0x8D3A
0x8D3A on Hacker News
If you're doing stock ownership "in contracts", why not just have the company manage it? Obviously you trust them if you're investing in them, what's to gain by doing it "autonomously"? A centralized version is faster, cheaper, and private, you're going to need a hell of a good reason to actually go down this route rather than "it's the future".
It boils down the point that you don't actually want to be doing computation at that level anyway. There's a very good reason that Bitcoin Script should be simplistic, why the hell would you want to be doing any sort of detailed computation at that level? With n nodes on the network you amplify the load n times, why not do it on an oracle where it's practically free? There's already comments by the Ethereum developers that it will be incredibly hard for a client to ever bootstrap from genesis once they launch, just due to the insane amount of script execution time.
If you're taking input from an oracle (you almost always are), you have the same level of trust in it anyway, you just moved computation into the stupidly expensive and massively redundant portion of the system. The 'solutions' for distributed oracles with ShellingCoin and related garbage is just hand wavy nonsense with so little basis in reality that it's not worth talking about.
> If not, why are you complaining about people unconnected to you trying these new ideas out as an experiment?
No, I take issue with them selling broken shit to people for tens of millions of dollars.
ShellingCoin has pretty hand wavy economic justifications and won't see real world use (or if it does, it'll see use until it loses people lots of money due to faulty incentives).
Even in cases where it might be possible the end result to a human is often completely unusable. You might hate the Uber taxi cartel or whatever, but at least using them you have some degree of privacy (with "smart contracts" your privacy is absolutely gone, and not just financial privacy) and customer service.
For example there's a fad of putting "ownership" of physical assets into bitcoin tokens for example, fine, that works until someone steals the token and not the physical asset. Now who owns the asset? Reality is out of sync with what the block chain says so, there's no support to help me get it back and no backdoor.
Privacy is even harder. With Bitcoin everyone knows what you spend, where you spend it, probably what you spend it too with some extrapolation. With "smart contracts" now everybody knows who your arbitrator is, who you play poker with, what brand of fridge you own. There's no getting around that if you want a public ledger.
Some of your examples need oracles to deliver information into the script, which is (oh no!) your counter party so you're back to square one again. It doesn't work in any other way due to the realities of distributed consensus. The example of a poker system within Ethereum is incredibly unlikely, a social network or Uber clone the same but for meatspace issues rather than cryptographic ones.
I've still yet to come across a single person who can give me a compelling reason for Ethereum to exist other than "this is awesome because it will change the world" or other similar drivel. It's always impossible due to limits in Ethereum's design, limits of reality, or just stuff you can do in Bitcoin anyway and nobody has realized.
Scammers isn't the least of it. The system they have designed and executed is ludicrously insecure and falls to even the most basic of flaws. It's unlikely that it will ever be able to achieve consensus given the endless stream of crashes and logic errors, like being able to send yourself a negative balance (thus, infinite money) or crashing every node in the network by sending a block header with a nonce of zero. The sheer quantity of security bugs and undefined behavior in the
two clients attempting to act in bit-for-bit identical ways in two different languages is quite alarming.
https://github.com/ethereum/go-ethereum/issues?utf8=%E2%9C%9...
I'd bet against it ever getting to try it's consensus given that their launch is now going to be completely centralized (ie, it can't stand up on it's own let alone with malicious attackers, so it's going to be remotely controlled by the developers for now). Will they ever remove the crutch and risk everything crumbling? Seems very doubtful.