Yes it does. "deserves" very much alludes to revenge, not rehabilitation.
"As far as whether punishment 'makes sense', that depends on what moral system you use. I wouldn't treat it as so obvious."
Everything depends on everything; could you elaborate? Just to further the discussion a bit. Being a deterrent has nothing to do with morals, which I see as the main argument for punishment so I'm curious where you're getting at.
Possibly revenge. You might want nobody to ever face that person again, etc. Even if it's revenge that doesn't mean you want them to suffer in any particular way. Take away their freedom and turn them into an inert ignorable abstract in a box somewhere. You could stick them in an average motel room and the result would be the same.
>could you elaborate?
Just as an example, Christianity is pretty big on the concept of retribution. While it does say that it's God's job rather than man's, that doesn't change that it declares bad people deserve punishment independent of the deterrence factor.
That's...debatable, and varies considerably between different approaches to Christianity, even within individual denominations/sects.
> While it does say that it's God's job rather than man's, that doesn't change that it declares bad people deserve punishment independent of the deterrence factor.
This is only true of Christianity in general if you define "bad people" extremely broadly; Christianity in general holds that essentially infinite punishment is deserved by (or, in some formulations, the natural consequence of) sin, of which all humans [0] are guilty. Christianity is -- in pretty much all formulations -- very much about God eliminating this deserved punishment or bearing (through Christ) in the place of sinners this natural cost.
So, one could argue at least as convincingly (if not more) that the central theme of Christianity is refraining from retribution even where it is "deserved" as one could argue that "Christianity is pretty big on the concept of retribution".
[0] with either 1 or 2 (exactly, not as a figurative form for "a small number") exceptions, ever
>refraining from retribution
That's very true, but the important thing here is that it's deserved in the first place.
I don't think that's the important thing here; I think that whether it is appropriate for any person to exact it is at least as important in discussing whether punishment (which is an action) "makes sense". Even if a cost is viewed as earned within a moral system, if that moral system equally holds that it is immoral for any person to impose that cost on the one that deserves it, retributive punishment does not make sense in that moral system.
I guess this thread of discussion is getting moot and semantic, but I do find it curious that someone would say "that person deserves to be in a motel room", without that motel room indicating some kind of punishment (revenge). "deserves" indicates that he should suffer somehow, i maintain.
> Just as an example, Christianity is pretty big on the concept of retribution. While it does say that it's God's job rather than man's, that doesn't change that it declares bad people deserve punishment independent of the deterrence factor.
Excellent point! You are speaking in strictly logical terms though, which is why i referenced dialectics earlier. It is very hard to discuss this subject meaningfully if you're ignoring all the intricacies of real life. I.e. we do not send people to prison to do gods job of retribution.
And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.
And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.
And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.
And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.
And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.
And yes it's not done to take away God's job, but many people will tell you a key part of prison is retribution.
"makes sense" has nothing to do with morality. It's to do with likely outcomes and cost. Also, if your "morality" is based on revenge, it's not moral.
As far as whether punishment 'makes sense', that depends on what moral system you use. I wouldn't treat it as so obvious.