetering over a precipice and any sudden shock could push you over the edge with many customers leaving all at once. Loyal, happy customers paying you recurring revenue buffing up your cash flow is worth more than anything.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by zzzcpan on Sunday June 07, 2015 @10:19AM (#9674696)
> The user discounts the value of the free component to nothing and only measures the value of the additional functionality that is unlocked with buying the premium portion.

I think you could solve this by having two distinct websites, apps or even brands. It's not going to feel like a ripoff if they are perceived very differently from each other.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by scriptman on Sunday June 07, 2015 @10:31AM (#9674747)
Sorry, I have to disagree.

If you did this, why would you even have the free version? The whole point of the free portion is to act as feeder for the paid version. If the branding is completely separate then how are the users going to know they can have the same level of confidence in the paid version as what they do in the free version? May as well not have the free version at all.

Re:How I killed app sales by going freemium by zzzcpan on Sunday June 07, 2015 @10:38AM (#9674769)
> how are the users going to know they can have the same level of confidence in the paid version as what they do in the free version?

You are going to tell them. Kind of like this: "Need more space? Try our paidapp."