News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by philip1209 on Monday November 24, 2014 @04:45PM (#8654918)
> "The Gates Foundation will also pay the author fees charged by many open-access journals."
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by dang on Monday November 24, 2014 @05:24PM (#8655078)
It's surprising what a big deal "author fees" are. A historian told me recently that when submitting articles to one major journal, there's a checkbox saying "I want this work to be in the public domain". If you select it, the system automatically adds $5,432 to your bill. That wasn't the exact number, but it was about $5k. In his field, and surely for most academics, that's prohibitive, and an odd way to treat people who are already effectively giving their work away. Yes, journal economics and so on, etc., but something's got to give here.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by dougmccune on Monday November 24, 2014 @05:48PM (#8655170)
$5k is about the top of the scale. Nature, Cell, etc can get that. More typical is the $1,500 range (OA publisher PLoS One is about that). One of the most interesting things to see is that the big winner of the APC (article processing charge) landrush is Elsevier. The Wellcome Trust published data about who they are paying APCs to, and the biggest player was Elsevier: http://blog.wellcome.ac.uk/2014/03/28/the-cost-of-open-acces... So it's interesting to see the (at least short-term) winners in the rise of APC-based open access are still the same big publishers, at least for now.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by niels_olson on Monday November 24, 2014 @06:37PM (#8655376)
Can you imagine if every scientist sent Wikipedia 20% of their journal fees? What would they do with that much money?
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by voronoff on Monday November 24, 2014 @07:13PM (#8655555)
Wikipedia is notoriously poor on science, particularly cutting edge. That's the wrong model.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by jeffreyrogers on Monday November 24, 2014 @08:43PM (#8655862)
That's surprising, since their math and CS stuff is usually pretty good.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by Coding_Cat on Monday November 24, 2014 @09:19PM (#8655975)
The thing with math (and abstract CS) is that it's generally purely logic. In principal you should be able to write (at least verify) an entire article with no outside references as it is all logical deductions, it's armchair science in that sense (no negative connotations meant).

But if you're going to write an article on say quantum computing or confocal microscopy, to name random things, you are going to need outside references to experimental work, history, best practices, open debates, etc. And that is usually where the errors slip in, how many people actually check the sources properly?

They're also usually pretty terrible when it comes to modern science things, but I suppose that can be attributed to a small group of people actually knowing about those things in the first place.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by sjtrny on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @04:35AM (#8657018)
This is for a very narrow definition of maths. Also it's rare that a paper is completely comprehensive. Some proofs are usually defered to other papers.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by scott_s on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @10:37AM (#8658105)
Wikipedia - and encyclopedias in general - are good sources for established works, not the cutting edge. I think this applies to computer science as well. The CS material on Wikipedia that you would expect to find in an undergrad curriculum is excellent. But the treatment for the research areas I am familiar with is not good. That, however, is to be expected - we're still figuring it out!
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by lultimouomo on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @03:56AM (#8656927)
I think the open data approach, where readers do not pay, but authors do, shows who really is the customer in the academic publishing business: the authors who must publish to advance in their career.

It used to be that the reader, as someone who needs reliable information in a field, payed a journal so that the people could work for guaranteeing the quality of the articles. Now the authors pay the journals to rubber stamp their articles with an often cargo-culted peer review, so that they can keep receiving grants.

I am all for giving free access to information; but if you want reliable information in a competitive field such as academia, where people have all incentives to cut corners, cook data, embellish results etc., you have to pay someone to do it.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by frozenport on Monday November 24, 2014 @07:32PM (#8655635)
You think that's nuts, consider that I just did a review and got paid nothing!
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by ecesena on Monday November 24, 2014 @09:00PM (#8655925)
$5k is surely high, but from a researcher/professor point of view I don't think it's prohibitive, especially if you compare it with papers accepted to conferences where you need to cover travel and staying, sometimes maybe for 2 people. It's just sad that you have to pay for openness.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by p4bl0 on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @03:11AM (#8656821)
> $5k is surely high, but from a researcher/professor point of view I don't think it's prohibitive

This is not true, $5k is a lot of money. It is certainly more than what traveling to a conference cost! I'm in France, and even going to California for a week, including plane tickets, accommodation, food, and conference registration is less than $5k. The thing is we are sometimes told to target journals rather than conferences because "there is no more budget this year" for instance. If we had to pay $5k to publish in journals we would just be told not to publish in these journals.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by Al-Khwarizmi on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @02:29AM (#8656736)
It depends on the country. In many countries funding agencies will just not give you $5K to pay for open access fees. Conferences that involve intercontinental travel are already prohibitive for many academics, by the way, and more than two people going is quite a luxury. In my university, the most normal thing to do if we get several papers at a conference is that a single person goes and presents them all, and many research groups don't do conferences in other continents (or only when they have some international coauthor that can go).
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by ecesena on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @02:58AM (#8656795)
I totally agree, I'm just saying that often the cost for conferences is also high/comparable. Here $5k is intended for a major journal. Similarly is for conferences, I remember traveling from Italy to the US only for ACM CCS (one of the top conferences in security). For "standard" conferences the budget was "standard" :) Again, I won't repeat it enough, I'm not saying is good paying for openness.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by Schiphol on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @06:46AM (#8657317)
But those are not the fees the Gates foundation are going to pay. They are talking about the somewhat lower fees payable to open-access journals. E.g., some $2000 for PLOS journals, if I remember correctly.

What you describe appears to be the opt-in open-access option provided by commercial academic publishers such as Springer or Elsevier. If you ask me, this option is probably there so that they can say they accommodate open access; they don't really expect many researchers to pay them.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by p4bl0 on Monday November 24, 2014 @05:04PM (#8654991)
That's where the remaining problem is.

Funding agencies should really stop kneeling in front of publishers and refuse to pay for this, or at least fix themselves a maximum price per publication. Currently publishers ask for $1000 to $5000 in some cases, which is completely insane. I'm not denying the cost of publication. But there is that actual cost, and then there is the prices demanded by publishers, which looks more like violent theft than it looks like the actual cost.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by markbao on Monday November 24, 2014 @05:13PM (#8655033)
Even more insane when you consider that peer reviewers are unpaid.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by alttag on Monday November 24, 2014 @05:24PM (#8655075)
So is content editing, in many disciplines.

I believe copyediting and layout is paid, however.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by PeterisP on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @05:17PM (#8660070)
My discipline is conference-heavy; all the copyediting and layout generally falls to assorted grad students and other underlings at whichever institution hosts the particular conference that year.

The major publishers (who need to get involved to have the proceedings indexed and "counted") get everything ready to publish online (well, they do slap a cover on the thing and get an ISBN) after the review process and technical process is done, and still try charge for access to the articles.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by alphydan on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @04:49AM (#8657050)
> I believe copyediting and layout is paid, however.

I've published in Nature Physics, Physical Review Letters, PRA ... and we did 99% of the copyediting and layout (with LaTeX and unpaid, of course). The editor would correct a few typos, modify the layout slightly (1h of work tops) and that was that.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by scott_s on Monday November 24, 2014 @07:02PM (#8655505)
I think there is some confusion here.

Some open access journals charge authors. But these open access journals are not the publishers we hear about (such as Elsevier). In some ways, it's accurate to say that the old model with publishers is "reader pays", and the open access model is "author pays".

The good thing about open access journals is that they are typically not a for-profit endeavor. This means that what they will charge to the authors is, hopefully, reasonable.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by acveilleux on Monday November 24, 2014 @08:36PM (#8655846)
When was the last time you published in a traditional journal? Last I saw an invoice was 4 years ago and we paid to be published in journals that were pay-only.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by scott_s on Monday November 24, 2014 @11:54PM (#8656402)
This year; it was IEEE, which counts as "traditional" for my field. Computer science is different from most other science and engineering though, since most of our conferences and journals are run through our professional organizations (ACM and IEEE), not a for-profit company.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by p4bl0 on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @03:16AM (#8656833)
Sadly you are wrong. Elsevier, Springer, Wiley, etc. they all have (what they call) "open access" journals where you have to pay to publish, and even some "authors choses" journal where you can pay to make your article freely available on the web but also choose the "free" closed access option. And yes, this means that universities still have to pay the subscriptions to these journals because not all of their papers are open access, so you end up paying one more time…

I'm insisting here on the fact that publishers attempt to melt the notion of "open access" and "gold open access" with author processing charges, but this is manipulative propaganda (and sadly it works, lobbies at EU and in the US succeed in convincing politics and funding agencies that they have to pay to publish in "open access").

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by dougmccune on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @09:09AM (#8657754)
Conflating OA with APCs isn't a nefarious PR campaign by the paywall publishers (disclaimer: I'm affiliated with one). It's the only way that anyone has shown is a sustainable model (so far). PLoS is the prime non-profit example, Hindawi is a for-profit OA example, and there are countless others that all focus on APCs being the mechanism to sustain OA publication (some call them different things, like PeerJ's membership model). Granted, I'm sure you can find examples of individual societies choosing to provide a high quality OA journal without the use of APCs, but that's the exception, not the rule. But overall the meteoric rise (and financial success) of non-profit PLoS seems like the biggest contributor to "OA = APCs".
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by p4bl0 on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @05:12PM (#8660045)
I really think what you say here is deeply ideological. As I explained in another comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8657030), there exist ways to have high quality OA venues at a fraction of the cost per publication that are demanded by gold/APCs OA publishers. You can read more about these models by googling for Diamond Open Access and Platinum Open Access (and see very successful and large scale exemples such as SciELO and revues.org).
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by scott_s on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @07:15AM (#8657382)
I was unaware that the old publishers had co-opted the label "open-access". But it is still true that some "true" open access journals require author fees - there's no free lunch.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by p4bl0 on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @07:54AM (#8657484)
Sorry for the messed up formatting, I used a star in the parenthesis and at the beginning of the second paragraph to mark a footnote. I can't edit it anymore.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by akjj on Monday November 24, 2014 @09:11PM (#8655952)
To me, $1000 per article sounds insanely low. PLoS is a non-profit founded for the purpose of publishing open-access journals. They charge between $1350 and $2900, depending on the journal, and only one journal is less than $2200. Another open-access publisher, BMC charges over $1900 for most of its journals. Do you think that PLoS and BMC are very inefficient? Are there _any_ large-scale open-access publishers that charge less than $1000? I don't count low-volume journals where the administration work is done by professors on donated time that would be valued at more than the cost of hiring a professional.

Sources:

http://www.plos.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/about-journal... http://www.biomedcentral.com/about/apcfaq/howmuch

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by p4bl0 on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @04:41AM (#8657030)
First I would like to show the fallacy of your reasoning: we're discussing the unreasonableness of the current price of APCs for open access publications, and you are justifying its reasonableness by giving the current prices.

Now I think you are thinking about this the wrong way. Nobody is denying that publication has a cost. But take all the money that universities around the world spend in subscriptions, add all the money that is paid in APCs. With that kind of money you could laaaaargely support many publishing platforms and professional librarians and technicians to manage, improve and maintains articles metadata and the platforms.

The remaining amount of money (which would be most of it in my opinion) could be used to actually fund research and higher education.

But let's be even wilder! Consider that, rather than being owned by a publisher who's main job is making money, each journal is owned by its editorial board (i.e., the scientific committee composed by the researchers who actually do the peer reviewing work for this journal as part of their researcher work (they're not paid for this task in addition to their salaries)). Now with relatively cheap¹ technical platforms (such as arXiv, HAL, revues.org, easychair, sciencesconf, SciELO, …), we would have everything we have now² for almost free. And publishers could act as contractor (and would be in competition against each other for quality and price) when we want professional editing and paper prints of some journal volumes. If in addition to that the papers use free content copyleft licenses such as CC-BY-SA, then when any university choose to spend a little money to get a professional edition of some papers everyone benefits.

¹ These platforms are not that cheap in fact, but they cost nothing compared to the current cumulated spending in subscriptions etc.

² Many publications todays are actually not professionally edited, publishers actually take the camera-ready version of the authors and just put the PDF online. So their job mainly consist in hosting PDFs, yet they get a freaking awful lot of money for that.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by akjj on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @10:46AM (#8658141)
I agree with you that incumbent commercial publishers are sucking up a lot of money that could be better spent elsewhere. Where I disagree is on the specific numbers. It's not about the publishing platform or physical printing but the administration of journal's operations. The editorial board and the referees work for "free" (which actually means paid for by someone else, usually universities), but the management and administration does not.

I point to PLoS as essentially the model you're asking for. It's a non-profit publisher started by open-access advocates working as researchers. There are no investors making a profit and they're mission is to spread open-access as a model, and they end up charging $2200+ per article for most of their journals. If that's the number they came up with, then I'm led to believe that that's what it costs to publish a journal, at least in the biosciences. As I said, there are small journals that operate for free, but if you look at large-scale open-access operations, started by idealists, I don't think you're going to find any that sustainably gets by with article charges less than around $1500.

For comparison, when I looked at Elsevier's finances, it seemed that they're charging roughly $5000 per article and half of that goes to their operations and half is profit. So their costs are roughly the same as PLoS, but they charge twice as much in order to make a substantial profit.

As for why I felt the need to correct you, I think it's because I think in general people ignore the real monetary costs associated with open-access publishing. I believe that author-pays open-access is the way of the future, but getting there will mean that researchers will have to find ways to pay these fees when they haven't had to pay before. In principle, this just involves redirecting money from subscriptions to pay author charges and there'd even be money left over, but actually performing that switch across thousands of institutions is not simple. Too often I run into the attitude that for-profit publishing is charging money for a trivial job, and so people wonder why it hasn't been replaced. However, the truth is that they're performing an important and real task with real costs, while also over-charging for it, and that's not going to be replaced overnight.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by p4bl0 on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @05:09PM (#8660029)
I guess this varies a lot across domains, but in computer science for instance, most of the management and administration is done by researchers too, using platforms such as EasyChair for example. So there isn't any cost here either. At the end when all the work is done, the publisher receives the work and only has to put its stamp on it. Okay I may be exaggerating: last time I published in a Springer journal they did two additional things to my paper: they changed the page number color from black to blue, and they changed all the internal references to other section from "Sec. n" to "Sect. n"… Clearly that must have cost the $3500 in APCs that they asked to make the paper open access.

Of course neither me nor my lab could afford that so I just went with the regular way, signed their fucking copyright release form while cursing a lot against them, and in the end didn't really care because in my field (cryptology), most of the papers are on the IACR ePrint Archive even before they are published (including mine) and they are updated there when they change.

So, my personal experience and my research on the subject (I have done a lot of work on open access, see http://pablo.rauzy.name/openaccess/introduction.html which is only available in French for now) say that no, the publishers work is most of the time not that important: for instance in my case if the conference or journal just published a list of links to the accepted versions of the paper on the IACR ePrint archive, the cost of publishing would decrease drastically and the quality of the publication would not change at all.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by hackuser on Monday November 24, 2014 @05:25PM (#8655080)
> Currently publishers ask for $1000 to $5000 in some cases, which is completely insane.

How many articles do they publish per month and what are their costs?

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by mathattack on Monday November 24, 2014 @05:42PM (#8655147)
Journals are an amazingly profitable business. There's a reason that Warren Buffett likes them. :-)
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by sre_ops on Monday November 24, 2014 @06:38PM (#8655381)
Yes, publishers should work for free. plonk
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by pkaye on Monday November 24, 2014 @06:46PM (#8655411)
yes, tax payers should fund publishers for free. plonk.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by sre_ops on Monday November 24, 2014 @07:35PM (#8655644)
Tax payers aren't funding publishers. Don't like it? Go publish it on your blog.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by dalke on Monday November 24, 2014 @08:01PM (#8655735)
"publishers should work for free. plonk"

We expect peer reviewers to work for free. We expect the authors of the papers to work for free. But no, we don't expect the publishers to work for free.

As p4bl0 wrote, "But there is that actual cost, and then there is the prices demanded by publishers, which looks more like violent theft than it looks like the actual cost." That means p4bl0 think the prices should be reduced, not that the prices should be zero, as you somehow concluded.

"Go publish it on your blog."

See, I've actually done that. I can tell you what happens. A large subset of people don't believe something has been published unless it's in the scientific literature. People end up writing papers which say things like "the first comparison between X and Y". I write to them pointing out several previous blog publications which report the analysis, to be told that they knew about one of them, but didn't consider it sufficiently academic to count as a real publication.

Publishers make their profits because a lot of people, including those who hire or fund academics, believe that a publisher's imprimatur is essential to being a publication.

This is not completely invalid. Google's standard search engine, good as it is for search, is lousy for searching the academic literature. Google Scholar is better, but it only manages it because it only indexes the academic journals.

So if you publish on your blog, it's not likely that people will know about your work.

If you want to advance career in science that has a strong academic orientation, then it's very hard to do so by only publishing blog posts.

Therefore, if you don't like it, change the system. Which is what this debate has been about for the last 15+ years.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by p4bl0 on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @04:22AM (#8656985)
Just a remark: actually Google Scholar indexes everything that resembles a publication. For instance it indexes PDF linked from the "research" page of my personal website: if you search for "rauzy ARMv7-M" for instance [1] you'll find a preprint paper that is publicly only available on that web page.

[1] https://scholar.google.fr/scholar?q=rauzy+ARMv7-M

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by dalke on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @04:39AM (#8657024)
"resembles a publication" is an interesting concept, though point taken that it indexes more than just articles published in a journal.

One paper I'm thinking of compared implementations of two different algorithms, and showed that for chemical data VF2 was several times faster than the Ullman algorithm for subgraph isomorphism. A couple of years earlier, two of the free software projects in the field did the same analysis, with the same conclusion. Both published their results on their respective blogs/wiki, and changed the internals to use VF2.

These don't resemble a publication in a way that Google Scholar can discern.

It's a bit annoying to me in that the scientific literature is supposed to be "self-correcting", in the sense that I could publish a followup paper highlighting some of the pre-history. But the journal I'm thinking of is an OA journal, with no letters to the editor or similar section. The only way to update the literature is to pay ~$1,000 for a full-sized paper, or convince some other journal (... or arxiv? Hmm...) to publish a correction piece.

Quite annoying.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by robryk on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @03:24AM (#8656849)
> Google's standard search engine, good as it is for search, is lousy for searching the academic literature. Google Scholar is better, but it only manages it because it only indexes the academic journals.

Google scholar seems to index arxiv.org (a free for readers and authors, no review paper archive). Would you consider publishing those things you've published as blog posts there too?

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by dalke on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @04:27AM (#8656996)
I have considered it. However, I work in cheminformatics, which doesn't really fall under "Physics, Mathematics, Computer Science, Quantitative Biology, Quantitative Finance and Statistics". I don't see an appropriate place for my work.

For example, under Quantitative Biology you'll notice a lack of pharmaceutical chemistry, toxicology, or pesticides, which are closely related areas to the types of work I do.

Searching out of curiosity, I found http://arxiv.org/abs/1303.1724 as an example of something in my field. It's under the catch-all "Computer Science > Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science", so that's a possibility.

There is some toxicology under metabolomics, but that focused on expression data, not structure-based prediction. There's another tox paper filed under "Mathematics > Statistics Theory", again based on gene expressions.

There's no history of people using arxiv.org in my field. If people don't like to cite blog publications, I don't know if they would like to cite preprints. Something to find out the hard, slow way, I guess.

Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Monday November 24, 2014 @08:40PM (#8655857)
"plonk"??? usenet's been dead for years.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by cmsmith on Monday November 24, 2014 @04:57PM (#8654965)
This is important, but what would be interesting is whether they will pay open access fees on top of your grant, or let you pay open access fees with your grant. The first option would obviously be preferable, especially since you can easily be publishing work after using up your direct grant money.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by dnautics on Monday November 24, 2014 @04:59PM (#8654973)
on the other hand, the first option would encourage open access journals to rack up the price of publishing.
Re:Gates Foundation to require immediate free access for jou... by wodenokoto on Monday November 24, 2014 @08:58PM (#8655916)
Essentially it's the same thing, it's just about who is responsible for what part of the budgeting. E.g. You get $100k of which $4k can only be used towards publishing expenses vs you get $100k and promise to publish open access and figure out the alotment on your own.