News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @12:41PM (#8845706)
> Just as an example, Christianity is pretty big on the concept of retribution.

That's...debatable, and varies considerably between different approaches to Christianity, even within individual denominations/sects.

> While it does say that it's God's job rather than man's, that doesn't change that it declares bad people deserve punishment independent of the deterrence factor.

This is only true of Christianity in general if you define "bad people" extremely broadly; Christianity in general holds that essentially infinite punishment is deserved by (or, in some formulations, the natural consequence of) sin, of which all humans [0] are guilty. Christianity is -- in pretty much all formulations -- very much about God eliminating this deserved punishment or bearing (through Christ) in the place of sinners this natural cost.

So, one could argue at least as convincingly (if not more) that the central theme of Christianity is refraining from retribution even where it is "deserved" as one could argue that "Christianity is pretty big on the concept of retribution".

[0] with either 1 or 2 (exactly, not as a figurative form for "a small number") exceptions, ever

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @12:50PM (#8845781)
I am intentionally being very broad, yes. I'm only trying to support my claim that 'deserving' punishment depends on your moral system. Maybe I should focus on Judaism? I'm really not trying to get into any specific systems.

>refraining from retribution

That's very true, but the important thing here is that it's deserved in the first place.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @12:58PM (#8845853)
> That's very true, but the important thing here is that it's deserved in the first place.

I don't think that's the important thing here; I think that whether it is appropriate for any person to exact it is at least as important in discussing whether punishment (which is an action) "makes sense". Even if a cost is viewed as earned within a moral system, if that moral system equally holds that it is immoral for any person to impose that cost on the one that deserves it, retributive punishment does not make sense in that moral system.

Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:50PM (#8847060)
Once it's accepted that some people think retributive punishment is moral, imo it's a small and obvious step to realize that some people think it's right to have humans dealing out that punishment. Especially people influenced by earlier-mentioned moral systems that don't believe in an afterlife.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:18PM (#8846670)
Once it's accepted that some people think retributive punishment is moral, it's a small and obvious step to realize that some people think it's right to have humans dealing out that punishment. Especially people influenced by earlier-mentioned moral systems that don't believe in an afterlife.
Re:When a Cartoonist Landed in L.A. County Jail, She Drew Wh... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @03:18PM (#8846667)
Once it's accepted that some people think retributive punishment is moral, it's a small and obvious step to realize that some people think it's right to have humans dealing out that punishment. Especially people influenced by earlier-mentioned moral systems that don't believe in an afterlife.