News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Jtsummers on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:54PM (#8837358)
> After that, beyond basic bar soap, you’re on your own. You have to order supplies through the commissary system, a sort of monopoly drugstore run by the Keefe Group out of Missouri. This is where you purchase everything from hygiene supplies and chips to a Styrofoam cup. You place orders once a week, and the following week a delivery guy shows up with a cart piled high with plastic bags of stuff. If nobody on the outside puts money on your “books” (inmate account), you can order a second indigent kit. But as soon as someone sends you money, Keefe deducts that cost. And with a 20-cent pack of ramen costing $1.18, just like most monopolies throughout history, goods are sold at an inflated rate.

This is one of the parts of prisons I find particularly distressing. I'm trying to find (but can't recall the name of the company) an article, perhaps posted here a few months ago, about a company that handles inmate "bank accounts". The percentage they took was absurd. Between what the financial company took and the prisons, $100 sent to a prisoner might end up only being $50 by the time they could spend it. Paired with the high prices in the commissary they can barely afford "essentials".

EDIT: JPay. Here's an article, but not the one I was looking for:

http://www.publicintegrity.org/2014/09/30/15761/prison-banke...

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by rhgraysonii on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:00AM (#8837376)
I can speak to this personally.

My father is currently in a federal prison. I do not want to reveal sentencing, names, etc. but I deal with Jpay on a daily basis.

Their core currency is 'stamps' if you are technologically literate.

It is $4.50 to be able to buy 12 'stamps'

It takes one stamp to send an email, plus one stamp per attachment.

Beyond this, there are music 'credits', video call 'credits', etc.

It is a fucking racketeering ring. I literally keep a Windows laptop so that I can have video calls with my father because its incompatible with OSX and Linux (Ubuntu 14.04 in my case)

Would love to hear a way to make a difference here...I've thought of nothing.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by virmundi on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:09AM (#8837396)
Sadly the only way to a make a difference, presuming you're in America, is to get a movement going to reform the penal system. The reason it's sad is that for many Americans the point of prison is punishment rather than rehabilitation. So they're happy with people going through hell, 'cause you know, they deserve it.

Your best bet is to find an existing rights group to pursue the changes. It will be a hard sell since the US moved to a private system. This means that the states and fed will have less direct control of things. More red tape and contract negotiations.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by wtvanhest on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:22AM (#8837436)
The two big issues in the US prison system are:

1) Treatment of prisoners

2) Number of people in prison

As a country we need to improve treatment and reduce the number of people imprisoned quickly.

If there is anyone located in San Francisco or northern south bay that wants to get together and do a hackathon with the focus of building something that generates either awareness or solves a particular problem we should meet up for coffee. I can meet anywhere in the Mission to discuss it. (Contact info in profile). I am currently swamped running my business but I would figure out a way to take a weekend off to build something.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by stefantalpalaru on Monday January 05, 2015 @09:14AM (#8838836)
the revolution will not be appified
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by eevilspock on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:37AM (#8839609)
i agree, but in a world where "going viral" determines what people pay attention to (almost always stupid shit), maybe figuring out how to make socially valuable things go viral is an important approach.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by ams6110 on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:26AM (#8837445)
Though the US has some private prisons, they are a minority by a wide margin. And other countries use them as well; the UK has 11% of its prisoners in private prisons and apparently are working on expanding (according to Wikipedia).

The county jail referenced in this piece is almost certainly not privately owned.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by smtddr on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:32AM (#8837459)
A position similar to yours has been countered on HN before... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8562786
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by afarrell on Monday January 05, 2015 @09:49AM (#8839009)
> find an existing rights group to pursue the changes.

If you're fine hanging out with a mix of Christians, Agnostics and Atheists who occasionally quote scripture in support of their cause, check out the Quaker Prison Fellowship.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Mz on Monday January 05, 2015 @02:08PM (#8840503)
I will suggest that one obvious answer is to try to develop a competitor for Jpay and see if it isn't possible to arrange for people to have another option, even if individuals in prison don't get a choice, maybe a few prisons would take the option and then at least a subset of prisoners would be less screwed over by this system.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by vacri on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:41AM (#8837626)
In addition to virmundi's suggestions, find your state and/or federal representative and talk to them about it. While it's not likely to make a big impact, these are the people who have the most sway in this regard, and you never know what might 'take' with them.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by sremani on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:10AM (#8837398)
JPay et al. are the worst scum. One of the justifications though is that our dear leaders expand definition of "crime" and "criminality" but do not expand budgets for incarceration so it falls on the Jailor and/related staff to get finances. They typically bring in these JPay kind of shady dealers who promise a cut per person in jail. So JPay takes a cut but shares it with the Jail or department. To give the kind of commission promised to the Jails they rob the inmates - its that simple. So we not only hold an inmate for crime but his family for ransom. This is sad because people do not have empathy for in-mates. One of the many "criminal" faces of the Criminal Justice System.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by pdkl95 on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:26AM (#8837446)
When $0.20 ramen and basic hygiene products (kind of required for the sanity housing of anybody) are not provided, it kind of makes you wonder[1] where the several-hundred dollars per-day we spend to keep most people in jail[2] is actually ending up.

[1] rhetorical question; we know, more or less, where the money goes.

[2] prison is usually more expensive

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by nodata on Monday January 05, 2015 @02:36AM (#8837749)
> we know, more or less, where the money goes.

Show us? It's publically available information I guess, where can we read about it?

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by pdkl95 on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:34AM (#8839595)
There's nothing fancy about where the money goes - it was paid to the police/jailers involved along with any contractors or other people on the receiving end of the "jail" budgets.

The point is that running a jail should be easy on $250/day/person-in-jail (or more!). The cost of bulk toothbrushs or ramen is basically in the noise. It says a lot about the character and values of a person that would choose to pocket this kind of spare change just to make their income very slightly bigger.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by MoOmer on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:24AM (#8837439)
Heres a video that public integrity made with interviews of people hurt by the system: http://www.publicintegrity.org/2014/09/30/15797/time-money-w...
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by paulhebert on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:16AM (#8837418)
Yeah it's pretty crazy. For those who want more information here's a short documentary I watched about jPay a while ago.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by danboarder on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:15AM (#8837570)
do you know the name of the doc or have a link?
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by paulhebert on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @03:04PM (#8852920)
Sorry about that! here you go: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OiZj2wgbedg
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by valar_m on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:10PM (#8837212)
Red State recently featured an article calling for prison reform, which I thought was an encouraging development[0]. Conservatives, historically, have taken a hard line against criminal justice reform in any way that might appear soft on crime[1]. For a prominent conservative site to come out in favor of reform is a step in the right direction.

Reading the Red State article, I get a sense that the author is walking a tightrope to frame the argument in terms that conservatives would favor:

>I have relatively little sympathy for violent criminal offenders in terms of the punishments they receive.

>However, all these efforts are opposed by powerful interest groups that give almost invariably to Democrats – including police and jailer unions who want to protect the jobs of their members.

>I am not advocating for free HBO for all prisoners and for government sponsored gender reassignment surgery or anything of the like

And so forth. He pretty much covers all the bases. I think that shows a high level of awareness. I also think that going to such lengths suggests a strong desire for reform to actually occur (disclaimer: I had never heard of the author before reading the article).

I feel like I should add, conservatives are in no way unique in demanding that scary ideas come with a popsicle. I personally prefer cherry.

[0] http://www.redstate.com/2014/12/18/americas-desperate-need-p...

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joe_Arpaio#Pink_underwear

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Shivetya on Monday January 05, 2015 @05:55AM (#8838187)
Being a Conservative, albeit a Libertarian, I am all for punishment, provided it fits the crime. I and I am sure many others like me do not believe in exploiting prisoners or such, but I also do not believe in coddling them either.

Right now we have another government regulated and implemented disaster. People bitch and moan over the issues the VA has and that institution is supposed to HELP people, yet they don't want to look at the penal system which is supposed to help society. Both are examples of a government to big to be held responsible. Both are just minor examples of government regulation permitting abuse and neglect.

Yet people want more regulation, more government, and such. Why should government improve when you want them to step in and do everything you don't like being done by others (internet, health, etc) We get what we deserve

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by kqr2 on Monday January 05, 2015 @03:49AM (#8837918)
For deleted scenes and outtakes, check out her blog:

http://www.elanapritchard.com/2014/12/jail-comics-deleted-sc...

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by ryen on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:43AM (#8837631)
If you don't make it to the last page of the 6-page clickthru, there's a link to her Kickstarter campaign for her side animation project: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/341471863/the-circus
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by spdustin on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:48AM (#8839665)
It's worth mentioning that many people in jail are there waiting for adjudication. For felonies, this can take months. For misdemeanors, a day or two is common.

In other words, in accordance with basic human rights, they're innocent as their accuser has not yet proven their guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by hawleyal on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:47PM (#8840364)
You're being too logical about it.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by somberi on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:06AM (#8837546)
May be its me, but her style reminds me of Asterix comics.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by thret on Monday January 05, 2015 @06:09AM (#8838219)
I was thinking Mad Magazine or early Disney.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by chanux on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:14PM (#8837233)
Probably not HN worthy but isn't it depressing to see things that are highly unlikely to ever improve?
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by rtpg on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:22PM (#8837265)
There are countries where not as many people are locked up, prison sentences are shorter, and as a result the people locked up are given a minimum of humanity.

By beating it into the minds of everyone (especially in more privileged classes who won't come within 500 feet of somebody who has seen the inside of a jail in their lifetime) of how absolutely dehumanising prison is, we could maybe stop demanding people be thrown into jail for 25 years.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by ams6110 on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:19AM (#8837431)
Some people deserve to be in prison for 25 years, or the rest of their lives. This is not to discount your first point that we may well be locking too many people up.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by bambax on Monday January 05, 2015 @03:15AM (#8837839)
> Some people deserve to be in prison for 25 years, or the rest of their lives.

Really, no.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by logicchains on Monday January 05, 2015 @03:58AM (#8837946)
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by MrJagil on Monday January 05, 2015 @05:37AM (#8838151)
The deal is, who does it help? I live in Denmark, have norwegian friends and family. I might think he is the devil, but it does not make sense to punish him; it helps no one but my ego.

There is certainly a case to be made that he is too dangerous to let outside, no way I will disagree with that notion. But having him fight for toilet paper is pointless cruelty, and there is no sense in fighting the pointless cruelty of killing with pointless cruelty poor living conditions.

Using Breivik as an example does not further the discussion though, as it is such an extreme case. It's fear mongering, and you're disregarding Hegelian dialectics by arguing in such logical extremes. I think we can all agree that lobbing the dysfunctioning members of society together in a desensitized and unsanitary confined area is no way to produce functioning, productive members of society.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:57PM (#8840437)
'deserves to be in prison' does not imply 'deserves terrible living conditions' So most of your comment is wasted.

As far as whether punishment 'makes sense', that depends on what moral system you use. I wouldn't treat it as so obvious.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by MrJagil on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @05:22AM (#8843675)
'deserves to be in prison' does not imply 'deserves terrible living conditions'

Yes it does. "deserves" very much alludes to revenge, not rehabilitation.

"As far as whether punishment 'makes sense', that depends on what moral system you use. I wouldn't treat it as so obvious."

Everything depends on everything; could you elaborate? Just to further the discussion a bit. Being a deterrent has nothing to do with morals, which I see as the main argument for punishment so I'm curious where you're getting at.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @12:27PM (#8845586)
>Yes it does. "deserves" very much alludes to revenge, not rehabilitation.

Possibly revenge. You might want nobody to ever face that person again, etc. Even if it's revenge that doesn't mean you want them to suffer in any particular way. Take away their freedom and turn them into an inert ignorable abstract in a box somewhere. You could stick them in an average motel room and the result would be the same.

>could you elaborate?

Just as an example, Christianity is pretty big on the concept of retribution. While it does say that it's God's job rather than man's, that doesn't change that it declares bad people deserve punishment independent of the deterrence factor.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @12:41PM (#8845706)
> Just as an example, Christianity is pretty big on the concept of retribution.

That's...debatable, and varies considerably between different approaches to Christianity, even within individual denominations/sects.

> While it does say that it's God's job rather than man's, that doesn't change that it declares bad people deserve punishment independent of the deterrence factor.

This is only true of Christianity in general if you define "bad people" extremely broadly; Christianity in general holds that essentially infinite punishment is deserved by (or, in some formulations, the natural consequence of) sin, of which all humans [0] are guilty. Christianity is -- in pretty much all formulations -- very much about God eliminating this deserved punishment or bearing (through Christ) in the place of sinners this natural cost.

So, one could argue at least as convincingly (if not more) that the central theme of Christianity is refraining from retribution even where it is "deserved" as one could argue that "Christianity is pretty big on the concept of retribution".

[0] with either 1 or 2 (exactly, not as a figurative form for "a small number") exceptions, ever

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @12:50PM (#8845781)
I am intentionally being very broad, yes. I'm only trying to support my claim that 'deserving' punishment depends on your moral system. Maybe I should focus on Judaism? I'm really not trying to get into any specific systems.

>refraining from retribution

That's very true, but the important thing here is that it's deserved in the first place.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @12:58PM (#8845853)
> That's very true, but the important thing here is that it's deserved in the first place.

I don't think that's the important thing here; I think that whether it is appropriate for any person to exact it is at least as important in discussing whether punishment (which is an action) "makes sense". Even if a cost is viewed as earned within a moral system, if that moral system equally holds that it is immoral for any person to impose that cost on the one that deserves it, retributive punishment does not make sense in that moral system.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:50PM (#8847060)
Once it's accepted that some people think retributive punishment is moral, imo it's a small and obvious step to realize that some people think it's right to have humans dealing out that punishment. Especially people influenced by earlier-mentioned moral systems that don't believe in an afterlife.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:18PM (#8846670)
Once it's accepted that some people think retributive punishment is moral, it's a small and obvious step to realize that some people think it's right to have humans dealing out that punishment. Especially people influenced by earlier-mentioned moral systems that don't believe in an afterlife.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:18PM (#8846667)
Once it's accepted that some people think retributive punishment is moral, it's a small and obvious step to realize that some people think it's right to have humans dealing out that punishment. Especially people influenced by earlier-mentioned moral systems that don't believe in an afterlife.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by MrJagil on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @02:12PM (#8846295)
> You could stick them in an average motel room and the result would be the same.

I guess this thread of discussion is getting moot and semantic, but I do find it curious that someone would say "that person deserves to be in a motel room", without that motel room indicating some kind of punishment (revenge). "deserves" indicates that he should suffer somehow, i maintain.

> Just as an example, Christianity is pretty big on the concept of retribution. While it does say that it's God's job rather than man's, that doesn't change that it declares bad people deserve punishment independent of the deterrence factor.

Excellent point! You are speaking in strictly logical terms though, which is why i referenced dialectics earlier. It is very hard to discuss this subject meaningfully if you're ignoring all the intricacies of real life. I.e. we do not send people to prison to do gods job of retribution.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:49PM (#8847059)
The punishment is being trapped in the room, not how much toilet paper is in the room. Taking away toilet paper is just a petty insult.

And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:19PM (#8846678)
The punishment is being trapped in the room, not how much toilet paper is in the room.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:38PM (#8846953)
The punishment is being trapped in the room, not how much toilet paper is in the room. Taking away toilet paper is just a petty insult.

And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:37PM (#8846950)
The punishment is being trapped in the room, not how much toilet paper is in the room. Taking away toilet paper is just a petty insult.

And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:30PM (#8846813)
The punishment is being trapped in the room, not how much toilet paper is in the room. Taking away toilet paper is just a petty insult.

And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:29PM (#8846802)
The punishment is being trapped in the room, not how much toilet paper is in the room. Taking away toilet paper is just a petty insult.

And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:25PM (#8846741)
The punishment is being trapped in the room, not how much toilet paper is in the room. Taking away toilet paper is just a petty insult.

And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by lotsofcows on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:38AM (#8861766)
"'deserves to be in prison' does not imply 'deserves terrible living conditions'" - It might not, but that is what this article is about. His comments are entirely appropriate.

"makes sense" has nothing to do with morality. It's to do with likely outcomes and cost. Also, if your "morality" is based on revenge, it's not moral.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by logicchains on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @04:13AM (#8843488)
>Using Breivik as an example does not further the discussion though, as it is such an extreme case.

I was supporting the grandparent post's suggestion that maybe some people to deserve to be in prison. The argument against this is implicitly an argument that no-one deserves to be imprisoned, and such an argument may be refuted by showing a single instance of someone who deserves imprisonment.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by bambax on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @09:19AM (#8844397)
For the record, and even if it doesn't help the discussion much, I completely agree with everything you're saying! ;-)
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by logicchains on Monday January 05, 2015 @05:25AM (#8838126)
To the downvoters, what alternative to prison would you prefer for someone who killed over 70 people in cold blood?
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by toonshow on Monday January 05, 2015 @06:36AM (#8838278)
25 years (if that's what it takes) of therapy to fully understand why he did it, how we can make life better for everyone so the next person doesn't feel this is their only option, and perhaps after a couple of decades of empathy he will realize why what he did was wrong and we can all move forward in peace and greater knowledge. Instead of primal vengeance that makes us feel better while learning nothing.

If we're going to spend the effort and money to incarcerate someone for that long, I don't see how turning it into intensive therapy instead is any more work -- and it's certainly more beneficial to society.

[dead]
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by optimusclimb on Sunday January 04, 2015 @09:37PM (#8836858)
I think the point of the story was to inform the reader what a jail experience is actually like, with the added benefit that the author was a cartoonist.

I don't know HN's policies, but I think you should re-consider your post, and edit/delete it.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by laoba on Sunday January 04, 2015 @09:50PM (#8836899)
If posting a back story on how the author got into the situation that the article is about is against the rules, I will gladly remove my comment.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by optimusclimb on Sunday January 04, 2015 @09:56PM (#8836921)
I wrote my suggestion to you not based on the "rules", so much as good taste. The author of that piece never wrote of anything that would have been affected by why she landed in jail. What value does it add?
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by optimusclimb on Sunday January 04, 2015 @09:50PM (#8836902)
Down voted twice for suggesting you don't try and publicly invade someone's privacy just for the hell of it? When did HN become 4chan?
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by jtreminio on Sunday January 04, 2015 @09:56PM (#8836924)
Court documents are public record. As in, everyone has a right to view court documents as long as they've not been legally suppressed.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by maxerickson on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:23PM (#8837020)
Whether people have the right to look at the records or not is a separate question from whether it is polite or appropriate to direct attention at them.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by comrh on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:06PM (#8836949)
Its the aggregation of information for no purpose. Plenty of info in "doxs" is public, doesn't make it any more seedy to do it.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by ams6110 on Sunday January 04, 2015 @09:58PM (#8836929)
I think if the author were concerned about her privacy she would not have written an article for LA Weekly about the experience.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by valar_m on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:22PM (#8837262)
Perhaps the downvotes were because your comment had little to do with the article in particular, or the larger issue of prison reform in general.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by comrh on Sunday January 04, 2015 @09:56PM (#8836923)
What does this all matter besides a desire to pry into a random person's life? It adds nothing.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by vacri on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:09PM (#8836965)
I was interested in why she was there, given that most of her self-referential imagery has her depicted as an innocent toddler, and most other inmates have unflattering depictions. Was she in for something that would generally be seen as 'not a crime' by the wider public? That was my curiosity.

And it's not exactly a 'random person' - the author is specifically announcing an article on her personal experiences. She's trying to draw attention and in this context is a public figure. It's not like this question came out of the blue for someone trying to keep their time inside on the quiet.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by comrh on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:12PM (#8836974)
That is my point, it was out of pure curiosity. The equivalent of rubber necking. Her article is on prison conditions, are you going to believe her more based on her crime or something? It has no relevance.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by vacri on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:46PM (#8837109)
Indeed. How dare I be curious about the background to an experience someone is writing about, given her disconcordant self-depiction in that experience. How dare I have a question about an article that is not directly related to the primary point.

I must remember to be less curious.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by waterlesscloud on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:14PM (#8836982)
Yes. The nature of her crime does in fact shade the credibility of her reports.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by comrh on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:22PM (#8837016)
How? Are murders more likely to lie about bad prison conditions?
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by waterlesscloud on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:32PM (#8837056)
If she'd done something relatively minor and ended up in jail because the system just grinded along, she'd have more credibility.

The fact that she repeatedly broke laws and intentionally disregarded court orders and never seemed to really acknowledge the reality of her situation does reduce her credibility.

Would you really judge someone in each of those situations as equally trustworthy? Really?

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by mschuster91 on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:49PM (#8837121)
> If she'd done something relatively minor and ended up in jail because the system just grinded along, she'd have more credibility.

Human rights are called human rights because they're universal and apply to every human being, no matter the circumstances.

And I personally don't care about how exactly one landed in prison - for minor offences or major, that inmates do not have the right to shower daily is just fucked up. Or that sexual violence or drug dealing in prison seems to be widespread.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by waterlesscloud on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:53PM (#8837141)
This isn't about the conditions, it's about her credibility in reporting the conditions.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by andrewliebchen on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:52PM (#8837349)
So it's about ethics in cartoon journalism?
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by mschuster91 on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:05PM (#8837195)
And what exactly does the credibility of her reporting the conditions have to do with the conditions themselves?

In my opinion, zero. Facts are facts, and it's not exactly new that prisons in the US tend to be shitholes.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by vacri on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:38AM (#8837621)
You've generated something of a catch-22. If her information is already well-known, she doesn't need credibility - in which case, why bother with the article in the first place? But 'facts are facts', and if she had new information, then she would need credibility in order for it to be considered 'fact'.

In any case, my curiosity had nothing to do with her credibility. I was curious about how she drew herself versus how she drew others. Why she was in jail speaks to some extent as to who she is, and fills in a little more of the mental picture of her.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:15PM (#8837235)
As a general rule, credibility is needed to figure out the facts.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by stefantalpalaru on Monday January 05, 2015 @09:27AM (#8838887)
As a general rule, any fact you derive from a person's credibility is not a fact. Humans are unreliable and relying on their authority/credibility/good looks to establish the truth value of a proposition is a logical error.

We accept this error when we have to do some fast thinking and the consequences of being wrong are small, but the moment you make this flawed logic the general rule is the moment you lose any chance at establishing the facts.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:48PM (#8840372)
'fact' generally excludes unreasonable uncertainty. Otherwise you've wandered into an area of philosophy where nothing is a fact. And that is not the general meaning of the word.

And credibility is a measure of how close their assertions are to the truth, how is that a logical error?

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by dragonwriter on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:54PM (#8840415)
> Otherwise you've wandered into an area of philosophy where nothing is a fact.

Or, rather, the area of philosophy where only the class of facts which can be certainly described as such are the facts of having particular present sensations (whether the kind that present as sense-data or the kind that present as memories) is a fact, and all other ideas about the world are either axioms or conclusions supported on the basis of either axioms, sensations, or a combination of the two.

Of course, when you leave that area of philosophy, you are in the area of fuzzy and imprecise thinking, so its not a bad area of philosophy to be in.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:28PM (#8837040)
I admit to secretly wondering why she was incarcerated. She described herself as 'landing in jail' as if she fell out of the sky and whoops! in jail. No idea that maybe she deserved it, or did something that precipitated it - just 'landed' there.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by laurent123456 on Monday January 05, 2015 @04:42AM (#8838045)
I understood her depiction as "helpless" rather than "innocent" toddler. There is nothing in her writing that indicates that she sees herself as innocent.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Torgo on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:46AM (#8839656)
She didn't draw the other inmates as infants, only herself.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by simplexion on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:49PM (#8837126)
Apparently she had a restraining order against her. She had been stalking Ren & Stimpy creator John K.
[dead]
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by rtpg on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:19PM (#8837250)
Why is it that when HN talks about the TempleOS guy, we're all careful with our terminology, but now we're totally cool to call this person "fucking crazy"?

I get that in the former, the man fits the mold of "misunderstood bit-twiddling genius" or related mythologies of the craft, but the latter is no less of a person. Show some humanity.

Besides, what did putting this person in 2 months of jail do? I doubt this accomplished anything other than spending more of taxpayers dollars. If she's "fucking crazy", then do you think 2 months of jail is a deterrent to stalking somebody? Or just something to make sure she's more careful when stalking?

Throwing people with mental illnesses into jail is as effective as spanking a baby. Sure, they might be conditioned to associate certain behaviour with punishment. But it won't fix underlying causes like behavioural patterns, addiction, or value systems.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by agrona on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:57AM (#8837529)
The comment you're replying to is word-for-word copied from a highly upvoted comment on reddit yesterday (but is now deleted) by a user with a handle I won't repeat here. [1]

So what you're seeing is cross-pollination. I'm honestly surprised to not see this comment down-voted, as it's pretty impertinent to the conversation and is textbook ad hominem. ("Crazy lady says prisons are terrible: who cares she's crazy").

[1] http://www.reddit.com/r/TwoXChromosomes/comments/2r7y8h/when.... You can see it with something like http://uneddit.com/

edit: oh, I see my second paragraph basically did happen already in some flagkilled posts.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by superuser2 on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:57PM (#8837368)
TempleOS doesn't victimize people; stalkers do.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by nether on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:32PM (#8837292)
templeOS guy hasn't stalked anyone?
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by g8gggu89 on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:14AM (#8837568)
Bingo
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by belorn on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:00AM (#8837377)
> Why is it ...

Because it fits the gender stereotypes people use. Male stalkers don't need to be attributed as crazy, since all males are portrayed in culture as stalking rapists. A female stalker cant' be directly explained by her gender, so the attribute "crazy" is used instead, which then fits into an other gender stereotype.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Monday January 05, 2015 @02:08PM (#8840500)
What? When is a stalker ever not referred to as crazy? I've heard about plenty of stalkers of either gender, and while male stalkers are portrayed as more dangerous I have not seen them portrayed as any less 'crazy'.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by smtddr on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:19PM (#8837248)
Being a stalker doesn't make you crazy. In our pop-culture world we have plenty of stalkers and I'd bet they're not completely out of their minds; just suddenly obsessed over a particular person(s).

Also, I don't know how many HNers have actually interacted with a person who is locked-up because they've been labeled insane. I can say that my dad & wife have interacted with many in their line of work and what I've learned from them is that even a lot of those that are locked up are not totally out of their minds. Usually it's some kind of environmental stimulus that triggers their "madness". But in a controlled facility (sometimes with medication as well) they can tell very coherent stories of their childhood, what school(s) they went to, what they did yesterday, about their parents/siblings, etc.

Don't automatically discount the views of a crazy person. More often than not they're not totally 100% crazy, just have certain issues that make them unable to function in our society.

I personally believe her illustrations are mostly accurate if for no other reason than the "unnatural" rush of comments trying to discredit her.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by jacquesm on Monday January 05, 2015 @03:08AM (#8837815)
I don't care one bit for what got her in jail or how terrible a person you think she is. What matters is that she went there and that either what's in those cartoons is a credible representation of what being in jail in America as a woman is like. If it is then those images should be reason for wholesale reform.

Even if she was a murderer it would still be reason to go and make some drastic changes.

Even if they're inmates, they are still people and with the number of people in American jails running in the millions and taking into account that the men probably won't have it any better it's a thing to be very much ashamed of.

Whatever she did has nothing to bear on the information in the article, it's either true or it isn't.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Pxtl on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:00AM (#8837536)
I don't think anybody can fault her for lifting the Ren and Stimpy style - everybody has influences and she's obviously a fan. It's not like she stole his characters.

And yeah, she broke the law and is in jail. I figured she wasn't there for cartooning. So it was stalking. Okay, right then.

Still tells a good story and makes nice illustrations to accompany them.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by andrewliebchen on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:46PM (#8837330)
No one deserves the inhumane conditions she (and others) have experienced in American jails.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by pdkl95 on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:13AM (#8837407)
One cartoonist gets obsessed and implements the creepy-stalker pattern on another cartoonist, which results in having to stay in a creepy American jail.

The NSA, Facebook, Google implement regular creepy-stalker patterns (sometimes milder, sometimes more worrying) as part of their regular {mission,business plan}, and they are awarded with profit?

> "Okay, the last thirty-seven comments didn't win him over, but the next one is going to totally make him want me!"

Ahh, yes, we can't forget to include the Comcast-style marketing department and their robo-dialers.

/* /sigh/ stalker behavior isn't good, of course, and the comparison has several flaws. Regardless, dual-standard still exists. */

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by ffn on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:02AM (#8837537)
Yes, but you forgot the other important part in her article where she writes:

>But because I had no money and an overworked...

Time = money in the US so it makes sense that if you don't have the money, you gotta do the time.

That being said though, I sincerely hope her publication of her jail adventure and her kick-starter take off so she can derive some value from this otherwise dismal experience.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by valar_m on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:15PM (#8837237)
Did you have any thoughts to share on the article?
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by DanBC on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:53AM (#8837656)
> Basically, she's fucking crazy.

This is hate speech and has no place on HN.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by DanBC on Monday January 05, 2015 @06:48PM (#8842045)
This comment received a bunch of up and down votes - roughly seven each.

I stand by it.

"She's fucking crazy" is not an accurate description of her. It assumes her behaviour is pathological when there hasn't been any suggestion of illness from any source. It then assumes a narrow type of illness, when stalkers could have any of a wide variety of mental illness (or no mental illness). So, it's pure bullshit speculation that is inaccurate about the person and inaccurate about mental illness.

Worse is the blatant stigmatisation of mental illness. This is a simple logic fail. You hear the behaviour and think "stalker with a mental illness" and not "stalker". This is the "conjunction fallacy". The clearest explanation of that fallacy is "the Linda problem" where readers are presented with a short bio of a young woman ("Linda is 31 years old, single, outspoken, and very bright. She majored in philosophy. As a student, she was deeply concerned with issues of discrimination and social justice, and also participated in anti-nuclear demonstrations.") and are then asked to select the most likely of two options ([1] Linda is a bank teller or [2] Linda is a bank teller and a feminist). People usually chose [2] even though [1] is more likely.

Speculation on the mental health status of an offender is as ignorant as suggesting that an offender is probably black.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by g8gggu89 on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:10AM (#8837562)
Nice. It was obvious they were leaving that out for some reason.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by trhway on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:42PM (#8837100)
>But because I had no money and an overworked public defender, I knew I’d have to serve time for my violation.

an animator in LA can't pay for a lawyer to fight 2 month of jail (i.e. supposedly something relatively minor). Are animators there doing that bad? (i'd expect it to be more like programmers in SV)

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by optimusclimb on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:55PM (#8837149)
"Animator" could have lots of interpretations/types of jobs, and many people that have pursued careers in the arts may have spent money on special purpose art colleges that cost a lot, but definitely don't always translate to high paying jobs.

Also, anecdotal evidence from friends in the digital animation field (think Pixar, Dreamworks, etc) is that even those jobs can be relatively low paying for years because they are dream jobs, hence high supply of workers.

Without knowing socio-economic background and life history, I could easily see a creative type in LA choosing a short jail term over the financial hit.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by waterlesscloud on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:01PM (#8837181)
Yep, low-level animator is a relatively low-paying job, and you're lucky to get it.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by jonnathanson on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:17AM (#8837428)
Also, there aren't very many "high-level" animator jobs at the end of the line, either.

The ideal career path for an ambitious, hard-working, and politically savvy animator is to switch over to the producer track as soon as the opportunity presents itself.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by egypturnash on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:09AM (#8837395)
There are a lot more people who want to be animators than there are jobs for animators in LA. I used to be one of them.

A lot of the work is seasonal at best; you're hired for the duration of one production, and let go when it's over. If the show gets renewed and the folks running it like you you may get offered your job back next year.

You can make a decent living but not working for Bakshi or Kricfalusi; you work for those two because you want the prestige of Having Worked Under A Legend. Or because you worked with them back in the day, have a decent amount of money to fall back on, and they've approached you with a new project that will give you a lot of creative freedom because they trust your sensibility.

(I mostly worked for John K when I was hanging around the industry, so I saw this first-hand.)

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by rtpg on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:03PM (#8837186)
Pretty sure that animators are paid more in line with musicians than programmers.

Also, think about going to jail for 2 months. 2 months where you're locked up and have absolutely no liberty. If this thing was minor, there's still 2 months you'll never get back. Not to mention the job you probably lose during this stint. I don't wish prison sentences to anybody, not even my worst enemies.

I wouldn't feel as bad that we feel so strongly about locking people up if the conditions weren't so absolutely awful. I'm sure there's a way to make prisons more survivable without sacrificing the "making sure people are inside the box"-ness.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by trhway on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:20PM (#8837256)
>If this thing was minor, there's still 2 months you'll never get back.

There is no argument what jail time is bad. It is the offense that seems to be minor (and thus easy to fight for a lawyer) - while IANAL, my understanding from what i see and hear around, misdemeanor resulting in 2 months of county jail without a lawyer is really not that big a deal, on par with second DUI, something what with a lawyer can be on the scale of like a month or two of community service, etc...

After googling around, i even more convinced that not having a lawyer (whether by choice or due to not being able to afford it) was her great misfortune as while legally she seems to be a violator, personally i got the impression that at the social level she was kind of a victim, or more precisely she happened to be too weak for (and was broken by) the relationships and the people (much higher-ups in her professional and social hierarchy) she allowed herself to be involved with. Basically she needs counseling, and instead the society comes with all the power of law upon her and throws her in jail (the events do seems to had gotten somewhat out of hands, so something needed to be done, the issue here is what should have been done - the good lawyer would probably was able to turn it into correctional/rehabilitation/treatment direction instead of the pure punitive).

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by rtpg on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:41PM (#8837318)
Sorry, didn't mean to imply you thought this was acceptable. Guess this is another one of those 'used car dealer' things: the sticker price might be 2 months of jail, but any lawyer can lower that immensely.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Gravityloss on Monday January 05, 2015 @06:19AM (#8838239)
Who does this kind of system benefit except the lawyers?
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Zaephyr on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:54AM (#8837524)
From her tweets and other posts it sounds like she was broke with no place live. A difficult situation even before getting into legal trouble.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by fsloth on Monday January 05, 2015 @02:08AM (#8837680)
From my understanding animators are more or less in the lower rungs of the income ladder. Like most creative professionals.