News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by billpg on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @05:54AM (#8686531)
What viruses "want" is to reproduce. Killing you is an unfortunate unplanned side effect.

If only we could negotiate and agree to allow them to reproduce and not kill us, we'd all get along much better.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by Houshalter on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @11:53AM (#8688048)
It's like the foxes that over-populate, eat all the rabbits and then all die. The foxes would be better not to reproduce past the limits of their environment, but each individual fox passes on more of it's genes if it doesn't restrain it's own breeding. And so those genes propagate to the detriment of the community.

You need very strong group selection to restrain breeding, and this becomes less and less likely as the population size increases (so each individual has less and less affect.) See The Tradgedy of Group Selectionism: http://lesswrong.com/lw/kw/the_tragedy_of_group_selectionism...

Even when organisms are selectively breed by scientists with group selection to limit their population size, they often just become cannibalistic rather than restrain their own reproduction. Killing someone else's kids is better than killing your own.

Essentially the same thing happens with viruses, where over reproduction means killing all the hosts cells.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by teddyh on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @06:53AM (#8686676)
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by MiddleEndian on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @09:15AM (#8687152)
Made me think of this one: http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=3091
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by zecg on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @06:44AM (#8686653)
Epstein-Barr virus is close to that ideal, 90-95% of adults have it. Unfortunately, it's connected with cancers: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epstein%E2%80%93Barr_virus
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by hazz on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @06:51AM (#8686669)
90-95% of adults had it at some point. Most people develop immunity to it and so it doesn't survive in them. I'd say the most successful virus in humans would be the common cold, given how frequently we seem to get it, although it's more of a massive family of virii.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by jbogp on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @07:24AM (#8686745)
No actually once you have it, you have it forever.

   EBV latently persists in the individual's B cells for the rest of the individual's life [1]
[1]: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15546128
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by JabavuAdams on Saturday December 06, 2014 @02:10PM (#8709879)
jbogp, I'd be interested to chat with you about your experience interviewing with DeepMind (found that searching HN for DeepMind info). My contact info is on my user profile page. Sorry about the thread-jack.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by henderson101 on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @07:31AM (#8686762)
Virii is a nonsense word. Unless, Virius was your original reference word.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by anon4 on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @10:53AM (#8687679)
I'm afraid that battle is long lost now :(.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by chc on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @01:36PM (#8688886)
Why do you think so? Virii doesn't seem that much more common than viri or viruses.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by TrainedMonkey on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @01:25PM (#8688801)
There is some evidence that we went full borg on at least some viruses and assimilated them into our cell machinery: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15310846
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by acveilleux on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @11:38AM (#8687953)
Herpes Simplex is another example. A majority of americans are carriers.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by billpg on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:42PM (#8688448)
That can only be transmitted in one direction. Its Herpes Duplex you have to worry about.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by eru on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:15PM (#8688233)
The common cold describes a bunch of symptoms that can be triggered by quite a few different viruses.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by bayesianhorse on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @08:06AM (#8686843)
"Unintended" side-effect yes. But not really avoidable. The very nature of viruses means destruction, competition for resources with other physiological processes in the host, and they only have a limited capacity to tune their reproduction for optimal transmission. Too little reproduction (and in the wrong places) means too little transmission, too much reproduction means too much damage and thus also less transmission.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by dredmorbius on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @02:08PM (#8689089)
It's quite avoidable. The viral load in various ecosystems can be tremendous, and many are generally benign. Even the non-benign generally don't kill their hosts.

An interesting tidbit from xkcd's "What If" series: individual cell mortality from viruses in the oceans is about 20% per day.

http://what-if.xkcd.com/80/

http://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1vyanj/viral_so...

Jared Diamond has offered related observations on pathogens and parasites in tropical vs. temperate climates. It strikes me that an ecosystem in which there are periodic resets (e.g., killing winter frosts, or long summer droughts) offer a more amenable set of living conditions to those species not affected by those resets, whether by adaptation or technology.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by bayesianhorse on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @10:31PM (#8691755)
So mostly people are talking about virus which can be actually identified and studied. Up until very recently this was pretty much restricted to those who reproduce massively and leave at least some clues. We know next to nothing about benign virus in eucaryote hosts (or at least I don't).

Also, I don't think "benign" virus compete with pathogenic virus for anything. This may seem strange, but unless the organism is completely shutting down, and probably not even then, only an extremely small fraction of cells are infected by any one virus. That's why you still have a nose after surviving the flu. Any competitive mechanisms would have to be more complicated.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by learnstats2 on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @09:37AM (#8687259)
This negotiation is rather weak since it doesn't recognise the passage of time. Once the viruses have reproduced to their satisfaction, they can renege on the deal when humans have a weaker negotiating position.

That is to say, "Don't negotiate with terrorists."

Fortunately the human/mammalian immune system does not typically permit this kind of deal. With a few exceptions: including HIV.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by egeozcan on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @09:51AM (#8687343)
If killing you means that the pathogen can spread more rapidly, it will evolve to do so. I don't see the HIV virus gaining anything by killing the host as it depends mostly on sexual intercourse to spread. Correct me if I'm wrong, but, Ebola would have been a better example in this case, I suppose.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by learnstats2 on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @10:33AM (#8687571)
> If killing you means that the pathogen can spread more rapidly, it will evolve to do so.

Sure, but killing the host is not generally the goal of a pathogen. Killing the host typically means the pathogen won't spread any further, and that direction leads to the pathogen's extinction. Or, the death of this family line, if you like.

But, before worrying about that, if a virus does not address the immune system, it will not be able to spread at all - there will be no family line. The initial goal of a new virus is to evade the (highly advanced) immune system.

Ebola apparently has a very naive way of bypassing the human immune system. That is, overwhelm the system, so that the host dies, but you have a small chance of spreading. This works, sometimes, for a little while, but not too much, maybe just enough to gain a few generations of evolution to try and improve your strategy. If you are already a latent virus in a related species, you might get a few attempts at this, as Ebola has.

HIV does this in a frighteningly more effective way - a way which is more evolved - hide from the immune system while maintaining a route to spread to other hosts. This has to be a very subtle balance - hiding from the immune system is no mean feat. This is why I used HIV as an example - HIV somehow negotiates its own and the host's survival with the immune system (where Ebola has not been able to).

The dance between immune system and virus ultimately leads to AIDS. Death of the host is not ideal for the local strain of HIV, but it had a good chance to reproduce in other hosts, so it's a good result for HIV as a whole.

To become an effective and latent human virus, you need to evolve some sympathetic way of defeating the immune system that doesn't have a significantly negative result for the host. It's likely that HIV is still on that path, and Ebola might be on the start of that path.

This is why we observe viruses to become less deadly and more easily spread over time.

It's not necessarily true that this is the only evolutionary path, but the immune system presents such a huge barrier that you have to overcome this before meeting any secondary goals.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by kale on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:12PM (#8688201)
You are correct, Ebola's high mortality rate is a by-product of how it spreads.

Ebola virus is successful at spreading due to the fact that it's in various fluids secreted by endothelial cells (which are everywhere in the body). The virus has mutated to let those tissues start to "leak", which means a person infected with Ebola is more likely to leak fluids (which is why it sometimes causes bleeding out of mucous membranes). Since there is an increase in the endothelial fluids released, there is more exposure to those trying to treat a patient with Ebola.[1]

The way the virus spreads (increased discharge of endothelial fluids) is what causes it to be so fatal, which is a by-product.

[1] Great overview of the virus: http://arstechnica.com/science/2014/11/understanding-the-ebo...

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by mason240 on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:29PM (#8688355)
>If killing you means that the pathogen can spread more rapidly, it will evolve to do so.

The plague/black death/Y pestis is another is a great example of this. It keeps its rat host just alive enough for just long enough for maximum use of the rats body. The rat then dies, which sends sends it plague-ridden fleas off to infect other rats.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by abakker on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:57PM (#8688574)
Just an FYI from a thread a few months ago - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7513455

It seems that the Black Death was pneumonic as well as bubonic.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by kingkawn on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @07:00AM (#8686691)
http://www.hhmi.org/research/cell-cell-communication-bacteri...

this work is being done with bacteria, not sure it is possible with viruses though.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by waps on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @07:52AM (#8686810)
While this is a communication pattern, it is still governed by evolution. Therefore, as a host, you get one vote.

Either you live at least long enough to spread the virus a little bit, and you vote that what the virus is doing is good, or you die before spreading, and you vote what the virus is doing is bad.

Let's get voting !

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by kingkawn on Wednesday December 03, 2014 @05:48AM (#8692970)
We must live, if not for ourselves, then for the trillions of life forms that call us home.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by cJ0th on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @10:12AM (#8687462)
That's an interesting thought. It's like they posses "artificial intelligence", i.e. they behave like the famous paper clip maximizer.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @10:28AM (#8687541)
No, that's just evolution - plain, simple and extremely dumb. Viruses don't really "want" anything, they are just biomolecular machines that run around replicating themselves and screwing things up; some manage to copy themselves, some don't - and this way, generation after generation, you're left with those viruses that are good at copying themselves in the environment they're in. Evolution is a statistical phenomenon.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by Dn_Ab on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @11:34AM (#8687922)
In other settings, a simple approximation of what Evolution does will balance your portfolio and find Nash Equilibriums for zero sum games much more quickly than linear programming (query: multiplicative update evolution).

Having to wait for things to die can be restrictive (but genomes are declarative, what does that buy?). Roughly, with what amounts to the assumption that Lamarckian evolution is more or less not true, you can characterize evolution's learning power as almost as good as PAC (query: statistical query learning evolution).

See alsos:

http://vserver1.cscs.lsa.umich.edu/~crshalizi/weblog/601.htm...

http://arxiv.org/abs/1211.4037: Natural selection. V. How to read the fundamental equations of evolutionary change in terms of information theory

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @11:40AM (#8687968)
Thanks for the references, I'll check them out after work :).
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by saulrh on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @10:59AM (#8687710)
Except that, depending on your definition of "intelligence", evolution even as a statistical process fits most to all of the criteria necessary to be intelligent. Basically any definition of intelligence that fits the stuff you see in the movies will also tend to fit evolution. "Has goals, biases set of possible futures toward completing those goals, demonstrates creativity", and so on. It's just that evolution, as an intelligent entity, is utterly, unbelievably alien - psychologically, physically, and 'physiologically'. Which I guess makes sense, right? Aliens aren't going to have rubber foreheads and five fingers; they're going to be utterly unbelievably alien.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by ajkjk on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @11:22AM (#8687847)
This splits into two points:

1. You're right, our intelligence is the same thing. Intellect is a statistical creation that makes us good at surviving.

2. But usually, when people talk about our intelligence and our having goals, they aren't talking about the fact that we statistically exhibit tendencies towards self-preservation (which is what we're talking about viruses doing). It's that we literally have conceptual goals, which can be written down ahead of time and talked about.

aka you won't find a virus with a to-do list. Conflating that intelligence with viral 'intelligence' is kinda disingeuous.

--

That said, I do agree that we might/will find alien life that looks nothing like what we expect and has 'intelligence', for some reasonable (non-virus) definition.

I would not be inordinately surprised if we managed to find this in the motion of waves in the ocean, or in the swirling gases of the sun, or the gravitational interactions of the asteroid belt, or in tremors in the earth, or in hive-minds of billions of ants. And I definitely reject dualism and fully expect that a human brain simulated in a computer would be as intelligent as we are.

I'm not sure what the criteria for an 'intelligence medium' is, but it seems to require sufficiently high entropy to allow for complex patterns to form, but not too high - there has to be enough order and especially a not-too-high temperature such that self-contained systems can form and replicate without being blurred back into the whole system.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @11:15AM (#8687803)
True, but it's a kind of a "null garbage collector" case. It's the dumbest type of intelligence, a random one. But it did also created intelligences less dumb than itself, if you view the evolutionary process as separate from the workings of human mind.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by snowwrestler on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @10:32AM (#8687566)
Obviously viruses are not intelligent and they don't "want" to reproduce.

However, they do reproduce, just like pretty much every other form of life. The question of why life does that is closely related to the question of what life is and how it came to exist. Those are deep questions and we don't really have a clue as to the answer right now. There's certainly nothing in the fundamental physical laws of the universe, as we understand them today, that seems to indicate or require the existence of life.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by Justsignedup on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @11:39AM (#8687965)
What if life is just an accidental misshapen rock which spreads itself changing constantly to adapt to ever hostile environments.

OMG What if we're the cancer of the universe, who is in itself a giant amoeba!??!!?!?!?

deep thoughts, with jack handy

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by dredmorbius on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @02:03PM (#8689056)
Closer than you might think. Howard Odum in 1971 suggests that humans are something of a decomposer, working on a backlog of accumulated energy and mineral deposits:

Sometimes in half-seriousness we say that man may have been evolved by the system as a mechanism to get the fossil fuels and other minerals back into circulation. We hope he is pre-adapted for other roles after that.

From Environment, Power, and Society.

An analog I use is to opportunistic benthic whale fall communities. The emerge and develop rapidly. They do not sustain.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by snowwrestler on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @05:11PM (#8690321)
Is life an accident, or a predictable outcome of physical laws? That's a pretty fundamental question, and one we should be able to answer scientifically. But we can't right now.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by john_b on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @10:47AM (#8687653)
Fundamentally life is just patterns of information and their associated support structures capable of reproducing and adapting to their environment. There really is no answer to the question of "why" life reproduces because life that does not reproduce ceases to be life. The reproduction component is inherent in its definition.

As to why our universe is one which supports life, nobody really knows. Some invoke the anthropic principle, but that is more of a philosophical answer than a scientific one.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by snowwrestler on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @05:06PM (#8690287)
> As to why our universe is one which supports life, nobody really knows.

There's an implicit distinction in this statement, between the universe and life. Really, life is part of the universe too.

I'm familiar with the anthropic principle, but it doesn't tell us whether life is a necessary outcome of the physical laws of our universe, or whether it's just one of many accidental outcomes that are not forbidden by the laws of our universe. Both of those situations satisfy the anthropic principle, but are very different.

For example, we could speculate about a universe in which the nuclear strong force is stronger than it is here. Based on our theories of quantum mechanics and gravity, we can predict how that would affect, for example, star formation. Isaac Asimov explores this idea in "The Gods Themselves."

But Asimov also predicts what alien life would be like in that universe, and there he's on much shakier ground, because nothing in our theories of quantum mechanics or gravity predicts life. We don't know how chemical systems become alive...there's even not solid agreement on the definitions.

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by mikeash on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:14PM (#8688214)
I thought the question of why life reproduces is easy to answer: things that reproduce become greater in number, and things that reproduce better become even greater in number than things that reproduce worse. Thus, the world is filled with things that reproduce really well.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by abandonliberty on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:21PM (#8688292)
8% of our genome may be viruses that decided to live with us: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endogenous_retrovirus?#Human_en...
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by snowwrestler on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @10:35AM (#8687581)
Our ancestors have successfully concluded such negotiations numerous times:

http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-17809503

Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by shittyanalogy on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @09:49AM (#8687326)
I think the problem is DNA. If we could get rid of it we'd be better off.
Re:HIV evolving 'into milder form' by smorrow on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @11:58AM (#8688084)
The selfish DNA.