News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by lmm on Sunday February 08, 2015 @05:49PM (#9018913)
Gold miners have incentives to be more efficient about it. And realistically the 21st-century alternative isn't gold bullion, it's Visa - which I'd submit is a whole lot greener.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by gambiting on Sunday February 08, 2015 @06:10PM (#9018974)
I remember this one post on HN some time ago, where someone calculated how much electricity the entire Bitcoin network was using per month...and then someone who runs operations at a large coal mine came around and said that his mine uses that much electricity....daily.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by emiliobumachar on Sunday February 08, 2015 @06:21PM (#9019006)
Well, coal is different. It's mined for energy, not store of value. But I suppose gold and silver would be in the same ballpark.
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by emiliobumachar on Sunday February 08, 2015 @06:24PM (#9019011)
I believe Bitcoin miners have every incentive to be efficient, as they pay for their hardware and energy. Am I missing something?
Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by lmm on Monday February 09, 2015 @10:17AM (#9021530)
If bitcoin mining becomes more efficient, miners run more of them, the hashrate increases, the difficulty goes up, and we reach a new equilibrium - with the same overall amount of value being created, and therefore assuming efficient market, the same amount of energy being expended. The blockchain is worth the same whatever the hashrate (at least if we're just talking about more efficient miners - if more effort is being put into mining then the blockchain becomes more secure, but if someone makes a more efficient miner then that same miner also makes attacks easier).

In contrast when gold mining gets more efficient, either we expend less energy, or we produce more industrially-useful gold. Admittedly in the limit where people are just buying gold and putting it on the shelf I guess the same considerations as bitcoin apply? Hmm.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by wpietri on Sunday February 08, 2015 @07:08PM (#9019122)
The value of gold mining is gold, which has various personal and technical uses. The value of Bitcoin mining is to support the blockchain. The value of which is, honestly, still unknown, but so far appears mainly to be transferring money.

So if we're measuring ecological efficiency of Bitcoin, it'd be something like cents or watt-hours or grams CO2 per financial transaction. I've never seen a rigorous comparison, but I wouldn't be at all surprised if Visa and Paypal are more ecologically efficient than Bitcoin.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by brainburn on Monday February 09, 2015 @03:51AM (#9020240)
And what do we do with most gold?

We store it in vaults...

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by wpietri on Monday February 09, 2015 @11:51AM (#9022130)
No, we mostly make it into jewelry. It also has various industrial uses. Like any commodity, some of it ends up getting stored. And some of it also serves as a shelf-stable form of collateral. But mostly it gets used:

http://geology.com/minerals/gold/uses-of-gold.shtml

I suspect that even a lot of the "investment" uses of gold are much more about human emotional needs. I helped someone sort out the house of a deceased elderly relative. There was quite a bit of stuff purchased and stored away: coins, silver, gold. A number were of the Franklin Mint variety, where they wildly overprice the metal:

http://coins.thefuntimesguide.com/2008/11/franklin_mint_coin...

I'm sure the guy was happy with his purchase, but as investments go it was a terrible idea. He would have been much better off putting his money in index funds.

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by dsuth on Monday February 09, 2015 @11:19AM (#9021922)
No, gold miners have incentives to maximise their profit, which is different from maximising their efficiency. Take, for example, the typical refining process for low grade ore[1]. This occurs in a lot of developing countries, and involves chucking all of the ore on the ground, then leaching it with cyanide... which then runs off into the nearest river.

Gold mining and refining can be nasty stuff.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_cyanidation

Re:Inside a Chinese Bitcoin Mine That's Grossing $1.5M a Month by nickik on Sunday February 08, 2015 @09:07PM (#9019437)
You don't have to get away from the crypto currencys just because you dont like mining. Look at Delegated Proof of Stake System that has been used by some crypto currencies like Bitshares. You get all and more of the benefits of Bitcoin and Visa.