News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by big_paps on Sunday February 08, 2015 @03:12PM (#9018345)
What a depressing business. Making money out of noise, and warm air ...
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by emiliobumachar on Sunday February 08, 2015 @04:56PM (#9018752)
True enough, but how does it compare to literal mining, as in gold mines? I would guess that Bitcoin mining is greener.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by wpietri on Sunday February 08, 2015 @07:01PM (#9019101)
The difference being that the gold was put there by natural processes, whereas bitcoins are purely artificial. It's more like spending a lot of money to win an easter egg hunt.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by martinko on Monday February 09, 2015 @01:46AM (#9019988)
A pretty arbitrary distinction, if you ask me.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by wpietri on Monday February 09, 2015 @11:54AM (#9022154)
Not at all. If the whole process is human-controlled, then we can change it, whereas the gold's going to be wherever gold's going to be.

Suppose somebody spends a lot of money hiding easter eggs, and then I spend a lot of money finding and getting the eggs. We can both save a lot of money by them just giving me the eggs.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by lmm on Sunday February 08, 2015 @05:49PM (#9018913)
Gold miners have incentives to be more efficient about it. And realistically the 21st-century alternative isn't gold bullion, it's Visa - which I'd submit is a whole lot greener.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by gambiting on Sunday February 08, 2015 @06:10PM (#9018974)
I remember this one post on HN some time ago, where someone calculated how much electricity the entire Bitcoin network was using per month...and then someone who runs operations at a large coal mine came around and said that his mine uses that much electricity....daily.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by emiliobumachar on Sunday February 08, 2015 @06:21PM (#9019006)
Well, coal is different. It's mined for energy, not store of value. But I suppose gold and silver would be in the same ballpark.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by emiliobumachar on Sunday February 08, 2015 @06:24PM (#9019011)
I believe Bitcoin miners have every incentive to be efficient, as they pay for their hardware and energy. Am I missing something?
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by lmm on Monday February 09, 2015 @10:17AM (#9021530)
If bitcoin mining becomes more efficient, miners run more of them, the hashrate increases, the difficulty goes up, and we reach a new equilibrium - with the same overall amount of value being created, and therefore assuming efficient market, the same amount of energy being expended. The blockchain is worth the same whatever the hashrate (at least if we're just talking about more efficient miners - if more effort is being put into mining then the blockchain becomes more secure, but if someone makes a more efficient miner then that same miner also makes attacks easier).

In contrast when gold mining gets more efficient, either we expend less energy, or we produce more industrially-useful gold. Admittedly in the limit where people are just buying gold and putting it on the shelf I guess the same considerations as bitcoin apply? Hmm.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by wpietri on Sunday February 08, 2015 @07:08PM (#9019122)
The value of gold mining is gold, which has various personal and technical uses. The value of Bitcoin mining is to support the blockchain. The value of which is, honestly, still unknown, but so far appears mainly to be transferring money.

So if we're measuring ecological efficiency of Bitcoin, it'd be something like cents or watt-hours or grams CO2 per financial transaction. I've never seen a rigorous comparison, but I wouldn't be at all surprised if Visa and Paypal are more ecologically efficient than Bitcoin.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by brainburn on Monday February 09, 2015 @03:51AM (#9020240)
And what do we do with most gold?

We store it in vaults...

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by wpietri on Monday February 09, 2015 @11:51AM (#9022130)
No, we mostly make it into jewelry. It also has various industrial uses. Like any commodity, some of it ends up getting stored. And some of it also serves as a shelf-stable form of collateral. But mostly it gets used:

http://geology.com/minerals/gold/uses-of-gold.shtml

I suspect that even a lot of the "investment" uses of gold are much more about human emotional needs. I helped someone sort out the house of a deceased elderly relative. There was quite a bit of stuff purchased and stored away: coins, silver, gold. A number were of the Franklin Mint variety, where they wildly overprice the metal:

http://coins.thefuntimesguide.com/2008/11/franklin_mint_coin...

I'm sure the guy was happy with his purchase, but as investments go it was a terrible idea. He would have been much better off putting his money in index funds.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by dsuth on Monday February 09, 2015 @11:19AM (#9021922)
No, gold miners have incentives to maximise their profit, which is different from maximising their efficiency. Take, for example, the typical refining process for low grade ore[1]. This occurs in a lot of developing countries, and involves chucking all of the ore on the ground, then leaching it with cyanide... which then runs off into the nearest river.

Gold mining and refining can be nasty stuff.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_cyanidation

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by nickik on Sunday February 08, 2015 @09:07PM (#9019437)
You don't have to get away from the crypto currencys just because you dont like mining. Look at Delegated Proof of Stake System that has been used by some crypto currencies like Bitshares. You get all and more of the benefits of Bitcoin and Visa.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by imaginenore on Sunday February 08, 2015 @03:24PM (#9018400)
And processing transactions. And increasing security.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by raverbashing on Sunday February 08, 2015 @03:29PM (#9018421)
Increasing security how?

It seems a pointless waste of electricity and human effort, but justifiable with the current bitcoin prices.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by mcintyre1994 on Sunday February 08, 2015 @03:53PM (#9018515)
The security of the whole system depends on no one entity controlling >50% of the hash rate in the whole network (that is, the energy being used to mine). Further attackers with below 50% can impact the blockchain with a lower probability of success.

More information better written at [0] and [1], but they'd be able to reverse their own transactions (and double spend), and also stop any other transactions being confirmed.

So essentially these miners are making it more difficult for anybody to attack the blockchain, thus they're providing security.

[0] http://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/658/what-can-an-a... [1] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Weaknesses#Attacker_has_a_lot_of_...

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by raverbashing on Monday February 09, 2015 @03:16AM (#9020161)
True, I had forgotten about this aspect.

Of course, this only works if they're (or someone else is) not big enough to control more than 50% of the hash rate (not sure how much they would have to grow to do that)

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by ryanlol on Sunday February 08, 2015 @04:50PM (#9018728)
You don't need miners to process transactions.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by ceejayoz on Sunday February 08, 2015 @03:58PM (#9018533)
> And increasing security.

Only for the Bitcoin network, which is like saying that putting a fence and armed guards around a plot of industrial wasteland is inherently good because it increases security.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by vertex-four on Sunday February 08, 2015 @04:28PM (#9018644)
If there wasn't demand for Bitcoin (no matter how misguided you might think that demand is), Bitcoin would not be worth anything, and so mining it would be pointless as it would get you something that is not worth anything.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by Retra on Sunday February 08, 2015 @05:58PM (#9018939)
You can create demand for anything with enough hype.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by lmm on Sunday February 08, 2015 @05:54PM (#9018931)
Sure. Bitcoin provides value for criminals (it may provide a little value for some legitimate use cases, but they're very marginal in comparison to the criminal uses). Those running the system are providing a service to criminals and receive a proportion of their criminal profits in return. Still a very depressing business.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by gnaritas on Sunday February 08, 2015 @07:07PM (#9019117)
That's like blaming cash for crime, it's just ignorant.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by dragontamer on Sunday February 08, 2015 @04:22PM (#9018631)
I'm not a BTC enthusiast... but it's no less wasteful than Fort Knox.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by saalweachter on Sunday February 08, 2015 @04:44PM (#9018704)
Fort Knox is fairly economical. While obviously the depository and its guards cost something, most of the security is circumstantial: Fort Knox is an active US military base in the middle of the continent.

The fear at the time was that the Germans could do a stealth smash-and-grab on New York and steal all of our gold. So they moved it all across a mountain range to the middle of an Army base (in fact, they used to train tank crews there). Even in peace-time, the prospect of being chased by the entire US military across a thousand miles of US territory is sufficiently daunting that the depository itself doesn't need to be that impressive.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by mike_hearn on Sunday February 08, 2015 @05:20PM (#9018813)
The overheads of the existing financial industry aren't really things for physical security at Fort Knox. They are:

• All the employees, regulators and effort put into the auditing and compliance needed to make fractional reserve lending slightly less risky

• The leakage and losses due to carding fraud which goes unfixed because banks have little incentive to fix it

• The mind-blowing resource misallocations that result from misguided but well intentioned economic interventions, like the Spanish housing estates that were built then knocked down without ever being occupied ...

and so on.

Yes, Bitcoin mining is pretty wasteful today. It's a misallocation of resources caused by monetary inflation - the fact that you get to print money by solving SHA256 preimage puzzles diverts lots of energy and effort into doing so even though it makes no real sense. But Satoshi knew inflation caused harmful resource misallocation which is why he scheduled it to halve every four years (some inflation at the start is needed to actually issue the currency into existence, of course).

Now think about the wastefulness of mining, but on a massively larger scale, and without any end in sight. That's other currencies.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by jeffreyrogers on Sunday February 08, 2015 @06:50PM (#9019077)
I'm curious why you think inflation is harmful? Most (all?) economist think that slight inflation is beneficial.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by o2sd98 on Sunday February 08, 2015 @11:03PM (#9019679)
Inflation is extremely harmful in the long term. Deflation is harmful in the short term. When you get a deflationary spiral, the shock to the economic system is sharp and sudden, and causes political/social unrest, economic upheaval, capital flight and sometimes horrendous wars.

Inflation on the other hand, in the long term, guarantees bifurcation of rich and poor (wealth disparity). The reason for this is fairly simple. The poor spend between 100 and 110 percent of their disposable income, and they spend it on consumption. The rich, on the other hand, invest at least 10 percent of their disposable income in some kind of asset, either fixed assets or financial assets. Assets can then be used as collateral against loans which are used to purchase more assets. Inflation erodes the real value of the loan i.e. the nominal principal of the loan does not inflate, but it's real value deflates with inflation. Thus, inflation is a virtuous circle of asset ownership, which gives access to credit, which both increases assets owned, and whose liability decreases with inflation.

To put it another way, never ending inflation is a transfer mechanism of wealth from the poor to the rich. Once the poor realise this, they demand a political solution. The political solution inevitably involves increasing taxes on the middle class (the rich don't pay taxes), to pay for social welfare programs (i.e. free money). In this way, inflation not only transfers wealth from the poor to the rich, it also indirectly destroys the middle class by crushing them with a punitive tax burden to placate the poor.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by seanmcdirmid on Sunday February 08, 2015 @11:12PM (#9019696)
Intrest rates generally take into account inflation (the rate should be greater than anticipated inflation as part of risk) unless there is a consumption deficit (e.g. China can't use all the dollars it earns without overhearing their own economy so it lends them back to the US at a small loss; the US's role as debtor of last resort is what makes the dollar appealing as a reserve currency).

If you have savings and investments, inflation puts pressure on you to make them perform, otherwise you are losing money; it works like a capital tax in that regard. You just can't sit on it since money can't really be saved without someone else borrowing it (production and consumption have to even out at the end of the day!). So no, the rich don't really get richer off inflation. They aren't brorowing money from the poor at any rate.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by o2sd98 on Monday February 09, 2015 @12:39AM (#9019846)
I think I may have not been clear, or I am misinterpreting your post.

If you think of a person as having a balance sheet, with assets (property, shares, bonds, cash) and liabilities (loans), and a profit and loss of revenues (salary, dividends, coupons, rents, i.e cashflows) and expenses (food, shelter, clothing, transport, interest etc), then inflation:

* increases the value of your assets => asset prices rise with inflation

* decreases your liabilities => loan balances stay constant in nominal terms, but in real terms the liability is decreasing.

* increases your income => wages and salaries rise with inflation

* increases your expenses => the price of consumables increases with inflation.

So, ideally, in a high inflation environment, you want to hold as many assets as you can afford, levered as much as possible, with a high income, and low expenses.

So the rich purchase assets with debt. Inflation pushes the price of assets up, and the real value of the debt down. I agree that the assets you purchase should generate a cashflow to cover the financing drag. Inflation also increases dividends, rents and coupons.

Because the poor have expenses (outgoings) equal to or greater than income (wages, salary), price inflation erodes their disposable income, and price inflation is elastic, but wages are sticky, so the poor are always playing catchup, and in the interim, the rich are buying up their assets with cheap debt.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by seanmcdirmid on Monday February 09, 2015 @01:39AM (#9019972)
The poor have nothing to protect from inflation: they don't have significant savings, they spend their income the day/week/month that they get it. Their wages should go up to match inflation, and if they don't, its not really related to inflation itself but stingy bosses who aren't sharing increased prices (since given inflation, prices are supposed to rise, right?).

The rich are both lending and borrowing money; again, who do you think they are borrowing money from? Who are they buying the assets from? Again, it is not the poor, unless you are suggesting they are accumulating previously non-existing or non-utilized assets?

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by o2sd98 on Monday February 09, 2015 @03:36AM (#9020198)
Stingy bosses has got nothing to do with it. Those who control the means of production can set their prices. The poor's only means of rising wages is through force (either government intervention or strike action). Any wage increase they receive is eaten by inflation. If prices started deflating, it is the poor who would immediately benefit and the rich would immediately be worse off. This is why the rich lobby politicians and academics to maintain inflation at any cost. Once prices start deflating, the immediate effect is relief for the poor and credit stress for the rich. The poor have no savings because they are inflated away. Look at the GINI index for the US and Japan during the "lost decades". In deflationary Japan, the index contracted (i.e. wealth disparity declined), in the inflationary US, it increased.

The rich are not borrowing from each other. Banks create money endogenously. They are buying existing assets from each other, and they are also buying new assets as they are created. Without inflation, asset purchases would look less attractive on a cash return basis, so inflation does serve that purpose. However, persistent inflation is forcing the market to be investors when they may want to save or spend.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by exo762 on Monday February 09, 2015 @02:49AM (#9020105)
Comparing to amount of waste (cost of operations) of regular banking system and direct harm from banking system to society (influencing politics, strong-arming rest of players on the market), cost of bitcoin as network is a chump change. I'm not saying that it replaces banking system and two numbers should not be compared directly, but I believe that it can heal it banking system by introducing greater transparency and taking away control of money from banks.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by kruczek on Monday February 09, 2015 @04:49AM (#9020390)
Well, it's about as depressing as assigning arbitrary value to gold or silver (or paper!) and using it as money.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by criloz2 on Sunday February 08, 2015 @03:18PM (#9018372)
What a naive comment...
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by LunaSea on Sunday February 08, 2015 @03:33PM (#9018447)
Explain how he's wrong ?