The weakness of the phalanx is that you can be outflanked; it's really hard to turn a long pike to address an opponent not in front of you. I would imagine that having cavalry to protect your flanks would make it a lot more effective.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting
by Sander_Marechal on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:43PM
(#8948714)
The swiss didn't ise a classic wide phalanx formation but a more densely packed square formation. Their pikes would stand out in all directions as a sort of hedgehog. Only the corners would be a weaker point. The flanks and rear would be well covered by pikes.
Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting
by Tuna-Fish on Monday January 26, 2015 @05:30PM
(#8950041)
The pikes would generally stand only in one direction at once, and their drills had diagonal forms, so the corners would not be a weak point.
When people think pikemen, they think of very static formations, with little mobility. This is true of a lot of historical pike units, but the Swiss pikemen are the opposite of it. They drilled as small companies of ~100 men, and they were so successful because they made mobility as an unit into an art. A swiss pike block was drilled to change facing in seconds, and they liked to charge pikes levelled at near running speed. Many a condottiere got their last surprise when they were at the last stretch of their charge against an exposed flank or rear of a swiss block, and suddenly all the pikes rise, everyone turns, all the pikes come down again, and the swiss start charging the would-be attackers like madmen.
This sounds a bit like a Greek Hoplite Phalanx.