News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by snitko on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:16AM (#8910734)
It's bizarre to me that people prefer to focus on how much somebody owns rather than if he earned it honestly. If a person didn't steal, cheat or coerced anybody in the process of making his money, he is entitled to it. I don't care how rich he is, because he didn't do anything bad to anybody else.

Then of course people say "but greed". Yes, as if only rich people are greedy and you are not.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by rgbrenner on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:40AM (#8910801)
I don't think that's the primary issue. I think there's a large number of people who feel like the rules that everyone plays by are harder than the rules the rich play by. For example, the negative opinion many have of the lower tax rate for capital gains vs payroll taxes. It's not that those who pay capital gains tax are dishonest. It's that it's unfair that their earnings are taxed at a lower rate.

Other examples might be CEO pay vs average pay; the shrinking middle class; etc.. These create a feeling that while the rich grow richer, things get harder for the middle class... and add to this sense of unfairness. Since it's unfair if a company is improving it's earnings/productivity/etc, but most of those gains go to the CEO (since that increase is the result of everyones input).

From that angle, this really has nothing to do with greed.

If it were to come to light that some rich person also earned their money dishonestly.. that seems to create anger that's directed toward that person/group.. see the anger people had over the bank bailouts... that didn't grow into an anti-rich campaign.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by jnbiche on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:48AM (#8911018)
>For example, the negative opinion many have of the lower tax rate for capital gains vs payroll taxes.

Not to mention the fact that contractors pay almost double employment tax at a time when more and more employees are being pushed out into being contractors.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by mherkender on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:39AM (#8910800)
I can't speak for everyone, but for me it was more about the growing divide between the rich and poor. I don't think a healthy/happy society with room for upward mobility can exist if things keep moving in this direction. This is literally how wars start.

I really can't understand how you think this is about some person's individual success. People don't hate that, they want it for themselves too. The problem is that statistically it's becoming less likely for poorer economic groups, regardless of their honesty.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by snitko on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:51AM (#8911029)
I agree with you that a healthy society is the one where the gap between the poor and the rich is small. However, I believe this must not be achieved by any kind of coercion coming from government. It may work sometimes (as in Scandinavian countries, but those are exceptions and I'm not gonna go into the details of why I think this cannot be duplicated), but ultimately, I think the gap can only be made smaller by free market and free trade, without government violence and coercion.

If you look at the wealthiest people in the world, those are the people who are either in power or close to power. Nobody will be able to make money by favoritism or coercion or corruption if there is no entity (e.g. government) that facilitates those things. Look at the world map. Which countries (again, with the exception of Scandinavian countries) are the richest and in which countries the lot of ordinary men is better? The ones where there's more free market, not less. The US, of course, is absolutely not in the top list of those countries, being highly regulated and taxed.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by dasil003 on Monday January 19, 2015 @11:21AM (#8912522)
> Nobody will be able to make money by favoritism or coercion or corruption if there is no entity (e.g. government) that facilitates those things.

Sure, government corruption is one way rich people make themselves richer, but money by itself is powerful too. Imagine we lived in anarchy, the strongest few would amass all the wealth, they would run their own private armies, and no one who wasn't rich and strong would have any leverage to get anything.

The point of a progressive taxation scheme is that wealth itself confers an advantage that needs to be offset by some collective power of the populace. Claiming that free markets will make the wealth gap shrink is just magical thinking. Money is power, regardless of the form of government.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by snitko on Tuesday January 20, 2015 @04:32AM (#8916121)
If you re-read your comment you will see that there's no logical proof in what you're saying, nor is there any evidence. Saying things like "your point is just magical thinking" will not prove me wrong.

Furthermore, please notice that when you say "The point of a progressive taxation scheme..." means that this is an intention of the policy. The actual effect might be quite different, as is very often the case with government policies. I would argue that rich people will always be more powerful, you simply cannot avoid that. And there will always be inequality. Question is, under which system will the rich be less powerful and my answer is that without government they won't be able to coerce others and force others to do things, they will only be able to spend THEIR own money and act on the market as market players, with no special privileges.

The problem is that while your intentions are noble, intentions alone cannot solve the problem. You always have to look at results. Tell me, where in the world has progressive taxation produced innovation and wealth? Perhaps, Scandinavian countries are innovative and are responsible for a great deal of awesome new things in the world? No they're not. Or perhaps China or Russia before they started liberalizing their markets had produced a lot of innovation and increased the standards of living for their citizens? No. Only in countries with less government intervention have we seen the lot of ordinary men greatly improved.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by aninhumer on Monday January 19, 2015 @01:35PM (#8913222)
>I believe this must not be achieved by any kind of coercion coming from government.

The thing is, as soon as you talk about a system of property, you're talking about violent coercion. Even before you consider corruption, the government is disproportionately helping rich people by enforcing that they have exclusive access to a larger share of the world's resources. That's fundamentally what it means to be "rich".

Now don't get me wrong, I'm not going to suggest completely abolishing property rights. I just get sick of people using "it's coercion" as an argument against any government intervention, while quietly ignoring the absolutely huge amount of coercion involved in enforcing a "free market".

>Nobody will be able to make money by favoritism or coercion or corruption if there is no entity (e.g. government) that facilitates those things.

People are perfectly capable of favouring, coercing and corrupting others without any help. Centralised power can make it worse in some cases, but it's not like all that power disappears when you take away the government.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by tomp on Monday January 19, 2015 @05:08AM (#8911228)
> Which countries (again, with the exception of Scandinavian countries) are the richest and in which countries the lot of ordinary men is better? The ones where there's more free market, not less

Which countries, specifically, do you have in mind?

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by snitko on Monday January 19, 2015 @07:20AM (#8911558)
It's very simple. If you looked at Hong Kong vs China, or South Korea vs North Korea, or Western Germany vs Eastern Germany, you only needed to follow the people's footsteps. Have people been lining up to go from the former to the latter ones or vice versa?
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by aninhumer on Monday January 19, 2015 @12:52PM (#8912985)
Well sure, if you compare free markets with dysfunctional dictatorships, they come out pretty well. But when you start looking at the nuances of regulation within relatively free markets, the answers aren't so clear cut.

Even if you omit the best examples of European social democracy, a lot of people would argue that quality of life for the average person in France, Germany or the UK is much better than in the US, due to such government meddling as social healthcare, labour laws and consumer protections.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by 7952 on Monday January 19, 2015 @04:07PM (#8914074)
It makes it almost impossible to set tax rates that are fair. People always have someone richer than themselves who they think should pay more. People always have someone poorer who is "scrounging". You end up with massive income redistribution with the government having all the spending power. It is bad from almost any political perspective.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by mc32 on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:27AM (#8910762)
I think the honesty part is what bothers people. People want to know that wealth wasn't gained via dishonesty, favors, favoritism, advantage, etc. In some ways wealth accumulation, if not managed by government thru taxation or other means can snowball and can create power plays favoring the wealthy. So I think the drumbeat has to do with the 'pendulum' being perceived to be too much in the 'wealthy' phase. People would prefer to see less sharp inequality not so much the disappearance of it as that is also undesirable (being that it too is too artificial)

One of the symptoms is the spread of CxO pay to staff pay. Or companies with record profits paying near minimum wage --sure it makes sense in pure competitive capitalism, but is that what is best for society? Should we govern those disparities more, would it make society at large better (result in better educated and more productive people with reduction in crime, etc?)

Unrelated to this but nonetheless a question this brings up is how well could the world deal with 7billion people with incomes similar to middle income euro/nam/east Asians?

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by meric on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:19AM (#8910746)
You could frame the report in terms of "How in equal are people in terms of the ability to generate wealth honestly?". I don't think the report mentioned anything about stealing, cheating or coercing.

A janitor in Australia makes a whole lot more than a janitor in India, and is able to save a lot more after consuming the same amount of goods, for example. Both earned their wealth honestly but why is one wealthier than the other merely because of living in a different country? Statistics like these can provoke some good questions.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by xnull2guest on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:48AM (#8910835)
What if a person did not earn, but inherited wealth?

Nearly 50% of the Forbes 500 have inherited their wealth. The Walton children will soon be inheriting a sum equal to the combined wealth of the bottom 3/4 of all black American families.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by snitko on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:42AM (#8911007)
A society where inheritance is not possible or heavily taxed are doomed to spiral into short-term entertainment consumer economies. That is, people, knowing they can't leave anything to their children, will spend as much as they can on things they don't really need, thus provoking the wrong kind of spending.

The question is, if I made my money honestly, do I have the right to spend my money as I please? If yes, then I should be able to leave it to my children, and not to someone else's children. If you think I shouldn't do that or that inheritance should be heavily taxed, you're essentially saying "even though you actually earned that money, it doesn't belong to you", which is practically communism - I think it's immoral, evil and unfair.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by jnbiche on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:46AM (#8911011)
>If you think I shouldn't do that or that inheritance should be heavily taxed, you're essentially saying "even though you actually earned that money, it doesn't belong to you", which is practically communism - I think it's immoral, evil and unfair

If our current system of government weren't rotten to the core, I'd actually agree with you. But so much of the top 1% of net worth has been accumulated through government spending (particularly DoD spending) or corporate welfare (particularly in the finance sector), and that's equally immoral, evil, and unfair.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by snitko on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:55AM (#8911039)
oh, but I agree. I'm not advocating government spending. I'm only saying that in principle, ANY government is corrupt and the most wealth is accumulated by being close to the power (either by lobbying, favoritism, coercion or plain corruption). Government (both as a concept and as a specific entity in each country) is the source of most of the inequalities, not the cure.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by jnbiche on Monday January 19, 2015 @04:01AM (#8911053)
>most wealth is accumulated by being close to the power (either by lobbying, favoritism, coercion or plain corruption)

Then you understand why people are so pissed about the 1%? The middle class, particularly under 40, is fucking suffering, man. That's not a good thing.

If you're an honest man in the top 1%, you should be working like a demon to change the current system, because having so much resentment against the most wealthy doesn't bode well for your future (either due to extraordinarily high taxes or civil unrest, neither or which I am advocating for).

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by snitko on Monday January 19, 2015 @04:08AM (#8911069)
This is why I believe in Bitcoin and work on its infrastructure. It doesn't need government. You don't need to ask for permission. There is no way you can massively steal it from individual wallets or in many cases even know that someone has a certain amount of money. Governments can't fund wars and can't just bail banks out by more taxation and printing more money. Bitcoin is the answer.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by jnbiche on Monday January 19, 2015 @04:27AM (#8911117)
Yeah, that's one of the big reasons I got interested in Bitcoin, including contributions to its development.

Unfortunately, it has attracted a huge swarm of scammers, pumpers, and other dishonest people as it's grown, so I've lost interest.

While all the hacks are unfortunately part of a growing process, security will continue to improve[1]. I'm much more concerned about this type of people Bitcoin has attracted, and that much of its community has promoted. I'm particularly concerned that the constant influx of scammers may be inevitable in an anonymous or pseudonymous, irreversible currency, which a decentralized currency almost necessarily must be.

1. By necessity cryptocurrency may well bring about a rebirth in information security

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by jnbiche on Monday January 19, 2015 @10:05PM (#8915267)
By the way, in case you see this later, I didn't downvote any of your posts. Looks like someone wasn't happy with either of us.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by snitko on Tuesday January 20, 2015 @08:58AM (#8916917)
Ah, yeah. Well, that's ok. I never downvote people with whom I have discussions here either. I think for some it's easier to downvote than to reply, which is fine with me.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by userulluipeste on Monday January 19, 2015 @11:23AM (#8912537)
"even though you actually earned that money, it doesn't belong to you"

But that's valid for a lot of things. Say, although you own a land, you still have to pay taxes on it, and if you won't, in the long run it will be forcefully seized from you. It's just how the society was designed (or "evolved into", if you please), with its laws that we, for the most part, just come to accept. Similar acceptance exists and/or can be (not that it should be) further extended for many other instances. The only necessary thing for imposing such an order is power. An authority has the power over land owners, thanks to the nature of that owned good - being immobile and having an intrinsic value. Now, given the right kind of power, a similar order of things can be forced on pretty much everything!

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by xnull2guest on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:05PM (#8913417)
> A society where inheritance is not possible or heavily taxed are doomed to spiral into short-term entertainment consumer economies

1.) Are there numbers that back up this claim?

2.) I've already heard our society is in a death spiral of short-term entertainment and consumerism (and for reasons deeper than an estate tax). How do you suppose that an estate tax is somehow more fundamental?

> That is, people, knowing they can't leave anything to their children, will spend as much as they can on things they don't really need, thus provoking the wrong kind of spending.

Again numbers. Or any kind of precedent? Might one suggest that the children who inherit the wealth but don't have the work ethic are provoked into the wrong kind of spending? This claim seems all the work of narrative and no work of empirical grounding.

> The question is, if I made my money honestly, do I have the right to spend my money as I please?

That is not the question. It is one question in a long list of questions. Another question is how much of a right does someone have to do "A" before it interferes with the rights of others (the foundation of our values) - in cases where "A" is wealth accumulation there does exist points at which the rest of society is hurt.

And in fact, nobody is suggesting that you may not pass inheritance, just that it be taxed like everything else. In fact taxed heavily.

> If you think I shouldn't do that or that inheritance should be heavily taxed, you're essentially saying "even though you actually earned that money, it doesn't belong to you", which is practically communism - I think it's immoral, evil and unfair.

It is a far, far cry from communism. Remember Locke's own concept of property - no land or wealth is owned by anyone, a person merely the products of their own labor (an apple for picking it, a crop for sewing it). The wealthy in this country and in modern capitalism have not earned the wealth by working the fields. They own the machines that work the field and pay the labor force that works the field. That is to say, they own the vaunted 'means of production'. Essentially, wealth creates and captures wealth.

Piketty's analysis of this is damning. Piketty's framework is simple:

An individual with accumulated capital's purpose is to live from their accumulated capital and grow the rest faster than inflation, so that their accumulation grows. When the savings rate (today for the top elite ~10%) outstrips the inflation rate (~1.2%), accumulated wealth grows. But workers wealth, which doesn't grow at 110% per year, actually decreases to 98% a year - they must be 2% more productive every year to get a 2% raise since they do not have access to the same savings rate as the financial elite.

> think is immoral, evil and unfair

I (and others) think that children inheriting billions of dollars, giant estates, seats of corporations, and ivy league entry by birth alone is immoral, evil and unfair.

That is, a system which created classes of people based on dynasty rather than merit is not fabled capitalism - presumed to be based on merit.

What we call for is not communism, but capitalism. A capitalism where there is equal opportunity for hard workers to get ahead. Huge inheritances is one of the largest hurdles to a functioning capitalism.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by bksenior on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:41AM (#8910807)
Wrong. Money becomes family money and when there is an inequity large enough that they can affect large parts of infrastructure you are basically guaranteeing power to scions who were not trained for the responsibility or the value of the fortune.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by rdtsc on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:09AM (#8910912)
> If a person didn't steal, cheat or coerced anybody in the process of making his money, he is entitled to it.

Depending on the interpretation of "cheat","steal", "coerced" and "anyone" means. Take the banks that made money from the real estate bubble. Did they cheat, steal or coerced anyone? Maybe if you comb through the legal details they haven't. Yet many will say they did.

> Then of course people say "but greed". Yes, as if only rich people are greedy and you are not.

The problem is if the rich are greedy they have the potential to inflict a lot more damage than say if someone poor is greedy.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by gdne on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:33AM (#8910970)
Whether or not the rich earned their wealth honestly has nothing to do with the issue of excessive wealth inequality.

Excessive wealth inequality creates a massive imbalance in society. The concentration of wealth in the hands of so few leads to corruption, oppression, and wars. We already see all of this and it will only get worse unless we address the issue.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by rab_oof on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:49AM (#8910836)
Ethics are important, without a doubt, just orthogonal to how much more poor people are struggling.

If it's any sign, look at the homeless camps in Silicon Valley. People (outside tech) were never so broke as now, it's almost a 1920's pattern, to a limited degree. Janitors live in their cars in our parking lot because they can't afford housing. I wish they were paid more. :((

Eventually, we may need redistribution of wealth, voluntary or not, because people need at least enough food and shelter, and some path to self-sufficiency, if possible. I don't advocate rash direct wealth transfer but at first voluntary subsidization/underwriting of bare, minimal essentials (food (organic, fair trade fruits/vegetables/etc.[0]), housing, transport, education) adjusted to income.

(Santa Clara county General Assistance (GA) for singles is ~$150 USD/month and food stamps (CalFresh) is about the same... Seriously not enough to survive on but also not enough for people to hurt themselves with either.)

0: to avoid workers being sprayed with horrible chemicals and such. (Btw, in California, CRLA are cool folks.)

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by rgbrenner on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:54AM (#8910858)
Eventually, we may need redistribution of wealth, voluntary or not, because people need at least enough food and shelter, and some path to self-sufficiency, if possible.

And this is why at some level, a person is no longer entitled to additional wealth (even if it's earned honestly and fairly).

We know from history that when a small group of people control the vast majority of wealth, it creates an unstable system. So in order to maintain a stable government and economy, there must be some limits on wealth.

(and progressive taxes are one of the ways we control wealth, and prevent this instability.)

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by pgsandstrom on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:41AM (#8910810)
If one honest hardworking person is living in poverty and one honest hardworking person is a billionare, then I do have a problem with it. I'm greedy myself, does that make it wrong of me to want to change the system?
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by coldtea on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:54AM (#8910859)
>It's bizarre to me that people prefer to focus on how much somebody owns rather than if he earned it honestly.

From a state where everybody is born naked and without any god given possesions, it's only through injustice, and accumulated violence, exclusion, etc that you get to a state were somebody has billions and others nothing.

Even the mere act of inheritance (in which you did nothing at all, neither bad nor good to get those money from) makes an old injustice persistent.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by refurb on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:00AM (#8910881)
So you're saying that if i die i can't give my money (which i already paid taxes on) to whomever i want?
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by xnull2guest on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:12AM (#8910919)
It's called an estate tax.

Gifts of property and money to people while you are alive, when they exceed certain totals per year and when they exceed certain totals on individual terms, these exchanges are taxed.

There is no reason why it should not also be so when you pass on.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by coldtea on Monday January 19, 2015 @08:14AM (#8911751)
Yeah, I'm saying that.

Believe it or not "It's my money, I do whatever I want with them" is not seen by everybody as some divine-being-given right.

Nor it was always available in all societies.

And it's quite hypocritical to be called from a society that supposedly believes in the advantages of capitalism and the free market as motivating forces for progress and hard work, etc. Inherited money are against all that. In fact they take us to feudal times, taken in extreme.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by refurb on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:08PM (#8913441)
Inherited money are against progress and hard work? They would take us to feudal times? Where are you getting this from?
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by coldtea on Monday January 19, 2015 @05:03PM (#8914403)
Obviously if you have inherited wealth you have less needs-based pressure to work hard or create things.

Working to make money for yourself is what is used to explain the difference between capitalism and really existing socialism (USSR et al), that is to explain why in the former people worked more and were more motivated, as well as the latter's decline in progress, industry, etc. "Why work hard and be creative since you have a guaranteed salary from the state", the reasoning went.

Adopting this argument, we can say: "why work hard and be creative, since you have a guaranteed fortune that you inherited".

Think Paris Hilton. Or really any lazy, fast-spender inherited-money-from-his-self-made-parents person you know...

Isn't it obvious in retrospect? Of course someone can have $10 billion in his name and still be creative, but I'm talking about the average person here, not outliers.

As for the thing about this "taking us back to feudal times", as has been pointed out by other people in this thread, inherited wealth is not really that different from the inherited castles, and plots of land and fortunes of the feudal overlords.

With inheritance, just because you were born in a certain family (like in feudal times) you automatically get wealth and power. And you can use that power to ensure you keep the wealth and pass it on to your "noble" descendants. It's not by accident that we talk about "silver spoons" and such.

(Power, in our society is directly associated with wealth. From a point and above you can have a few congressment in your pocket, for example).

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by yoavm on Monday January 19, 2015 @08:13AM (#8911745)
In a world where money == power, giving millions to your children isn't a lot different from a king passing on the crown to his.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by afarrell on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:26AM (#8910759)
If you buy something in a peaceful and non-coersive transaction from someone who burgled it, have you acquired it honestly?
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by RobertKerans on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:53AM (#8910856)
One issue might be that, going by history, there is likely a tipping point where those not in the 1% use force to redistribute. That's got nothing to do with whether the wealth was accrued lawfully.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by mc32 on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:00AM (#8910878)
Revolutions aren't typically driven by the starving populace who worry about their next meal --it's more people already in power or higher classes who use the masses to effect their change. Change usually has champions at the top. In other words it's a power struggle at the top manifested at the bottom.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by RobertKerans on Monday January 19, 2015 @08:57AM (#8911908)
I'd kinda agree with that, there generally needs to be a driving force, and that driver is often primarily a group of persons who already have a measure of power. But it's not as much a starving populance that would be worrisome, rather an ignored one that a. feels it has no power and b. feels it cannot ever bridge that gap between haves- and have-nots. If that group includes the majority of the population, it would seem ripe for people with specific [often extremist?] agendas to manipulate, or maybe ground-up revolution driven by [demagogues?].
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by xnull2guest on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:33AM (#8910969)
I would love to hear more about this analysis of the ontology of revolutions. I can think of instances in history where this seems to be the case (1850s America) but also instances were it does not seem to be the case (The Peasant's Revolt).

Do you know of a more nuanced (empirical) approach to predicting or recognizing which instances are driven by the masses, rather than political narrative?

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by mc32 on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:53AM (#8911037)
Unfortunately not. This is just what I've heard from students of history not actual experts. It seems like a subject that could do with more analysis --although this would require lots of inference with regard to older revolutions I think
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by quadrangle on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:50AM (#8910843)
> If a person didn't steal, cheat or coerced anybody in the process of making his money, he is entitled to it.

What a completely empty concept of morality. Human societies and philosophers have wrestled for generations with ideas about justice, fairness, compassion, ethics… You will do well to take some time with an open mind to explore the range of ideas people have worked out. Moral judgments about what people deserve in life are far more complex than whether a single person didn't themselves cheat, steal, or coerce.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by VikingCoder on Monday January 19, 2015 @05:46PM (#8914597)
We rejected inherited political power as a system of government. Some of us feel that inherited wealth is just as detrimental. We'd love to see more evidence of upward mobility, and we question the legal and tax systems that stop upward mobility from happening, even for those who are skilled and willing to work very hard.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by CmonDev on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:36AM (#8910986)
Rich people owned most of Russia once... Quite "honestly" according to the laws of those times. What could possibly go wrong?
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by chrisbennet on Tuesday January 20, 2015 @01:59AM (#8915771)
And now they do again...
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by mapt on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:03AM (#8910892)
I understand where you are coming from 100%, but ultimately, money & wealth is the manner in which this socioeconomic system describes power imbalances between people - power imbalances which are not natural and which are not indefinitely feasible. With $1B, I can hire 20,000 people for $50,000 a year. I possess the things they think are necessary for their livelihood (the much-vaunted 'means of production'), laundered through this thing we call an 'economy', and my ownership of those things is protected with force of law and custom. My $1B is heritable, and according to the doctrines of personal property, essentially inviolable.

Is there a distinction between a billionaire and a dynastic prince of a small nation who can command up to 20,000 people for up to a year before they get angry enough at him that they stop listening?

Large amounts of wealth inequality implicitly distort liberal democracy - the thing that recognizes "rights" as a philosophical system of morality & ethics - and destabilize it. There is no "correct" level of wealth inequality, but a system in which wealth inequality is growing in an out of control fashion, is an unstable system whose existence is threatened. That this system is liberal democratic market capitalism matters little - this is not some kind of natural arrangement, it's something we built, and it's something which can fail. Because people, as a whole, only respect what's written on little bits of paper - only respect the customs and law of property rights and the existing power structure - so long as the system provides them with the things they think are necessary for their livelihood.

Well, that's our system. Nearly all growth of the economy is ending up technically "owned" by a narrower and narrower minority. For one reason or other, the economic equation has developed an unbalanced variable, and wealth is completely failing to trickle down... and our system can't sustain this perpetual exponential growth in power imbalance forever.

Some of the greatest attacks on inequality were performed in part due to a very real fear that the whole system would collapse in a socialist revolution; The fact that the Communists are fallen has made this less credible, and perhaps, for all their evils, that's not a great thing for us.

Apparently, in the early history of currency, after we had gotten property rights laid down tightly and developed a fungible system of value, various civilizations developed a problem. Unlike the vague bonds of social obligation that they had previously represented, debts that are denominated in coinage attract contract arrangements with penalties such as slavery. This was accepted until surprisingly recently as an unfortunate necessity of life. The elite discovered that the accumulation of slaves was a practical problem, because their customary service as cook or manservant or sexual partner took them out of the fields, and first currency crises were born: It was recognized that if the fields were left fallow, this was a worse outcome for all than the property of the elites not being sacrosanct. The arrangement that was periodically arrived at was that the king would issue a jubilee, freeing all the slaves to go back to their fields and their families, with no compensation to the elites. When this was missing for a protracted period, slave revolts tended to pop up, with summary execution of the masters as a prize.

The system of norms ("rights") is subordinate, at some level, to the proper functioning of a society. It doesn't particularly matter whether we call people with an indispensable debt that they need to perform service to partially mitigate, "slaves" or "working class" or "debt peons". You can only push them so far and still earn positive economic returns, and beyond that, in the full view of history, you can only push them so far and still keep your head.

Whether one is "entitled" to property is a view from so close to the ground one can't see past the blades of grass.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by noelwelsh on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:52AM (#8910848)
Update: edited to reflect comments of xnull2guest below.

Wealthy people have disproportionate power in society and use that power to distort society to serve their needs. One simple example is how large US companies use government lobbying to transfer money from the public to themselves. Here is a list of the top spenders on lobbying:

  https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/top.php?indexType=s 
(Incidentally, notice how underrepresented consumer groups are.) Consider Lockheed, Boeing, and Northrup, which each spent about $200M. These companies all produce expensive military goods. Much has been written about the military-industrial complex (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military%E2%80%93industrial_com...), and how it serves the needs of the defence companies. A fairly clear example is the program to transfer excess military equipment (worth $billions) from the military to the US police (e.g. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/aug/14/ferguson-police...), which supports over-spending on military equipment. Another is the cost overruns in F35 project (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning_...).

What happens to the money that these companies acquire? Just as inequality is increasing in society, so is inequality in pay within companies (e.g. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2014/09/25/t...). Choosing Boeing at random, it's CEO has received over $20M for several years running (http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2014/03/14/comp...)

All up, this is a complex system to transfer money from the public into the pockets of the high level executives at a few firms.

There are other examples of systematic changes to benefit the wealthy, such as declining tax rate for top earners in the US and other countries. See http://milescorak.com/2013/05/29/do-falling-tax-rates-explai...

I don't want to give the impression that all these shenanigans involve government corruption. The wage fixing case against Apple, Google, etc. (http://www.cnet.com/uk/news/apple-google-appeal-settlement-r...) is a good example of private companies acting to screw over workers without involving government.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by jnbiche on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:36AM (#8910985)
Have you ever considered that some of us have become libertarian precisely because we're concerned with increasing inequality?

Let's not forget that government:

* Are the other end of "spending on lobbying"

* Are the buyers of "expensive military goods"

* Create the concept of corporations, and gives tax breaks to them ("corporate welfare")

* Give sweetheart deals to political favorites

* Lock up citizens for non-violent offenses, denying them the chance to earn a living

* Allow and promote regulatory capture, which forbids many smart, driven individuals from challenging current business leaders.

The sooner we can get government out of business, the fairer and more equal things will be for everyone.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by noelwelsh on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:03AM (#8910896)
Awesome, the unexplained downvote. There is factual content in my post, with cites, and yet someone would rather bury comments that challenge their worldview than debate. I guess we are dealing with libertarian idiocy then.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by xnull2guest on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:23AM (#8910944)
I didn't downvote you. I actually think I probably agree with your point(s). And I'm exactly the liberal populist kind of guy who perfectly fits into the most sympathetic of audiences. But I have trouble trying to understand your point(s) because they seem to meander a bit, almost like you're trying to say too much with too few sentences. And the comment starts off with a paternalistic tone and with an quasi-insult.

It looks like there could be really good information in there - I'd love to give it an upvote if it were unpacked a bit, and cited and argued more clearly.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by noelwelsh on Monday January 19, 2015 @05:00AM (#8911208)
Thank you for taking the time to respond. You are absolutely correct that my tone was off putting and I was not clear in the argument I was making. I have updated my post accordingly.
Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by _benedict on Monday January 19, 2015 @10:57AM (#8912387)
You're ignoring heritable wealth. Personally I support a 100% estate tax above some small multiple of the median salary, so that the meritocratic element of society can flourish. This doesn't prevent the parents spending lavishly on their children whilst still alive, and might need some provisions to permit such spendings (for educational and other pursuits while still developing) to be secured in trust form in case of premature death.

Right now inheriting valuable property and other assets is an "honest" mechanism, but is not at all clearly fair.

Re:Richest 1% to own more than rest of world, Oxfam says by iamds on Monday January 19, 2015 @11:19AM (#8912507)
I think this comes with lots of difficulties.

For example should you be evicted from your family farm that you've worked on your whole life when your 80 year old mother dies just because you haven't saved up enough money to buy it on the event of her death.

What if you are a subsistence farmer in Cambodia in the same situation - should you lose your family land to the state on the event of the death of your parents?