Energy consumption is an important thing to pay attention to, but the point of recycling is about not taking more stuff out of the ground.
...the only difference is that when the original tree rotted, it didn't leach chemicals into the soil from the inks, bleaches and other chemicals used in the production of the magazine.
So contaminants aside, composting paper instead of recycling it is actually better for the environment - assuming renewable tree harvesting practices are followed.
Of course, you can't actually put the contaminants aside nor assume that renewable harvesting practices are being used, so even this argument is flawed. At some point, the only way to affect the environment positively is to stop buying as many of the paper products as you can reasonably avoid buying.
In California and some other US states, you can sell them, though this is in part due to a redemption fee charged when you buy them. Here's a price chart from this year (price per pound):
Aluminum Cans - $1.59 Glass Bottles - $0.104 #1 PETE Plastic Bottles - $1.16 #2 HDPE Plastic Bottles - $0.59 #3 PVC (Polyvinyl Chloride) - $0.56 #4 LDPE Plastic Bottles -$2.03 #5 PP Plastic Bottles - $0.60 #6 PS Plastic Bottles - $5.69 #7 Others Plastic Bottles - $0.31 Bimetal - $0.35
This is profitable enough that crews of people come around to steal curbside recyclables in many California cities [1].
[1] http://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Battle-brews-over-raiders...
isn't this the type of thing where a tax might be useful- for example, a tax on products that use 'new' plastic/glass as opposed to recycled? basically, convert the 'cost' of garbage everywhere into an actual cost?
Taxes are useful to capture externalities, where the costs imposed are on other people unrelated to the transaction. For example, taxing air pollution helps to capture the costs it imposes on the general population, which the manufacturer and their customer could otherwise ignore.
Quantifying that cost is a challenge--maybe start with how much $$ it would take to "un-product" the product and return it back to the raw materials it came from. In some cases, we'd find it probably costs more to un-make a product than it was sold for.
Could also (in addition to, or instead of) charge the MANUFACTURER for a portion of this shared environmental cost, as they ultimately chose to make a product designed to be turned into pollution.
I wouldn't want to put a tax on the manufacturers, because you'll end up discouraging reuse. You don't want somebody who comes up with a novel way of using old Coke bottles to pay the same as somebody who just pitches them.
Unfortunately it's also leading to local government approving incinerators for other types of rubbish
Taxes are a cost of doing business. Tax breaks and incentives is unearned income.
Apparently from the discussion here, working with recycled material is more costly for corporations and therefore they
would not be compelled to give up profits to save the environment and improve sustainability.
So, it's now either the people's or the govt's duty to step in and try to mitigate the risk since the market dynamics are
not favorable to work on their own.
People or govt could help by subsidizing the cost of recycling the materials and making it more appealing for businesses to
use them in their manufacturing processes and therefore preserving the environment.
As to which is better raising taxes or giving tax breaks from the point of view of govt interference, I believe that
incentive is less invasive and more importantly less coercive than raising taxes and distorting the market and pushing the
increase in operating costs to the consumers instead.
It's a bad idea to make paper the way we do now in the first place. Pulping and bleaching is energy intensive and involves a bunch of not-so-friendly chemicals resulting in a bunch of pollutants.
Omitting the bleaching would help, or at least finding a different way to do it.
Shouldn't it be able to be downcycled cheaply? Like shredded paper products for things like insulation and other filler?
Surprisingly this just isn't true. It takes a lot of work and chemicals to clean inks and glues out of paper for recycling.
Penn & Teller looked into this in an episode of Bullshit! a while back - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rExEVZlQia4
Aluminum and clear glass are very efficient to recycle, plastics and colored glass depend on commodity prices, and paper is just a terrible idea to recycle. It's much better for the environment to farm trees for making paper, then put that paper in landfills and harvest the methane gas the paper emits when it decomposes.