The issue of "abuse" which is harmful to people other than users of the forum should also be considered carefully.
Hipcrime destroyed many groups until people worked out how to filter the sporges; snuh made a lot of noise across a wide range of groups but didn't have much effect; Meow army disrupted many groups; and obviously alt.syntax.tactical
The fact that snuh were more disruptive than gnaa is telling because snuh just wasn't very disruptive.
Do you have some search terms?
>The issue of "abuse" which is harmful to people other than users of the forum should also be considered carefully.
If you think of always accessing the information through a "reader" rather than in raw form, than effectively the reader mods can delete and remove spam - users could subscribe to a reader, or several readers that can give different views of the same information - but also would have the choice not to do so.
Well, if there's one thing we know from 10 years of reddit its that people being able to delete content and usernames completely has negligible impact on readability.
Similarly, with 20 years of experience with ignore lists, I can confidently say that what small amounts of confusion might occasionally be generated from my ignore list being different to yours are well offset by the benefits of us being able to choose who we don't want to interact with.
Hypothetically, the worst you could do would be astroturf. (aka the US/Chinese military style "slightly biased posts from a large number of centrally controlled but seeming unrelated accounts")
However, the idea of slight bias over longer periods is somewhat antithetical to the idea of a spam. In that it might influence you to buy Sparkle towels (honestly, with Amazon prices that low and shipping that easy... [meta :p]) over a competitor, but isn't going to convince you to navigate to {insert sketch get-rich-quick spam scheme here}.
Weeding out astroturf is an entirely more interesting problem though...
Good example: I want to see everything my Aunt Susan is doing in her personal life on Facebook. I do not want to see anything ever for any reason that has to do with her Zynga games.
A single trust score doesn't really encapsulate that relationship and it's very possible she would effectively breach the WoT by allowing Zynga to send me messages, notices or e-mail in exchange for her to get a shiny new Farmville tractor or something.
I stopped using Facebook because of this kind of crap. I don't have the time, energy or interest to deal with people I do know sending me crap I don't want, and more importantly Facebook's flexible definition of privacy and customer service. I had Facebook change my settings away from their desired state more than once as part of an "policy" or "feature" update.
So I guess the meta discussion is about whether you trust the holder of the trust. LOL.
No it hasn't been validated for that use case for that large a system. Some examples where it has been used: PGP uses web of trust to validate keys. Freenet boards used web of trust to succesfully stave off spam attack. They are a lot smaller than reddit of course.
Someone made a fake PGP for me several years ago, and many people have chosen that over my genuine key when e-mailing me, just because the fake key is newer, even though my genuine key has lots of signatures and the fake key has none at all. (It was probably Enigmail helping them make the choice rather than a clearly informed decision.)
Meanwhile, there is already a complete clone of the strong set with colliding key IDs. That is, people have spent the computing time needed to make a fake version of every single public key, with the same name and key ID and signatures as the real one, just with a different fingerprint. (There's one at https://evil32.com/, but I think at least one other group has done the same thing!)
If someone uploaded those to the keyservers, there would be a fake copy of each PGP public key with the same key ID and the same signature structure (of course signed by other fake keys rather than by other real keys). At that point you would always have a 50% chance of getting a fake key every time you tried to use PGP to contact a new person, unless you consciously manually used an out-of-band fingerprint verification mechanism to bootstrap your selection of what key to use. You would never be safe in just guessing because you "found a key out there" for someone and it "looked right" and "had a bunch of signatures"!.
I'm willing to be more charitable toward the web of trust than someone like Moxie is -- I think more users could be taught to be more cautious, and software could help automate key exchange better -- but my own experiences with having a fake key out there in my name don't make me very optimistic about the way the web of trust is being used today. It's also sad to ponder, as Moxie has, that it seems PGP isn't even being used widely enough to make it worthwhile for attackers to try to DoS the web of trust, let alone to try to trick people into using the wrong keys on a large scale. (That is, PGP hasn't even reached Gandhi's "then they fight you" stage in the mass market.) This isn't to deny that PGP has provided major communications security benefits to smaller communities and groups that have consciously adopted it and use it carefully.
While spam would still be a problem, requiring a negligible payment would greatly reduce the ability of spammers to flood forums with posts.
It's highly decentralized, censorship resistant, and can be very anonymous.
Based on how poor the opsec of previous darknet admins has been, I see no reason to assume theirs was any better.
Hosting AMAs is both stupid and provocative IMHO when you're a drug dealer.
Unless your endgame, as would seem entirely reasonable as a logical illicit dealer, is pump sales and dump the entire business as quickly as possible.
In which case the additional attention and growth might offset the additional risk over short time horizons.
This is a public forum. Hell, one of the users even VOLUNTEERED himself to be interviewed by the users of one of the most popular websites in the world under the topic of what amounts to "I run or help run a drug smuggling/selling marketplace".
What reasonable expectation should this user have to privacy? You can't do all these things in public and then say "well, the government shouldn't be able to look at me for it" - I'd think what he did met the very definition of probable cause.
Note, for emphasis, that this is entirely an aside to the subject of legalization, as I'm actually much more pro-legalization than anything else.
You think the British weren't concerned at all about who was writing this propaganda and weren't willing to violate the "rights" of their colonists... because I think the authors were quite concerned.
Regardless if the Federalist Papers had bragged about smuggling a subsequent investigation would have compelled printers etc to name the authors.
subreddits are fantastic for that type of thing, and i like the ease of use and PRAW, however, handing over all of the community's data to conde nast isn't something i'm interested in.
what i'd like is a tool with which to create online communities, which would consist of a message board with upvotes/downvotes, user profiles, and perhaps a small chat system, with good mobile integration. as you said, it should be decentralized. it should also be as secure as possible without requiring non-standard software like TOR.
http://www.redditblog.com/2013/08/reddit-myth-busters_6.html
vBulletin has support for all of this, as does WordPress, and probably a hundred other pieces of software.
The downside, as always, is that you become a sysadmin and moderator and hacker and on-call technician.
Ethereum is a decentralized, consensus-driven data store and execution environment.
Whisper is a decentralized messaging protocol, which you'd use for data that doesn't require consensus. Consensus is expensive and relatively slow, but communication between parties doesn't require it.
Swarm and IPFS are content-addressable, decentralized file transfer systems. You'd use one of these to store the HTML, CSS and JavaScript that implement an application on top of the other decentralized systems. Or just to store arbitrary static files.
It's hard to shut down a system that lives on thousands of computers and can be accessed by typing the name of the site into a web browser. That's the experience that's motivating people to build these systems, and they're going to change the way the world works.
I was very active on usenet back in the early to mid 1990s and I would say that it was an enormously valuable experience. I interacted with a lot of smart people, I got to explore a lot of exciting areas of interest, and I spent a lot of time improving my writing abilities. It makes me sad to think that there are lots of people who well never benefit from that experience. At their best HN and parts of reddit can be excellent, but there's still a lot that they're missing.
This would make it so content that's purely spam wouldn't be pulled to all the USENET servers. If a moderation provider started vouching for a lot of spam, it would quickly be removed by providers.
This is pretty close to being what you describe, in that it will function as a transport layer - now all that is needed is a standardized protocol for how to put information onto it that can be easily found.
I'm not saying that drug discussion is the quintessential act that deserves to be protected, but I am worried that the government has such an easy avenue to get this information. What happens when it's something far more political? What happens when they serve a gag order alongside their subpoena? What happens when the people talking aren't technically inclined, and don't use Tor? (By the way, I would bet these people were using Tor and this subpoena is useless.)