News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by flexie on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:08AM (#8947313)
Looks like great fun!

I doubt it has close resemblance with medieval long sword fighting, though :-)

It must have been a lot slower fighting in leather, chainmail or plate armor than in this ultra light modern equipment.

And, I assume a medieval fighter would take far smaller chances than these modern hobbyists knowing a counter blow could be (almost surely would be) fatal.

Also, these guys fight one on one. But in a war you would have to guard yourself from blows and cuts not just from one enemy but from a crowd of enemy soldiers, left and right.

The guy you were fighting might be using a sword or he might have another weapon. Maybe he was using a shield and you didn't. And if he had a sword, he might not have read the memo that it should be max 4 feet long.

And fighting on some uneven, damp meadow he might be fighting uphill or downhill, and just keeping ones balance when striking or blocking would be hard compared to fighting indoor on a floor.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by Sander_Marechal on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:33AM (#8947501)
I'm a HEMA practitioner from The Netherlands

> I doubt it has close resemblance with medieval long sword fighting, though :-)

It does actually resemble it very much, but medieval longsword fighting was probably very different than what you think it was.

> It must have been a lot slower fighting in leather, chainmail or plate armor than in this ultra light modern equipment.

Not really. The main difference is visibility. First, the modern HEMA equipment is a lot heavier than e.g. standard fencing gear. It's a lot thicker (like those dog attack suits) and often have steel or kevlar plates in the inside. Second, medieval gear wasn't all that heavy. I have a full suit of maille (as it's really called) and it weighs less than 15 kilos, helmet included. A full steel plate armour shouldn't weight more than 25 kilos. That's less than modern soldiers have to carry around on the battlefield.

The biggest difference is that a fencing mask gives you better visibility than a historical closed helmet.

> these guys fight one on one

That's what happened in medieval times too most often. The original medieval books were written mostly for one-on-one combat, either for dueling or trial-by-sword. That happened a lot more than being caught in a war on a battlefield. Swords have little use on a medieval battlefield anyway. You use different weapons and tactics.

> And fighting on some uneven, damp meadow [...] would be hard compared to fighting indoor on a floor.

My HEMA group trains for this as well, and I suspect many other groups too. It is also mentioned in the medieval books. I have trained in loose sand, in the surf on a beach, in deep snow, etc. It's true that competitions are usually held indoors on an even ground though.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by gatesphere on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:39AM (#8947534)
Hooray! Another HEMA practicioner!

I'm from upstate NY (US), and I agree wholeheartedly with everything mentioned here. This man speaks truth.

Our group focuses on medieval German Longsword, but we also take a dip into several other techniques, ranging through history from slings, to viking sword and axe, all the way through la canne and savate.

Like true vikings, we train in the snow (when the weather cooperates and gives us snowy fields). Nothing quite invigorates the blood like doing laps and duels in the frozen north!

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by rsync on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:20PM (#8948205)
"Hooray! Another HEMA practicioner!"

I am surprised that nobody in this thread has mentioned the Dog Brothers from California. They do not fight with swords, but they practice live, full contact stick and staff fighting. In a cage. Without any armor.

Yes, I also thought that that can't possibly be a thing...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvmLQ_Jjqmk

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QjAkbQb6axU

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by swatthatfly on Monday January 26, 2015 @03:56PM (#8949511)
Great videos. These contests seem to be modeled on Kali/Silat, the Filipino and Indonesian martial arts.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by hessenwolf on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:29AM (#8947834)
I came across a troupe of Longswording Englishmen in a fencing workshop in Scotland. They mainly practiced mowing down unarmed peasants with longswords, from what I could see. Perhaps you could expand on my limited insight?
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by yummyfajitas on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:36AM (#8947514)
Swords have little use on a medieval battlefield anyway. You use different weapons and tactics.

Just curious - could you explain this in a bit more detail? It's surprising.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by mcv on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:01AM (#8947665)
He puts it a bit too general, but against full plate armour, swords are nearly useless. In the late Middle Ages, when plate armour became increasingly common, people started using weapons with better armour-piercing capabilities, like maces, warhammers and various polearms.

Swords are great against lightly armoured and unarmoured targets, like peasants, archers and civilians. Swords remained in use as a side arm and civilian weapon, and a popular duelling weapon, which may also be why so many medieval manuscripts are about one-on-one fights. Carrying a polearm with you everywhere you go is a lot more cumbersome than having a sword hanging on your belt.

But swords were absolutely used on the battlefield. Romans and vikings used them a lot. Knights had them of course, and even they became increasingly less useful against other knights, they often didn't really want to kill each other anyway. Pikemen generally had a short sword as backup weapon (the Katzbalger), and there's of course the massive two-handed swords used by Landsknechts to break up pike formations (supposedly; nobody knows for sure). But again knights in plate armour, you'd better get something that can knock holes in it. If you want to kill him, that it.

You might compare the sword to a pistol. You don't usually send a mass of soldiers into battle with just a pistol; you give them assault rifles (or polearms). But officers and civilians tend to carry a pistol, and maybe some soldiers have one for backup.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by voidlogic on Monday January 26, 2015 @02:29PM (#8949004)
>He puts it a bit too general, but against full plate armor, swords are nearly useless.

A sword may not be an ideal weapon against an armored opponent, but half-swording with one is still very effective...

Also its important to note, the sword pedagogically-speaking is the root weapon of HEMA systems. So the fact these folks train with a sword as their primary weapon makes sense. Manuscripts support historical training following the same pattern. I teach you how to use a sword, then I teach you how to use a pole-axe...

I elaborate more here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8948675

>You might compare the sword to a pistol.

This is a good point, I think people often overlook how knights and samurai on foot share the same battlefield weapon configuration: <primary weapon> + <longsword/Katana> + <dagger/Tantō>

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by mcv on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @09:23AM (#8953119)
> A sword may not be an ideal weapon against an armored opponent, but half-swording with one is still very effective...

That's exactly why I said "nearly". That, and the Mordhau.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by trhway on Monday January 26, 2015 @04:38PM (#8949736)
>He puts it a bit too general, but against full plate armour, swords are nearly useless.

they are useless for penetration. The rest of effects are in place. The beauty and usability of sword comes from it being very convenient weapon to focus and amplify the power of your movement in much wider envelope of possible positions and movements - much better than any other type of weapon. Hammer/axe comes close but it trades in significant part of the envelope for penetrating abilities in other part of the envelope.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by dragontamer on Monday January 26, 2015 @07:24PM (#8950568)
A spear or halberd were much more effective than swords.

Swords were partially ceremonial and partially "nobility" weapons. Walking around with a spear in town is tiring, because its big, heavy and awkward.

On the other hand, swords can be sheathed. They were expensive to manufacture, so they denoted wealth. And finally, they were effective weapons at the end of the day.

Pistol vs Machine Gun is the best way to compare a Swordman vs Spearman. It is said that you can train a Spearman in a week to beat even expert Swordsmen (with years of training) regularly.

Spears / Polearms were cheaper to manufacture, more effective in the battlefield, and easier to teach. Swords were more of a "city personal defense weapon", very similar to pistols today. I'm sure the HEMA players around here know how much that range advantage gives you.

A Halberd was perhaps the perfection of Medieval combat weaponry. A long spear-tip for stabbing, a strong blade for cutting, and a hook for pulling people off of horses. Halberds could definitely do a lot more than swordmen, at much cheaper costs.

I mean, what is a swordman supposed to do against a heavy-Calvary charge? Halberdiers also outrange Swordmen, and have stronger formations. The two-handed poleweapon can be swung with massive leverage that can break shields and cut through even plate with ease. While the stabbing point can be dug in to brace against calvery charges. It was an effective weapon at all stages of medieval combat.

The only swordmen on the medieval battlefield were the legendary "Double-paid" Zweihanders (The Doppelsöldner). But the massive swords these Doppelsoldners used were approximately the same size as a halberd.

http://i.imgur.com/KPEFFD4.jpg

But they were expensive, and the full-metal massive swords that they wielded were heavy, expensive, and required extensive training. (ie: more expensive) It was more effective in the long term to just train more Halberdiers, and the Zweihanders left the battlefield by the 1500s.

In any case, the "Longsword" is much shorter than these Zweihanders, and is at a considerable range disadvantage against spearmen. Mind you, King Author of legend killed Mordred with a Spear.

Swords were probably carried by Soldiers in case their primary weapon broke. They are excellent sidearms (like Pistols today), but I personally am much more comfortable with a pole-weapon (Spear, Pike or Halberd) than I am with a Sword. And I started with Foil Fencing mind you.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by brohee on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:18PM (#8951075)
Video made on XVth century full plate armor sword fighting, made for an history thesis

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hlIUrd7d1Q

Swords pretty much work against plate armor, because they trained to precisely drive the point toward the joints.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by thelibrarian on Monday January 26, 2015 @05:24PM (#8950011)
> You might compare the sword to a pistol.

Indeed, there is a reason that both are generally referred to as 'sidearms' in military parlance.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by MiddleEndian on Monday January 26, 2015 @06:01PM (#8950212)
>they often didn't really want to kill each other anyway

Can you elaborate on this? What were they doing with swords instead?

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by cbp on Monday January 26, 2015 @07:13PM (#8950513)
They killed peasants and mercenaries instead. The knights they took hostage for ransom.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by thret on Monday January 26, 2015 @07:16PM (#8950529)
My understanding is that in battle, there were very few knights in full plate - it was very expensive, required training, ie. tended to be nobles. So while swords were effective against the peasants, knights were usually captured alive and ransomed.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by onethree on Monday January 26, 2015 @08:01PM (#8950691)
if someone can afford plate armor, they can probably afford a decent ransom

edit: beaten to it, that's what i get for loading a whole bunch of tabs when i first get into work...

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by Sander_Marechal on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:56AM (#8947633)
Sure. The problem is that swords don't have much effect on an armoured opponent. There are three types of attacks you can do with a sword: slashing, stabbing and cutting. Against a gambeson (jacked made of 20+ layes of linen stitched together) stabbing works, slashing is hard and cutting mostly doesn't work. Now add a layer of maille over the gambeson. Cutting doesn't work at all anymore, slashing probably only bruises you or breaks some bones and stabbing only works with narrow and sharp-tipped swords. Replace the maille with steel plates and you're pretty much invulnerable to swords, except at the joints, eyeslits, etc).

So, sending out a group armed with swords on the battlefield isn't going to do much. You want warhammers with backspikes that can pierce steel plate and crush bone, halberds that can hit so hard it crushes anything underneath armour, long pikes to keep the enemy at a distance, bows to pierce maille. The best weapon on the battlefield is actually mass. Get a group large enough close together and trample your opponents.

That's how most battles were won. In viking and early medieval times you would use large shields and short spears, create a shield wall and run over your opponent. Later on heavy cavalry appeared who could easily run over them. Cavalry dominated until the English started using the longbow en masse to kill the mounts of the cavalry. Swiss pikemen started using 6+ meter long pikes in tight bock formations. These pikes were so long that cavalry could be stopped dead before they reached the pikemen in a charge. It's like a wooden cumple zone. That pretty much spelled the end of heavy cavalry. Then soldiers started using halberds to get in between the pikes and crush pike blocks.

Swords were often carried on the battlefield but usually as a backup weapon, not as the primary weapon. Their cross shape granted them a lot of symbolic meaning in those religious times, but there are much better weapons available if you want to win large battles.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by henrikschroder on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:06PM (#8948087)
I think the most important insight about medieval warfare is that it too was a constant arms-race, it was not some sort of static period with knights and swords that magically disappeared one day to be replaced with musketeers and riflemen. There are so many weird myths and ideas, and it's always nice to see people who know what they're talking about. :)
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by kbenson on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:18PM (#8948186)
I've read a few accounts and seen a few programs about how the word bulletproof came about, which also illustrates this period of change. It was a title given to (plate?) armor to protect the wearers against bullets (I'm not sure to what effect). For that even to be a thing means that suits of armor and guns were on the same battlefield.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by mcguire on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:47PM (#8948734)
> I'm not sure to what effect

Early blackpowder was of poor quality, as were the handgonnes, and round balls are ballistically inefficient (and the actual projectiles were usually worse). So, probably pretty well, until you got too close.

P.S. The primary effect that I keep seeing mentioned is that they make a really loud noise and scare the crap out of everyone.

P.P.S As far as I can tell, the use of armor declines as the momentum of the projectiles (and number of firearms) goes up. Accuracy was the last attribute that was important on the battlefield. (Except for individual rate of fire.)

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by pluma on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @07:32PM (#8957218)
I'd imagine that facing a row of soldiers aiming things that go "boom" at you must have been an extremely effective way to break morale no matter how inaccurate the projectiles are.

Besides, all that hot lead had to go somewhere. Maybe you wouldn't be hit by the guy in front of you, but you'd still risk getting hit by the one behind him or the ones next to him. Arrows may have been more precise, but at least you could see where they were going.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by craigching on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:51PM (#8948756)
Not that I question your knowledge about bullets and armor, but weren't the things they shot out of slings also called bullets?
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by kbenson on Monday January 26, 2015 @03:00PM (#8949211)
I have no idea whether the term used at the time for sling ammunition was bullet, but even so, I can't imagine that being a selling point given the penetration power of human powered sling projectiles would have with regard to plate armor. Also, the sources I've seen were very clear to link it to the rise of guns on the battlefield.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by kragen on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @01:44PM (#8954850)
Much to my surprise, you are right — sling bullets probably could not penetrate armor: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk%3ASling_%28weapon%29#Armo...
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by kbenson on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @02:27PM (#8955113)
Interesting. I didn't know there was that much controversy (albeit for earlier armor technology). I was assuming, so I guess I was luckily right through ignorance. ;)
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by voidlogic on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:42PM (#8948713)
>The problem is that swords don't have much effect on an armored opponent.

A sword may not be an ideal weapon against an armored opponent, but half-swording with one is still very effective...

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by gadders on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:08AM (#8947710)
>Swiss pikemen started using 6+ meter long pikes in tight bock formations.

This sounds a bit like a Greek Hoplite Phalanx.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by aidenn0 on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:48AM (#8947957)
The weakness of the phalanx is that you can be outflanked; it's really hard to turn a long pike to address an opponent not in front of you. I would imagine that having cavalry to protect your flanks would make it a lot more effective.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by Sander_Marechal on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:43PM (#8948714)
The swiss didn't ise a classic wide phalanx formation but a more densely packed square formation. Their pikes would stand out in all directions as a sort of hedgehog. Only the corners would be a weaker point. The flanks and rear would be well covered by pikes.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by Tuna-Fish on Monday January 26, 2015 @05:30PM (#8950041)
The pikes would generally stand only in one direction at once, and their drills had diagonal forms, so the corners would not be a weak point.

When people think pikemen, they think of very static formations, with little mobility. This is true of a lot of historical pike units, but the Swiss pikemen are the opposite of it. They drilled as small companies of ~100 men, and they were so successful because they made mobility as an unit into an art. A swiss pike block was drilled to change facing in seconds, and they liked to charge pikes levelled at near running speed. Many a condottiere got their last surprise when they were at the last stretch of their charge against an exposed flank or rear of a swiss block, and suddenly all the pikes rise, everyone turns, all the pikes come down again, and the swiss start charging the would-be attackers like madmen.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by jrells on Monday January 26, 2015 @02:09PM (#8948884)
While I'm sure your knowledge is aggregated over many sources, are there any particularly excellent sources (books, documentaries, etc) on the history of military tactics?
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by vacri on Monday January 26, 2015 @06:26PM (#8950327)
What is the difference between 'cutting' and 'slashing' as you refer to them? It seems they would be the same to me.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by svachalek on Monday January 26, 2015 @08:39PM (#8950819)
Based on the description of effects I believe "cutting" would be a sliding motion meant to leave a long, shallow cut while "slashing" would be more of a chopping motion with the blade side.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by Sander_Marechal on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @12:30AM (#8951398)
Yes, that's exactly what I meant.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by Tuna-Fish on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:57AM (#8947638)
Swords are sidearms, designed for self-defense, duels, and as last resort. They were very rarely used as main battlefield weapons between the fall of Rome and the widespread use of firearms. In general, people on foot in this period fought with some kind of polearms, from spears to dane axes to bardiches to pollaxes to pikes. Same goes for Japan, btw -- the fetishization of katanas happened after samurais stopped being soldiers and became bureaucrats. On the actual battlefield a samurai was most likely to hold a long spear or a bow.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by rodgerd on Monday January 26, 2015 @03:21PM (#8949323)
And in Roman formations they were used in much the same way later and earlier combatants used spears: tightly locked ranks of shields, with the sword as a thrusting weapon.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by JetSpiegel on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @06:31AM (#8952506)
> On the actual battlefield a samurai was most likely to hold a long spear or a bow.

As seen in Seven Samurai

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by voidlogic on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:37PM (#8948675)
I want to point out that the system that HEMA teaches (all though done usually by teaching longsword first) is a multi-weapon + unarmed system. A given technique that you can do with a longsword can also be done with a pole-axe. A pole-axe us better suited for armored combat (Harnischfechten) and a sword is better suited for unarmored combat (Blossfechten).

Although its worth pointing out, there are Harnischfechten techniques for longsword commonly referred to as half-swording (and you almost NEVER see these in movies). Btw, the unarmed component is called Ringen.

P.S. There are two similar schools for HEMA, the German and Italian school, my terms used above are the German terms. Most of the difference is either style, terminology or quite subtle.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by GnarlinBrando on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:13PM (#8951052)
There are also a lot of other non-HEMA historical european martial arts groups and less historical EuroMA. For instance you can find stick fighting most palces, Jogo Do Pau is Portuguese stick/staff fighting, Savate is French kickboxing usually with cane and maybe some sailor stuff, Zipota is similar, but from Basque Spain. Lots of herding cultures kept this stuff alive and whether it is MMA or something else they seem to be getting more attention.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by bane on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:56AM (#8947632)
just echoing what termain said. Going back to at least the Greek Phalanx and up to even quite a while after the introduction of gunpowder, massed warfare typically involved long weapons like spears or pikes.

A reasonably good depiction is the Phalanx shown in the movie "300". The history of warfare is generally about increasing the standoff distance between two militaries. The side with longer spears generally did better, then the side with the better archers.

Even after gunpowder was introduced, the reload time was so long that after getting a shot off, armies would switch to pikes.

The "wall of men in formation" you see in the Napoleonic wars and the American Revolutionary and Civil wars was sort of the last use of that kind of traditional formation and movement. The widespread use of heavy artillery put an end to it much like the airplane put an end to trench warfare.

http://bcw-project.org/military/tactics

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by sswaner on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:26AM (#8947819)
Armor (tanks) and other forms of mechanized infantry contributed more to the end of trench warfare than airplanes.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by kbenson on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:25PM (#8948238)
Yeah, listening to Dan Carlin's Hardcore History[1] series, which is currently covering WWI, this is very apparent. Airplanes seem to have been used for reconnaissance more than anything. That makes sense when the artillery brought to bear was so concentrated is literally reduced forests to fields of churned up earth with splinters.

Edit: Added link I forgot.

1: http://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-50-bluepri...

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by termain on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:46AM (#8947569)
It's hard to get a sword into play against massed pikemen. And you want massed pikemen against the heavy cavalry of the period.

Also swords expensive compared to spears.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @02:59AM (#8951954)
Still a sword, but not the same kind of sword most people think of:

For much of their history, the Roman Legions used a kind of short, broad-bladed sword called the gladius. There were various types across the centuries, but generally they were quite a bit shorter than the swords we see in the movies, sometimes as short as 18 inches from guard to point. This was not a great one-on-one weapon; all other things being equal, a warrior with a traditional long-bladed sword would usually beat a shorter one.

But the Legions didn't fight one-on-one. They fought shoulder-to-shoulder, leading with big rectangular shields, and thrusting around the side, top, or bottom with the gladius. Quite a few of their of their enemies came from traditions that emphasized personal glory and used big, long swords that needed room to swing. These men had to space themselves out further to avoid hitting their fellows, and so each one would find himself facing two Legionnaires shoulder-to-shoulder. A bigger sword doesn't help much against odds like that.

(I am not an expert and I have probably got some details wrong; feel free to correct me.)

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by elbows on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:59AM (#8947649)
I would say, rather, that the sword was used as a sidearm rather than a primary weapon. Most soldiers would have been armed with a spear, lance, or other polearm -- weapons with greater reach and ability to penetrate armor.

But many of those soldiers would also have carried a sword as a backup weapon and for use at closer range.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by BashiBazouk on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:29AM (#8947835)
So, what is difference between your group and The Society for Creative Anachronism? Is there cross over?
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by Sander_Marechal on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:46AM (#8947944)
There is only a little bit of crossover. The focus of HEMA groups is to approach medieval sword fighting like a modern sport or martial arts (e.g, much like Karate, Judo or Kempo). That's why you see modern sports equiptment.

The focus of the SCA is more on reliving medieval times. They wear medieval clothing and armour for example, they hold medieval banquets, practice dancing, etc. As for fighting style, I don't think medieval swordsmanship skills will get you very far on an SCA battlefield. Maybe in one-on-one tournaments though.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by BashiBazouk on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:12PM (#8948127)
That's interesting. I'm a fencer and it's interesting to see how quickly even sword fighting changed (and armor wearing in public and duels). Every time the swordsman in the video put the sword above his head all I could think was: free points! Just about any ranked fencer would have popped the guy in the chest and moved back before he could do a counter attack. Foil and sabre are pretty wussy (light) compared to their real world equivalents but an epee is quite close to a rapier or dueling sword.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by jessaustin on Monday January 26, 2015 @03:31PM (#8949390)
Just about any ranked fencer would have popped the guy in the chest and moved back before he could do a counter attack.

This has long been my dissatisfaction with fencing. The type of strike you describe (a glancing touch at maximum extension of one's body, arm, and fingertips) is unlikely to disable any opponent wearing so much as a leather vest. Not to mention the fact that a sword and arm extended thus are highly likely to be mangled or removed by an overhead slash by a heavier sword from the position you describe.

Of course, this is a matter of taste. Since few of us will ever find ourselves fighting for keeps, we can play in whatever sword discipline we prefer.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by EpicEng on Monday January 26, 2015 @08:29PM (#8950793)
Fencing models modern" dueling, typically a contest that ends with first blood. From that perspective it does apretty good job of staying close to its roots. That said, i prefer epee for just that reason.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by Sander_Marechal on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:52PM (#8948761)
That technique doesn't work well in HEMA combat. It's not hard to parry a thrust like that from a high, open guard and it leaves the attacker completely open to strikes on the hands, arms and head.

There's also a difference in scoring with regards to defense. In my HEMA group if opponent A strikes B, but B strikes back in the same motion (roughly 0.5 seconds, but basically the same "move") then it's a double-hit. Often counted as 0 points for either side but on some tournaments even counted as -1 for both sides.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by henrikschroder on Monday January 26, 2015 @05:42PM (#8950095)
In modern foil fencing, a riposte (B in your example) gets the point. Also, the only way to get a hit is by thrusts to the torso. No other body parts count, and no slashing or cutting.

It's very interesting that modern fencing is so "ritualistic" and far removed from actual sword combat. I wonder how that happened?

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by BashiBazouk on Monday January 26, 2015 @06:24PM (#8950315)
I think that other weapons and combat forms pushed the sword to be limited to duels and mainly duels of honor. Fencing came from training to duel. The foil is a learning weapon and even though the entire torso is a target, most attacks ideally aim for the heart. Epee you really see the dueling roots. In epee many points are scored off your hand or foot. Duels of honor were commonly fought to first blood rather than death. First blood was typically a wound to the hand or other body part close to the action.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by EpicEng on Monday January 26, 2015 @08:26PM (#8950788)
An epee is close to a dueling sword, but still pretty far from a rapier. I imagine you know this, but a rapier is not the ultra fast moving sword most people think it is due to movies and the like. They are actually pretty heavy (1.7-2.2 lbs).
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by sgt101 on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @08:52AM (#8952967)
I was really surprised to see people wearing fencing masks to do this. These masks are not designed to stand up to the kind of blows that are shown on this video, if I were doing it I would be inclined to wear a keno mask instead.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by prawn on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @04:40AM (#8952167)
A modern soldier is probably running in bursts and often firing from a crouched or prone position. I imagine someone fighting in armour with a swung weapon is going to feel the weight from the ongoing movement?
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by eru on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @06:30AM (#8952505)
I heard that tournament armour was usually heavier than what was used for war? (I think tvtropes said so.)
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by bane on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:48AM (#8947586)
>It must have been a lot slower fighting in leather, chainmail or plate armor than in this ultra light modern equipment.

I recently saw a full-armor longsword fight. It was fast as hell. I'm talking leather, chainmail, chest plates and metal helmets. I could barely follow the action.

It was pretty awesome and that one live match turned me from skeptic into fan.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by snori74 on Monday January 26, 2015 @03:37PM (#8949420)
Both SCA "heavy" fighting and HMB, as in the "Battle of Nations" are full-contact so tend to use armour similar to historical. Very different spins again on the whole topic, but worth looking into.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by daeken on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:28PM (#8948612)
> It must have been a lot slower fighting in leather, chainmail or plate armor than in this ultra light modern equipment.

Others have commented on the heft of modern equipment relative to medieval equivalents, but it bears mentioning that the plate armor of the period was exceptionally well made. Not just light weight, but form fitted for the wearer. It's been said that fighters in good plate could do cartwheels, due to the exceptional balance of the armor; it was like a second skin.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by voidlogic on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:40PM (#8948701)
Also worth pointing out is not all fighting was done in armor. See my comment above: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8948675
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by maurits on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:24AM (#8947425)
This is a demonstration of combat in plate armour from the 15-th century. It also implicitly shows why a hammer is so effective. [1]

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hlIUrd7d1Q

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by gambiting on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:18AM (#8947383)
This video shows how people fought in full body plate armour using some 15-th century techniques, it's really surprising how flexible it is, you can even jump and do body rolls in it. It's definitely not as stiff as I always thought it was.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hlIUrd7d1Q&feature=youtu.be

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by some_username on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:02PM (#8948062)
Regarding speed and mobility, you may be surprised.

The Met has a fantastic lecture, How to Mount a Horse in Armor and Other Chivalric Problems, where a this question is explicitly addressed. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NqC_squo6X4#t=1427

The short of it being that armor wasn't particularly heavy, especially when compared to the modern combat load, and that it affords quite a bit of mobility.

If this interests you, the entire lecture is worth your time.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by dagw on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:25AM (#8947431)
It must have been a lot slower fighting in leather, chainmail or plate armor than in this ultra light modern equipment.

Take a look at people fighting and doing various exercises in full plate armor on youtube. They're surprisingly fast and mobile.

Also there are HEMA groups that train and compete in group combat and various weapon combinations.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by platz on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:55AM (#8947626)
Interesting video of how round shields might not have been used the way we had expected: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dkhpqAGdZPc

TLDR: The round shield was uniquely suited to be used or assist as an attack weapon instead of merely defensive

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by arnsholt on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:15AM (#8947364)
I think it's very similar to kendo, the Japanese equivalent of fencing (sort of). Since kendo dates back to the 1800s or so, the sword is a bamboo stick, but like in HEMA points are awarded based on a couple of criteria: the strike has to be to one of the designated target zones, the strike has to be an intentional attack (that is, flailing wildly won't score you a point), and something called zanshin which is basically the same as what they call control in the video; does the attacker control the situation after a successful strike?

But just like here, it's more a sport than faithful recreation of sword fighting since a) you're not gonna die if an attack fails and b) this is not battlefield conditions.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by PakG1 on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:49AM (#8947961)
> It must have been a lot slower fighting in leather, chainmail or plate armor than in this ultra light modern equipment.

One thing that nobody has mentioned so far is (I believe) people were much more fit in those days. Today we have a very sedentary lifestyle. Not so much in those days, people were much more active. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2614780/How-F...

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by anentropic on Monday January 26, 2015 @04:34PM (#8949713)
fit people do exist in the present day too
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by PakG1 on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:22PM (#8951225)
The data suggests that even the most fit today would not compare to ancestors, the farther you go back, the more fit they are.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by barry-cotter on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @05:41AM (#8952366)
What data? The average hunter-gatherer was fitter, better nourished and less diseased than the average peasant after the dawn of agriculture (and the population was overwhelmingly peasants) but there was always a warrior class and they ate well and trained hard.

Agriculture did have a noticeable impact. People who have a longer evolutionary history of grain monocultures are shorter on average than those whose ancestors adopted agriculture later but the difference isn't that big. Humans have only gotten about 5 cm shorter since the dawn of agriculture.

I'm aware of no evidence on speed or strength but the thing is that most people were not near the limits of human performance, ever.

It's almost certain that modern humanity is the fittest that it's been since the dawn of agriculture. Most hunter-gatherer skeletons are fit and strong because of low disease burden but mostly because in famine times they just died. Farmers OTOH survived, stunted, diseased and with deficiencies in vitamins, minerals and just not enough food.

But the warrior class always ate fine. Even as late as WW1, the average member of the House of Lords was a foot taller than the equivalent Member of Parliament.

So, what data?

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by PakG1 on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @08:57PM (#8957559)
Yes, it's true that the data I see is not an actual historical measurement of physical strength, and so quantification of strength is only inferred. Thanks for calling me out on that. But basically, it seems to me that society in general was more active back then, whether you were a hunter-gatherer or a farmer, and that this decreased as more and more modern amenities came about (and truly accelerated after the Industrial Revolution). Here's a great summary: http://www.unm.edu/~lkravitz/Article%20folder/history.html

It is clear, however, that early childhood physical activity creates a foundation for adult physical fitness that is difficult to compete with. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2874089/

When you have an entire society living that lifestyle due to circumstances, not by choice, you'll also have a much larger sample pool from which to draw exceptional warriors. That is my argument. And the farther you go back, the larger the source pool will be, simply due to the circumstances of how the world lived.

It is interesting that the History of Fitness article guys claim that a society becoming lazy in general contributed to a loss in their overall fighting power. Can we prove it? OK, maybe we can't. But I'd posit that we can't say there is NO data out there to create better theories, as long as we acknowledge the possibility that we could be wrong.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by Cthulhu_ on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:00AM (#8947664)
I've seen a video of a big Polish swordfighting battle (you can probably find it on google), people in full armor and swords. What I could spot is that swords are completely ineffective against armor; swords glance off, are unable to penetrate armor, and just bend. I'd use a mace or club and beat people's head in. Which is probably why those weren't used in that one.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by mcv on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:08AM (#8947708)
It's the disadvantage of recreating historical martial arts in a realistic way; if you actually did it completely realistic, you need to figure out what to do with all the bodies.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by scott_s on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:25AM (#8947814)
That can't be completely true - historical soldiers still needed to train. So, in theory, we can still recreate their training with historical accuracy. And I imagine their training still had the concept of winners and losers, even though both people walked away to train another day. I imagine their training would look a lot like the sport fighting in the linked video.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by mcv on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @09:20AM (#8953100)
Yes, they trained, but their training wasn't realistic combat. They used blunt, often wooden swords, for example, or practiced stuff in slow motion. And we do the same, but it's not the same as actual combat, because in actual combat, people get hurt. You can get a perfect simulation of that without people getting hurt.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by elbows on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @09:16AM (#8953085)
In Germany around the 16th century, people fought unarmored with blunted swords, and the winner was the first guy to cause a bleeding wound on his opponent's scalp.

We certainly could reproduce that today, but I don't think most people would want to. :)

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by mr_luc on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @01:01AM (#8951468)
Swiss pikemen and (briefly) spanish swordsmen aside, foot soldiers were either horse or archer fodder.

The implicit contract for military support between the King and the areas he ruled changed in the Dark Ages: instead of providing many men, you provided few mounted men (a requirement that led directly to the feudal system).

So many other people here are correct in pointing out that these sword skills weren't the most relevant thing to the conducting of all-out war.

Nonetheless, europe was pretty martial, and there were a lot of martial contexts besides massed combat.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by scott_s on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @08:42AM (#8952923)
I don't disagree with any of that - is there something I said that you disagree with?
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by gexla on Monday January 26, 2015 @10:14AM (#8947356)
> I doubt it has close resemblance with medieval long sword fighting, though :-)

Probably closer to training than fighting. It may also be close to whatever sport they made of it back in the day.

I'm comparing modern day martial arts. Pretty much all training and sport.

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by TrevorJ on Monday January 26, 2015 @02:39PM (#8949068)
Proper armor of the period was not like what we see in films, it wasn't nearly so clumsy.

It's a bit silly, but check this short clip out it will open your eyes a bit. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xm11yAXeegg

Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting by pluma on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @09:01PM (#8957569)
It also wasn't made out of rubber.

If only I had a dollar for each movie that shows rubber maille in closeups.