News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by rootbear on Thursday February 12, 2015 @10:47AM (#9039261)
I like the idea of having solar cells that charge up a bank of batteries that could power my house at night. I was recently talking to a Solar City rep and they are thinking along those lines.

I wonder if this would be a good time to define a standard low voltage plug for house hold use. An awful lot of modern electrical devices don't need 110VAC and end up wasting a lot of power converting AC to DC. I've seen replacements for wall sockets that combine a single AC socket with a few USB power ports. That's convenient, but USB wasn't designed as a power plug, it's just been co-opted for it. A well designed system of 24VDC or 48VDC would be a nice thing to have. Bonus points if it's a world standard. I'd also like a pony.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by todd8 on Thursday February 12, 2015 @01:38PM (#9040437)
The problem with low voltage power is power loss during transmission. Power in a circuit is voltage times current:

Watts = Volts * Amps

Power lost in transmission is current through the wire times the voltage drop across the wire. The voltage drop is easy to figure out with Ohms law:

Volts = Amps * Ohms

Rewriting these with V = voltage, I = current in amps, R = resistance in ohms and P = power in Watts and simplifying one gets:

    P = V * I
    P = (I * R) * I
    P = I**2 * R
So power losses are proportional to the square of the current flowing through any given piece of wire (that will have a resistance independent of the voltage or current).

My house has 20 Amp circuits at 120 Volts. The same power transmitted at 5 volts needs 24 times the current (i.e. 480 Amps) and 24^2 times the copper in the transmission wire to have the same power losses. So I would basically need a wire with 576 times as much copper to have the same power loss in that one low voltage circuit.

This is why it isn't practical to run the whole house on low voltage. High efficiency transformers can step up or down a voltage while losing only a few percent of the power. When their output voltage is 10 times higher their output current will be 10 times smaller and can be transmitted over the same wire with only 1 percent of the original voltage's transmission power loss.

This is the reason that power transmission lines run at 120,000 volts--a million times lower transmission line losses. (It actually is a bit more complicated due to the alternating current interactions, but it's the basic idea.) Power transformers can be 99% efficient. I have no idea of the power losses that would occur between DC current from solar panels to 120 VAC and then back to 5 VDC for USB, but you definitely don't want to transmit 5VDC over long distances.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by rootbear on Thursday February 12, 2015 @03:24PM (#9041153)
Thanks, I'm getting a great understanding of all of this from the comments here. I suspect that USB is going to end up being the universal low-voltage power source, but I still think that's a shame, as something more like 24 to 48V would be better, especially if there was a well designed, universal connector.

I'm still amazed that they can get 100W out of those tiny USB wires...

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by wlesieutre on Thursday February 12, 2015 @06:53PM (#9042121)
The 100W delivery over USB actually bumps it up to 5 amps at 20V. The higher power profiles aren't available by default until the devices negotiate the higher voltage and confirm that the cable can support it.

With how much USB cables get beat up, staying on the lower end of voltage is probably a good idea. I've definitely seen some old ones that ended up with wires exposed. But 20V is definitely more capable than the old 5V. You'd need a lot of copper to run 100W at 5V.

More info: http://www.usb.org/developers/powerdelivery/PD_1.0_Introduct...

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by CucumberLime on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:31PM (#9040829)
I think the idea is use these only for low wattage applications, way below 2400 Watts. 48V at, say, 10A is plenty of power for many uses. Also the transmission distances should be relatively short if coming from a battery in the home.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by jws on Thursday February 12, 2015 @03:34PM (#9041221)
The cross over is surprisingly early. I care for a cabin that uses a 24VDC battery for its solar power storage. I run that in #6 copper to the cabin (pencil thick conductors). I regularly see a >2 volt drop on that run when the tiny high efficiency fridge kicks on, on top of the ~40watts that the telemetry and comm gear takes. You wouldn't notice that on a 120v line, but that's 10% of my power gone to heating the earth.

Given a do-over on infrastructure, with today's equipment costs, it would save up front capital and power to use a small inverter at the batteries and run those items off of AC using smaller copper lines for the long run. Keep in mind that you still need DC-DC converters at the loads, since nothing is going to want to run off of your varying DC socket voltage.

(Batteries closer to the cabin is not a win, the solar panels are off that direction and those lines need to be kept short too. I do have a large inverter in the battery shed and send 120v to the cabin for big loads, but its idle current is too high to keep up for the base loads. The most expensive part of this spring's wind turbine installation (and heaviest) is the copper wire. Low voltage DC is not an answer.)

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by samatman on Thursday February 12, 2015 @10:55AM (#9039314)
The new USB standard supports up to 100 watts per port, which is sufficient to many applications.

If we accepted 20 amps as the current rating, a 12v ride-on system would offer 100 / 5 * 12 -> 240 watts, which seems low, except that DC, especially if well filtered, stacks in parallel and series much more composably than AC.

The cigarette charger standard plug sucks though, and there's a limited window of opportunity to replace it.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by rootbear on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:07AM (#9039388)
Yeah, we have two standards now, auto cigarette sockets and USB, neither of which is optimal. And I agree, the window of opportunity here is narrow and I'd hate to see us miss it.

Oh, and to address the comment on wattage, I should have made clear I don't want to eliminate AC sockets where they are needed. I'm just looking at having DC in the wall as a convenience and efficiency thing and a way to reduce the number of power adaptors I need.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by wodenokoto on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:43AM (#9039671)
What could a new standard do that usb can't? Next generation is reversible, there's little to no chance of touching a half plugged in plug and get shocked. It seems pretty good to me.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by MichaelGG on Thursday February 12, 2015 @03:17PM (#9041108)
There's the security downside of plugging in a data capable port when you think you're just getting power. I know this isn't worth consideration for most people, though, and there are "condoms" to deal with it. Still, it'd be nice if we could fully rely on charging devices with no chance of being attacked, like dedicated power systems in use on most laptops today.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by wodenokoto on Friday February 13, 2015 @01:41AM (#9043207)
I agree on the security issue you bring up, but I also disagree.

I don't see it as a step forward to add an extra port to my cellphone or tablet. Lamps and small kitchen appliances don't even read data.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by MichaelGG on Friday February 13, 2015 @02:42AM (#9043314)
No, but when you bring a charge adapter for normal electric, there's no risk. Whereas as USB gets more universal, you're less likely to bring your own charger, or even your own cable, opening up attack vectors.

There's probably no mass-appeal way to satisfy both goals.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by m_mueller on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:37AM (#9039615)
USB has the best chance to be successful (since people already get used to it on airplanes etc.) - it's better than nothing.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by ChuckMcM on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:40AM (#9039652)
I've often wondered if someone would make a DC outlet strip. As the typical one has a half dozen "wall wart" type power supplies plugged into it, doing the conversion to say 24VDC and then down converting from there seem to be more convenient. But efficiency wise its something of a wash.

And from a whole house perspective, I keep hoping for a capacitor (storing charge directly rather than in chemical bonds) which would give me back most of the energy I had stored.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by reportingsjr on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:44AM (#9039679)
That is sort of becoming a thing with USB outlets. It is starting to become quite ubiquitous. I wouldn't be surprised to see an outlet that had 4+ USB ports and a standard outlet maybe.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by jimktrains2 on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:57AM (#9039790)
Laptops, speakers, and many other devices require more than USB2 can deliver (though Type-C might change that).

Also, USB outlets still down convert 120V AC. It'd be much better to do it in bulk at once place in the house and let devices use that

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by JoshTriplett on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:01PM (#9039807)
> Also, USB outlets still down convert 120V AC. It'd be much better to do it in bulk at once place in the house and let devices use that

That's not entirely clear. Low-voltage DC has higher transmission losses, so converting to USB-level voltage in one central location might do quite a bit worse. Plus, you still need logic at the plug to detect how much power to supply.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by ChuckMcM on Thursday February 12, 2015 @01:29PM (#9040365)
This is my opinion as one. Switching supplies are 90+ efficient, at nominal load and they are less efficient below and above that nominal load. So your 48VDC converter might by 87% efficient because its rated for 500W and you're only drawing 50. And your 5V regulator may be only 92% efficient while your device is charging but 88% when your device is 'idling'.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by seanalltogether on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:31PM (#9039994)
Is there any plug system for automatically stepping voltage based on the plug design, so people wouldn't have to set it manually? Like say you had 24v as the base, using a plug with 4 prongs gives you the full 24v, a plug with 3 prongs gives you 12v, 2 prongs gives you 6v, etc...
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by wtallis on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:29PM (#9040808)
Almost all the power connectors used inside a desktop PC have at least two voltages. For example, a hard drive will usually draw from only the 5V and 12V pins, but some SSDs are designed to use 3.3V.

The problem with these connectors is that they usually aren't designed for many plug/unplug cycles. The SATA power connector is also nearly unique in being designed for hotplugging by ensuring that the ground pins make contact first and disconnect last.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by tcdent on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:43PM (#9040060)
I'm using XLR connectors in some of my projects for just that. In my case: 5v, 12v, 24v, low amperage only.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by JshWright on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:35PM (#9040019)
It would be two prongs, just spaced differently to contact a different positive rail.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by fastball on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:34PM (#9040008)
> "Most of the energy I stored"

??

I was under the impression that a capacitor takes twice the amount of energy to charge than what is actually stored within it. i.e. efficiency is a maximum of 50%.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by coryrc on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:48PM (#9040093)
Only when you parallel an empty capacitor with a full one. Ordinary electrolytic capacitors filled via a switching supply are >99% efficient.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by JshWright on Thursday February 12, 2015 @10:54AM (#9039311)
Modern switching transformers are pretty darn efficient. I think it's very unlikely that the losses from converting AC to DC would outweigh the transmission losses you'd get from using low voltage DC (even over the short distances inside a house).
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by samatman on Thursday February 12, 2015 @10:58AM (#9039336)
I would love to see a Fermi estimate of this, I'm afraid it's outside my bailiwick.

The proposal would be 48VDC (pretty standard for panels) to 120VAC 50Hz, back to 5 and 12 volt at the application, versus sending 12 and 5 volt around a house, call it 10x10 meter perimeter and pessimize the layout (some outlets go all the way around the house).

My strong sense is that the single-step conversion beats the three-step, but losses transmitting low voltage DC are substantial.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by wtallis on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:16AM (#9039435)
Sending 12V around a 22' boat leads to voltage drops that are beyond the tolerances of many of the devices that consume 5 and 12 volt DC. Sending it around a whole house would require stupidly thick wires to stay within ATX spec (5%).
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by adamgravitis on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:15AM (#9039428)
My understanding was that the greater losses in today's tech tend to lie at the VDC->VAC conversion panel-side.

Also, I agree that the USB Power Delivery spec is a very good candidate for modern homes/vehicles.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by aptwebapps on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:54AM (#9039762)
Of course, if you're running off a battery it's DC to start with, so you're avoiding using the inverter.

If houses started coming with standardized low-voltage DC alongside the regular 110 AC, manufacturers could perhaps start selling CFLs and LEDs without builtin transformers. Although I'm not what voltage they actually run on internally.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by coryrc on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:56PM (#9040132)
CFLs require a switching power supply because they operate at far higher voltages than line voltage. LEDs require some sort of current regulator, and a switching power supply is far more efficient than a series resistor. So, you don't gain anything for them by using a different voltage.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by aptwebapps on Thursday February 12, 2015 @09:34PM (#9042589)
So much for that pet theory. ;)
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by rootbear on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:12AM (#9039416)
Yeah, I wondered about that, but my electronics-fu is not up to analyzing it. Running low voltage DC from one end of a large house to the other might simply not be practical. I'd still like to see a low-voltage plug standard other than USB and cigarette sockets, even if the conversion was being done inside the electrical box in my wall. I see the huge number of wall warts I have as a source of needless duplication and waste. (They are also, I understand, a revenue source for vendors selling replacements at inflated prices, so there is an economic incentive for the status quo.)
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by TD-Linux on Thursday February 12, 2015 @10:57AM (#9039329)
Running off-grid solar cell systems has been quite popular in the hobbyist space for a while. There are tons of products and examples out there for DIY installations. These generally use lead-acid batteries and inverters to convert DC up to 110 VAC for your house.

There are already DC power standards used for electronics, too. Telecom equipment commonly uses -48 VDC. However, I expect that you will find that the majority of your electricity is used by motors and other appliances that run directly off of 110 VAC.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by diydsp on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:17AM (#9039442)
Exactly. And not even just in hobbyist space. There is a long-established history of running homes off of solar power using lead-acid batteries in professional installations. And not even just in homes; many, many businesses have invested in it. The only barrier is financing... and companies are even forming California to amortize the financing of solar to the home, so home owners can get started with ~$200/month instead of a $20k installation.

There, the possibility that a "Tesla" battery could do anything the same or better is not new, redundant and this article is just marketing hype: It's a report of an investor call, for crying out loud, not researched journalism. There is no reason to expect a lithium battery in the home would be cheaper than traditional, established lead-acid batteries.

The advantage of lithium in a car is obvious (weight, if you haven't had your coffee). In the home, weight is not a factor. Lithium would save space, but at the expense of lifetime and cost. Since cost is the only factor holding back installation now, I don't expect many people to pay even more for the privilege of a lithium home battery bank.

BTW, in reference to your expectation, a motors expert I work with says that 50% of all electricity consumed is consumed by motors. The refrigerator's compressor motor is generally the heaviest electricity consumer in the home.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by IgorPartola on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:35AM (#9039603)
The barrier is batteries and the cost of them. I briefly looked into this. To run my house's essentials: heat, water, fridge, and 1-2 outlets for electronics I currently use a 5KW generator when the power goes out. I have a transfer switch that shows me my peak current: roughly 2.5-3 KW when the well and fridge are running. A deep cycle marine batter that you can readily buy from Amazon costs $100 or so and gives you 12 Volt 35AH. That's 420 Watt hours. Thus to run just the bare essentials in my house for 1 hour, I'd need 7 of these (assuming perfect DC to AC conversion). To run for 24 hours, I'd need 168 of them. So I am investing $16,800 in just batteries. But don't forget, that there will be periods of cloudy days, so you want enough capacity to get through those. I haven't seen the sun here in CT for about a week now... Oh, and in the summer, I do like my AC which itself pulls 5kW and has a relatively high starting current. I'd have to quadruple the capacity to run it. My basement is simply not large enough to contain all these batteries + inverter system. Doing all this to save under $200/month on the electric bill will never pay for itself.

A low cost space saving battery with high energy density would be pretty game changing here.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by jvickers on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:41PM (#9040045)
In a home, size and weight is a bit of a factor.

Is the building strong enough to support the weight? Space also has a cost.

It would also cost more to manufacture, transport and install big and heavy equipment, because it is big and heavy equipment.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by danielweber on Thursday February 12, 2015 @01:01PM (#9040159)
As you probably know, lead-acid also requires more maintenance than Li-Ion. Li-Ion's nice selling point for consumers is that you don't need to (especially) worry about stuff like battery memory.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by nerfhammer on Thursday February 12, 2015 @01:21PM (#9040301)
Why do we need to use a chemical battery for large things that aren't mobile? Why can't we store kinetic energy by, say, raising and lowering a big counterweight?
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by HNaTTY on Friday February 13, 2015 @12:58PM (#9045788)
http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/11/pump-up-the-stor...

"The main problem with gravitational storage is that it is incredibly weak compared to chemical, compressed air, or flywheel techniques (see the post on home energy storage options). For example, to get the amount of energy stored in a single AA battery, we would have to lift 100 kg (220 lb) 10 m (33 ft) to match it. To match the energy contained in a gallon of gasoline, we would have to lift 13 tons of water (3500 gallons) one kilometer high (3,280 feet)."

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by bdcs on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:01PM (#9040619)
Steel is 36 cents per pound. Assume you can move it up and down 300ft (30 story building). This will get you 1pound * g * 300ft of energy storage. This comes out to 300,000 USD/kWh, about a 1000 times more expensive than Li-ion batteries, per kilowatt-hour.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by wtallis on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:41PM (#9040888)
Gravity is too weak. Flywheels are the way to store kinetic/mechanical energy, but the up front cost is pretty steep.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by ph0rque on Thursday February 12, 2015 @10:52AM (#9039300)
One could bootstrap by using 12V RV appliances, with the exception of big items like the refrigerator, range, and washing/drying machines.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by IgorPartola on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:36AM (#9039613)
Don't forget AC and furnace. In most places where you can efficiently use solar panels, AC is pretty essential.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by freehunter on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:45AM (#9039683)
It would be nice to re-think the necessity of AC, as well. It's been around for quite a long time and the ineffectiveness are crazy (same thing with whole-house heating). Why heat or cool your house and deal with the insulation problems that come from having doors and windows and walls and exposure to sun or wind on one side? Your house doesn't get hot or cold, it doesn't care. You get hot and cold.

Supercomputers run on batteries for an entire day or more in our pockets. Powerful mobile gaming machines can be run from a USB socket. There has to be a way to cool me down in the summer without needing to cool my entire house (and watch as the cold air streams out underneath my door).

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by IgorPartola on Thursday February 12, 2015 @01:10PM (#9040226)
I am guessing you live alone. Try telling a one year old to put on a snowsuit to eat soup in. Or your dog. When the weather is -40 degrees, a sweater won't save you. When it is 110 you will need a trunk with batteries behind you to power your personal AC 24/7. Give it a try and turn off the heat and AC for a season. You might make it, but will it be worth the $100-200/month?

Edit: don't forget that AC is much more efficient than heating. With AC you are looking to change the temperature by at most 35 degrees and you are moving heat, so you are getting a multiplier there. With heating, you are heating from freezing or below for most places.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by toomuchtodo on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:38PM (#9040871)
> Edit: don't forget that AC is much more efficient than heating. With AC you are looking to change the temperature by at most 35 degrees and you are moving heat, so you are getting a multiplier there. With heating, you are heating from freezing or below for most places.

Its also incredibly efficient if you're using a geothermal system to pull cold out of the ground vs pushing heat into existing hot air with a compressor.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by IgorPartola on Thursday February 12, 2015 @04:31PM (#9041516)
It can be, assuming you are in the right location in the world. The problem is cost efficiency: you are talking about tens of thousands of dollars for a system that will only pay for itself in a decade (often times; in some situations this is the perfect answer). Geothermal is no silver bullet unfortunately. There is physical efficiency, and there is economic efficiency.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by freehunter on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:54PM (#9040978)
Look at that, there is an improvement over forced air. Everyone else said that didn't exist.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by jeremycole on Thursday February 12, 2015 @09:05PM (#9042500)
Er, geothermal doesn't "pull cold out of the ground", it pushes heat into it.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by toomuchtodo on Thursday February 12, 2015 @09:29PM (#9042571)
Splitting hairs. Its utilizing a temperature differential, as heat and the lack of heat are both forms of energy that can perform work.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by freehunter on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:45PM (#9040915)
I don't live alone, and I live in a place where the weather occasionally dips to -30F wind chill (and in summer occasionally hits 90F), so I understand hot and cold weather. I have a family and pets.

Literally every single person who commented on this has completely and 100% failed to read a single word I wrote. You're wrong, you're missing the point, and it seems like you're intentionally being obtuse.

Sorry if this sounds snappy, but I've read and re-read my original post over and over again and I'm not seeing why everyone interprets it as me telling them AC and heat isn't necessary. Things like "It would be nice to re-think the necessity of AC, as well" and "There has to be a way to cool me down in the summer without needing to cool my entire house" don't mean "turn off your climate control", they mean "let's get better climate control".

Your comment is exactly the kind of thinking that I was arguing against. Right now we need AC and heat for the entire house. Just a few years ago, we needed gasoline to power our cars and just a few decades ago we needed a dedicated room to run a calculator.

I have a coat with a battery that heats up just the coat for when I'm outside in winter. Shrink it to a normal long sleeve shirt that you would wear inside anyway. That's a start. The point is, we need heat/AC now, but are they the best we could possibly do? And is forced air the best we can do?

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by IgorPartola on Thursday February 12, 2015 @03:18PM (#9041112)
I believe I understand you correctly. You want some type of smart system to heat/cool only what's necessary. Fair enough, and maybe there is even something to it. I do see problems with it.

If you are talking about a per-room system, latency becomes an issue. If I go from my bedroom to my bathroom, how long must I be in the room until the heat comes on? Moreover, won't turning heat on/off put a lot of strain on the system? This is not convenient. It's an actively worse system than what I have now. Additionally, I'll spend much more energy heating each individual room, unless I have insulated doors and inside walls: another huge expense.

If you are talking about everyone wearing electric coats and blankets and their AC equivalents, forget about it. First, you have to carry a battery pack and charge it every so often. Second, where you used to be able to just turn up the AC a bit and wear shorts, now you have to wear a spacesuit to not suffocate in the summer.

I think HVAC could definitely use innovation, and this goes beyond the really expensive geothermal systems or high efficiency condensers. Boring things like insulation and construction materials is what's going to make a huge difference here. Buildings with good insulation and little air exchange with the outside will use significantly less energy than those with poor insulation. Heating being the #1 consumer of energy in any given house, we need to trap it inside for as long as possible. Remember, it's much easier to insulate a wall that's not moving, sitting, bend, bathing, etc. than a human.

In short, I understand what you are saying, and I think that others on here do too. I simply disagree with it.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by freehunter on Thursday February 12, 2015 @07:02PM (#9042151)
Maybe you could have made that post first, rather than "you're wrong, we need AC exactly the way it is".

Look at it like this: in 2006, who thought that having phone that needed to be charged every night and was crazy expensive and ridiculously fragile was a good idea? Sure, there were some people who had a Palm or a Windows Mobile phone, but they weren't very good. Just like people have hand warmers and electric blankets, which are bulky, inconvenient, and not very good. The the iPhone came along and was slightly better, but better enough that people would take it seriously. Maybe something like the Nest fits that analogy. Then suddenly with a few small tweaks and a change of public mindset, everyone is carrying a 12-hour-battery-life, $700, all-glass smartphone in their pocket, to the point where PCs are being phased out and hardly anyone has a house phone anymore.

So what you're saying is, we need mainframes and house phones, but maybe we should have cordless phones and network those mainframes together, because the problem of making a smartphone is just too hard.

So no, I don't think you understand. You know what's not convenient? Walking out the door and having my face frozen off by -30F weather. Having an AC unit in the living room where the cold air never reaches my bedroom at night. Bundling up in the winter. Sticking to the leather in the summer. You want to talk about convenience? That doesn't sound very convenient at all. That just sounds lazy, because it's what we have now. Lazy is not the same as convenient.

Do you have a cell phone, or are batteries too inconvenient? With current HVAC systems, you only have them in your house, your office, or your car. I used to have a bag phone in my car that I could plug into the cigarette lighter. But now I can take my phone anywhere. Why can't I take my HVAC anywhere?

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by pdonis on Thursday February 12, 2015 @08:06PM (#9042313)
> now I can take my phone anywhere. Why can't I take my HVAC anywhere?

You mention that you have a coat with electric heating. Is that literally the only "personal HVAC" product you've found?

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by freehunter on Thursday February 12, 2015 @10:49PM (#9042778)
No, there are suits that circulate water to keep someone cool, hand warmers to use for hunting/ice fishing/etc, ice packs that you can wear strapped to your body, and probably many more I've not yet seen. Problem is, they're just not that good. But electric cars weren't that good not that long ago either, so there's room to grow in the space.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by astrange on Friday February 13, 2015 @04:55PM (#9047465)
Anyone who lives near SF will be used to living in a $2000/month apartment with no A/C, or for that matter the whole nation of Japan.

Not sure exactly how much more efficient it is, but it sure builds character. It also helps that the winters are not too bad, and the summers are only kind of too bad.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by bkmartin on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:06PM (#9039841)
Easy answer... it's convenient. You show me a people warming/cooling solution as convenient as whole home heating and cooling and then the conversation can begin. It's about creating an environment to live in that is consistent, has nothing to do with a house's feelings.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by the8472 on Friday February 13, 2015 @08:18AM (#9044130)
For warming you can use far-infrared panels. They heat surfaces (such as your skin) instead of air.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by freehunter on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:47PM (#9040928)
I honestly thought I was talking to a group of engineering-minded people. This comment? This is where dreams go to die.

But I guess there's no room for improvement, which is why heated seats were never invented in cars, why hand warmers were never invented, why heated jackets don't exist, why we don't have ice packs, etc. Those things would be crazy and useless.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by bkmartin on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:44PM (#9065270)
Maybe you are missing the point here. Heated seats in cars do not replace the heating system in the car. Hand warmer, heated jackets are for outside, not inside. Do you want to walk around, inside your house in a heated jacket and hand warmers? It isn't nearly as convenient as having your house be 70 degrees, or whatever you deem comfortable.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by emcrazyone on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:24PM (#9039951)
agree. Also, you need to heat your house here in Michigan if you don't want your water pipes to freeze... or your kid's pet cockatiel to die or suffer.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by 33W on Thursday February 12, 2015 @03:06PM (#9041049)
I can't speak to cockatiels, but the house should be okay ar 40-45degrees, where people would be uncomfortable.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by emcrazyone on Friday February 13, 2015 @02:50PM (#9046769)
I have a bathroom where the water pipes pass through an outside wall. On nights where the temperature goes below 0 degrees F, I open the cabinet door under the sink so heat can get in there. My thermostat is programmed to drop to 60 degrees F at night but because the thermostat is across the house, our downstairs bathroom gets very cold. It's on a slab too. Pipes always freeze if we forget to prop the door open and the temps get down below or in the single digits.

I had been thinking of getting one of those wires you put on the pipe to keep it from freezing but it's behind a wall and very hard to get too...

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by IgorPartola on Friday February 13, 2015 @11:40PM (#9048782)
You might be able to use a water circulator to keep hot water in the pipes.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by emcrazyone on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:19PM (#9039917)
Curious... I live in suburbia where putting solar panels on one's domicile would most likely be met with an order to remove or fines.

I had an experimental panel in my backyard to provide power to a work shop shed. The shed was there when I purchased the property & house. About 6 months after planting a pole in the ground, behind the shed, but in view to my neighbors garnered a letter from the township where I live that basically said to remove it for being an eye sore.

Has anyone else ran into this problem?

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by marincounty on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:09PM (#9040669)
I don't think people realize how many restrictions are put on their property--mainly my small towns, and entities. Every year Busy Bodies(usually retired with no interests), or local politicians looking for something to do; complain, and enact these rediculios laws. They are essentiall eye sore laws, and usually originate from people who should never talk about aesthetics. You buy a piece of property and really can't do much to it. I would like to call out my own town, but I have shared too much here--they could probally harass me in some way?

I would look into fighting whomever told you to remove the solar panel. I thought solar panels were protected by Federal law? In my town, I couldn't put up a car shade for one day--without risking a ticket. I don't know what country you are in, but in the United States we have way to many laws. "Oh it sounds good, and doesn't effect me; let's enact a law prohibiting it."

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by bdcs on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:02PM (#9040627)
>Has anyone else ran into this problem?

So many people did that this very practice is now banned in the state of California.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by toomuchtodo on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:25PM (#9040784)
Florida as well. Their state law specifically prohibits HOAs from disallowing solar panel installation.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by driverdan on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:30PM (#9039984)
Do you mean an HOA is regulating this or the town itself?
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by emcrazyone on Friday February 13, 2015 @02:44PM (#9046721)
there is no HOA. The township sent me a letter saying it violated some ordinance about affixing stuff to the ground like a flag pole. It was affixed to the ground with a solar panel on top of the pole. I've contemplated moving the panel to the roof of the shed where I think they wouldn't have an argument then.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by saraid216 on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:23PM (#9039940)
Maybe decorate it with flowers? Or talk with your neighbors? =/
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by blacksmith_tb on Thursday February 12, 2015 @01:29PM (#9040372)
That's crazy. What, they hate tax credits? I'm glad I live in middle of a smallish city, where the 20 panels on my roof don't raise any eyebrows whatsoever.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by roel_v on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:24PM (#9040772)
What if you put the panel on the shed roof?

Also, there are solar 'panels' in the shape of shingles or roof tiles that blend in much more than the 'traditional' ones.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by emcrazyone on Friday February 13, 2015 @02:46PM (#9046741)
Yes, I'm thinking of doing just that. I'm sure the neighbors complained about the eye sore and so they used an ordinance to force me to take it down. So, yes, moving to the roof I think might work.

Would you mind posting a link to the ones that look like shingles?

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by roel_v on Sunday February 15, 2015 @02:04PM (#9053614)
I know that the company 'Eternit' has roof tiles called 'Solesia'; real 'shingles' I haven't seen in real life myself, but one of the first Google hits is http://www.dowpowerhouse.com/ .
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by krschultz on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:55AM (#9039775)
We had 110VAC & 12V DC wall plugs on our boat. It wasn't exactly fool proof (there was just a label above each that said AC or DC), but it totally worked if you knew what you were doing. We had a bunch of devices that could plug into 12V DC directly and avoid the inverter penalty. Phone chargers, lamps, laptop chargers, etc.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by emcrazyone on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:21PM (#9039932)
my Chrysler Town & Country van has 110v outlets in the rear of the van. Occasionally, we trip the breaker but for the most part it works rather well too.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by spacecowboy_lon on Thursday February 12, 2015 @12:20PM (#9039923)
There are problems with using DC in a consumer environment incresaed losses and nore fires ( problem in Amrica with its use of wood as abuiding material)

Talk to any telecoms workers and they will tell you amusing stories about acidents with the DC supply - the Painters shorting out the bussbars whilst decorating an Echange (Central Office) was one I remeber.

48 V might be posble but that means 2 Diferent sets of wireing.

Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by higherpurpose on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:36AM (#9039611)
Europe uses 220-240V.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by walshemj on Thursday February 12, 2015 @02:57PM (#9040996)
Which is safer in terms of fires than 110
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by toomuchtodo on Thursday February 12, 2015 @04:38PM (#9041561)
220-240V is much more likely to arc then 110V.
Re:New Tesla battery could power your home, and maybe the el... by walshemj on Friday February 13, 2015 @04:07PM (#9047189)
its the old wiring getting hot and setting fire than the arcs