News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by zackmorris on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:17PM (#8858670)
One of the key points of the talk happens around the 32-37 minute mark, comparing the crew sizes of various ships. He makes the point that the core of development is really putting together the requirements, not writing code. Unfortunately we've put nearly all of the resources of our industry into engineering rather than science (tactics rather than strategies). What he stated very succinctly is that a supercomputer can work out the tactics when provided a strategy, so why are we doing this all by hand?

That’s as far as I’ve gotten in the video so far but I find it kind of haunting that I already know what he’s talking about (brute force, simulated annealing, genetic algorithms, and other simple formulas that evolve a solution) and that these all run horribly on current hardware but are trivial to run on highly parallelized CPUs like the kind that can be built with FPGAs. They also would map quite well to existing computer networks, a bit like SETI@home.

Dunno about anyone else, but nearly the entirety of what I do is a waste of time, and I know it, deep down inside. That’s been a big factor in bouts with depression over the years and things like imposter syndrome. I really quite despise the fact that I’m more of a translator between the spoken word and computer code than an engineer, architect or even craftsman. Unfortunately I follow the money for survival, but if it weren’t for that, I really feel that I could be doing world-class work for what basically amounts to room and board. I wonder if anyone here feels the same…

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by david927 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:46PM (#8858899)
That's exactly it. I sometimes wonder how many brilliant people have left this industry because they were similarly enlightened. (One prominent person in applied computer science recently told me she was considering going to go into medicine because she wanted to do something useful.)

It doesn't have to be like this. We have the brain power. But I feel we squander it on making silly websites/apps when we could be making history.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by sukilot on Friday January 09, 2015 @12:02AM (#8860853)
You know what medical professinals do? Get patients healthy so the patients can enjoy apps and sites.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jsprogrammer on Thursday January 08, 2015 @06:57PM (#8859860)
I think the previous poster already identified the problem:

>I follow the money for survival

Maybe we can have a system where people can survive without money?

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by colund on Friday January 09, 2015 @04:22AM (#8861416)
Nice, however that would remove an incentive for innovation
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by perfunctory on Friday January 09, 2015 @04:28AM (#8861429)
> incentive for innovation

Do you think Alan Kay was incentivised by money to do all the stuff he talked about in this video?

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by minthd on Friday January 09, 2015 @11:09AM (#8862783)
OK - so alan kay did working on creating this great system. Is there any knowledge from it used in a practical application today ? Probably no, because

a.It's probably too soon.

b.It often takes boring work(and money) to transfer pure ideas to successful practical applications.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by perfunctory on Friday January 09, 2015 @03:23PM (#8864286)
we were talking about insentives for innovation, not insentives for boring work. I agree that boring work should be insentivised by money.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jsprogrammer on Friday January 09, 2015 @05:40PM (#8864952)
I'd be interesting in going the course of: boring work should be eliminated through automation or obsolescence.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by Retra on Sunday January 11, 2015 @04:01PM (#8871291)
Who paid you for your comment?

Take a look at this thread -- scroll all the way to the bottom. What is the incentive for all of that?

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jsprogrammer on Friday January 09, 2015 @05:11PM (#8864821)
I don't think anything says you can't use another incentive.

Innovate or die (literally), doesn't seem like the wisest philosophy to base life on this planet around.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 08, 2015 @07:46PM (#8860053)
See Keith Weslowski's recent split.

I suspect a similar calculus may have inspired Joey Hess's retreat to a farm.

I can think of others: jwz, Bret Glass, Cringely.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by scotty79 on Saturday January 10, 2015 @08:29AM (#8866723)
I know about one such person that after having successful IT Business career moved to another country (mine) and became neurosurgeon (at absurdly stupidly low pay that doctors in my country get).
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by heeen2 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @08:37PM (#8860240)
The comparison of the sailship, submarine and the airplane doesn't really hold, though.

A sailship travels for weeks or months, has not a single piece of automation and has to be maintained during the journey.

Similarily the submarine is meant to travel for long periods of time during which it has to be operated and maintained.

Both of those are designed to be self-sufficient, so they have to provide facilities for the crew, and the crew grows due to maintenance required, medical and battle stations.

The airplane travels for 16 hours tops and is supported by a sizable crew of engineers, ground control, and for passenger planes, cooks and cleaning personell, on the ground.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by Animats on Thursday January 08, 2015 @11:01PM (#8860682)
Right. Warships try to be self-sufficient and able to deal with battle damage, which means a large on-board crew. The biggest Maersk container ships have a crew of 22. Nimitz-class aircraft carriers have about 3,000, plus 1,500 in the air units. US Navy frigates have about 220.

If you want a sense of how many people are behind an airline flight, watch "Air City", which is a Korean drama series about a woman operations manager for Inchon Airport. The Japanese series "Tokyo Airport" is similar. Both were made with extensive airport cooperation, and you get to see all the details. (This, by the way, is typical of Asian dramas about work-related topics. They show how work gets done. US entertainment seldom does that, except for police procedurals.)

None of this seems to be relevant to computing.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by lmm on Friday January 09, 2015 @10:55AM (#8862713)
Are those really a uniquely asian approach? Because the description sounds rather like the (earlier) BBC series Airport.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jameshart on Saturday January 10, 2015 @10:10AM (#8866890)
Drama vs documentary.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by dperfect on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:43PM (#8858876)
> ...I’m more of a translator between the spoken word and computer code than an engineer, architect or even craftsman.

What are engineers, architects, and craftsmen but translators of spoken word (or ideas) to various media or physical representations?

One could argue that the greatest achievements of history were essentially composed of seemingly mundane tasks.

We'd all love to feel like we're doing more than that, perhaps by creating intelligence in some form. Maybe as software engineers we can create as you say "simple formulas that evolve a solution" - and those kinds of algorithms/solutions seem to be long overdue - I think we're definitely headed in that direction. But at some point, even those solutions may not be entirely satisfying to the creative mind - after all, once we teach computers to arrive at solutions themselves, can we really take credit for the solutions that are found?

If one is after lasting personal fulfillment, maybe it'd be more effective to apply his or her skills (whatever they may be) more directly to the benefit and wellbeing of other people.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by flueedo on Thursday January 08, 2015 @04:40PM (#8859201)
Yeah but being a translator is a different kind of activity from being an engineer, architect or craftsman. It feels to me that being a Software Engineer -- though currently I've been working with something else -- is kinda like (grossly simplifying it) a really complicated game of Lego or Tetris, where the 'pieces' (APIs, routines, functions, protocols, legacy code, etc, etc) don't always fit where/how they were supposed to, sometimes you can tweak them, but sometimes they're black boxes. Sometimes you have to build some pieces, after giving up on trying to make do with what you got. I think that's what the OP means by time wasted. We waste a lot of time getting the pieces to fit and (as much as we can verify) work as they should when we should be spending our time focusing on what structure we want built after all the pieces are in place.

Engineers, architects and craftsmen don't work, nor waste anywhere near as much time, with as many "pieces" (if any) that behave in such erratic ways.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by stuart78 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @05:28PM (#8859459)
As the son of an architect, I must somewhat dispute this characterization. There are tremendous constraints in that craft which are sometimes parallel to those of software development.

Budget is the first constraint, which limits the available materials and determines material quality.

Components and building codes are a second. While the 'fun' part of building design might be the exteriors and arrangements, a tremendous amount of the effort goes into binding these 'physical APIs' in a standards-complaint manner.

Finally, there is physics. This brings with it the ultimate and unassailable set of constraints.

I know I'm being a bit silly, but my point is that all crafts have frustrations and constraints, and all professions have a high (and often hidden) tedium factor resulting from imperfect starting conditions. These do not actually constrain their ability to create works of physical, intellectual or aesthetic transcendency.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by bbcbasic on Thursday January 08, 2015 @05:15PM (#8859366)
I agree. I felt like this within my first month of working professionally in 2001 and ever since.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by innguest on Thursday January 08, 2015 @05:09PM (#8859340)
Thank you for the apt metaphor. I often struggle with explaining how I feel about this but you nailed it.

We spend too much time getting these tiny pieces to connect correctly, and more often than not they're misaligned slightly or in ways we can't see yet (until it blows up). It's way too much micro for not enough macro. And there isn't even a way to "sketch" as I can with drawing - you know, loosely define the shape of something before starting to fill in with the details. I keep trying to think of a visual way to "sketch" a program so that it would at least mock-run at first, and then I could fill in the function definitions. I don't mean TDD.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by tracker1 on Friday January 09, 2015 @02:45PM (#8864041)
Sorry, but UML provides enough definition to accurately describe any process... you generally need two graphs for any interaction though. Most people don't think in these terms. Some can keep it in their heads, others cannot.

It's easier for most people to reason about a simple task. Not everyone can also see how that simple task will interact with the larger whole. I've seen plenty of developers afraid to introduce something as fundamental as a message queue, which is external to a core application. It breaks away from what they can conceptualize in a standing application.

Different people have differing abilities, talent and skills regarding thought and structure. Less than one percent of developers are above average through most of a "full stack" for any given application of medium to high complexity (percent pulled out of my rear). It doesn't mean the rest can't contribute. But it does mean you need to orchestrate work in ways that best utilize those you have available.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by innguest on Friday January 09, 2015 @11:02PM (#8865879)
> Sorry, but UML provides enough definition to accurately describe any process...

Which is the opposite of sketching, which means (in drawing) to loosely define the basic shapes of something before accurately describing things with "enough definition".

We're not talking about the same thing at all and I can't relate to the rest of your post.

I'm talking about how there's no way to sketch a program that mock-runs and then fill in the details in a piecemeal fashion.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by minthd on Friday January 09, 2015 @10:50AM (#8862685)
One way to partially do this ,by using an auto generation as far as possible. Naked objects(for complex business software) takes this to the extreme - given a set of domain objects, it creates the rest, including GUI. Than if for example, you want to customize the GUI ,you can.

I think it even makes sense at start to create uncomplete objects, run the mock, as continue. Also, the authors of the framework claim that you work very close to the domain language s you can discuss code with domain experts, so in a sense you're working relatively close to the spec level.

The learning curve is a bit high though, i think it could have been much more successful if it has used GUI tools to design domain objects and maybe a higher level language,

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by ANTSANTS on Friday January 09, 2015 @12:09AM (#8860869)
Someday, mankind will give birth to an artificial intelligence far more sophisticated than anything we can comprehend, and our species will cease to be relevant. A very long time from then, the universe will become too cool to support life as we know it and our entire history will have been for naught. And long before any of that, you and I and everyone here will die and be completely, utterly forgotten, from the basement dwellers to the billionaires.

It's called an existential crisis. It's not a special Sillicon Valley angst thing, everyone gets them. Try not to let it get to you too much.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by thirdtruck on Friday January 09, 2015 @10:28AM (#8862585)
I feel exactly the same way. That's been a major driver behind my current career frustration, and one reason that I want to move away from full-time employment categorically.

So much of it comes down to focusing on everything but requirements. If someone asks for directions to the wrong destination, it doesn't matter how exceptional of a map you draw.

And, despite the importance of requirements, we often trust the requirements gathering tasks to non-technical people. Worse, in large corporate environments, the tasks are often foisted on uncommonly incompetent individuals. When I hear about "Do you want to ...?" popups that are supposed to only have a "Yes" button, I know something is fundamentally broken.

I haven't escaped the corporate rat race yet, but I'm taking baby-steps toward a more self-directed work-life. Here's hoping that such a move helps.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by dredmorbius on Thursday January 08, 2015 @06:05PM (#8859647)
nearly the entirety of what I do...

You are not even hardly alone. And while I suspect the PoV is prevalent in IT, it's hardly specific to it.

There's a guy who wrote a book about this so long ago that we don't remember his name. He's known only as "the preacher", sometimes as "the teacher" or "the gatherer".

It's Ecclesiastes, in the old testament of the Bible, and begins with "Vanity of vanities, saith the Preacher, vanity of vanities; all is vanity."

I'm quite an atheist, not religious, and generally not given to quoting scripture. I find this particular book exceptionally insightful.

Much of what you describe is in fact reality for most people -- we "follow the money for survival", but the purpose of it all quite frequently eludes me.

I started asking myself two or three years back, "what are the really big problems", largely as I saw that the areas in which they _might_ be addressed, both in Silicon Valley and in the not-for-profit world, there was little real focus on them. I've pursued that question to a series of others (you can find my list elsewhere, though I encourage you to come up with your own set -- I'll tip you to mine if requested).

My interest initially (and still principally) has been focusing on asking the right questions -- which I feel a great many disciplines and ideologies have not been doing. Having settled on at least a few of the major ones, I'm exploring their dynamics and trying to come to answers, though those are even harder.

It's been an interesting inquiry, and it's illuminated to me at least why the problem exists -- that Life (and its activities) seeks out and exploits entropic gradients, reduces them, and either continues to something else or dies out.

You'll find that concept in the Darwin-Lotka Energy Law, named by ecologist Howard Odum in the 1970s, and more recently in the work of UK physicist Jeremy England. Both conclude that evolution is actually a process which maximizes net power throughput -- a case which if true explains a great many paradoxes of human existence.

But it does raise the question of what humans do after we've exploited the current set of entropy gradients -- fossil fuels, mineral resources, topsoil and freshwater resources. A question Odum posed in the 1970s and which I arrived at independently in the late 1980s (I found Odum's version, in Environment, Power, and Society only in the past year).

But yes, it's a very curious situation.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by keithpeter on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:31PM (#8858776)
"...I’m more of a translator between the spoken word and computer code..."

At our current level of technology and business sophistication, that strikes me as a hard enough problem to justify a career with good compensation.

Any patterns you are noticing in the translation process?

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by zackmorris on Thursday January 08, 2015 @05:03PM (#8859322)
I shouldn’t post this.

It’s hard for me to single out specific patterns because it feels like the things I’m doing today (taking an idea from a written description, PowerPoint presentation or flowchart and converting it to run in an operating system with a C-based language) are the same things I was doing 25 years ago. It might be easier to identify changes.

If there’s one change that stands out, it’s that we’ve gone from imperative programming to somewhat declarative programming. However, where imperative languages like C, Java, Perl, Python etc (for all their warts) were written by a handful of experts, today we have standards designed by committee. So for example, compiling a shell script in C++ that spins up something like Qt to display “Hello, world!” is orders of magnitude more complicated than typing an index.html and opening it in a browser, and that’s fantastic. But what I didn’t see coming is that the standards have gotten so convoluted that a typical HTML5/CSS/Javascript/PHP/MySQL website is so difficult to get right across browsers that it’s an open problem. Building a browser that can reliably display those standards responsively is nontrivial to say the least.

That affects everyone, because when the standards are perceived as being so poor, they are ignored. So now we have the iOS/Android mobile bubble employing millions of software engineers, when really these devices should have just been browsers on the existing internet. There was no need to resurrect Objective-C and Java and write native apps. That’s a pretty strong statement I realize, but I started programming when an 8 MHz 68000 was considered a fast CPU, and even then, graphics processing totally dominated usage (like 95% of a game’s slowness was caused by rasterization). So today when most of that has been offloaded to the GPU, it just doesn’t make sense to still be using low level languages. Even if we used Python for everything, it would still be a couple of orders of magnitude faster than the speed we accepted in the 80s. But everything is still slow, slower in fact than what I grew up with, because of internet lag and megabytes of bloatware.

I started writing a big rant about it being unconscionable that nearly everyone is not only technologically illiterate, but that their devices are unprogrammable. But then I realized that that’s not quite accurate, because apps do a lot of computation for people without having to be programmed, which is great. I think what makes me uncomfortable about the app ecosystem is that it’s all cookie cutter. People are disenfranchised from their own computing because they don’t know that they could have the full control of it that we take for granted. They are happy with paying a dollar for a reminder app but don’t realize that a properly programmed cluster of their device and all the devices around them could form a distributed agent that could make writing a reminder superfluous. I think in terms of teraflops and petaflops but the mainstream is happy with megaflops (not even gigaflops!)

It’s not that I don’t think regular busy people can reason about this stuff. It’s more that there are systemic barriers in place preventing them from doing so. A simple example is that I grew up with a program called MacroMaker. It let me record my actions and play them back to control apps. So I was introduced to programming before I even knew what it was. Where is that today, and why isn’t that one of the first things they show people when they buy a computer? Boggles my mind.

Something similar to that, that would allow the mainstream to communicate with developers is Behavior-Driven Development (BDD). The gist of it is that the client writes the business logic rather than the developer, in a human-readable way. It turns out that their business logic description takes the same form as the unit tests we’ve been writing all these years, we just didn’t know it. It turns out to be fairly easy to build a static mockup with BDD/TDD using hardcoded values and then fill in the back end with a programming language to make an app that can run dynamically. Here is an example for Ruby called Cucumber:

http://cukes.info

More info:

http://dannorth.net/introducing-bdd/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mT8QDNNhExg

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behavior-driven_development

How this relates back to my parent post is that a supercomputer today can almost fill in the back end if you provide it with the declarative BDD-oriented business logic written in Gherkin. That means that a distributed or cloud app written in something like Go would give the average person enough computing power that they could be writing their apps in business logic, making many of our jobs obsolete (or at the very least letting us move on to real problems). But where’s the money in that?

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by eropple on Friday January 09, 2015 @02:29AM (#8861157)
> There was no need to resurrect Objective-C and Java and write native apps. That’s a pretty strong statement I realize, but I started programming when an 8 MHz 68000 was considered a fast CPU, and even then, graphics processing totally dominated usage (like 95% of a game’s slowness was caused by rasterization). So today when most of that has been offloaded to the GPU, it just doesn’t make sense to still be using low level languages. Even if we used Python for everything, it would still be a couple of orders of magnitude faster than the speed we accepted in the 80s. But everything is still slow, slower in fact than what I grew up with, because of internet lag and megabytes of bloatware.

It's even slower when you write it in Python or Lua. I've built an app heavily relying on both on iOS and Android and it's a pig. This was last year, too, and outsourcing most of the heavy lifting (via native APIs) out of the language in question.

"Low-level languages" (as if Java was "low level") exist because no, web browser just aren't fast enough. There may be a day when that changes, but it's not today.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by basch on Thursday January 08, 2015 @06:27PM (#8859741)
>There was no need to resurrect Objective-C and Java and write native apps.

I still find it crazy that the world went from gmail/googlemaps to appstores. It's beyond me why most apps arent anything more than cached javascript and uitoolkits.

I think one reason for this is because devices became personalized. You dont often go check your email on someone elses computer. People dont need the portability of being able to open something anywhere, so the cloud lost some of its appeal. Now its just being used to sync between your devices, instead of being used to turn every screen into a blank terminal.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by heeen2 on Thursday January 08, 2015 @08:44PM (#8860263)
> I still find it crazy that the world went from gmail/googlemaps to appstores. It's beyond me why most apps arent anything more than cached javascript and uitoolkits.

* because javascript is still not as efficient as native code

* because code efficiency translates directly into battery life

* because downloading code costs bandwidth and battery life

* because html rendering engines were too slow and kludgy at the time

* because people and/or device vendors value a common look and feel on their system

* because not everyone wants to use google services/services on US soil

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by e12e on Friday January 09, 2015 @03:06AM (#8861241)
Interestingly the Japanese smartphone market had most of these fixed by 1997 or so; defining a sane http/html subset (as opposed to wap). Less ambitious than (some) current apps - but probably a much saner approach. Maybe it's not too late for Firefox OS and/or Jolla.

[Edit: on a minimal micro-scale of simplification, I just came across this article (and follow up tutorial article) on how to just use npm and eschew grunt/gulp/whatnot in automating lint/test/concat/minify/process js/css/sass &c. Sort of apropos although it's definitely in the category of "improving tactics when both strategy and logistics are broken": prevous discussion on hn: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8721078 (but read the article and follow-up -- he makes a better case than some of the comments indicate)]

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by basch on Friday January 09, 2015 @12:47PM (#8863284)
but in the javascript model most of the processing is offloaded to the cloud when possible, making it MORE energy efficient. ideally you are just transmitting input and dom changes or operational transformations.

timesharing.

web ecosystems can still enforce common uitoolkits.

gmail was just an example.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by seanflyon on Friday January 09, 2015 @02:52PM (#8864083)
The difference between javaScrip in browser and native code has nothing to do with the could. Both can offload processing to remote servers.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by detaro on Saturday January 10, 2015 @11:32AM (#8867049)
As soon as we have reliable and energy efficient wireless connections actually available with perfect coverage, maybe.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by chipsy on Thursday January 08, 2015 @06:50PM (#8859827)
I think there's an element of "pendulum swinging" to how we ended up back at native. The browser is a technology that makes things easy, more than it is one that makes things possible. And "mobile" as a marketplace has outpaced the growth of the Web.

So you have a lot of people you could be selling to, and a technology that has conceptual elegance, but isn't strictly necessary. Wherever you hit the limits of a browser, you end up with one more reason to cut it off and go back to writing against lower level APIs.

In due course, the pendulum will swing back again. Easy is important too, especially if you're the "little guy" trying to break in. And we're getting closer to that with the onset of more and more development environments that aim to be platform-agnostic, if not platform-independent.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by stereosteve on Thursday January 08, 2015 @06:34PM (#8859769)
Well now you have a new job writing regular expressions for Gherkin...
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by innguest on Thursday January 08, 2015 @05:18PM (#8859390)
I want to subscribe to your newsletter where you write things you shouldn't write. I'm glad you wrote this. I'm not alone!
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by keithpeter on Sunday January 11, 2015 @05:43AM (#8869631)
Definitely a blog theme.

Meta: I'm glad I asked about the patterns now. I had doubts about the extent to which asking that question would add to this thread.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by SixSigma on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:37PM (#8858816)
When I got to that point ("All I ever do is write forms for editing databases") I switched to physical engineering - got qualified in Six Sigma, got qualified in Manufacturing Engineering and now I'm doing a degree in Supply Chain Management. Love it.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jpgvm on Thursday January 08, 2015 @08:32PM (#8860227)
Software is a force multiplier.

If the initial force is headed towards uselessness software won't save it from it's fate, it will in fact just get it there faster.

By the same token if you manage to write some software that is magnifying a force of good the results can be staggering.

Software allows us to accomplish more net effect in our lifetimes than was ever possible before. However if we spend our time writing glorified forms over and over again we aren't going to live up to that.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by Futurebot on Friday January 09, 2015 @05:05AM (#8861527)
I do often wonder how many people would do something with a great deal more positive impact (research, full-time work on free software, working on that crazy, but possibly actual world-changing idea/startup, whatever) if they didn't have to worry every day about survival, aging out of their field, being forced to run faster just to stay where they are, etc. One day perhaps we'll get to see what that looks like. For now, though, chasing the money is often the rational thing to do, even if that means building yet another hyperlocal mobile social dog sharing photo app.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by mavdi on Thursday January 08, 2015 @10:34PM (#8860596)
This is exactly how I feel. Even though my income has quadrupled in the last three years I haven't made a single positive impact to anyone's life using my skills. This was a very sad realisation that I've basically been reinventing wheels for a living and not really engineering anything.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jmickey on Friday January 09, 2015 @02:14AM (#8861119)
I find it hard to believe that someone would pay you a salary for three years to do something that is completely useless to everyone.

At the very minimum, the fruits of your labour are useful to your boss/customer. That is already a single positive impact in someone's life right there.

Most likely, your boss/customer then used your developments in their primary business, which, no doubt, affects even more people in a positive way.

I believe being in technology, we have the capability to positively affect many orders of magnitude more people, than in most other industries. So cheer up! ;)

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by normloman on Friday January 09, 2015 @09:53AM (#8862431)
I'd caution against making the argument "If someone pays you, it's useful to somebody." It reminds me of the naive assumption of economists, that people are rational and seek to maximize utility. But exceptions easily come to mind.

People waste money all the time. Maybe the OP's boss paid him three years salary to do something the boss thought was important, but really just wasted time. And nobody knew it wasted time, because it was hard to measure.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by thirdtruck on Friday January 09, 2015 @10:01AM (#8862460)
I agree. You may be "helping" your manager, but that may mean helping them displace their political opponent for the sole purpose of taking more power for themselves. That, and I've seen far too many inane requirements and heard too many stories of code that was never used to remain especially optimistic.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by im2w1l on Friday January 09, 2015 @12:26PM (#8863176)
Pursuing promising avenues is not wasted time, even if it ultimately comes to nothing.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by normloman on Friday January 09, 2015 @01:17PM (#8863461)
I agree with you, but I've been in situations where management continues wasteful projects because they can't admit failure, can't define goals for the project, or throw good money after bad. I should have been more specific.

A personal example: At a small marketing agency, my boss insisted we needed to offer social media marketing, since "everyone's on facebook now a days." Because we were posting on behalf of clients, we didn't have the expertise to write about the goings on of their business, and often had no contacts in the client organization. We were forced to write pretty generic stuff ("happy valentine's day everybody!" or "check out this news article"). Worse, we had clients who shouldn't be on social media in the first place: plumbers, dentists, and the like. I have never seen anyone like their plumber on facebook. So naturally, these pages were ghost towns.

Yet despite having zero likes and zero traffic, clients insisted on paying someone for social media (They too had read that "everyone's on facebook") and my boss never refused a paying customer.

Want to know how it feels getting paid day in and day out to make crap content that nobody will read? Feels bad.

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by eli_gottlieb on Friday January 09, 2015 @12:00PM (#8863054)
>Unfortunately I follow the money for survival, but if it weren’t for that, I really feel that I could be doing world-class work for what basically amounts to room and board. I wonder if anyone here feels the same…

Ok. So find where to do that, and do it. If you don't have children to support or other family to stick by, you're only excuse is your fear of doing something too unconventional.

You want to do world-class work? Cool, let's talk about it. What's world-class to you? What would get you out of bed rather than give you an existential crisis?

Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by zackmorris on Friday January 09, 2015 @04:19PM (#8864584)
For me, doing work that eliminates work is something to aspire to. It doesn't even matter if it's challenging. I would actually prefer to be down in the trenches doing something arduous if the end result is that nobody ever has to do it again. But that only happens in the software world. The real world seems to thrive on inefficiency, so much so that I think it's synonymous with employment. Automate the world, and everyone is out of work. I had a lot more written here but the gist of it is that I would work to eliminate labor, while simultaneously searching for a way that we can all receive a basic income from the newfound productivity. That's sort of my definition of the future, or at least a way of looking at it that might allow us to move on to doing the "real" real work of increasing human longevity or exploring space or evolving artificial intelligence or whatever.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by eli_gottlieb on Saturday January 10, 2015 @01:00PM (#8867363)
Well, there are lots of firms to work at whose primary goal is something that permanently eliminates work. Here's a list I just happened to have on hand: https://hackpad.com/Science-Tech-Startups-zSZ0KdT6Zk1
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by jes5199 on Friday January 09, 2015 @02:21AM (#8861138)
Much of programming is mindless plumbing, but the problem of specifying what problem you're trying to solve will never go away. Focus your attention there.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by stickperson on Friday January 09, 2015 @01:47AM (#8861051)
Doesn't that depend on where you work and what you're working on though?
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by tonyedgecombe on Friday January 09, 2015 @04:58AM (#8861505)
Most workplaces are broken in some way or other, eventually you either learn to grin and bear it or you find a way to escape the system.
Re:Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicat... by innguest on Thursday January 08, 2015 @04:24PM (#8859105)
Yes, I feel exactly the same. I ride the rollercoaster of depression and the impostor syndrome is definitely there. Most of what I do is mired in incidental complexities that have little to do with the task at hand. Programming in itself is simple because it's a closed system that you can learn and master. What makes it seem hard is having to manage the logistics of it with the crude tools we have (checking logs instead of having a nice graphical control panel for instance). I also feel like all the problems I have to solve are ultimately the same, even if in wildly different areas, because it's all about how do I put these function calls in the right order to get my result. I can never shake the feeling that there could be a generic-programming genetic algorithm that tries a bunch of permutations of function calls and the way the results are the arguments for the next calls, given a list of functions I know are necessary for the solution. I always feel like I am still having to do computer things in my head, while sitting in front of the computer.