> Making claims one is unable to substantiate and dragging a case through discovery is normally considered an abuse of the legal system
A judge can decide to kill said "fishing expedition" too. It's not like these fishing expeditions just "happen" and once initiated are unstoppable. If it was ludicrous, then the judge should have denied it.
The fact that this got shut out so quickly simply points to the fact that there was essentially nothing to substantiate Pao's legal claims.
The purpose of discovery in these cases is that you don't know what has been said about you. That's why, if you think you might be a victim of discrimination, you often have to sue in order to get that information.
In her particular case, she found no proof. That said, she couldn't have possibly known before the discovery process that it wouldn't be there.
If she were sifting through the files to find breaches of irrelevant, outdated laws and regulations, that'd be a fishing expedition. In this case, the communications that were discovered were relevant to her (justified, because even though she wasn't able to prove gender discrimination, she did prove that, except for John Doerr, they were unprofessional and horrible toward her) grievance.
The fact that they did not find any such "smoking gun" after all that legal discovery makes me believe that they are honest, as that means they couldn't find anything at all after a lot of searching.