Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by na85 on Friday April 10, 2015 @04:41PM
(#9356980)
Looks like they've updated/changed their whitepapers. A few months ago their literature was chock-full of statements like "engendering positive disruption" which made me wonder how anyone takes this project seriously.
Is it possible this is a serious project and not a pump-and-dump?
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by IkmoIkmo on Friday April 10, 2015 @08:09PM
(#9357798)
I'm not sure... I think there's quite a bit of genuine development. But at the end of the day, it appears anything you can build on ethereum you can build on bitcoin.
Beyond that they did this huge crowd funding which was quite strange, not through investments or donations (ownership or charity/support), but rather through selling ethers, which is a bit like an API selling an access token. Only the ethers sold for upwards of $15-20 million as far as I remember, while not having any real value, and not being necessary in large volumes for developers to work with. They said it wasn't an investment, yet sold it as such. Nobody got any ownership, yet people didn't give them $15 million+ out of charity or support, either. They also had this strange scheme where the price continued going up, again, as if it was an investment that was 'on sale' and if you didn't buy now, it'd only become more expensive, in the span of like a few weeks while whatever you were supposed to buy (ethers) didn't go up in value, and in fact, remained non-existent as you couldn't use them as it my next point: vaporware.
Sot the fact it's still vaporware (can change, but factually speaking its vaporware today) and the fact that nothing ethereum does can't be done on existing platforms, which unlike ethereum actually exist, work, are used by large companies and has network effects, and the focus on Vitalik being some brilliant 20 year old next Zuckerberg, it's very much reminiscent of pump & dump.
We'll have to see. They've got the money, the team, a paper, and some promises for a 2015 launch. So we should know soon enough. I've got modest hope, but I'm not terribly excited.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by bachback on Friday April 10, 2015 @04:27PM
(#9356918)
raised = 18m$
assets left = 7.5m$
expense = 4m$
trading losses = 6.5m
It's an insane amount of money to burn through, without releasing anything of utility so far. I had to deal with several people from that team and they are scammers. Idea itself is interesting, but not workable.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by 0x8D3A on Friday April 10, 2015 @04:36PM
(#9356958)
Scammers isn't the least of it. The system they have designed and executed is ludicrously insecure and falls to even the most basic of flaws. It's unlikely that it will ever be able to achieve consensus given the endless stream of crashes and logic errors, like being able to send yourself a negative balance (thus, infinite money) or crashing every node in the network by sending a block header with a nonce of zero. The sheer quantity of security bugs and undefined behavior in the two clients attempting to act in bit-for-bit identical ways in two different languages is quite alarming.
I'd bet against it ever getting to try it's consensus given that their launch is now going to be completely centralized (ie, it can't stand up on it's own let alone with malicious attackers, so it's going to be remotely controlled by the developers for now). Will they ever remove the crutch and risk everything crumbling? Seems very doubtful.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by bachback on Friday April 10, 2015 @05:11PM
(#9357134)
Right. It's not really a block-chain, but a block-tree (whatever that is supposed to be).
I suspect to make smart contracts work, one needs a different time-stamping/incentive system altogether (non-blockchain), but haven't seen any progress in that direction.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by DennisP on Friday April 10, 2015 @06:28PM
(#9357445)
For more information on the block tree see the GHOST protocol paper, which predates Ethereum. It does collapse into a linear chain for all but the most recent blocks.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by bachback on Saturday April 11, 2015 @03:11AM
(#9358797)
I know that paper. The authors have no background in distributed systems and use math to prove absurd things. If you look at the core proposed algorithm, it's not even a P2P algorithm.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by DennisP on Thursday April 16, 2015 @07:33PM
(#9391386)
Eh? It's P2P just like Bitcoin. The only difference is how forks are resolved.
Bitcoin nodes choose the longest chain they see. Another way to put that is: at any forking point, Bitcoin nodes choose the block with the longest chain after it.
GHOST nodes choose the block with the most total computation after it (which may include additional branches).
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by drcode on Friday April 10, 2015 @04:28PM
(#9356922)
Last I heard, it was in the 5-7M range. Most of the decrease can be accounted for by the fall in Bitcoin since the presale- For the most part, the core team seems to have been pretty decent with maintaining a reasonable burn rate. (as much as outsiders can determine)
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by drcode on Friday April 10, 2015 @04:39PM
(#9356975)
As I said, most of that is due to the drop in Bitcoin value, not an actual burn rate, in terms of how most people would consider the term "burn rate".
For better or worse, had ethereum sold all their Bitcoin holdings immediately after the presale they would have been hated by a large chunk of the cryptocurrency community... They ended up taking a big volatility risk for this reason (among others) which worked against them.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by natrius on Friday April 10, 2015 @04:42PM
(#9356989)
Don't confuse Ethereum for a currency that competes with Bitcoin. It's different. It's a decentralized, consensus-driven database that anyone can use. Anything that required a trustworthy middleman or counterparty can be replaced by this database where no one can forge entries or take unpredictable actions.
Ethereum and systems like it make it easier for humans to interact with each other, and it will be a core part of the story of our era.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by zzalpha on Friday April 10, 2015 @05:22PM
(#9357184)
it will be a core part of the story of our era.
ROFL, wow... that's not grandiose at all.
It's a database. On the internet. I'm gonna go out on a limb and bet at least a few billion folks on the planet likely won't see their lives change much any time soon because Etherium was conceived.
Edit: Ahh. Zapchain again. Now I get it.
Times like this I wish there was a way to filter my Hacker News RSS feed to cull out posts from particular users or sources...
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by lazaroclapp on Friday April 10, 2015 @07:52PM
(#9357735)
So, here is the thing, let's not consider the question of whether Ethereum will or won't be successful. I don't have the faintest clue whether it will be or not. But, let's for a moment assume it is successful, wildly so. Would it be a big deal? Yes, it likely would be.
If Ethereum is as successful as some of people working on it hope it will be, it could be as important as HTTP. Yeah, HTTP is one protocol... on the internet, most people have little idea about how it works or what it's about, yet it does affect billions of people and is an important part (at the infrastructure level) of one of the defining phenomenons of our era: the Internet. Some people hope that cryptocurrencies are going to be next decade's Internet and Ethereum is going to be its HTTP.
The main break from the standard internet given by Ethereum is the following: fully distributed apps that exist not in any server, but as a public contract between their users. If you want eBay on the internet, you build a program on a server you own and tell it how to mediate transactions between buyers and sellers. If you want eBay on Ethereum, you publish a contract about how buyers and sellers should behave, and include in that contract some provisions that enforce themselves, no middleman required. Will this be practical? Who knows. Would it be useful if it works? I believe it would be. Would it be industry changing? Perhaps. Would it be world changing? Well... let's say it at least has a chance.
Now, whether Ethereum is another http/www/html or, say, another Project Xanadu, that's a different question. Ethereum is an idea that can only work if many untested pieces turn out to work together as desired and the main benefits from those technologies are sufficient for people to buy into what would be a clean departure from the existing web. Experience shows that such departures are seldom successful (remember when every website was going to be a Java Applet? That was still way less of a moonshot than Dapps). But the thing is, regardless of whether Ethereum succeeds or not, its development is likely to produce useful ideas, and it is a project that, at least in principle, should it succeed, really can change our infrastructure. It is worth keeping in mind, that, in some cases, changing infrastructure has changed the world quite significantly (e.g. trains, telegraph, Internet, and even WWW vs the telnet/email era of the Internet).
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by zzalpha on Friday April 10, 2015 @05:36PM
(#9357237)
What? That's not at all true. Just because a person doesn't, themselves, own a computer, doesn't mean their lives aren't touched by their existence.
As the first example that springs to mind: computers have enabled access to telecommunications infrastructure (think cell phones), which have utterly transformed the lives of many of the world's poorest.
But a pipedream consensus database running on the internet? Colour me skeptical that it's going to utterly transform the world the way the computer has.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by RoboTeddy on Friday April 10, 2015 @08:17PM
(#9357825)
Ethereum seems like a decentralized consensus-driven trustless COMPUTER that anyone can use -- it's not just a database.
Anyone can pay to start and run a process ("contract" in ethereum-speak) that runs arbitrary (albeit sandboxed) code. Like you mentioned, processes can store data. Processes can also send and receive messages ("transactions" in ethereum-speak) with users and with other processes.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by natrius on Friday April 10, 2015 @09:27PM
(#9358000)
Yeah, I guess calling it a database makes it sound like a cloud MySQL service. But to be clear, it's not an EC2 analogue either. If there were demand for a distributed EC2, we could build one way better than Ethereum. Ethereum is necessarily slow because consensus must be reached on the data.
You wouldn't run an arbitrary program on Ethereum. You run programs on Ethereum to define the state transitions in a database the whole world can access and trust. If you're building a marketplace, for instance, then you're defining what it means when a customer buys something. Every customer and merchant who uses your system has proof of how their interactions will work, and it's impossible for anyone to try to cheat.
The database and its state transitions are what matters.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by fossuser on Friday April 10, 2015 @05:21PM
(#9357179)
Can you give a little more detail? After reading this article and some of their web page I still have no idea what this actual is (beyond the fact that it's a decentralized platform for decentralized applications).
Can you give an example of what this would be used for and how?
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by hidingfromherd on Friday April 10, 2015 @06:53PM
(#9357559)
I like to think of it as a global coordination platform.
If you're familiar with bitcoin: bitcoin is a platform that coordinates global views of bitcoin balances and verifiable logic for transfer of bitcoin from one account to another.
In a similar way: ethereum is a platform that coordinates global views of state and verifiable logic for state transitions.
> Can you give an example of what this would be used for and how?
This would be used in any scenario where a global or otherwise undefined group of actors desires to coordinate action in a way that does not inherently require trust from a single party.
In human terms, it is used when you want to communicate or interact with some unknown others without relying on a company/single entity to provide the medium.
Oh yeah, the example. Lets build a small one.
Lets say the people at the tor project wants to publish some master public keys, etc. There is a core group of folks who should have write access, but they don't necessarily trust each other. Some of their 'important decisions', like changing their group membership, or changing a public key, should be put to a vote. (Oh and lets say they need to be able to cycle their individual keys, as well)
They could create an ethereum contract (or interacting contracts) that managed the operation. They wouldn't have to necessarily trust each other individually, and their progress would be visible/verifiable by all.
The contract(s) would handle their published data (allowed adding/removing content), maintain their group membership, and would presumably only be modifiable by the members of their group. Members could be modelled as ethereum addresses. Member needs to change keys? Include logic to swap a member for another address, iff the call came from the member to be swapped out. Important tasks need to be voted on? Include logic to initiate and track votes on certain operations.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by drcode on Friday April 10, 2015 @05:28PM
(#9357207)
It's hard to really summarize ethereum well... it's just so different from any existing system, IMHO.
Unless you're really into the nitty gritty of cryptocurrency technology, it won't really make sense until people manage to build some compelling apps for it, hopefully around the summer time.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by drcode on Friday April 10, 2015 @05:41PM
(#9357249)
OK, I'll give it a shot...
At its heart, ethereum is a tool for minimizing counterparty risk and cost. You don't want Twitter to extinguish 3rd party twitter clients? You don't want Uber to take a 30% monopoly fee on every transaction? You don't want your stock broker to front-load your market orders? These are all forms of counterparty risk/cost.
So the compelling applications for ethereum are: A prediction market with minimal counterparty risk, a stock exchange minimal counterparty risk, a product market with minimal counterparty risk, a currency exchange with minimal counterparty risk, a poker site with minimal counterparty risk, a social network with minimal counterparty risk, a ride sharing site with minimal counterparty risk, etc.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by 0x8D3A on Friday April 10, 2015 @06:24PM
(#9357435)
Some of your examples need oracles to deliver information into the script, which is (oh no!) your counter party so you're back to square one again. It doesn't work in any other way due to the realities of distributed consensus. The example of a poker system within Ethereum is incredibly unlikely, a social network or Uber clone the same but for meatspace issues rather than cryptographic ones.
I've still yet to come across a single person who can give me a compelling reason for Ethereum to exist other than "this is awesome because it will change the world" or other similar drivel. It's always impossible due to limits in Ethereum's design, limits of reality, or just stuff you can do in Bitcoin anyway and nobody has realized.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by 0x8D3A on Friday April 10, 2015 @06:48PM
(#9357532)
Even in cases where it might be possible the end result to a human is often completely unusable. You might hate the Uber taxi cartel or whatever, but at least using them you have some degree of privacy (with "smart contracts" your privacy is absolutely gone, and not just financial privacy) and customer service.
For example there's a fad of putting "ownership" of physical assets into bitcoin tokens for example, fine, that works until someone steals the token and not the physical asset. Now who owns the asset? Reality is out of sync with what the block chain says so, there's no support to help me get it back and no backdoor.
Privacy is even harder. With Bitcoin everyone knows what you spend, where you spend it, probably what you spend it too with some extrapolation. With "smart contracts" now everybody knows who your arbitrator is, who you play poker with, what brand of fridge you own. There's no getting around that if you want a public ledger.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by bachback on Saturday April 11, 2015 @03:26AM
(#9358813)
Much agree - those are the big conceptual holes in smart contracts. The concept still has a lot of merit, in the very long term. It's a bit like trying to imagine Google in 1993. Most of the things one can assume are most likely going to be wrong, including even the usages of these systems. I'd personally start with extending the Bitcoin script and thinking about better ways for multiple users to use it.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by 0x8D3A on Saturday April 11, 2015 @03:47AM
(#9358839)
It boils down the point that you don't actually want to be doing computation at that level anyway. There's a very good reason that Bitcoin Script should be simplistic, why the hell would you want to be doing any sort of detailed computation at that level? With n nodes on the network you amplify the load n times, why not do it on an oracle where it's practically free? There's already comments by the Ethereum developers that it will be incredibly hard for a client to ever bootstrap from genesis once they launch, just due to the insane amount of script execution time.
If you're taking input from an oracle (you almost always are), you have the same level of trust in it anyway, you just moved computation into the stupidly expensive and massively redundant portion of the system. The 'solutions' for distributed oracles with ShellingCoin and related garbage is just hand wavy nonsense with so little basis in reality that it's not worth talking about.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by bachback on Saturday April 11, 2015 @04:56AM
(#9358915)
I agree that there is a lot drivel, but I'd extend that to Bitcoin discussions also, where rarely economic underpinnings get discussed.
There is this notion of a contract. In a democracy a valid contract is an agreement (say between 2 parties) which is enforceable by courts and executive. Enforceable means that there is a cost of cheating. Even the most simple purchase contains a purchase agreement. If Alice walks into Bob's store and takes something without paying, then this is what we call theft (although the precise details of theft can be argued about ad infinitum).
In the real world when we enter agreements, we usually know to some extent who we are dealing with (Alice knows Bob's store). What would an arbitrary agreement over a network look like? That's hard to say. An analogon of a court is some arbitrary human decision, which can serve as an input. In Bitcoin there is no notion of an agreement, only cash transactions (and some limited facilities for escrow).
I believe that the concept of an oracle, and several other crypto-terms like Zero-knowledge proofs are an academic dead end. For my purposes I'm assuming that most people who want to use crypto systems don't understand or care about these things. There will be a great need for mapping abstract concepts to useful tools, such as an GUI operating system maps very abstract physical calculations and processes and makes them usable. I suspect 99% of Bitcoin users don't understand public-key cryptography, much less Elliptic curves and distributed systems. "Key", "signature" and "coins" are useful metaphors.
What is already happening are the first beginnings of joint stock ownership developing (DAC's) with mixtures of online formal agreements and informal agreements. Voting is not a panacea, but it helps. That's the kind of contract that can be developed in the short term.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by 0x8D3A on Saturday April 11, 2015 @06:39AM
(#9359050)
If you're doing stock ownership "in contracts", why not just have the company manage it? Obviously you trust them if you're investing in them, what's to gain by doing it "autonomously"? A centralized version is faster, cheaper, and private, you're going to need a hell of a good reason to actually go down this route rather than "it's the future".
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by bachback on Sunday April 12, 2015 @03:28AM
(#9362503)
Joint accounts are very useful. What one can do is issue stock at zero cost, have onchain accounting, be worldwide distributed etc., without the involvement of a lawyer or accountant. These things already exist in primitive form. For example there are already online communities with trusted members who provide escrow functions to manage the funds (basically an onchain Bitcoin foundation). Most of these things are being developed with Proof-of-stake systems, since they are already inherently based on explicit voting. Blocks get produced by vote of stake. While in Proof-of-work the computer doing the voting can change very frequently in PoS it's more constant. A good (old) paper in this respect is b-money: http://www.weidai.com/bmoney.txt
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by 0x8D3A on Friday April 10, 2015 @07:21PM
(#9357642)
ShellingCoin has pretty hand wavy economic justifications and won't see real world use (or if it does, it'll see use until it loses people lots of money due to faulty incentives).
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by drcode on Friday April 10, 2015 @08:21PM
(#9357838)
Look, nobody disagrees with you that there's a risk of failure when people try building new things.
Are you saying you have citations that prove ShellingCoin won't work? Are you saying you have a citation from an ethereum developer that these ideas are 100% certain to work out on the first attempt?
If not, why are you complaining about people unconnected to you trying these new ideas out as an experiment? Nobody disagrees that these are new and untested ideas.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by drcode on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:07PM
(#9361773)
You're trying to change the framing of this conversation. The 4 comment parents above this one all concern Schellingcoin and Augur. Nobody has spent a nickel on those systems.
I agree that the core ethereum tech is 100% fair game for criticism, but that's not what's being discussed here.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by MCRed on Friday April 10, 2015 @06:23PM
(#9357432)
It's an alt coin, it's pre-mined and because of that it cannot be a successor to Bitcoin which was not pre-mined. (Though Satoshi mined a little bit, that bitcoin has been left out of circulation.)
For alt-coins pre-mining generally means its a scam.
They are proposing a whole bunch of next generation functionality, which if they pull it off may overcome the unfairness of pre-mining and make them all super rich.
But it's super ambitious and isn't yet clear that it will even be possible to do what they want to do, and if they do it will take years to establish the trust necessary to use it for its intended purpose.
Choosing to pre-mine means anyone who does due diligence won't be trusting them for quite awhile.
I think this is still a lot of hype (And this article is just adding to it) without substance.
I think the way bitcoin was done was correct-- no hype and just a release of code.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by chm on Friday April 10, 2015 @06:50PM
(#9357542)
What one usually means by "pre-mining" is the allocation of a certain quantity of resources/value (in this case ether) _before_ the genesis block. So in this regard he was right.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by DennisP on Friday April 10, 2015 @07:10PM
(#9357608)
Because of those ambitious goals, they thought it necessary to get a fair number of developers and cryptographers working on it full time. 98% of the premine was a public presale of coins, which paid the expenses for all those people. How would you have done it?
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by drcode on Friday April 10, 2015 @08:35PM
(#9357881)
Actually, a significant amount of the premined coin will go to the ethereum organization- They are premining more than they put up for the presale, if I recall.
(INB4 someone says the ether allocated in the genesis block doesn't fit the strict definition of a premine)
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by drcode on Friday April 10, 2015 @09:07PM
(#9357958)
So, two sections of the premine allocation are called "Reserve spent pre-sale" "Reserve used post-sale" and account for 16.52%. Are you claiming those line entries also were also part of a "public presale of coins", to use your own terminology?
(FYI I'm a fan of ethereum, just trying to get the facts straight)
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by DennisP on Saturday April 11, 2015 @12:17AM
(#9358475)
Hmm I'm not sure what they mean. I was looking at the part just before that:
> 0.099x the total amount sold (60102216 ETH) will be allocated to the organization to compensate early contributors and pay ETH-denominated expenses before the genesis block.
> 0.099x the total amount sold will be maintained as a long-term reserve.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by xnull6guest on Friday April 10, 2015 @08:15PM
(#9357819)
Yeah... we need decentralization, but I can't tell Ethereum apart from any of the other many proponents who have claimed to have invented that system and technology. If we were to apply a tech adaptation of Aaronson's red flags for outrageous math claims to Ethereum (http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=458) I'm convinced we'd walk away immediately.
Re:Vitalik Buterin, Creator of Ethereum, Talks Bitcoin’s Mos...
by drcode on Friday April 10, 2015 @08:28PM
(#9357859)
Well, I know of four systems that try to solve this problem: Codius, Counterparty, Ethereum, and Bithalo (in a limited sense.) I think all of the developers for each system would agree 100% that the other three have successfully solved the core problems, as well.
Nobody is making any extrordinary claims that they have some sort of magical technology that others can't duplicate (and all of them except bithalo are open source, making duplication easy.) The only question is which platform will be first to deliver an experience that will attract main stream users, in terms of stability and functionality.
Is it possible this is a serious project and not a pump-and-dump?
Beyond that they did this huge crowd funding which was quite strange, not through investments or donations (ownership or charity/support), but rather through selling ethers, which is a bit like an API selling an access token. Only the ethers sold for upwards of $15-20 million as far as I remember, while not having any real value, and not being necessary in large volumes for developers to work with. They said it wasn't an investment, yet sold it as such. Nobody got any ownership, yet people didn't give them $15 million+ out of charity or support, either. They also had this strange scheme where the price continued going up, again, as if it was an investment that was 'on sale' and if you didn't buy now, it'd only become more expensive, in the span of like a few weeks while whatever you were supposed to buy (ethers) didn't go up in value, and in fact, remained non-existent as you couldn't use them as it my next point: vaporware.
Sot the fact it's still vaporware (can change, but factually speaking its vaporware today) and the fact that nothing ethereum does can't be done on existing platforms, which unlike ethereum actually exist, work, are used by large companies and has network effects, and the focus on Vitalik being some brilliant 20 year old next Zuckerberg, it's very much reminiscent of pump & dump.
We'll have to see. They've got the money, the team, a paper, and some promises for a 2015 launch. So we should know soon enough. I've got modest hope, but I'm not terribly excited.
assets left = 7.5m$
expense = 4m$
trading losses = 6.5m
It's an insane amount of money to burn through, without releasing anything of utility so far. I had to deal with several people from that team and they are scammers. Idea itself is interesting, but not workable.
https://github.com/ethereum/go-ethereum/issues?utf8=%E2%9C%9...
I'd bet against it ever getting to try it's consensus given that their launch is now going to be completely centralized (ie, it can't stand up on it's own let alone with malicious attackers, so it's going to be remotely controlled by the developers for now). Will they ever remove the crutch and risk everything crumbling? Seems very doubtful.
I suspect to make smart contracts work, one needs a different time-stamping/incentive system altogether (non-blockchain), but haven't seen any progress in that direction.
http://eprint.iacr.org/2013/881.pdf
Bitcoin nodes choose the longest chain they see. Another way to put that is: at any forking point, Bitcoin nodes choose the block with the longest chain after it.
GHOST nodes choose the block with the most total computation after it (which may include additional branches).
For better or worse, had ethereum sold all their Bitcoin holdings immediately after the presale they would have been hated by a large chunk of the cryptocurrency community... They ended up taking a big volatility risk for this reason (among others) which worked against them.
Ethereum and systems like it make it easier for humans to interact with each other, and it will be a core part of the story of our era.
ROFL, wow... that's not grandiose at all.
It's a database. On the internet. I'm gonna go out on a limb and bet at least a few billion folks on the planet likely won't see their lives change much any time soon because Etherium was conceived.
Edit: Ahh. Zapchain again. Now I get it.
Times like this I wish there was a way to filter my Hacker News RSS feed to cull out posts from particular users or sources...
If Ethereum is as successful as some of people working on it hope it will be, it could be as important as HTTP. Yeah, HTTP is one protocol... on the internet, most people have little idea about how it works or what it's about, yet it does affect billions of people and is an important part (at the infrastructure level) of one of the defining phenomenons of our era: the Internet. Some people hope that cryptocurrencies are going to be next decade's Internet and Ethereum is going to be its HTTP.
The main break from the standard internet given by Ethereum is the following: fully distributed apps that exist not in any server, but as a public contract between their users. If you want eBay on the internet, you build a program on a server you own and tell it how to mediate transactions between buyers and sellers. If you want eBay on Ethereum, you publish a contract about how buyers and sellers should behave, and include in that contract some provisions that enforce themselves, no middleman required. Will this be practical? Who knows. Would it be useful if it works? I believe it would be. Would it be industry changing? Perhaps. Would it be world changing? Well... let's say it at least has a chance.
Now, whether Ethereum is another http/www/html or, say, another Project Xanadu, that's a different question. Ethereum is an idea that can only work if many untested pieces turn out to work together as desired and the main benefits from those technologies are sufficient for people to buy into what would be a clean departure from the existing web. Experience shows that such departures are seldom successful (remember when every website was going to be a Java Applet? That was still way less of a moonshot than Dapps). But the thing is, regardless of whether Ethereum succeeds or not, its development is likely to produce useful ideas, and it is a project that, at least in principle, should it succeed, really can change our infrastructure. It is worth keeping in mind, that, in some cases, changing infrastructure has changed the world quite significantly (e.g. trains, telegraph, Internet, and even WWW vs the telnet/email era of the Internet).
As the first example that springs to mind: computers have enabled access to telecommunications infrastructure (think cell phones), which have utterly transformed the lives of many of the world's poorest.
But a pipedream consensus database running on the internet? Colour me skeptical that it's going to utterly transform the world the way the computer has.
Anyone can pay to start and run a process ("contract" in ethereum-speak) that runs arbitrary (albeit sandboxed) code. Like you mentioned, processes can store data. Processes can also send and receive messages ("transactions" in ethereum-speak) with users and with other processes.
You wouldn't run an arbitrary program on Ethereum. You run programs on Ethereum to define the state transitions in a database the whole world can access and trust. If you're building a marketplace, for instance, then you're defining what it means when a customer buys something. Every customer and merchant who uses your system has proof of how their interactions will work, and it's impossible for anyone to try to cheat.
The database and its state transitions are what matters.
Can you give an example of what this would be used for and how?
If you're familiar with bitcoin: bitcoin is a platform that coordinates global views of bitcoin balances and verifiable logic for transfer of bitcoin from one account to another.
In a similar way: ethereum is a platform that coordinates global views of state and verifiable logic for state transitions.
> Can you give an example of what this would be used for and how?
This would be used in any scenario where a global or otherwise undefined group of actors desires to coordinate action in a way that does not inherently require trust from a single party.
In human terms, it is used when you want to communicate or interact with some unknown others without relying on a company/single entity to provide the medium.
Oh yeah, the example. Lets build a small one.
Lets say the people at the tor project wants to publish some master public keys, etc. There is a core group of folks who should have write access, but they don't necessarily trust each other. Some of their 'important decisions', like changing their group membership, or changing a public key, should be put to a vote. (Oh and lets say they need to be able to cycle their individual keys, as well)
They could create an ethereum contract (or interacting contracts) that managed the operation. They wouldn't have to necessarily trust each other individually, and their progress would be visible/verifiable by all.
The contract(s) would handle their published data (allowed adding/removing content), maintain their group membership, and would presumably only be modifiable by the members of their group. Members could be modelled as ethereum addresses. Member needs to change keys? Include logic to swap a member for another address, iff the call came from the member to be swapped out. Important tasks need to be voted on? Include logic to initiate and track votes on certain operations.
Unless you're really into the nitty gritty of cryptocurrency technology, it won't really make sense until people manage to build some compelling apps for it, hopefully around the summer time.
Think like a marketing guy. I don't care about the specifics of the mechanism. Tell me what it will do for me, the user, that I'll care about.
At its heart, ethereum is a tool for minimizing counterparty risk and cost. You don't want Twitter to extinguish 3rd party twitter clients? You don't want Uber to take a 30% monopoly fee on every transaction? You don't want your stock broker to front-load your market orders? These are all forms of counterparty risk/cost.
So the compelling applications for ethereum are: A prediction market with minimal counterparty risk, a stock exchange minimal counterparty risk, a product market with minimal counterparty risk, a currency exchange with minimal counterparty risk, a poker site with minimal counterparty risk, a social network with minimal counterparty risk, a ride sharing site with minimal counterparty risk, etc.
I've still yet to come across a single person who can give me a compelling reason for Ethereum to exist other than "this is awesome because it will change the world" or other similar drivel. It's always impossible due to limits in Ethereum's design, limits of reality, or just stuff you can do in Bitcoin anyway and nobody has realized.
For example there's a fad of putting "ownership" of physical assets into bitcoin tokens for example, fine, that works until someone steals the token and not the physical asset. Now who owns the asset? Reality is out of sync with what the block chain says so, there's no support to help me get it back and no backdoor.
Privacy is even harder. With Bitcoin everyone knows what you spend, where you spend it, probably what you spend it too with some extrapolation. With "smart contracts" now everybody knows who your arbitrator is, who you play poker with, what brand of fridge you own. There's no getting around that if you want a public ledger.
If you're taking input from an oracle (you almost always are), you have the same level of trust in it anyway, you just moved computation into the stupidly expensive and massively redundant portion of the system. The 'solutions' for distributed oracles with ShellingCoin and related garbage is just hand wavy nonsense with so little basis in reality that it's not worth talking about.
There is this notion of a contract. In a democracy a valid contract is an agreement (say between 2 parties) which is enforceable by courts and executive. Enforceable means that there is a cost of cheating. Even the most simple purchase contains a purchase agreement. If Alice walks into Bob's store and takes something without paying, then this is what we call theft (although the precise details of theft can be argued about ad infinitum).
In the real world when we enter agreements, we usually know to some extent who we are dealing with (Alice knows Bob's store). What would an arbitrary agreement over a network look like? That's hard to say. An analogon of a court is some arbitrary human decision, which can serve as an input. In Bitcoin there is no notion of an agreement, only cash transactions (and some limited facilities for escrow).
I believe that the concept of an oracle, and several other crypto-terms like Zero-knowledge proofs are an academic dead end. For my purposes I'm assuming that most people who want to use crypto systems don't understand or care about these things. There will be a great need for mapping abstract concepts to useful tools, such as an GUI operating system maps very abstract physical calculations and processes and makes them usable. I suspect 99% of Bitcoin users don't understand public-key cryptography, much less Elliptic curves and distributed systems. "Key", "signature" and "coins" are useful metaphors.
What is already happening are the first beginnings of joint stock ownership developing (DAC's) with mixtures of online formal agreements and informal agreements. Voting is not a panacea, but it helps. That's the kind of contract that can be developed in the short term.
Are you saying you have citations that prove ShellingCoin won't work? Are you saying you have a citation from an ethereum developer that these ideas are 100% certain to work out on the first attempt?
If not, why are you complaining about people unconnected to you trying these new ideas out as an experiment? Nobody disagrees that these are new and untested ideas.
No, I take issue with them selling broken shit to people for tens of millions of dollars.
I agree that the core ethereum tech is 100% fair game for criticism, but that's not what's being discussed here.
It'd be trustless (i.e., anyone can verify that they're not being cheated), and couldn't easily be taken down [1]
[1] https://forum.ethereum.org/discussion/comment/2944/#Comment_...
- Decentralized, low-margin labor markets (e.g. Uber, Postmates, etc.) with lower prices for consumers and higher profits for workers
- Currencies based on local prices indexes, which can give even the smallest of countries stable money that they don't have today
And lots of other things people haven't thought of yet.
For alt-coins pre-mining generally means its a scam.
They are proposing a whole bunch of next generation functionality, which if they pull it off may overcome the unfairness of pre-mining and make them all super rich.
But it's super ambitious and isn't yet clear that it will even be possible to do what they want to do, and if they do it will take years to establish the trust necessary to use it for its intended purpose.
Choosing to pre-mine means anyone who does due diligence won't be trusting them for quite awhile.
I think this is still a lot of hype (And this article is just adding to it) without substance.
I think the way bitcoin was done was correct-- no hype and just a release of code.
https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/04/10/the-issuance-model-in-e...
(INB4 someone says the ether allocated in the genesis block doesn't fit the strict definition of a premine)
https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/White-Paper#currency-a...
(FYI I'm a fan of ethereum, just trying to get the facts straight)
> 0.099x the total amount sold (60102216 ETH) will be allocated to the organization to compensate early contributors and pay ETH-denominated expenses before the genesis block.
> 0.099x the total amount sold will be maintained as a long-term reserve.
But here's a pdf of the terms of sale which has figures similar to the chart: http://ethereum.org/pdf/TermsAndConditionsOfTheEthereumGenes...
Nobody is making any extrordinary claims that they have some sort of magical technology that others can't duplicate (and all of them except bithalo are open source, making duplication easy.) The only question is which platform will be first to deliver an experience that will attract main stream users, in terms of stability and functionality.