News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by zxcvvcxz on Thursday April 23, 2015 @10:27PM (#9431100)
Good for Kleiner. It seems their reputation was being dragged through the mud on a merit-less case of "she said they said". No factual evidence was presented justifying Pao's viewpoints.

Before you downvote, please provide factual evidence and I will gladly update this comment.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by tomasien on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:15PM (#9431236)
I reject your plea not to downvote - not because I disagree (that is not an appropriate reason to downvote a comment on HN from my understanding) but because of two things:

1. You said "good for Kleiner". Whether you agree or not, KPCB is massive firm now asking threatening a $1MM suit against an individual who had good faith claims and that just feels really icky to be called "good". I'm fully aware that the burden of proof for damages rests with the plaintiff and she failed that claim, however this is nowhere near the frivolous lawsuit standard. I am going to also reject your plea for factual evidence because I'm not doing your research for you in this instance, but read over some summary judgements in frivolous lawsuit claims that have been ruled in the plaintiffs favor and compare it to the facts of this case.

2. You asked not to be downvoted. Pleas w/r/t voting do not belong on vote based social networks and forums. They are purely manipulative.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by res0nat0r on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:26PM (#9431274)
You probably would be taking a different tone if it were you whom was personally sued by someone which cost you a million dollars out of pocket, and then have every claim against you dismissed.

Why should KPCB be any different in trying to recover money from a court case they won on every count? Just because they have $X amount of money more than you or I?

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by tomasien on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:08AM (#9431392)
I believe I have sufficient experience to say that I would not change my opinion if I experienced your hypothetical scenario.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by jes5199 on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:32PM (#9431295)
Yes, exactly for that reason. Wealthy organizations have more than an equal share of resources, and should carry an increased burden of the process when in conflict with individuals.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by Natsu on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:38AM (#9431458)
Can you explain more on why it's fair for a party who was judged to be innocent to bear the costs associated for claims judged as false?
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by pyre on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:05AM (#9431522)
> who was judged to be innocent

Because this was not a criminal trial and therefore the judgement does not determine "guilt" or "innocence?"

Because monied interests always have more power whether they are the plaintiff or the defendant in a case?

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by Natsu on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:33AM (#9431601)
No evidence was found after lots of expensive legal discovery. If there was any evidence of guilt, they should have been able to find something that at least made them look bad, but they did not.

You are correct that the proper term for a civil case is "not responsible" but frankly that sounds silly to non-lawyers, as it's too similar to "irresponsible."

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by obstinate on Friday April 24, 2015 @03:37AM (#9431899)
I don't think it's fair to characterize the amount of evidence as "no evidence." There are plenty of folks who think Kleiner looks bad in this case. There is not enough to reach the confidence level required for the plaintiff to succeed. That is a more accurate thing you could say.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by Natsu on Friday April 24, 2015 @06:41AM (#9432393)
I saw lots of allegations but no real evidence. That was, essentially, why the case was lost: for all the things said, nothing of substance could be corroborated. I don't think they even found a bad review....

That makes it really hard for me to believe she was a victim of anything but her own imagination.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by FireBeyond on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:21PM (#9434321)
"I don't think it's fair to characterize the amount of evidence as "no evidence." There are plenty of folks who think Kleiner looks bad in this case."

There were a lot of people who decided Kleiner looked bad based purely on the word of Ellen Pao.

Verbal recollections are not, however, evidence.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by bmelton on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:54PM (#9431349)
Is your intent to prevent companies from becoming successful, or would that just be a happy side effect of such a policy?

Edit: The question was sincere, and I can't think of any reason for which a corporation of means should be in some way more responsible for frivolous lawsuits than one of lesser means, or of an individual.

The logical outcome, to me, seems to be that if there were some inequal burden in the eyes of the law for "wealthy companies" that it would invite frivolous lawsuits on the grounds that suing wealthy companies is now a zero risk endeavor.

If I, as an individual, could sue Google with zero fear of retaliation, I can't see why I wouldn't, on the off chance that I might land a pretty large windfall, if I were to win.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by nulltype on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:30PM (#9431289)
I'm not sure a company can be personally sued.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by cbd1984 on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:47PM (#9431337)
> I'm not sure a company can be personally sued.

Depending on what you mean by "personally sued", this is one of the main reasons limited liability corporations exist: So the shareholders aren't personally responsible for lawsuits the company gets involved in. This is where "corporate personhood" comes from, the idea that, in some limited circumstances, corporations can function as people to make legal proceedings possible.

Suing a company to redress a grievance is feasible. The company has an office, assets, and so on. Trying to track down and sue everyone who has or had a financial stake in the company is not feasible, and if it were, companies would cease to exist because nobody could stomach the risk of all of their personal assets being up for grabs if a lawsuit doesn't go their way.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by pbreit on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:36AM (#9431608)
Because a million bucks is nothing for them and they obviously behaved poorly on a number of occasions.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by cbd1984 on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:42PM (#9431326)
> an individual who had good faith claims

How do you know this?

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by tomasien on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:54PM (#9431352)
Nobody is even alleging bad faith claims at this time, the claim seems to be about lack of evidence. I addressed that separately.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by jegutman on Thursday April 23, 2015 @10:35PM (#9431124)
There were performance reviews that said she did well, they were mixed and complicated like all performance reviews. Also given that the defense tried to discredit her by noting that she sent e-mails to herself it seems strange to call "she said they said" invalid evidence since without those e-mails there would be nothing at all.

What would hard evidence even be for this type of case? Is there going to be an e-mail between partners saying "we should not promote Ellen because she's a woman"?

Did Ellen Pao prove her case conclusively? I think not. Was it clear that there were plenty of issues going on at the time that Kleiner could've handled a lot better? I think so.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by MagicWishMonkey on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:02PM (#9431194)
Doing well in performance reviews doesn't mean much. It was pretty clear that she was not easy to work with, and a lot of her coworkers didn't like working with her. I have no doubt that she was a brilliant employee, but that doesn't really matter if no one wants to work with her.

There's a reason why so many companies put a lot of emphasis on "culture fit".

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by jegutman on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:22PM (#9431261)
She was a fine culture fit. I can tell you this because they kept her around for quite a while. Bad culture fits don't last, especially not at a well-run firm. Culture fits aren't soul mates, there are still normal difficulties and things to work through.

People had trouble working with her possibly after she brought up issues of sexual harassment and discrimination, but there's actually something under the law to protect her from this, anti-retaliation laws, which she tried to sue Kleiner over and lost, but that part of the case definitely seemed like there was some merit to although possibly not enough to meet a preponderance of the evidence.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by growupkids on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:05AM (#9431383)
In reality bad culture hires stick around because most people are polite and assume it's just them, and They give difficult people second chances, they put up with them for a long time because they're not used to being around people that are that "off".

So you can't assume just because someone isn't dismissed quickly that they automatically were a good hire. I've seen plenty of bad hires kept around because people were unable to grok why this person was difficult. They give them lots of second chances and it took time before everyone finally gave up. I'm not saying that's what happened here, what I am saying is you can't jump to a conclusion that because someone wasn't fired that means they were a good fit.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by trhway on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:54AM (#9431651)
> I can tell you this because they kept her around for quite a while.

what alternative did they have? A lawsuit "they gave me bad performance/fired me because i'm a woman"? A lawsuit which they would lose with much higher probability and much higher damages. They could only wait until she leaves on her own.

>People had trouble working with her possibly after she brought up issues of sexual harassment and discrimination

People had trouble working with her possibly because she is a total jerk - she complained that the assistant of her colleague was sending brain scans of dying from cancer mother from office.

Wrt. promotion - promotion isn't something employee is entitled to. If you think company doesn't value you enough - get an offer at other place and you will immediately see how much your company really values you. Did Kleiner tried to keep her when she was leaving? Seems like they didn't. Why? Because she is a woman?

Now at Reddit she installed "no negotiation" hiring policy. She seems to be unaware that in case of good employees it isn't the prospective employee who negotiates, it really his current employer who doesn't want the employee to leave. Probably her former employers has always just let her leave easy, without counters :)

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by zxcvvcxz on Thursday April 23, 2015 @10:51PM (#9431162)
Even perfect performance reviews doesn't entitle one to be promoted. Why does everyone have this idea in their head, that if they cross all the t's and dot all the i's the world is going to reward them?

Are we really going to start to sue over disillusionment?

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by tw04 on Thursday April 23, 2015 @10:58PM (#9431179)
When a woman who has perfect reviews is passed over for a promotion by a man who doesn't... ya, they have some room to be pissed off and gripe.

And yes, if you do everything your employer asks of you and then some, you should be rewarded. What is this world coming to when doing so is considered "average"?

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by AnkhMorporkian on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:53AM (#9431495)
Playing devil's advocate, being perfect at position X doesn't necessarily mean you'll be a good fit at position Y, and being less than perfect at position X doesn't mean you won't be a perfect fit in position Y.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by ptaipale on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:58AM (#9431656)
Right. Remember Peter's Principle:

Selection of a candidate for a position is based on the candidate's performance in their current role rather than on abilities relevant to the intended role. Thus, employees only stop being promoted once they can no longer perform effectively, and "managers rise to the level of their incompetence."

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by phamilton on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:14PM (#9431230)
If a promotion is available, then you are probably right. But if no position is available you could be the perfect employee and not get a promotion and there would be nothing wrong with that.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by rhizome on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:33PM (#9431299)
Being passed-over implies a promotion was available.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by cbd1984 on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:44PM (#9431328)
So if a man got passed over and a woman got the promotion, would the man have a good case, in your eyes?

How about if they were both the same gender?

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by cbd1984 on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:27AM (#9431584)
It seems like there's a conversation we're not having here, and a few people should not be allowed to force us to not have it.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by pen2l on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:15PM (#9431235)
> And yes, if you do everything your employer asks of you and then some, you should be rewarded. What is this world coming to when doing so is considered "average"?

You probably should, but the reality of a capitalistic system is you probably won't.

I have a lot of friends who did everything they were told would get them good jobs, a stable pay, money to have a house, a vacation... but they have nothing. Not to discredit Pao, but I sometimes just laugh at people lamenting about not getting their millions whilst I'm sitting here, drinking with my suicidal buddy who's lamenting about not being able to land a job, after having submitted his resume to over a hundred places.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by jegutman on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:23PM (#9431264)
To be clear, they fired her, they didn't just "not promote" her.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by tsotha on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:14PM (#9431234)
She slept with a coworker. Who does this without realizing one of you may have to go?
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by zak_mc_kracken on Friday April 24, 2015 @02:20AM (#9431707)
Hundreds of thousands of people do this on a daily basis without having to leave their job.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by tsotha on Friday April 24, 2015 @03:23AM (#9431862)
And yet a whole lot of them do end up leaving. If you carry on an office romance, particularly when one or both of you is married, that's a possibility. I've seen it at my office - it's pretty common for people to be unable to work together after the breakup.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by untog on Thursday April 23, 2015 @10:59PM (#9431183)
I don't know. Any details of the case aside, "shut up or pay $1m" doesn't ever look very dignified. Besides, by doing this they've put the case back in the news again - leave it and it goes away.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by echoless on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:06AM (#9431528)
How would it go away? Ellen Pao's going to appeal against the verdict which will lead to Kleiner-Perkins being in the news again.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by supercanuck on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:23PM (#9431266)
Then why was it an 8-4 vote? Didnt it come down to one juror?
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by michaelochurch on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:14AM (#9431402)
It wasn't a frivolous or "merit-less" case.

Before she initiated the lawsuit, she did not know what would be found in discovery. From her standpoint at the time, a suspicion of gender discrimination was valid. She hoped to find a "smoking gun" in discovery.

There was no smoking gun, and she was far from a sympathetic or innocent plaintiff (the affair with Mr. Nazre really killed her) so she lost.

Every bit of testimony from a Kleiner employee should be thrown out, at least on subjective matters like job performance. A person who is employed by one party or the other cannot possibly be expected to give a valid representation. No one's going to testify against someone who can end his career inside of a couple months (obviously with phony performance reviews, because no employer will admit to firing someone over inconvenient testimony).

Do I think that the jury made the right call? Sadly, I'd say "yes". I think that she did end up on the wrong side of an exclusionary culture (that may have been for reasons other than her gender; you never know if it's ethnicity or gender or health or age, the last of which can cut against young or old depending on the group) and was therefore evaluated inaccurately and unfairly. She failed to prove it, though. It would have been very different if discovery had brought forward a smoking gun that proves gendered discrimination... which didn't happen, but there's no way she could have possibly known that.

This is the thing about discrimination that most HN posters don't get. It's not like the people who are guilty of it (and there are many, along age and gender and ethnic and class lines) make it obvious. They don't. It's a silent crime. Most of the time, the victims have no idea that it is happening. They might have suspicions, but it's hard as hell to prove. Ellen Pao tried to do so and came close, but ultimately failed in proving anything conclusive.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by Natsu on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:49AM (#9431485)
Making claims one is unable to substantiate and dragging a case through discovery is normally considered an abuse of the legal system, as we saw in, e.g. SCO vs. IBM, where they also hoped to be able to eventually find an IBM document somewhere that might prove them right.

The fact that they did not find any such "smoking gun" after all that legal discovery makes me believe that they are honest, as that means they couldn't find anything at all after a lot of searching.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by pyre on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:11AM (#9431543)
A big difference is that SCO spend years in "discovery" always claiming that some sort of evidence was just around the corner. The only reason that judges allowed that charade to go on was out of an extreme abundance of caution (probably too much).

> Making claims one is unable to substantiate and dragging a case through discovery is normally considered an abuse of the legal system

A judge can decide to kill said "fishing expedition" too. It's not like these fishing expeditions just "happen" and once initiated are unstoppable. If it was ludicrous, then the judge should have denied it.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by Natsu on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:39AM (#9431617)
Yes, but as your own post alludes, the judges didn't even shut down a SCO-level fishing expedition for... how many years was that? I lost track and I used to follow Groklaw daily.

The fact that this got shut out so quickly simply points to the fact that there was essentially nothing to substantiate Pao's legal claims.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by michaelochurch on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:58AM (#9433753)
There's a difference between an unsuccessful lawsuit and a frivolous one (i.e. one without merit, intended to harm or extort). All evidence indicates that she made the claims in good faith.

The purpose of discovery in these cases is that you don't know what has been said about you. That's why, if you think you might be a victim of discrimination, you often have to sue in order to get that information.

In her particular case, she found no proof. That said, she couldn't have possibly known before the discovery process that it wouldn't be there.

If she were sifting through the files to find breaches of irrelevant, outdated laws and regulations, that'd be a fishing expedition. In this case, the communications that were discovered were relevant to her (justified, because even though she wasn't able to prove gender discrimination, she did prove that, except for John Doerr, they were unprofessional and horrible toward her) grievance.

Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by yuhong on Friday April 24, 2015 @02:38AM (#9431748)
I am thinking of removing anti-discrimination laws completely (not just to create exceptions) and allowing regulators (such as anti-trust) to impose anti-discrimination conditions on specific companies instead.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by binxbolling on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:25PM (#9431270)
Wow, it's super brave of you to be defending those poor maligned billionaires. Takes a lot of courage to stand up for an underdog like KPCB.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by SG- on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:45PM (#9431329)
Isn't she super rich too and a big CEO? Anyways, it's silly to take a side simply because one side has more money than the other, that has nothing to do with it.
Re:Kleiner Perkins seeks legal fees or dropped case from Ell... by selectodude on Friday April 24, 2015 @02:16AM (#9431693)
I guess it depends on how big you consider Reddit to be.