News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by option on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:14PM (#9292988)
Having worked as researcher/dev in both private office and open space setup, I am absolutely convinced that private offices are way more productive than open office setup for researchers and developers. Most, if not all, of my colleagues feel the same. In fact, I don't think I will ever accept an offer from a mature company (not startup) which houses its developers in open space.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by Swizec on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:19PM (#9293007)
The only redeeming feature of open plan comes from Hamming's essay, you and your research:

Another trait, it took me a while to notice. I noticed the following facts about people who work with the door open or the door closed. I notice that if you have the door to your office closed, you get more work ✥ done today and tomorrow, and you are more productive than most. But 10 years later somehow you don't ✥ know quite know what problems are worth working on; all the hard work you do is sort of tangential in ✱ importance. He who works with the door open gets all kinds of interruptions, but he also occasionally gets clues as to what the world is and what might be important. Now I cannot prove the cause and effect ✞ sequence because you might say, ``The closed door is symbolic of a closed mind.'' I don't know. But I can ✝ say there is a pretty good correlation between those who work with the doors open and those who ✝ ultimately do important things, although people who work with doors closed often work harder. Somehow ✲ they seem to work on slightly the wrong thing - not much, but enough that they miss fame.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by legohead on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:42PM (#9293407)
The key takeaway from that to me is to at least have an office. Keep it open most of the time for communication, close it when you need privacy.

The whole "easier to collaborate with others" with an open floor plan is just excuse. I communicate better over text chat anyway.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by PMan74 on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:27PM (#9293589)
> I communicate better over text chat anyway.

I don't know you of course but I really doubt that text chat would ever surpass the effectiveness of face to face communication.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by TillE on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:12PM (#9294162)
Text makes it much easier to share a link, refer to something in the code, etc. It's not ideal for in-depth discussions, but it can often be better for handling typical questions.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by kevinskii on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:54PM (#9293174)
Sitting in an office with the door open to welcome impromptu conversation is very different from, and much preferable to, sitting in an open floor plan with no privacy whatsoever. Hamming's essay doesn't redeem the open plan at all.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by conitpicker on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:38PM (#9293386)
I had a single office at my last job. I'm in a shared office today. At my current job I feel much less aware of what's going on around me because I spend all my time with headphones on.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by romland on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:14PM (#9293272)
I sort of half concluded that people with closed doors are more likely to be introverts and thus less likely to look for fame. :)

I'm not saying that you are saying the opposite, I'm just saying that the cause/effect is very much up in the air. I never thought it was as straight forward as asking "what is better?" (as he rightly asks too)

Personally, I never looked for fame (and I'm old enough to say that I likely never will look for it). In the end, what I want is: to be right. Even if it takes 100 wrongs to get there. With that in mind, I would be better off if I was an extrovert as I'd probably get through the wrongs quicker than if I preferred my solitude.

But as it stands, I like to be able to stare absentmindedly in a random direction without the risk of accidentally glancing at someone's new hat or haircut.

I don't know if I am slower or slightly wrong. I would not rule it out, though. :)

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by markeroon on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:00PM (#9293481)
N=1, sure, but I'm very extroverted and I strongly prefer a closed, single occupancy office.

There's nothing about being extroverted that makes you like concentrating less. ;)

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by nostrademons on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:43PM (#9293125)
I think Hamming's quote pretty much sums up my personal experience with both open and closed offices. In a private office, your personal productivity is maximized; you get the most lines of code written, the most research done, the hardest problems solved. And yet the cumulative effect of that productivity seems to be much less than that of peers who write little, endure distractions, but are always in tune with which problems people are interested in.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by Swizec on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:04PM (#9293223)
I think the real problem is one of aligning incentives. I would welcome open plan offices much more if I was incentivized for team performance.

Instead I get forced into open collaboration-enhancing offices with the idea of increasing team productivity. But on scrums and all other things I am judged on the merits of personal productivity (tickets closed, issues resolved, whatever). This leaves me disgruntled because I have no way of showing to project managers that I've helped N people with their issues. They only care how many issues I closed.

This then shapes my personal values and how I judge myself as well. Which in turn makes me shun the open plan office. Which in turn ultimately makes me a worse engineer a few years down the line.

This is a problem.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by geofft on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:38PM (#9293635)
We, as an industry, need to start pushing employers to make job posts talk more about "Management measures your value to the company in these ways, and rewards them in these ways" and less about "We've got a kegerator and a ball pit."
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by pan69 on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:03PM (#9293215)
I think that there are pros and cons with both, however, I believe that a developer should have at least a "choice". With this I mean, for some of the work I do I can sit in a noisy environment and get stuff done, take e.g. doing some HTML or something else mostly "visual", however, when I need to focus and I am going to be juggling loads of tiny details in short term memory I want an environment that is quiet so I can focus.

The problem with a noisy open space environment is that my environment is going to decide when I can do work. When I have the inspiration to fix a problem and I need to be able to focus, this has to be on "my terms", not that of my environment.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by noddingham on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:33PM (#9293083)
You and all the research seems to agree. Of course, the anecdotal evidence outliers will disagree, but I don't see how there's a debate anymore when you look at productivity.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by option on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:42PM (#9293121)
Google yourself on pros and cons of open office. There are lots of studies on both. I am yet to see practical solutions to noise and disease spread (e.g. flu season) problems.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by unholiness on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @03:24AM (#9294809)
I've seen the phrase "all the research" thrown around quite a lot in this thread. Would you mind linking to a few studies you refer to?

Mainly, I'm curious about how they define productivity. An office full of people performing completely independent tasks is almost certainly less productive than having separate offices; the advantage of open offices comes when everyone's work is interrelated. In an open environment, whenever I need to make a decision on implementation, I can easily ask someone intimately familiar with the area my code effects, and vice versa. The result is that people are more likely to make the better choices for the long-term future of the code base.

I'm also curious if there are any longitudinal studies that address moral. I wouldn't be surprised if people in open offices feel less like a cog in the system. I could also imagine it's a lot harder to develop a hatred of your coworkers and your boss if they're working right in front of you.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by frostmatthew on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @09:27AM (#9295962)
> I've seen the phrase "all the research" thrown around quite a lot in this thread. Would you mind linking to a few studies you refer to?

There's a good New Yorker article[1] from last year that references a number of studies. This blog post[2] links to a couple others and addresses costs/alternatives. Also, "a study of over 40,000 survey responses collected over a decade has found that the benefits for workers are quickly outweighed by the disadvantages"[3]. Here's a Washington Post article[4] referencing Facebook's new building and linking to a few other studies.

Of course you can certainly decide to dismiss the research and base your opinion on anecdotes or assumptions, but don't judge research as being poorly done just because you disagree with the findings.

[1] http://www.newyorker.com/currency-tag/the-open-office-trap

[2] http://nathanmarz.com/blog/the-inexplicable-rise-of-open-flo...

[3] http://theconversation.com/open-plan-offices-attract-highest...

[4] http://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2014/12/30/g...

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by noddingham on Wednesday April 08, 2015 @11:31AM (#9341391)
Thanks for this, I went away for a week and didn't know this sub-thread took off so much and felt bad for not responding.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by threeseed on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:41PM (#9293115)
I don't know if the research is that crystal clear right now.

I have no doubt that developers will write more code whilst in offices free of distraction. But the question is do they miss out on key business knowledge by not being around other people. Especially if they are in Agile feature teams.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by InclinedPlane on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:41PM (#9293406)
When I was working in offices I felt the cross pollination was actually superior in that environment. I could have a long (hours long) talk with a co-worker in their office or mine and really dig down into something and share a lot of knowledge (either general or tribal). Whereas with an open office you tend to try to keep things short because you tend to be interrupting many people instead of just one, and because you lack the almost conspiratorial intimacy that you can have with an office the sorts of discussions you have are comparatively constrained.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by vonmoltke on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:50PM (#9293159)
> But the question is do they miss out on key business knowledge by not being around other people.

Considering the amount of money and effort engineers put into blocking distractions in open-plan offices, it is probably about the same.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by threeseed on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:01PM (#9293206)
Again the trend seems to be mixed plan. Open plan offices with private areas.

In which case you can not argue that there is significant money/effort involved. It's either the cost of headphones and the effort of walking tens of metres. Developers are going to need better arguments than that to convince HR/Management that this is not a trend worth doing.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by vonmoltke on Monday March 30, 2015 @09:06PM (#9293745)
> Again the trend seems to be mixed plan. Open plan offices with private areas.

What do you mean, "again"? This statement is the first mention of such in this sub-discussion. Also, I'm not going on a tangent about the joke that the "private areas" in such offices turn into or how infeasible this design is for many lines of business.

> In which case you can not argue that there is significant money/effort involved.

"Significant money and effort" as in the sum total devoted to finding solutions to the problem of distracting, sub-optimal environments being foisted upon engineers, not the cost to a single hypothetical engineer.

> It's either the cost of headphones and the effort of walking tens of metres.

That statement presumes: a) headphones are allowed; b) headphones work for everyone; c) people have work they can pick up and move; d) that private areas actually exist in sufficient quantity for those who want them; e) that private areas are not appropriated permanently by people up the political food chain.

> Developers are going to need better arguments than that to convince HR/Management that this is not a trend worth doing.

That statement assumes HR and Management care about any argument besides cost.

Also, you completely ignored the point I was actually making, which is that throwing engineers together into a giant room does not give you the cross-pollination that so many management consultants claim you get.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by thrownaway2424 on Monday March 30, 2015 @09:04PM (#9293736)
If I have to walk tens of meters to meet in a private space with anyone I want to talk to, then 1) the supposed serendipitous transfer of knowledge does not happen, and 2) we could just as easily have had this encounter in my or their private office space.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by thrownaway2424 on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:34PM (#9293618)
Maybe you can train your Agile developers to write down "key business knowledge" in complete sentences. You don't prefer to live under the tyranny of oral tradition, do you?
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by JohnBooty on Monday March 30, 2015 @10:20PM (#9294015)
The debate isn't whether or not collaborative work is highly beneficial. It is highly beneficial. Crucial, even.

The debate is about whether or not we want to force employees to exclusively in a collaborative way, with no reliable option for quiet solo work -- as many of these "open office" workplaces do -- is a good idea.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by borplk on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @05:17AM (#9295126)
No they would miss out on what Crystal did over the weekend and how shit-faced Jenny got.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by threeseed on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:31PM (#9293076)
The trend in most modern workspaces is to have mixed use. Generally open plan for most day-to-day work and then a variety of private areas. For example offices and cubicles that are shared.

Development is always tricky because often you need clear air to solve problems but then occasionally collaboration is required.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by Devthrowaway80 on Monday March 30, 2015 @09:32PM (#9293860)
It'd be helpful if there was some way for people to collaborate using computers, or if facetime is what you want, some sort of shared room where you can talk without disturbing others who are working.

Technology might get us there someday.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by patmcc on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:10PM (#9293521)
I think everyone agrees that you need both options, but there's still the question of which is better:

1. Open plan for day-to-day with some private rooms. 2. Private rooms for day-to-day with lots of breakout rooms (or similar).

I think the first is cheaper (lower square footage), but I'd much rather work in the second.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by MCRed on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:16PM (#9293286)
It's not really that tricky- there are many tools for collaboration including IRC. And you can always go to another developers office, in the ideal one developer-per office situation.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by vlunkr on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:42PM (#9293120)
For me, open office + headphones = private office. At a vastly reduced cost. I know that doesn't work for everyone though.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by EC1 on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:48PM (#9293145)
I've tried to make myself believe that I'm more productive with headphones. Unfortunately the truth is I work best in terrifying silence.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by sdrothrock on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:02PM (#9294125)
I work in an open-ish office and have two problems with this:

1. I have glasses and a hearing aid (cochlear implant) and have yet to find headphones that don't make my left ear/head throb with pain after more than six hours.

2. Visual distractions: people walking through, people seemingly approaching me (but actually approaching someone nearby), people waving, etc. are all just as bad as auditory distractions, if not worse for me personally since I tend to rely heavily on vision to replace what I can't hear.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by jmspring on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:33PM (#9293360)
Open office + headphones negates some of the "pluses" touted by open office advocates. When I worked at Skype, the office in Palo Alto got some kudos for the "design" -- http://www.designblitzsf.com/projects/skype-hq/ being one such URL.

As far as noise goes, even with audio engineers on staff, the level of disruptive noise was horrible. People having calls at their desks, testing mobile notifications, etc. Thankfully, I worked at home 50+% of the time as getting productive work done in the office was incredibly difficult. Large open space + open office = bad idea.

Our office in Stockholm, while an open office, had many smaller sections offset by walls, break rooms, etc. It was a much better experience overall, but still not optimal.

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by option on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:47PM (#9293139)
Yes, that's what many devs do. That is of varied efficiency to different people. In laboratory settings, noise has been repeatedly tied to reduced cognitive performance [1].

Also, what happens during flu season? How many people are gone and how often vs private office setting? I'd love to see a study on this.

[1] http://eab.sagepub.com/content/40/2/151.abstract

Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by jquery on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:03PM (#9293219)
It also equals hearing loss, but that doesn't show up on the company balance sheets.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by therealdrag0 on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:16PM (#9293283)
Closed cans or IEMs allow you to have very little (or no) audio volume while still blocking outside noise.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by moe on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:40PM (#9293400)
And both tend to get very uncomfortable when worn for extended periods of time.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by therealdrag0 on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:36PM (#9293623)
Totally agree. I think offices should be default with optional communal areas, not the opposite (communal offices with limited private work rooms).
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by pbreit on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:52PM (#9293699)
It does occur to you that wearing headphones all day in the office is kinda weird and undesirable for a lot of people?
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by afandian on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:54PM (#9293175)
+ hearing damage in a couple of decades
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by tedunangst on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:12PM (#9293261)
How loud is your open office?
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by praneshp on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:21PM (#9293308)
It's as a result of prolonged headphone use, not loudness.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by wishinghand on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:37PM (#9293384)
I don't see how that's true, but I'm open to having my mind changed. But a comfortable listening level with well-insulated headphones/IEMs for prolonged hours shouldn't be damaging. It can be tiring but having periods of quiet (home life, sleep) re-invigorates them.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by arsenide on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:59PM (#9293474)
Source? I've only heard of sound intensity (not duration of sound) contributing to eventual hearing loss.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by afandian on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @03:29AM (#9294825)
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by jack-r-abbit on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:32PM (#9293355)
I guess I'm screwed either way. I have an office currently but I still use my headphones as much as when I didn't have one.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by InclinedPlane on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:19PM (#9293554)
A private office means you can have a meeting (scheduled or not) with up to 2 or 3 other people without having to bother looking for a conference room.
Re:“Today we moved into our new Facebook building” by threeseed on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:56PM (#9293183)
And when you allow for private working areas it is going to be very difficult for developers et al to argue against this trend. Everything has seemingly been thought of e.g. if you are sick give free flu shots and health checks to employees.

I am working in a company that is redesigning the building to be more open plan. It is clear that HR is driving the decision not architects or interior designers.