News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by cwyers on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:15PM (#9663694)
The low-end Alienware box has specs that don't meet the minimum requirements for Batman Arkham Knight, one of the few AAA titles coming out this year that supports SteamOS. And it costs more than either the Xbox One or Playstation 4, both of which will run Arkham Knight fine. I think Steam Machines are a failure waiting to happen. PC enthusiasts can get a Steam Link for $50 for most of the benefits of this. And people who aren't PC enthusiasts have no reason to buy these over a console.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by jcastro on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:12AM (#9663856)
The existing Alienware Alpha (which is basically what the SteamOS box is) benches about the same as an Nvidia GTX 750Ti, which outpowers both the XBox One and the PS4. It should have no problem matching or exceeding either console's performance, just like the existing Alpha.

The debut price is about the same as the PS4/XBone, but doesn't include the monthly fee for multiplayer, and if you look at the long-term total cost of ownership it's cheaper than a console, especially when you consider that in the future you can upgrade to new hardware without rebuying your games, which consoles cannot guarantee.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:23AM (#9663889)
> The existing Alienware Alpha (which is basically what the SteamOS box is) benches about the same as an Nvidia GTX 750Ti, which outpowers both the XBox One and the PS4. It should have no problem matching or exceeding either console's performance, just like the existing Alpha.

Except that it runs on Linux, which has less performing drivers than on Windows, and Linux ports are usually far less optimized than their Windows counterparts as well (which is not hard to understand since most games are made with DX in mind).

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by jcastro on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:44AM (#9663935)
Steam Machines don't compete with Windows, they're complementary to existing Windows machines (game streaming); they directly compete with Xbox/PS4.

Most Steam Machines are Nvidia based, which makes sense, they have the best drivers, and they're generally 1:1 as performant as their windows drivers. I have a GTX970 in my Ubuntu machine and it rocks, supports my gsync monitor and everything; trumping console performance is pretty much a no-brainer with modern nvidia maxwell stuff...

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:52AM (#9663952)
> Steam Machines don't compete with Windows, they're complementary to existing Windows machines (game streaming); they directly compete with Xbox/PS4.

I hope you are joking, because branding-wise the Steam Machines are a clear mess and completely confusing for people who don't know how to read PC specs. Hell, you have Steam Machines planned with only Intel HD graphics and also called "Steam Machines" just like the Alienware Alpha and the Syber ones, while power-wise they fall in totally different categories. That's the best way to kill your brand, at least 3DO never did that kind of mistake.

> they're generally 1:1 as performant as their windows drivers.

No, this is clearly false. I don't know where you get this impression, check almost every benchmark out therefore for Borderlands 2, CS:GO, Witcher 2, Bioshock Infinite and almost every other AAA game out there, you will see that the Linux performance is clearly behind. I'm a Linux gamer as well but at least I don't pretend we are at the same level as Windows, because that's a clear lie at this point.

> trumping console performance is pretty much a no-brainer with modern nvidia maxwell stuff...

It should be, but many ports on Linux are far from being optimized (some rely on OpenGL 3.x to maintain compatibility with AMD while it's clearly less efficient than OpenGL 4.x calls) while console ports are much more likely to be tested thoroughly on a single hardware based and optimized for it.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by efuquen on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:34AM (#9664312)
> Hell, you have Steam Machines planned with only Intel HD graphics and also called "Steam Machines" just like the Alienware Alpha and the Syber ones, while power-wise they fall in totally different categories. That's the best way to kill your brand, at least 3DO never did that kind of mistake.

Replace "Steam Machines" with "Andriod" and you could make the exact same arguments. And the thing is people have, and they have been to an extent completely correct. But, I don't think you would say Android hasn't been a very successful bet for Google, despite the fragmentation and huge range of quality for different mobile devices, and the problems with branding they have. What I'm seeing is Valve trying to make the exact same play in the console world, where Microsoft and Sony have it locked down very much the same way Apple did (or was on the way to doing) with the smartphones. They want to break people out of those walled gardens and bring them into their ecosystem, and they're going to provide an open platform for any hardware maker to do it, just like Android did.

Of course mobile phones and consoles are two different industries, it might play out in a similar way or it might play out completely differently. But I think it's a bit premature to write it off as ridiculous or even a bad idea from the start when there is precedent for this sort of strategy working in other industries. It certainly has a chance of playing out well for Valve, branding and fragmentation be damned, as long as it opens up a much larger audience to Steam.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ZeroGravitas on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:27AM (#9664611)
Agreed, plus, Steam is already "fragmented" on it's home turf of desktop PCs:

http://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/videocard/

And every time I've looked at that list, Intel integrated graphics have been fairly prominent.

Some of the arguments against the steam machines make me feel like I've fallen into some weird "console vs pc" propaganda war, rather than a factual discussion about business strategies.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:01AM (#9664393)
I get the Android comparison, but I don't think it is very much relevant. People don't always get Android phones by choice, and they get a phone ANYWAY because they need a phone.

For consoles, the choice is already very clear out there and the well known brands are Xbox, Nintendo and Sony, period. You can see how nVidia is struggling to establish their Shield brand in the market by the way, as a good indication of how hard it is to enter the market. There is nobody who "needs" Steam Machines out there right now, because they already either have a console, a PC or both if they actually care.

And additionally, Valve is too risk-averse to actually build and sell hardware by themselves (or even take a NEXUS approach like Google), which makes me think they don't even believe in the Steam Machines themselves. We will see.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by monk_e_boy on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:03AM (#9664542)
Actually there are a few people (like myself, my brother and a bunch of our friends) who are waiting to see what the steam machines will be like. We're still using xbox360, wii, laptops etc to game on. Now looking to upgrade sometime this year... we've been waiting for steam machines... but the specs are way too confusing.

I just about understand nvidia cards and the numbering system, but how they interact with i5/i7 and different memory?

(cue 1,000 geeks who will try and educate me)

I just want to buy a box that is better than XBoxOne at the same price. At this rate I think a used XBoxOne off ebay is a better option. Let steam machines bake for a year or so.

The worst thing that can happen for steam machines is when 99 people buy the budget version and 1 person buys the dream machine, the 99 people see the dream machine beat their budget machines and now you've got 99 disappointed customers and 1 happy customer.

This doesn't happen with playstation, wiiU or xbox. Steam machines are going to fail and I'm pretty gutted about that.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by Shivetya on Friday June 05, 2015 @06:13AM (#9664708)
Honestly why don't they have an easy to understand rating system? Specs do nothing for me, having been out of the PC gaming market for ages since I swapped to Mac. I do have a basic understanding of the CPUs and GPUs but when you combine X with Y and throw in W, what do I have?

Give me a solid number so I can compare machines quickly. How much Steam does my SteamMachine have?

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by DanBC on Friday June 05, 2015 @06:25AM (#9664731)
Because this year's "Steam grade 1" will be next year's "Steam grade three".

Even if you include a date - "Steam 2016 grade 1" you're going to need some kind of comparison table to work out if your game ("runs on 'steam 2017 grade 3'") will work on your machine or not.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by e12e on Friday June 05, 2015 @09:56AM (#9665502)
Oh, I don't know. They could just take some aggregate standard benchmark, and coerce it down to an integer. Have higher numbers be strictly better. Sure, you might get box makers trying to game it, but it would still be better than "here's some specs, you figure it out".

After a recent review of low-end (well, compared to an i7) AMD apus paired with high-end gpus[1], I'm not even sure most "professionals" can get anything meaningful out of specs alone. Sure an i7 with ddr4 is "better" than a dual-core AMD APU -- but if your target is 1080p gaming, it might not be much of a difference -- given the same GPU.

So it shouldn't be that hard make the statement "runs on Steambox rated 24 or higher" be true for all generations of steamboxes. Even when that'll have to be changed from 24 to 24000.

[1] http://www.anandtech.com/show/9307/the-kaveri-refresh-godava...

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by tehbeard on Friday June 05, 2015 @09:55AM (#9665498)
Invert your categorization direction. (same as SD cards, Class 10 > Class 8...)
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:21AM (#9664587)
> I just want to buy a box that is better than XBoxOne at the same price. At this rate I think a used XBoxOne off ebay is a better option. Let steam machines bake for a year or so.

Honestly the XboxOne has more value, right now, than the Steam Machines in terms of how well games will run on it. But you can say that the Steam Machines may have more games (but not as many that you can play with a joypad - since some PC games require a keyboard anyway). It's not a straightforward comparison, and it depends a lot on what games you want to play in the end. If you want AAA games, right now it looks like the Xbox one is a better option, but maybe that will change later in 2016. Who knows...

> now you've got 99 disappointed customers and 1 happy customer.

Which is precisely why they should have setup minimum specs for their Steam Machines, or at least have a Valve Steam Machine that sets the standard. But Valve did not do that, and I am also concerned they will fail precisely because of that.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by Robadob on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:09AM (#9665965)
>But you can say that the Steam Machines may have more games (but not as many that you can play with a joypad - since some PC games require a keyboard anyway).

Apparently the steam controller is designed to be a suitable replacement for a keyboard/mouse, and will include a system for sharing controller mappings for games over steam.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:25AM (#9666062)
> Apparently the steam controller is designed to be a suitable replacement for a keyboard/mouse, and will include a system for sharing controller mappings for games over steam.

I have tried the Steam controller (the beta version from a while ago) and it is certainly not as easy to use at they make it look like. It certainly takes a while to get used to it.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by Robadob on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:38PM (#9668347)
It's understandable that it will take a while to get used to (it's a fairly new interface/form factor combination for an input device), a Valve employee on Reddit has confirmed that the steam controller use in the launch video was live action[1] and that the programmer who designed the keyboard interface can type faster than him on a standard keyboard using it.[2]

So it might require practise, but according to this anecdotal evidence, it has the potential (if your dedicated enough) to form a suitable replacement.

[1] http://www.reddit.com/r/Steam/comments/38jcel/introducing_th...

[2] http://www.reddit.com/r/Steam/comments/38jcel/introducing_th...

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by jcastro on Friday June 05, 2015 @01:16AM (#9663990)
> I hope you are joking, because branding-wise the Steam Machines are a clear mess and completely confusing for people who don't know how to read PC specs.

The entire point of Steam Machines is not to deal with this, just buy the cheapest Alienware, done. If you care about that sort of thing, you buy a different one.

> check almost every benchmark out therefore for Borderlands 2, CS:GO, Witcher 2, Bioshock Infinite and almost every other AAA game out there.

Doesn't matter. I have an Alienware Alpha and I can get 60 fps on every one of these games in SteamOS, as least as good as the modern consoles, Windows performance it depends; some are better, some are not; all TVs and projectors are 60hz, so unless someone is coming out with 144hz gsync TVs, then it's more than fine.

Sure, we get boned by games like Dying Light, but that's just software, totally fixable.

> t should be, but many ports on Linux are far from being optimized

You could make that argument about any crossplatform game.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by dagw on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:46AM (#9664351)
The entire point of Steam Machines is not to deal with this, just buy the cheapest Alienware, done.

Except that obviously won't work. In the console world I really don't have to deal with this. I buy a PS4 at launch and I can play every PS4 game that comes out from now until they stop making PS4 games. That is obviously not with Steam Machines. Will the cheapest Steam Machine play every SteamOS game that comes out in 2 years time without problem? If the answer is 'no' then it is something that I have to be aware of and deal with.

The other option is that Valve steps in and says that if you want your game to be SteamOS certified it must be optimized to run well on the slowest Steam Machine we've ever released, but I wonder if they're willing to that. Can you imagine telling game developers in 2017 that they must make their games work fine on 2015 era Intel graphics cards?

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by rtpg on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:13AM (#9664418)
>Can you imagine telling game developers in 2017 that they must make their games work fine on 2015 era Intel graphics cards?

This is totally fine for loads of indie games already. And If you replace 2015 with 2013, of course you could do this. PC technology has slowed down a lot compared to 10 years ago, and it's not the constant upgrading it used to be.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by dagw on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:04AM (#9664966)
Sure it's fine for loads of games, but unless it's fine for all games you're going to have to produce an N tiered system of steam machines (maybe class them on an A-E scale, and developers write something like "must have a C or better steam machine) and and the consumer is going to have to deal with system specs just like they do today (and just like they don't have to with consoles).
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @09:48AM (#9665449)
> PC technology has slowed down a lot compared to 10 years ago, and it's not the constant upgrading it used to be.

You know that VR is coming right?

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by monk_e_boy on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:10AM (#9664557)
This HAS to happen otherwise Steam Machines are useless. Sure, in a few years Steam Machine Two will come out, then games can target that if they want.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by tingol on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:56AM (#9665185)
On the other side of the coin they WILL stop making PS4 games, just like all consoles when they reach EOL. Yet you can play new games on a steam machine in decades to come.

You can play 2017 games on lower graphics quality (the same quality you get in 2015 games now) just like the consoles. Even if the games they get on the PS4 in 2017 are new, they are bound to remain the same quality in graphics.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by dagw on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:09AM (#9665586)
you can play new games on a steam machine in decades to come.

Decades? Decade, maybe. But then again they where still releasing PS2 games a decade after the PS2 came out and they'll almost certainly be releasing PS3 and Xbox360 games a decade after those consoles came out too.

No doubt that there will be lots of games coming out in both 2017 and 2020 that will run just fine on a 2015 steam machine, but unless it is ever single game they release for SteamOS, then we're right back to the classic PC gaming problem and you've lost the only real competitive advantage that consoles have.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @09:47AM (#9665441)
> Yet you can play new games on a steam machine in decades to come.

Where? Good luck playing something on a 2014 Steam Machine in 2024. If there is still one game 10 years later working on such a configuration that will be a miracle. PC gaming moves very fast, that's the point of PC gaming usually : you upgrade often.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by jackmaney on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:49PM (#9666503)
> that's the point of PC gaming usually : you upgrade often.

No. That hasn't been the case for years, now. I built a machine in 2010, and gave it its first upgrade a couple of months ago.

And to tell the truth, I could've gone on a couple years more before I really needed to upgrade. The biggest bottleneck was the GPU (an nVidia GTX 460). However, I splurged on a few upgrades (GTX 960, up to 16GB of RAM (from 8), and an SSD). It's once again a beast, even with the same CPU from 2010 (AMD Phenom II X6 1090T).

And that extra money that I've put into this system? I've made most of it back in the way of cheaper games.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:45AM (#9664187)
> The entire point of Steam Machines is not to deal with this, just buy the cheapest Alienware, done. If you care about that sort of thing, you buy a different one.

Yeah, and then complain that the newest games in 2016 don't run well on your hardware, while you thought it was just like a console! What a surprise!

> I can get 60 fps on every one of these games in SteamOS

Put in ultra details, with anti aliasing maxed up, and I'll be very surprised if you still get steady 60 fps, in all honesty. And oh, it's been benchmarked that anti-aliasing makes the performance go down significantly, I'll get numbers for you if you don't believe me.

> Sure, we get boned by games like Dying Light, but that's just software, totally fixable.

Yeah, except that it has taken them 3 months to fix to an acceptable level. Please explain that to consumers buying it on Day 1. Oh, and remember, they are "console gamers" since you said so, so I hope you enjoy the fun communication with people who don't care about specs or optimization or drivers.

> You could make that argument about any crossplatform game.

Yes, except that the requirements for Linux ports are usually higher than for Windows. Source: Steam requirements. Again, please go explain that to console gamers.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by abroncs on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:09AM (#9664245)
Custom built high end PCs have problems getting 60fps at ultra with maxxed AA in some games. Literally nobody is expecting such performance from these machines.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by reacweb on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:58AM (#9664387)
I do not know for steam os, but I am using ubuntu since many years and I do not tweak much my system. Each time I encounter a crash, a couple of days latter, there is a fix that is automatically installed (apt-get update, upgrade).

I imagine that steamOS can update drivers transparently to have always best configuration for gaming. The support team will only need to answer clients when a fix will arrive automatically.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ismot on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:29AM (#9664296)
>check almost every benchmark out therefore for Borderlands 2, CS:GO, Witcher 2, Bioshock Infinite and almost every other AAA game out there

That's not really a good benchmark, if drivers is the thing you want to compare.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by SolarNet on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:34AM (#9664469)
NVIDIA is really pushing though, they are moving up in the Linux developer commit charts [0]. In a few months they might be close enough to parity on the SteamOS (which likely could involve some proprietary code) for it not to matter.

[0] https://lwn.net/Articles/631509/

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by 0xFFC on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:51AM (#9664663)
Yes , Exactly , They have big plans for android and gaming(Shield line).They need excellent linux support for that .
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by 4ydx on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:35AM (#9664316)
You might want to vet your list. Witcher 2 is not a native linux game. I cannot comment on the other games.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:03AM (#9664396)
Does not matter, people who buy "consoles" don't care what is native or not. They just care if their game runs well.

And additionally, Witcher 2 is not really using a wrapper, at least not in the WINE sense of the word. Witcher 2 uses eON which basically does conversion of DirectX calls to OpenGL calls at compile time, not execution time. So it's arguably pretty close to native.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by squeaky-clean on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:20AM (#9665649)
> I have a GTX970 in my Ubuntu machine and it rocks, supports my gsync monitor and everything; trumping console performance is pretty much a no-brainer with modern nvidia maxwell stuff

Yeah, when your graphics cards costs mores than the entire console (Groupon has a deal right now for a $304 Xbox One without Kinect, and the cheapest GTX970 on PCPartpicker is a Zotac at $310.95), that tends to happen.

> Steam Machines don't compete with Windows, they're complementary to existing Windows machines (game streaming)

Sure they do. If anything, they compete against Windows much more than they do against consoles. There are reasons to own both a console and gaming PC. There's no reason to have a Windows gaming PC and a Steam Machine. Windows is a superset of a Steam Machine's gaming capabilities. The main reason for people owning a gaming console along with a gaming PC are the exclusive games, people will buy an entire Xbone for Halo or Destiny. There are no Steam Machine or Linux exclusive games.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by higherpurpose on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:03AM (#9664962)
Once the Vulkan drivers are in (and the games written for it) I'd expect Linux to have even better performance than Windows in gaming.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by girvo on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:46AM (#9663940)
> Except that it runs on Linux, which has less performing drivers than on Windows

Thats... not quite true, interestingly enough. Excuse the ZDNet link: http://www.zdnet.com/article/valve-linux-runs-our-games-fast...

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:49AM (#9663946)
That's a clear exception. Even CS:GO from Valve runs slower than the Windows version. All other recent benchmarks keep showing Windows ahead in FPS for the same games running on Linux. And hey, I'm a Linux gamer (almost exclusively these days), and for me this is not a problem, but it's just a fact.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by reddotX on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:06AM (#9664097)
Ubuntu 15.04 vs Windows 8.1 : Team Fortress 2 benchmark with a GTX 680 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dK7uEv8LTYU
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @09:50AM (#9665463)
You know that in that video, Windows wins clearly in FPS in high settings right ?
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by cwyers on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:42AM (#9665790)
And who cares about benchmarks for games on DirectX 9? Especially since the OpenGL port was made nearly 7 years after the DirectX version was released, and it's possible Valve could have made all sorts of optimizations based on advances in the meantime (either in their understanding of rendering or being able to take advantage of features that are in the newest versions of OpenGL but weren't around in a DirectX 9).
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by bad_user on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:30AM (#9664147)
So now we aren't discussing that there are no games for Linux, but about the performance of Linux games. What an odd world we live in.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by WalterGR on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:00AM (#9664536)

    What an odd world we live in.
Do you mean that discussing the performance of Linux games is an unfair moving of the goalposts, or that it's odd that Linux caught on enough that we're now discussing the performance of Linux games rather than just their existence?
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:40AM (#9664178)
I think there is still a problem of "not enough developers supporting Linux" - that issue is not completely gone yet, while it has massively improved. The next step is having a stronger adoption from devs + first-citizen kind of performance. But I agree with your sentiment, the improvement has been massive in the past 2 years.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by venomsnake on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:18AM (#9664436)
Well ... with the incoming low level apis support on linux should be easier. You need only disk access, network sockets, sound and audio system to make a game. First two are solved problems multiplaform-wise. Remove the drivers from the equations and there is no good reason why porting should take a lot of work.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:25AM (#9664454)
There are many tools used for Game development that are platform specific and have no Linux version. That's also why some porting efforts are stalled currently.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by reddotX on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:02AM (#9664081)
i've seen some game reviews with the linux version running faster on Ubuntu than Windows
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by cwyers on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:33AM (#9665730)
> The existing Alienware Alpha (which is basically what the SteamOS box is) benches about the same as an Nvidia GTX 750Ti, which outpowers both the XBox One and the PS4. It should have no problem matching or exceeding either console's performance, just like the existing Alpha.

It's a lot easier to optimize for the Xbox One or the PS4 than it is PC games, because there's only two hardware targets for console games, and so you don't have to code around drivers or corner cases that only affect some users, you can optimize to your heart's content and everyone has hardware identical to what you're testing on. Being more powerful than an Xbox One or PS4 is not the same as being able to run the same games well.

Cost of ownership is a more complicated question than you posit here -- you have to buy new hardware more often, and if you're taking advantage of the in-home streaming feature to fill the massive AAA gap these things have, it's almost impossible to recapture the cost of TWO gaming PCs compared to the cost of one Xbox/PS by saving money on games.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by jsingleton on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:05AM (#9664398)
You can't really compare hardware specifications between a PC and a console to get an idea of relative performance. Developers are able to squeeze a lot more performance from consoles as they aren't running a full OS and other things in the background. They are much more consistent so you don't need to leave as much leeway.

At least that used to be the case. Perhaps the modern generation of consoles are so complex that they can be compared to PCs.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by greggyb on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:10PM (#9667005)
XBox will run Windows 10, so I think your final statement seems accurate.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by cwyers on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:57PM (#9667326)
The Raspberry Pi will run Windows 10. I don't know that "running Windows 10" is a meaningful indicator of anything in this context. It's certainly not running the same sort of Windows 10 that desktop and laptop PCs are running -- Windows Universal apps will be able to run on it, but traditional Win32 apps (like any Windows game on Steam) won't run on the Xbox One.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by valgaze on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:46AM (#9664191)
It seems like the big gripe with consoles is that there's a performance ceiling and the supposed benefit of a PC is that there simply is no ceiling. The game can look as rad as you want to pay for.

But consoles have something that PCs don't-- a floor. If a kiddo buys any piece content for their xbox or whatever, the darn thing will run guaranteed and be pretty OK.

The same definitely not true for new a piece of content on a PC.

PC's might not have a performance ceiling but they probably need a baseline floor. MAYBE these Steam Machines can help rectify it for down/middle market.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by adamc on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:36AM (#9665092)
That's all true. If that was the only factor I might stick with consoles -- however, PCs have something else: A much more diverse collection of games. I'm interested in Steam machines largely because I would like to play PC games in a more Xbox-like way.

The fact that it will result in more games running on Linux is also a plus (for me).

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by zamalek on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:15AM (#9664572)
> Alienware

There's your problem right there. "No true gamer" would ever take Alienware seriously as there is a massive brand markup. You are paying for the logo on the box. The stuff in the box is obsolete when it hits the shelves. Look at practically any other brand if you want to see competent pricing.

Alienware are good business machines (as they do have unmatched post-sales support). They aren't gaming machines, not even at a basic competency level.

It's a big pity that Valve partnered with these extortionists, it's no good for the platform.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ZeroGravitas on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:22AM (#9664590)
I don't think Valve will be crying themselves to sleep if you buy a $50 dollar streaming box and a $50 dollar controller, and then continue to buy games on their service, instead of spending an extra $300 dollars (which will mostly go to the people producing the hardware) to get a system that's less reliant on your internal wifi.

Either way it's a beachhead for them in the living room, and as computing devices become smaller, and cheaper over time, (and Linux game support increases) they're better and better positioned.

I'm kind of adjacent to the demographic for this thing. I don't have a high-end gaming PC, but I have Steam installed on my Mac laptop (Mac and Linux support are basically the same in Steam) for mostly indie/classic/old games. Notably, you can't stream Steam games from the Mac currently (though I don't think there's a fundamental technical reason for that, edit: hmm, the info page seems to suggest I can stream games if I update to Yosemite).

If I didn't already have a Wii U for living room gaming, I'd probably buy one of these boxes. I might still, depending on how useful the hardware is for other purposes.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by jfoster on Friday June 05, 2015 @01:37AM (#9664034)
Where are the specs? All I'm seeing is "NVIDIA® GeForce® GTX GPU 2GB GDDR5 graphics and Intel® Core processors."

Which spec doesn't meet the minimum for Arkham Knight?

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by shurcooL on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:17PM (#9663703)
Consoles don't support Oculus Rift though. It might be great to satisfy that need while being lower maintenance than a normal PC.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by cwyers on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:22PM (#9663729)
The Rift demands a pretty hefty graphics card, and most of these don't have one. Alienware is shipping laptop GPUs in their Steam Machines, and Oculus is particular about how the GPU is connected to the output port:

https://www.oculus.com/blog/powering-the-rift/

I would not buy any of these and expect them to work well with the Oculus Rift.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by mkozlows on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:21PM (#9663720)
Oculus doesn't support SteamOS, either -- non-Windows versions are "on hold." But there's Valve/HTC's VR stuff, still.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by shurcooL on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:22AM (#9664278)
Oh crap, you're right. I forgot about that.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by greggman on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:47PM (#9663786)
Consoles do support Morpheus though
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:31AM (#9663913)
You mean only the PS4, which is not "All consoles".
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by tracker1 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:31PM (#9663752)
I have to mostly agree.. I think we're still 2-years from a hardware generation at a cost where generic hardware can support Steam OS (and top-tier games) at a decent price point for 1080p output.

I think that Steam Link with their controller is a pretty compelling option though. I also think that the nVidia Shield tablet was also an interesting approach... I'm hoping that the first generation of this hardware doesn't bomb too much... The mid-range systems should have enough oomph to come out over current gen consoles, one niggle is that I'd rather see hybrid or straight SSD drives when you're coming to that level of cost.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by cwyers on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:44PM (#9663783)
I also feel like Valve has missed the boat by having no video functionality on this. Consoles and regular PCs have Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime Instant, HBO Go, Plex... I don't expect them to have all that at launch, but Netflix has shown that they will go pretty much everywhere. Not getting Netflix on board means that they aren't even trying.

EDIT: And no optical drives in the Alienware machines as far as I can tell, so no using it as a Blu-ray player either.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:25AM (#9663893)
Valve mentioned in the past they would be bringing Video and Music with "partners" and indeed they are very late on this, unless they have a surprise announcement later down the road.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by voltagex_ on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:15AM (#9663867)
Stream the Chrome app tab for Netflix.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by chaostheory on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:48PM (#9663787)
Maybe a better approach would be to have a 'Steam Certified' badge on traditional PCs instead? Otherwise this vaguely reminds me of an improved version of 3DO's business strategy.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by cwyers on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:52PM (#9663806)
I haven't seen Valve advance a reason for these to exist outside of their worry at having to compete with Microsoft on their own platform. Which as a reason is completely besides the point for the consumer, which I think is why we have these confusing machines that combine the worst aspects of PC and console gaming.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ZeroGravitas on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:36AM (#9664632)
As the prices of hardware falls, the share you're paying to Microsoft increases. Look at the history of MPEG2 licences and DVD players, what was a reasonable cost of doing business when DVD players cost $1000 became unreasonable when they are only selling for $10.

The value Windows offers decreases too as it become more and more reasonable to buy a PC for nothing more than gaming, whereas before you'd need a bunch of uses to justify the cost. Would Windows make sense on the streaming box for example?

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by chaostheory on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:16AM (#9663872)
There would be more of a reason for these machines to exist if there were more apps on Steam besides games. Maybe Valve can do more deals like the one they have with blender?
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by lfowles on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:17AM (#9665621)
They do have an entire Software category now, although it's mostly tools for game dev. You Need A Budget being the only outlier I can think of.

http://store.steampowered.com/search/#sort_by=Reviews_DESC&c...

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by chaostheory on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:53PM (#9667287)
Yes that's my point. They need more normal apps so that people don't need to leave Steam OS to do productive stuff. They need to be more aggressive in getting them i.e. they won't take a cut of sales
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:28AM (#9663903)
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by chaostheory on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:19AM (#9664583)
Well there are a few key differences with Valve vs 3DO.

1. Valve is already profitable.

2. I do not believe that they are charging Steam Box manufacturers a licensing fee unlike 3DO so that may help.

3. Reading the article, it looks like some Alienware models are able to dual boot as a Windows PC? If so, that helps justify the price. A $750 PC isn't expensive vs a $750 video game console.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:24AM (#9664596)
1. Yes

2. They are not, indeed, but the other problem is that manufacturers need to make money on the hardware, making Steam Machines more expensive that consoles anyway (and more than self-built PCs as well).

3. Yes, and not just Alienware. But honestly, if you are going to put it under your TV, I have a hard time imagining people using it as a PC on their TV screen. Monitors are better in that regard, and you usually want to be closer to the screen for regular PC use.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by bau5 on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:02AM (#9664083)
So it has less space than a Nomad?
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by an_account_name on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:38AM (#9664172)
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by legohead on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:57PM (#9663822)
> PC enthusiasts can get a Steam Link for $50 for most of the benefits of this.

What are the benefits of SteamOS? 1080p is less resolution than a good PC monitor has.. not to mention most graphics cards can straight up use HDMI anyway.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by cwyers on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:01AM (#9663832)
In-home streaming. Lots of gaming PCs are too big and loud to have in the living room, so you can put them in another room and play games on your TV. But the $50 Steam Link does that,you don't need a Steam Machine for it.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:26AM (#9663900)
Yes, but with in-home streaming you are going to get some slight delay to transmit frames, and while it may be acceptable for some games, it may not be prefered for others where fast reflexes/inputs/screen feedback are needed.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by jon-wood on Friday June 05, 2015 @01:15AM (#9663986)
Over a gigabit network its pretty much unnoticeable, I've been playing Portal 2 and Metro 2033 via in home streaming and its not been a problem.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:46AM (#9664193)
Sorry but gigabytes network simply bring more pixels at once, it does nothing to remove the latency. It's bandwidth, not speed-related. You still get latency. Whether you notice it or not is a totally different issue.
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by YokoZar on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:18AM (#9664434)
Your wireless game controller probably contributes more to latency than your in home network. Your television almost certainly does.

That said, latency is additive since it all happens in serial, and if the sum of it hits a certain threshold ("human perception") you begin to notice. So maybe you save a few ms from the network with wired vs wireless, or a few ms with a fancy "gamer" controller, or a few ms with a nice gpu-powered video encoding algorithm.

Shave enough of these things (which are only now being designed with this sort of over-engineered latency in mind), and eventually playing over the network is less latency-prone than playing directly on a machine from not that long ago.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by Filligree on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:22AM (#9664281)
Not quite true. Latency is also lower on a gigabit network; it doesn't send more packets in parallel, it sends packets faster, in serial. At any given speed, it takes time for some number of bytes to traverse the wire.

Though the minimum on-wire latency at 100MBit is 0.12ms for 1500-byte packets, per packet, typically 1GBit cards also have lower latency internally.

(You can multiply that 0.12ms number by the number of intervening switches, plus one.)

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by ekianjo on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:58AM (#9664386)
Interesting, I was not aware of that. Do you have data as to how much latency there is on 1Gbit cards then ? Is it significantly lower?
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by lfowles on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:19AM (#9665638)
http://serverfault.com/questions/276651/network-latency-100m...

Here are some "real numbers" to give you a lead.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by izacus on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:50AM (#9664659)
That depends on the environment - I'm using In-Home streaming extensively on my setup (Living room gaming PC via 802.11ac -> Gigabit network to OS X) and it results in about 25ms of total lag (encode + transmit + decode). Interestingly enough, most lag is added by the video decoder on OS X not the network itself. Meaning, I'm getting about 3-4ms of encoder lag, 2-3ms of network lag and about 18-20ms of decoder lag according to Steam diagnostics.

Strategy, RPG and other mouse controlled games are certanly more than playable in such a setup. Didn't try online FPSes though.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by draugadrotten on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:09AM (#9664412)
If you're playing on a the TV, most TV:s have input lag of 20+ ms anyway. http://www.hdtvtest.co.uk/news/input-lag

Adding another millisecond from the network may not be significant for teenagers and casual gamers.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by vacri on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:42AM (#9664181)
Steam Link is for TVs, not computer monitors. TVs talk about 1080 like it's the pinnacle of video resolution...
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by vlunkr on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:46PM (#9666487)
The steam link is meant for playing on a tv, and most tv's are not over 1080p
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by fweespeech on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:56PM (#9663819)
Yeah, you basically are buying a PC-in-a-box in order to get AAA PC games. At which point...why not buy a PC and hook it up to the TV?
Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by jfoster on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:21AM (#9664132)
PCs generally don't have a user experience optimized for TVs, without a mouse and keyboard, for example.

For all intents and purposes, these are essentially Steam consoles. The only difference from other consoles being the variable specs.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by vacri on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:45AM (#9664190)
As an aside, playing around with the Oculus Rift was a good experience in different UIs for different use cases. In a tradition PC game the UI elements are around the edge of the screen, so they don't get in the way of the main view.

With the Rift, this simply does not work, as you can't really see the edges unless you strain - UI elements need to be near the centre of view. Skyrim controls worked well here, being a centralised HUD that you pop up when you need it.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by bloaf on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:43AM (#9663934)
>You are buying a PC... why not buy a PC?

Sounds like a DailyWTF error message. That being said, I don't think the goal is to get AAA PC games into the living room. I think it is to get greenlight games into the living room.

Re:Steam Hardware pre-order by rtpg on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:14AM (#9664424)
Because the PC-in-a-box (like the Alpha) is in a much nicer form-factor for being put next to the TV. Probably much quieter too. This is why I almost bought one the other day.