News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Project Fi by Google by MBlume on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @01:55PM (#9422195)
"We refund the data you don't use" is basically a way of saying "you pay by the megabyte for the data you do use" -- which is actually really great, I've been frustrated that everyone's settled on "all-you-can-eat" data as the standard, it doesn't align incentives well at all.

And they really are refunding it: if you use 1.2GB per month, it doesn't matter whether you sign up for 2, 5, or 10GB, your bill comes out exactly the same.

Re:Project Fi by Google by tomhschmidt on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:11PM (#9422330)
This plan actually makes no sense. Overage charges are the same rate ($10 / GB), so why am I buying a "plan" at all? Why don't they just charge $10 * x gigs / month instead of all this buying / refunding business?
Re:Project Fi by Google by richdougherty on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:44PM (#9422621)
They're equivalent plans, but people have cognitive biases. Here are a couple of explanations from Propspect Theory:

- refunds are perceived as gains (against the reference point of the monthly charge), whereas a fee is perceived as a loss (and losses hurt more) - bills are capped so the the possibility of big fees (losses) is eliminated (people struggle with probabilities and fear extremely unlikely events)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behavioral_economics#Prospect_t...

Re:Project Fi by Google by MBlume on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:14PM (#9422356)
People think they don't want to pay by the megabyte, so they're calling it something else. Also the plan provides a cap so that you know you're not going to pay more than $X per month without going to some app and adjusting something.
Re:Project Fi by Google by ElijahLynn on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @05:33PM (#9423732)
There isn't actually a cap.

Q: What happens if I go over my data budget?

A: Project Fi will first alert you if you're getting close to your data budget. If you go over, you'll still get full-speed data and data is charged at the same $10 per GB rate. For example, if you go over your data budget by 350MB, $3.50 will be added to your next bill."

source: https://fi.google.com/about/faq/#plan-and-pricing-4

Re:Project Fi by Google by nevir on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:12PM (#9422340)
It lets you impose a upper limit of how much you want to spend (I think)
Re:Project Fi by Google by RKearney on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:32PM (#9422509)
Not quite. Per the FAQ[0]

  > Project Fi will first alert you if you're getting close to
  > your data budget. If you go over, you'll still get full-speed
  > data and data is charged at the same $10 per GB rate. For
  > example, if you go over your data budget by 350MB, $3.50 will
  > be added to your next bill.
[0]: https://fi.google.com/about/faq/#plan-and-pricing-4
Re:Project Fi by Google by iamdanfox on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:46PM (#9422639)
I bet there would be a psychological impact. People would curtail their usage and frantically switch antennas on and off, resulting in an overall poor experience.

Perhaps having a big allowance in mind just encourages people to use their data!

Re:Project Fi by Google by bduerst on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @05:49PM (#9423809)
Maybe it's a purchasing nuance with the data supply chain?

As in, it's more expensive to meter everyone's data and charge per 100 MB, and cheaper to charge in 10 GB blocks and then refund retroactively. They are piggybacking off of other networks, which may not accept 100 MB purchases.

I can see them doing a purchasing scheme with the suppliers and then transferring the savings to the customer.

Re:Project Fi by Google by rizwank on Thursday April 23, 2015 @01:36AM (#9425157)
It's a CC charge issue.

You get incremental costs per CC charge. Better, in Googles mind, to overcharge and refund rather than a new charge every 100mb.

Re:Project Fi by Google by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @06:40PM (#9424043)
Perhaps because all the other carriers sell you X GB per month, so they want their plans to be easily comparable to the layman?

To you or I it is easy to see the true nature of their "plans" but to someone who isn't quite sure how many megabytes are in a gigabyte, this probably makes it a lot easier to compare to, say, AT&T.

Re:Project Fi by Google by daigoba66 on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:41PM (#9423025)
It's incredibly useful for household budgeting purposes. Knowing that, at most, I can expect to pay $xxx per month for a service makes estimating expenses easier.

The service apparently alerts you when you get close the "limit". Which means that if you're disciplined you can cut yourself off or just realize that you need to increase your monthly budget.

Re:Project Fi by Google by Gustomaximus on Thursday April 23, 2015 @12:32AM (#9425028)
This carries benefit for both the business and consumer;

For the business: Google carries zero risk of post-pay billing as you are paid upfront + they are earning interest on the aggregated cash they will either refund or pay to the telco(s) at the end of a month.

For the consumer: You are effective pay as you go, so you don't pay for unused data plus you have an upper limit on spend. The interest loss for money in holding is minimal at the individual level. And given this is likely recurring billing (so I doubt for most people they will ever get actually paid back) you simply keep a float in your google account and top up the difference each month.

Re:Project Fi by Google by maxerickson on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:18PM (#9422396)
I expect that it is prepaid and that they will require you to prepay an amount that matches your typical usage in previous months (based on whatever method of measuring).
Re:Project Fi by Google by cbhl on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:05PM (#9422773)
Ting Mobile (https://ting.com/rates) uses this exact pricing model (1.5 cents per megabyte) above and beyond 2 GB of usage.
Re:Project Fi by Google by bougiefever on Friday April 24, 2015 @04:27PM (#9435822)
Been using Ting for a while now. When you use a lot of data in a month, you definitely pay more. One month I used 10 GB of data, and my bill was $200. It's still less than when I had a contract, but I don't get phone upgrades unless I go buy a new phone.
Re:Project Fi by Google by yellowapple on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:15PM (#9422367)
Or better yet: why aren't they offering an unlimited data plan like what T-Mobile and Sprint (Google Fi's "partners") already offer? Why aren't they even at least going with T-Mobile's approach of "throttle the connection once you go past your data cap, but don't charge overages"?

It's like they're taking the best things of both carriers - their unlimited data plans - and pretending those things don't exist, that they're some figment of consumers' imaginations, and instead just taking the AT&T/Verizon approach, but using a soft and squishy dildo instead of a spiked rusty iron dildo to screw us with.

Re:Project Fi by Google by modeless on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:39PM (#9422574)
Unlimited data plans are actually bad. The incentives are all wrong. Consumers and websites have no incentive to fix any problem that causes them to use unnecessary data, clogging the network. Carriers actually have a perverse incentive to discourage use of the network, because increased use doesn't increase revenue, it just causes more congestion. This leads to stupidity like extra charges for tethering, blocking of VPNs, "traffic shaping" to kill "bandwidth hogs" like BitTorrent and Netflix, prohibitions on running servers, service termination for "excessive" use, cooperation with the MPAA to identify and stop BitTorrent users, etc.

With pay per gigabyte, incentives are aligned. Consumers and websites have an incentive to conserve data. Carriers have an incentive to encourage use and increase speeds. There's no reason to block servers or VPNs or tethering. There's no reason to throttle BitTorrent or Netflix or terminate anyone's service for "excessive" usage. In fact, with pay-per-GB carriers should encourage BitTorrent use and fight for consumers against the MPAA!

Historically unlimited data has been better for consumers because carriers have charged ridiculous prices for overages (e.g. per-KB prices that add up to hundreds of dollars per GB), and consumers don't have a good way of knowing how much bandwidth they're using when they use different services, so they can't predict their bills. If these two problems can be fixed, pay-per-GB is the best way forward. I'm glad Google realizes this.

Re:Project Fi by Google by yellowapple on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:57PM (#9422715)
> Consumers and websites have no incentive to fix any problem that causes them to use unnecessary data, clogging the network.

Who says that my usage of data is a "problem" needing "solved"? 10GB (the highest Google offers on its Fi page) can be burned through pretty quickly just by watching videos on a road trip or somesuch. I'd much rather pay $80 for an unlimited plan from Sprint or T-Mobile than pay $120 (or more) for Google Fi.

"Clogging the network" would be solved by carriers actually bothering to invest in their networks to handle the load. That would solve a multitude of other problems, too.

Re:Project Fi by Google by modeless on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:08PM (#9422800)
> "Clogging the network" would be solved by carriers actually bothering to invest in their networks

This is exactly my point. With unlimited data plans, carriers have little incentive to upgrade their networks. It increases costs without directly increasing revenue. With pay-per-GB, the incentive is clear: upgrading the network increases usage which directly increases revenue.

Re:Project Fi by Google by whoopdedo on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @07:53PM (#9424281)
The real incentive is improving speeds makes shared-bandwidth networks more cost effective. You can serve the same number of customers for less cost. Each connection receives its data quicker then disconnects so someone else can use the air space.

Time is the more important measure of cellular network usage than bytes. I think it would be more convenient for customers to be billed per minute. At $10/GB if my average speed is 5 Mbps that's $0.30 a minute. Or $30 to watch a full-length movie in HD. Makes me wish Netflix still had mail delivery.

Re:Project Fi by Google by modeless on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @08:21PM (#9424359)
> You can serve the same number of customers for less cost.

No, upgrading the network allows you to serve more customers at higher cost (the cost of the upgrades). If you have unlimited data plans, you can only recoup those upgrade costs by recruiting more customers because existing customers pay the same regardless of the speed. Recruiting more customers is also costly and affected by many more factors than just network quality. The connection between network upgrades and increased revenue is tenuous and indirect.

In contrast, with pay-per-GB, network upgrades increase usage and thus increase revenue from existing customers as well as new ones. The connection between network upgrades and increased revenue is direct and immediate.

I agree that $10/GB is far too expensive; I'm sure Google would love for it to be cheaper but the pricing isn't their choice to make. When carriers get some competition from Project Loon and/or Elon Musk's satellite thingy, hopefully prices will go down.

Re:Project Fi by Google by whoopdedo on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @08:40PM (#9424405)
> No, upgrading the network allows you to serve more customers at higher cost (the cost of the upgrades)

Upgrades are a one-time cost. You charge a higher rate for access to the faster network until the investment is paid off then you phase down to all customers. Then your operating cost is lower per subscriber in the long run.

Re:Project Fi by Google by modeless on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @08:58PM (#9424456)
These days, upgrades are a continuous cost. By the time you've paid off an upgrade it's time to upgrade again. Charging a higher rate costs you customers, and with fewer customers you don't even need the extra capacity you just bought. Also many customers are on contracts so you can't increase rates right away.

In contrast, with pay-per-GB, upgrades increase revenue automatically without losing customers. You don't have to increase your rates and you can probably even decrease them and still increase revenue.

Re:Project Fi by Google by yellowapple on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:16PM (#9422857)
> It increases costs without directly increasing revenue.

Attracting more customers because you offer unlimited data and other carriers don't sounds like a pretty-damn-direct increase of revenue to me.

See also: how T-Mobile makes money off me and millions of others.

Re:Project Fi by Google by shkkmo on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @11:23PM (#9424854)
The quote is talking about upgrading the network increasing costs without directly increasing revenue.
Re:Project Fi by Google by yellowapple on Thursday April 23, 2015 @02:30PM (#9428786)
The direct increase of revenue comes from more customers arriving now that you're combining a robust network with unlimited data. Both of those things even in isolation are pretty significant attractions; having both of them is even better.

Barring that, however (as I mentioned elsewhere in this topic), congestion issues are already resolved in the wired broadband realm by selling speed rather than data quantity. There's little reason why the wireless world can't do the same by selling access to 2G/3G/4G separately, then making every plan unlimited (or, at the very least, have way bigger caps for everyone, as is the case currently with some of the not-so-great broadband ISPs).

Basically, you'd have T-Mobile's approach, but with a lot more flexibility. In combination with a no-contract carrier (like T-Mobile) or reseller (like Google Fi), a customer could, say, subscribe to a 2G or 3G plan for normal usage, but then subscribe to the 4G plan for a day or so if he/she wants to binge-watch Game of Thrones or somesuch. This way, the congestion issues are addressed (there's a direct monetary incentive for carriers to build more robust networks, since the faster data subscriptions would cost more and generate more revenue) while not imposing arbitrary caps on the quantity of data "used" by a customer. Win-win.

This could be even further extended by providing the 2G and 3G plans with an optional scheme of "we'll give you $X days of 4G per month" (similar to T-Mobile's "we'll give you $X gigabytes of 4G per month"). That way, our Game of Thrones bingewatcher doesn't have to deal with changing the subscription; he'd instead have a week's worth of 4G per month that he could activate on a per-day basis (for example). An even sweeter deal would be for these unused days of 4G to roll over to the next month up to a year (or some other suitably-reasonable length of time), like what T-Mobile already does for its non-unlimited plans.

There's more than one way to do it :)

Re:Project Fi by Google by tacojuan on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:57PM (#9422714)
You seem to have the word incentive confused with the word discourage.

Or it's an obnoxious euphemism.

I have an unlimited data plan on T-mobile for 30 bucks. Paying by the megabyte would discourage me from using data, not "incentivize me to use less data".

>There's no reason to block servers or VPNs or tethering. There's no reason to throttle BitTorrent or Netflix or terminate anyone's service for "excessive" usage. In fact, with pay-per-GB carriers should encourage BitTorrent use!

Thank god for net neutrality, and unlimited/unmetered data, right?

Re:Project Fi by Google by modeless on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:04PM (#9422768)
I'm sorry I offended your sensibilities, but this is a perfectly cromulent use of the word "incentive". If you look in a dictionary under "incentive", you might find an example sentence such as "The rising cost of electricity provides a strong incentive to conserve energy."
Re:Project Fi by Google by tacojuan on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:09PM (#9422802)
Data isn't a scarce resource, bandwidth maybe, but data conservation is not (should not be) a user "incentive".

Carriers acting like data is scarce and in need of conserving are discouraging users from using their product...

Re:Project Fi by Google by wtallis on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:53PM (#9423111)
Gigabytes/month is strongly correlated with consumption of the actual scarce resource under the assumption that most users have similar usage patterns. Variable pricing based on peak times and places would be too complex to actually work well for cellular data, unlike time-dependent pricing for wired broadband or electricity.
Re:Project Fi by Google by toomuchtodo on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:21PM (#9422421)
> Or better yet: why aren't they offering an unlimited data plan like what T-Mobile and Sprint (Google Fi's "partners") already offer?

Because they're acting as an MVNO, and have to pay Sprint and T-Mobile for each MB they deliver to the handset. Google is not trying to replace carriers, they're trying to improve the experience as an MVNO (they providing what Republic Wireless does on a much larger scale).

Re:Project Fi by Google by yellowapple on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:02PM (#9422746)
Doesn't Republic Wireless offer unlimited data plans, too? Being an MVNO has nothing to do with Google Fi's apparent inability to do the same.
Re:Project Fi by Google by toomuchtodo on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:13PM (#9422828)
They ride on Sprint, who is desperate for revenue. Also, Republic retains the right to boot you if you use too much "unlimited" data on Sprint's network.
Re:Project Fi by Google by yellowapple on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:23PM (#9422911)
> They ride on Sprint, who is desperate for revenue.

Google Fi also rides on Sprint (and T-Mobile, though it doesn't seem like T-Mobile is nearly as desperate for revenue at this point). So there's not really a difference there.

> Also, Republic retains the right to boot you if you use too much "unlimited" data on Sprint's network.

Pretty much all carriers have that bit of legalese in their respective agreements (even T-Mobile does, IIRC, and I know for sure Sprint does). Usually that's reserved for extreme cases where one's use of the network significantly dwarfs that of the rest of the user base and is actually causing congestion issues; a few extra gigs is a drop in the pond in comparison.

Re:Project Fi by Google by ForHackernews on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:29PM (#9422950)
Republic Wireless also has a roaming agreement with Verizon, for areas where Sprint's network is lacking. But they are really touchy about abusing that. I assume it's very expensive for them.
Re:Project Fi by Google by codezero on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:18PM (#9422395)
My best guess is that these carriers regret offering unlimited data.
Re:Project Fi by Google by yellowapple on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:15PM (#9422843)
If they regret offering it, then they'd get rid of it like AT&T did.

No, T-Mobile and Sprint embrace it. It's what differentiates them from their competitors. They know that the claims of "oh no, unlimited data would cause congestion issues!!!!11one" were a poor excuse even a decade ago, let alone in the present day, and are thus unafraid to offer customers something that doesn't result in total shafting. AT&T and Verizon can have their fancy networks; they're moot compared to the millions of customers that pick Sprint and T-Mobile specifically because of the unlimited data plans.

Hell, T-Mobile's business model pretty much revolves around it at this point. "We'll give you a couple gigs of high-speed data; if you go over that, we'll just throttle you to 2G speeds without charging overages or any such nonsense. If you want more high-speed, pay for more of it or go with our actual unlimited plan. Oh, and we'll let you rollover your unused high-speed data and we won't make music streaming count toward it and we'll pay your current carrier's ETFs if you switch because we know that that's the only reason why you haven't already switched to us and you won't be locked into a contract anymore." They advertise all this every chance they get, and they deliver on those promises.

I switched to T-Mobile a year ago (from Sprint, which I switched to from AT&T) because of the zero overages, meaning that I wouldn't have to have an unlimited plan just for the peace of mind of not being shafted on a particular month because I watched one too many videos on YouTube or somesuch. A year later and I haven't looked back; definitely one of the better decisions I've made. Google Fi doesn't offer anything that would even remotely compel me to swtich (not even the dual-carrier stuff; I've found T-Mobile to be consistently better coverage-wise and speed-wise than Sprint in my area, so I'd probably just be on T-Mobile's network all the time anyway).

Re:Project Fi by Google by FireBeyond on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @10:45PM (#9424742)
"We'll give you a couple gigs of high-speed data; if you go over that, we'll just throttle you to 2G speeds without charging overages or any such nonsense. If you want more high-speed, pay for more of it or go with our actual unlimited plan."

... which slows you to 2G speeds after 5GB, instead.

I want to like T-mo, I've been a customer in the past until coverage made me give them up, but that point above is somewhat an important omission.

Re:Project Fi by Google by yellowapple on Thursday April 23, 2015 @05:07PM (#9429822)
> ... which slows you to 2G speeds after 5GB, instead.

You do realize they really do offer an unthrottled unlimited plan, right? $100/mo. for 2 lines (so $50/mo./line) as of five minutes ago when I double-checked their site.

Re:Project Fi by Google by Dylan16807 on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:42PM (#9422600)
I see a lot of new offerings that have unlimited slow data. I doubt they regret it; it gives people peace of mind while still giving them incentive to upgrade.
Re:Project Fi by Google by derefr on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:03PM (#9422761)
Unlimited slow data is kind of cool. But unlimited, really slow, and free data (like the Kindle's Whispernet) is awesome. It's great to never actually be stuck completely without network access, even if you're somewhere your usual provider doesn't even exist.

I wish Google and Apple would copy the concept and just have their phones always be on the network, with cell plans just serving as a way to get voice service and get a decent download speed. Now that Google has built out an MVNO, they could definitely enable such a thing.

Re:Project Fi by Google by foobarqux on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:26PM (#9422462)
They invest the float.

edit: Removed reference to cash conversion cycle because it doesn't really have anything to do with that.

Re:Project Fi by Google by miahi on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:31PM (#9422498)
It's Google, they have plenty of cash, do they really need to invest the float of a $20 data plan?
Re:Project Fi by Google by foobarqux on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:47PM (#9422650)
No, they could make a business unit less profitable than it could be. They can also afford to throw money away, it doesn't mean that they should.
Re:Project Fi by Google by Dylan16807 on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @10:43PM (#9424728)
The point is they don't need to do that to such an extent that it will affect the plans offered. It's a nice bonus, but no more than a bonus.
Re:Project Fi by Google by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:36PM (#9422985)
I find this sort of thing really quite clever - I wonder how much of a factor it is in the decision process, do they tailor it in specifically or is it just a nice extra; what sort of money are we talking?

My best guess with 2mins of [re]search: Let's suppose they hold on average $10 per month per customer that's unused, Nexus 5 sold between 3-5 million units, apparently. So for Nexus 6's on their Fi plan they're likely only looking at the invested benefit of $30M (USD)? Google probably have that sort of cash down the back of the sofa, would they even bother investing the float? Or are my guestimations just way off??

UK utilities I've always assumed are doing this hence the wilder and wilder over-estimation of bills in order to hold more customers cash. Wonder how much Google will push the "let us hold your cash, you'll get back what you don't spend" line in order to have more cash to play with. How evil are they prepared to get to hold some extra pocket change?

Re:Project Fi by Google by foobarqux on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @04:41PM (#9423413)
Yeah, although they probably invest the float, the main reasoning for the decision is likely consumer psychology as described by richardoughtery
Re:Project Fi by Google by higherpurpose on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @01:58PM (#9422224)
That's a good point. It's one thing to offer "unlimited data" for a fixed price - which is about ideal for a consumer, but that doesn't exist anymore. What you get is a fixed amount of data for a fixed price. But the provider has an incentive to make you use as little as possible, to increase its profits. But if instead you get the data returned to you, or you pay a reasonable amount by the MB, then the provider has an incentive to make you use as much data as possible. That could mean giving you a much faster service for example.
Re:Project Fi by Google by MBlume on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:01PM (#9422250)
Also, notice that they're not charging extra for tethering, or care how many devices you tether to. As far as they're concerned, data is data because you're paying for it.
Re:Project Fi by Google by wtallis on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:59PM (#9423147)
Won't the new FCC net neutrality rules effectively prevent tethering charges when they go into effect? Specifically, since providers will no longer be allowed to do anything to interfere with tethering, any tethering fees will be completely optional to the consumer.
Re:Project Fi by Google by pluma on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:13PM (#9422343)
Why would they charge extra for tethering?

Is that a thing in some countries?

Re:Project Fi by Google by wmf on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:14PM (#9422358)
It's a thing in the US, because "computer data" is better and more expensive than "phone data".
Re:Project Fi by Google by pluma on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:21PM (#9422420)
Amazing. How do they tell whether you're tethering, though? If you're using your own smartphone, I mean.
Re:Project Fi by Google by psquid on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @05:57PM (#9423850)
There's various ways:

Some rely on the device itself to enforce it, but that's obviously fragile if you can bring your own device.

Some check the TTL of your packets when they enter the carrier's network, because tethering is at least one more hop and so even if your computer's OS and phone's OS agree on what TTL starts at, the TTL will still be different than expected for your device's platform. Obviously this can still be mitigated by adjusting your TTL, but outside of software that'll handle this for them, that's already beyond a lot of customers.

Some even take the route of only checking HTTP traffic, and detecting tethering based on User-Agent, but I think a lot have abandoned that because it doesn't catch other protocols, and is easily bypassed even on HTTP.

Re:Project Fi by Google by jpco on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:42PM (#9422601)
They don't, but on-phone software (stock iOS, as a prominent example) enforces the policy.
Re:Project Fi by Google by pluma on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:57PM (#9422709)
I was furious when I bought a Nexus 7 (first version) and found out that tethering wasn't available on the device (although there was no obvious reason it shouldn't be and rooting the device would have allowed me to enable it). Running into this on stock devices seems absurd.
Re:Project Fi by Google by yellowapple on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:04PM (#9422283)
> It's one thing to offer "unlimited data" for a fixed price - which is about ideal for a consumer, but that doesn't exist anymore.

Yes it does; both Sprint and T-Mobile offer it (alongside their respective non-unlimited plans). The fact that Google Fi doesn't despite using those two carriers as its "partners" is incredibly disappointing.

Re:Project Fi by Google by EwanG on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:16PM (#9422385)
To Be Clear, they offer it, but T-Mobile will throttle your speeds after a certain number of megs. Sprint also used to do so, but apparently has stopped doing so due to a need to try to get folks to at least check them out.
Re:Project Fi by Google by yellowapple on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:25PM (#9422923)
T-Mobile also offers an unthrottled unlimited plan. Theirs is priced a little lower than Sprint's.
Re:Project Fi by Google by khuey on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:43PM (#9422610)
T-Mobile does offer an unlimited LTE plan.
Re:Project Fi by Google by repsilat on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:25PM (#9422456)
If bandwidth is scarce there's always an incentive to go towards "pay for what you use" schemes, though.

It's like an insurance "death spiral"[1] -- if one provider provides fixed-cost internet (or wide "bands"), the customers who use the least data will subsidise those who use the most. If another provider offers them internet at the true marginal rate, they'll move there. After they've moved on, the fixed-cost internet provider has to increase its rates, rinse and repeat.

Of course, customers may prefer to be insulated in the months they use more data than usual, and moving between providers may not be free, or they may just not care at all...

1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_spiral_(insurance)

Re:Project Fi by Google by yellowapple on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:43PM (#9423033)
> If bandwidth is scarce

That's a big "if". And even if bandwidth is indeed scarce, then that's the problem that needs to be solved by building out one's network; punishing users for using the network is not viable in the long term (especially when folks like T-Mobile, as I've mentioned elsewhere in this discussion, are able to offer both throttled and unthrottled unlimited data plans without issue on a network that's probably nowhere near as built-out as those of AT&T and Verizon).

> Of course, customers may prefer to be insulated in the months they use more data than usual

This is exactly why the low-data users in networks like T-Mobile's and Sprint's typically don't mind subsidizing the high-data users (not that they're really subsidizing a whole lot, seeing as their respective unthrottled unlimited data plans cost more than their respective throttled unlimited and capped data plans). Having an unlimited data plan (throttled or otherwise) provides the peace-of-mind that you won't ever be charged extra based on your data usage, and that's a pretty big win for a lot of customers (especially when coupled with T-Mobile's data rollover).

Re:Project Fi by Google by im3w1l on Thursday April 23, 2015 @05:38AM (#9425641)
The transaction cost is often higher for pay as you go (Did I use up my cap? I hope next bill wont be too large! Need to remember to top up soon).

Those who use the least, can then feel that it is easier to slightly overpay for fixed pricing.

Re:Project Fi by Google by ikeboy on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:22PM (#9422426)
http://www.straighttalk.com/wps/portal/home/shop/serviceplan... has a 3GB plan for a year at $41.25 per month. Google's pricing for the same amount is $50 per month. So the question is whether all the new features (wifi calling, international roaming, pay-for-usage) justify the extra $9, plus the cost of a new phone for those without a Nexus 6.

(Wifi calling should probably be left out of that list, since it's most likely going to come to the other carriers later this year.)

Re:Project Fi by Google by durin42 on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:33PM (#9422518)
It's worth pointing out that with Fi you only pay for the data you _actually use_, so if you only use 1G you end up saving a bunch, and if you need more you can still get it when it's required.
Re:Project Fi by Google by wlesieutre on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:41PM (#9422592)
T-Mobile has a 5GB (LTE) + unlimited (slowed after 5GB) plan for $30/month.

It only has 100 minutes, but you can use Google Voice or similar over data. And who talks on the phone anymore anyway?

Re:Project Fi by Google by ikeboy on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:46PM (#9422637)
The reason I mentioned Straight Talk was that it works with all 4 main US carriers. T-Mobile doesn't have service everywhere.

>And who talks on the phone anymore anyway?

I know a number of people who wouldn't buy a plan unless it had unlimited minutes. Some people use their phones for talking heavily.

Re:Project Fi by Google by wlesieutre on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:19PM (#9422876)
Ah, that's fair. I have good reception in my area, but I've definitely hit bad areas while traveling.

I do talk on the phone all the time at work, but for personal use it's pretty minimal. But even if I did, the Hangouts Dialer app will make GV calls over data, so I don't use any minutes, and I don't even use data when I'm on wifi.

Re:Project Fi by Google by raisedbyninjas on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @04:51PM (#9423462)
Straight Talk is compatible with multiple carriers but still makes you select a single carrier though right? Google Fi will jump between carriers dynamically. Tmobile coverage is spotty around here but I've had good luck with Sprint in the past, so I'm optimistic.
Re:Project Fi by Google by raisedbyninjas on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @04:48PM (#9423441)
I have this plan because I don't use a lot of voice service. I try to use Google Voice through Hangouts to avoid going over the limit anyway. IME call quality is garbage on both a good wifi or good a LTE signal.
Re:Project Fi by Google by nissimk on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:27PM (#9422467)
It's not just international roaming. StraightTalk does not support international texting. There is no way to text canadian phones from StraightTalk US. If you want International calling you can get that, but it costs more.
Re:Project Fi by Google by ikeboy on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:29PM (#9422484)
You can get that for free with Google Voice already, though. If Google already offers something for free, we shouldn't count it in the value calculation.
Re:Project Fi by Google by rhino369 on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:01PM (#9422241)
I just wish it had peak/non-peak pricing. Even something as basic as free nights.
Re:Project Fi by Google by grrowl on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @08:08PM (#9424321)
In the context of the wider Net Neutrality conversation (Connectiveness Neutrality?), I'm glad it's so simple. $20 + $10/gb across the board is very sane, fair, and makes no assumptions about who you are, how you're using it, or what you're using it for.
Re:Project Fi by Google by shkkmo on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @11:46PM (#9424915)
I do think we eventually need to move to more flexible pricing though. Not all data is equally cheap to transit (i.e. runs on infrastructure of the same capital and maintenance costs). Commoditizing wireless access and allowing flexible pricing would allow more competition and innovation in how that wireless access is provided.

It is going to requi

Re:Project Fi by Google by MBlume on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:02PM (#9422261)
Or better yet, some sort of dynamic pricing when, say, you're on a crowded subway platform. You'd really want solid software integration for that, though, so the user isn't unpleasantly surprised by it.
Re:Project Fi by Google by saidajigumi on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:26PM (#9422465)
I have a lot of problems with surge pricing in general, not the least of which (in this example) is that it creates two classes of 'net users: those with enough disposable income to probably not care about surge pricing ever and those for whom it's a burden. Yes, that's a reflection on larger societal issues, but it's still there.

Worse, surge pricing is often a distraction for nearly everyone. IMO, it's not ethical to implement surge pricing without allowing a user some mechanism to opt-out of it and to understand why they aren't getting bandwidth at that time. But having put that stake in the ground, the UX now requires that the user waste mental decision energy on ... business bullshit[1].

Last not far from least, it aligns the incentives of carriers against providing enough coverage to handle capacity. We're learning how to handle higher density wireless scenarios (cf. articles on stadium and other heavy-use event network systems). Would we rather incentivize trickle-down of these systems into high-traffic public areas (e.g. commuter zones), or just further line the pockets of a few near-monopolist carriers at our own expense?

[1] This relates to why users rightly don't like metered billing -- it creates decision pressure. A payment structure that alleviates use of decision energy is a value add.

Re:Project Fi by Google by maxerickson on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:33PM (#9422521)
How do you feel about services that require $650 phones?

Also, discounts when network utilization is low?

Re:Project Fi by Google by untog on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:36PM (#9422545)
How do you feel about services that require $650 phones?

Broadly speaking, few do. There are a lot of cheap Android phones out there.

Re:Project Fi by Google by maxerickson on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:37PM (#9422556)
This service requires a $650 phone.
Re:Project Fi by Google by untog on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:07PM (#9422790)
Sure, but there's no reason it will always be the case. It makes sense to start with a limited number of hardware devices, and only ones under your control.
Re:Project Fi by Google by maxerickson on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:15PM (#9422847)
Yeah, I'm not confused about that.

But the comment I replied to was concerned that some users of the service might have more disposable income than others, which is an odd thing to bring to the table when discussing a convenience service that has a $650 entry price (I don't have a smartphone, so I'm not being a ridiculous hypocrite describing it that way).

I'm pretty skeptical of price controls, I never expect them to do me any good. The argument presented there is that surge pricing is bad because some people can't afford it. The other side of the coin is that if you ban surge pricing, you make it more difficult to charge less at other times.

Re:Project Fi by Google by derefr on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:06PM (#9422778)
It does for now. Whether or not the tech filters down into other products, this exact phone won't still be $650 in two years.
Re:Project Fi by Google by rhino369 on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:10PM (#9422320)
I think customers would be pissed about never knowing when data will suddenly surge in price, even if you warn them. It would also kill the user experience. And stuff like background updates and push messages would be a pain.

I'm sure the usage pattern is steady enough to make a pretty good model.

Re:Project Fi by Google by mentat on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:08PM (#9422304)
Type "2.5" to accept surge pricing.
Re:Project Fi by Google by eli on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:14PM (#9422359)
But I want my email and push notifications to happen the background without paying extra. Unless it's been a while, then I probably am willing to pay extra. Seems awfully tricky.
Re:Project Fi by Google by Dylan16807 on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @02:47PM (#9422647)
Doesn't seem too tricky to me. Email and push notifications are almost zero data; go ahead and let them pay full price.

Download updates and podcasts at 4AM.

Maybe ask before doing interactive high-bandwidth things, depends on user preference.